ahmedzee
First Class Star
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2006
- Runs
- 4,020
Let me start by saying that I was extremely unhappy at how Misbah selected the teams for all three T20I he was incharge of, starting with the Sri Lanka series, then Australia series and now Bangladesh series.
Let’s look at how things were under Mickey and what our squad was. It was a consistent selection with settled openers and middle order, a settled lower order and a settled bowling unit. All this under the captaincy of Sarfaraz Ahmed (barring the games against South Africa in 2019, where Shoaib Malik captained and lost the first T20I series in 3 years). This all came post 2016 World T20, where the coach and captain worked hard to settle the team and make it strong for the next World T20, which was in 2020.
Enter Misbah in 2019!
Any coach would be extremely happy to get a settled #1 T20I side and make them completely unbeatable before the World T20. A winning formula was already set. Misbah on the other hand broke this winning formula. There is a famous saying “why fix it when it is not broke”. That is exactly what Misbah did in T20I against Sri Lanka, he selected a team with blokes like Ahmad Shahzad and Umar Akmal who were not a part of T20I winning formula. Moreover, putting pressure on Sarafarz Ahmad and his captaincy, knowing very well that it is the World T20 cricketing year.
Then we go over to the Australia series. A confused Misbah removed Sarfaraz as captain for a difficult Australia tour, and changed atleast 6 players (almost half the squad) for the T20I in Australia. He insisted on keeping Haris who was not really a part of the T20I winning formula from before, brought back a has been named Irfan, all in all with a Rookie captain, a rookie leg spinner selected whose late father had good ties to Misbah, and a good wicketkeeper who can’t bat in T20s. Was Sarfaraz’s replacement as Captain and Wicketkeeper in this winning formula really necessary? Moreover Misbah has been known as someone who likes to be consistent with his selection, but here he didn’t even change the XI for the first two games known well that Haris was struggling. It recons if it was really necessary to change the winning formula, which is, captain, and core players.
Now lets head over to the selection for the Bangladesh series. We now have more changes in the squad, with again atleast 6 players from the previous series being changed. Now there is no Fakhar, who has given many successes to Pakistan in T20I in the past. There is no Aamir or Wahab who are a vital cog in the bowling lineup. Moreover, Hafeez is brought back who was NOT a part of the winning formula. It is not just Hafeez, it is Hafeez the batsman, as he can’t bowl. Shoaib Malik’s inclusion could be argued which I won’t touch on here as he was indeed a part of the winning formula under Sarfaraz. This overhaul of the team shows that Misbah is either simply confused on what could work, or he has no clue on how to select a team.
Let me once against remind that it is a World T20 year, and Pakistan had core players for the last 3 years who brought them to #1 position and this winning formula was just broken by Misbah with his useless selection policies. While other teams are settling the core players for the World T20, Pakistan on the other hand is breaking the team of settled core players. Lets just hope sense prevails and the winning formula is brought back before the World T20.
Let’s look at how things were under Mickey and what our squad was. It was a consistent selection with settled openers and middle order, a settled lower order and a settled bowling unit. All this under the captaincy of Sarfaraz Ahmed (barring the games against South Africa in 2019, where Shoaib Malik captained and lost the first T20I series in 3 years). This all came post 2016 World T20, where the coach and captain worked hard to settle the team and make it strong for the next World T20, which was in 2020.
Enter Misbah in 2019!
Any coach would be extremely happy to get a settled #1 T20I side and make them completely unbeatable before the World T20. A winning formula was already set. Misbah on the other hand broke this winning formula. There is a famous saying “why fix it when it is not broke”. That is exactly what Misbah did in T20I against Sri Lanka, he selected a team with blokes like Ahmad Shahzad and Umar Akmal who were not a part of T20I winning formula. Moreover, putting pressure on Sarafarz Ahmad and his captaincy, knowing very well that it is the World T20 cricketing year.
Then we go over to the Australia series. A confused Misbah removed Sarfaraz as captain for a difficult Australia tour, and changed atleast 6 players (almost half the squad) for the T20I in Australia. He insisted on keeping Haris who was not really a part of the T20I winning formula from before, brought back a has been named Irfan, all in all with a Rookie captain, a rookie leg spinner selected whose late father had good ties to Misbah, and a good wicketkeeper who can’t bat in T20s. Was Sarfaraz’s replacement as Captain and Wicketkeeper in this winning formula really necessary? Moreover Misbah has been known as someone who likes to be consistent with his selection, but here he didn’t even change the XI for the first two games known well that Haris was struggling. It recons if it was really necessary to change the winning formula, which is, captain, and core players.
Now lets head over to the selection for the Bangladesh series. We now have more changes in the squad, with again atleast 6 players from the previous series being changed. Now there is no Fakhar, who has given many successes to Pakistan in T20I in the past. There is no Aamir or Wahab who are a vital cog in the bowling lineup. Moreover, Hafeez is brought back who was NOT a part of the winning formula. It is not just Hafeez, it is Hafeez the batsman, as he can’t bowl. Shoaib Malik’s inclusion could be argued which I won’t touch on here as he was indeed a part of the winning formula under Sarfaraz. This overhaul of the team shows that Misbah is either simply confused on what could work, or he has no clue on how to select a team.
Let me once against remind that it is a World T20 year, and Pakistan had core players for the last 3 years who brought them to #1 position and this winning formula was just broken by Misbah with his useless selection policies. While other teams are settling the core players for the World T20, Pakistan on the other hand is breaking the team of settled core players. Lets just hope sense prevails and the winning formula is brought back before the World T20.