mominsaigol
Senior Test Player
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2021
- Runs
- 29,862
- Post of the Week
- 2
Its cute that you're assuming i am going to read this.The dynamics between US and India are fundamentally different from those between the US and Pakistan and for good reason.
Historically, the US has seen Pakistan as a more agreeable and easily manageable strategic partner in South Asia. Pakistan has often been treated as a pliable geopolitical asset one that can be leveraged and controlled. Even then, the relationship has been turbulent. Nonetheless Pakistan’s military elite and geopolitical location have made it a convenient partner for specific American interests.
In contrast, India has never fit that mould and never will hopefully. The US has occasionally attempted to draw India into a similar strategic embrace, envisioning it as a counterweight to China or as a junior partner in their Indo-Pacific strategy. But these efforts have mostly fallen short. India’s deep-rooted democratic institutions fawed as they may be are far too strong and independent to allow any government to compromise national sovereignty. In fact governments in India will fall on mere allegations of foreign appeasement. The Indian public and political system have little tolerance for the idea of becoming a vassal state. Hosting US military bases or allowing foreign control over Indian waters is simply not an option.
I have always seen some commentators from Pakistan claim their country is more “geopolitically lucrative” to the US due to its proximity to flashpoints like Iran, China, and Afghanistan. While it’s true that Pakistan sits in a volatile geography you would be naive to not acknowledge that India's geographic position is far more dominant. Just like we have a lot more oil reserves too but we have been pragmatic about the fact that they're not viable enough to start drilling.
India possesses a massive, three-sided coastline and a network of over a thousand islands that give us unrivaled reach and control across the Indian Ocean. It is the only country in the region with the capability to project power across both its land borders and maritime frontiers. The Indian Ocean is India’s sphere of influence, and any power looking to dominate the region must either court India or confront it.
India is not less valuable to the US; it is simply not for sale.
This is what truly irks American strategists. Knowing that they cannot own India. Yet they cannot afford to ignore it either. India is a gigantic market. With a population of over 1.5 billion, India is on track to become the world’s largest consumer base. This is why the US is desperate to open up Indian agriculture and dairy sectors for their exports. The real prize for them is not what India produces but what India consumes. This is where many Indians misunderstand the power dynamic. They ask: What do we have to offer the US? We don’t have rare earths like China.But the truth is that India doesn’t need to sell a damn thing to assert itself. We are becoming the world's biggest buyers and that is a far greater flex. For decades, the US itself has wielded global dominance not through what it exports, but by being the largest and most lucrative importer. Being a consumer superpower comes with immense strategic clout. It forces nations to compete for your favor.
People often assume exporters are more powerful. Sometimes, yes especially when they manipulate supply chains or control scarce resources. But those tactics rarely last. Sellers can hold the world hostage only in artificially created monopolies. The real world is dynamic. If China halts the export of rare earth metals, the rest of the world will simply diversify supply, as we've already seen with joint mining treaties forming globally in the last few years. When the West denied software to China, China built its own. Buyers, on the other hand have a sustainable form of leverage. Everyone wants access to a large, dependable, and growing market. That is why global arms manufacturers are chasing Indian contracts for jets, submarines, and missiles. That is why American dairy lobbies are practically begging for market access. This is the economic muscle of a billion-plus people and it’s only growing & India is just beginning to wield this power. And the desperation from other countries is already showing. Even superpowers cannot ignore this kind of demographic and economic gravity.
The US hasn’t been able to contain much smaller, far more isolated nations like Iran or Russia. So the idea that they can somehow tame or control a vast and democratic behemoth like India is delusional. India may not be easy to manage but it’s impossible to ignore. And that right there is our ultimate strategic advantage.
Bruh, tone down the text volume.