What's new

[VIDEO] Babar Azam has to be removed as captain from all formats

Who would replace him?

Shadab in T20s?
Rizwan ODIs?

Who in Tests?
 
Saj said:
Who would replace him?

Shadab in T20s?
Rizwan ODIs?

Who in Tests?
Click to expand...

The cupboard is pretty bare. I liked what I saw from Shaheen as LQ captain, however you can’t give the captaincy to a quick whose workload needs to be judiciously managed.

I do like the idea of Shadab in T20s as long as he has real power, I.e. the ability to break up that RizBab top order. Mostly they need a very very good coach to guide the captain. Babar arguably hasn’t had that yet for Pakistan.
 
Giving it to Shaheen will be an Ultra positive aggressive move.
 
Forum363 said:
Shan. Utilise his purple patch, he’ll give Pakistan 3 good years.
Click to expand...

Yes, people talk about Shaan's so great test average in the past, but he is in great form now. Azhar had good average in the past now he is just a liability.
 
12 months of home Test cricket and not a single win. Time for Babar to either resign (unlikely as he has no shame), or be sacked.
 
I think we dont play test cricket for few months and people will forget about test captaincy for now. Unlikely he will be removed when we have ODI WC later this year
 
No win in the last 8 matches. All draws or loses.

He can’t bat and captain at the same time. He’s compromising his batting ability by being under pressure as captain all the time because he’s not good enough in that role. Possibly buckled in yet another 2nd innings today due to that reason.

It’s time.

Vacate the position or you will be removed forcibly.
 
Yes remove him but don't pick a player who is not a garranteed starter such as Masood as captain.
.
 
A question asked of him in the presser

Babar Azam: "You probably know better about who is getting captaincy, I am not aware of it"

<div style="width: 100%; height: 0px; position: relative; padding-bottom: 49.057%;"><iframe src="https://streamable.com/e/f9670h" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="100%" allowfullscreen style="width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;"></iframe></div>
 
MenInG said:
A question asked of him in the presser

Babar Azam: "You probably know better about who is getting captaincy, I am not aware of it"

<div style="width: 100%; height: 0px; position: relative; padding-bottom: 49.057%;"><iframe src="https://streamable.com/e/f9670h" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="100%" allowfullscreen style="width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;"></iframe></div>
Click to expand...

Fair response to the question
 
Saj said:
Who would replace him?

Shadab in T20s?
Rizwan ODIs?

Who in Tests?
Click to expand...

I think it's clear now - Sarfraz should replace Babar in all formats. He's a much better captain and he's in good form. Babar should focus on being a "no.1 batsman in all formats" as that is his main goal.
 
Babar Azam's All-Format Captaincy To Face Scrutiny In PCB Review: Report

As per a media report:

After a dismal home season, Pakistan cricket is preparing for a thorough evaluation of its squad structures, which may lead to changes in the captaincy.

The interim selection committee was established by the present PCB administration, which is itself a provisional arrangement. Saqlain Mushtaq, the head coach of the national men's team, is expected to resign after his contract expires in February.

It seems that changes are already afoot with Shadab Khan, Babar's regular deputy who is sidelined with a finger injury, replaced as vice-captain of the ODI team by Shan Masood, who was appointed by Sethi who has expressed a clear interest in Shan's inclusion in the XI.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Things are not good. The Babar lobby in the team and the players agents and the anti Babar lobby in the PCB are going to get into a serious tussle. It is sad that at this stage of his career, Babar is getting involved in all this, he should see the writing on the wall and just step down from the captaincy in a self respecting manner. What is more important for him? Retaining the Pakistani captaincy by hook or crook even if he is unwanted or playing for Pakistan and giving his best as a batsman?
 
ex-q-zit said:
Babar Azam's All-Format Captaincy To Face Scrutiny In PCB Review: Report

As per a media report:

After a dismal home season, Pakistan cricket is preparing for a thorough evaluation of its squad structures, which may lead to changes in the captaincy.

The interim selection committee was established by the present PCB administration, which is itself a provisional arrangement. Saqlain Mushtaq, the head coach of the national men's team, is expected to resign after his contract expires in February.

It seems that changes are already afoot with Shadab Khan, Babar's regular deputy who is sidelined with a finger injury, replaced as vice-captain of the ODI team by Shan Masood, who was appointed by Sethi who has expressed a clear interest in Shan's inclusion in the XI.
Click to expand...

The beginning of the end of Babar’s era as captain
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Savak said:
Things are not good. The Babar lobby in the team and the players agents and the anti Babar lobby in the PCB are going to get into a serious tussle. It is sad that at this stage of his career, Babar is getting involved in all this, he should see the writing on the wall and just step down from the captaincy in a self respecting manner. What is more important for him? Retaining the Pakistani captaincy by hook or crook even if he is unwanted or playing for Pakistan and giving his best as a batsman?
Click to expand...


As far as I think, Babar will never let go off captaincy.. he will be admanant on retaining captaincy..unless he is sacked..

One thing which PCB has done wrong is get Shan as VC, when he wasnt even part of ODIs earlier.. i think PCB should look at Shadab as future ODI and T 20 captain, instead of Shan..
 

ODIs:
Best Win/Loss ration among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 20 or more ODIs.



T20Is:
2nd Best Win/Loss ration among all main tams Captains who have lead in 40 or more T20Is. He has better win/loss record that Dhoni, Kohli and Morgan.



With this ODI and T20I captaincy record, it would an extremely foolish/ridiculus/stupid decision by PCB and the selectors if they remove Babar from white ball captaincy.
 

Attachments

  • CRIC-03.jpg
    CRIC-03.jpg
    385.7 KB · Views: 308
  • CRIC-02.jpg
    CRIC-02.jpg
    330.1 KB · Views: 306
W63L35 said:

ODIs:
Best Win/Loss ration among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 20 or more ODIs.



T20Is:
2nd Best Win/Loss ration among all main tams Captains who have lead in 40 or more T20Is. He has better win/loss record that Dhoni, Kohli and Morgan.



With this ODI and T20I captaincy record, it would an extremely foolish/ridiculus/stupid decision by PCB and the selectors if they remove Babar from white ball captaincy.
Click to expand...

Oh chall mera praa!

The record is inflated with results against B/C string sides
 
Rana said:
The record is inflated with results against B/C string sides
Click to expand...

Are you saying other captains never played against B/C string sides...... or PCB espcially arranged matches against B/C string sides for Babar make his captaincy record looks as good as it does now? :)


Rana said:
Oh chall mera praa!
Click to expand...
Kithay challan?? :)

By the way, any relations to Rana Naveed Ul Hasan (the Cricketer) Or Rana Sana Ullah (The politician)? :P
 
W63L35 said:
Are you saying other captains never played against B/C string sides...... or PCB espcially arranged matches against B/C string sides for Babar make his captaincy record looks as good as it does now? :)



Kithay challan?? :)

By the way, any relations to Rana Naveed Ul Hasan (the Cricketer) Or Rana Sana Ullah (The politician)? :P
Click to expand...

What I’m saying is please don’t use a questionable record against weak sides to suggest it would be silly to remove Babar

Inzimam had a good ODI captaincy record and there was no concept of playing significantly weakened or developing players side in his era. Babar’s record as captain will always be questionable in this era, especially considering he was playing his full strength side against those teams that he won against.

And I’m not related to any of them. I am a brand in my own right
 
Rana said:
What I’m saying is please don’t use a questionable record against weak sides to suggest it would be silly to remove Babar
Click to expand...
Which part of Babar's record is questionable and it is not for other captains on the list? Do you see me use different selection criteria for Babar vs other captains?

Rana said:
Inzimam had a good ODI captaincy record and there was no concept of playing significantly weakened or developing players side in his era. Babar’s record as captain will always be questionable in this era, especially considering he was playing his full strength side against those teams that he won against.
Click to expand...

Almost all captains on this list are from this era.... Morgan, Kohli, Sharma, Sammy, Finch, Williamson..... what are you talking about Rana [The Brand of your Own] Sahib?
 

Attachments

  • CRIC-02.jpg
    CRIC-02.jpg
    330.1 KB · Views: 290
W63L35 said:
Which part of Babar's record is questionable and it is not for other captains on the list? Do you see me use different selection criteria for Babar vs other captains?



Almost all captains on this list are from this era.... Morgan, Kohli, Sharma, Sammy, Finch, Williamson..... what are you talking about Rana [The Brand of your Own] Sahib?
Click to expand...

I genuinely can’t see the list on my phone

But I don’t need to. Just like I don’t need to see Shan Masood or Rizwan’s list A stats to tell you they will amount to nothing in international cricket
 
Rana said:
I genuinely can’t see the list on my phone
Click to expand...

So you were calling the list questionable without even being able to look at it????????
:D Thanks for making me laugh!

Rana said:
But I don’t need to.
Click to expand...

I am sorry, but what would you do/think if I called you ugly and fat when I have never seen you? :)

I will wait for your comments after you have looked at both lists... ODIs and T20Is.
 
W63L35 said:
So you were calling the list questionable without even being able to look at it????????
:D Thanks for making me laugh!



I am sorry, but what would you do/think if I called you ugly and fat when I have never seen you? :)

I will wait for your comments after you have looked at both lists... ODIs and T20Is.
Click to expand...

By all means call me what you want, just like I can tell you that NO STATISTIC right now will justify Babar to continue as a captain. He is a yaara da yaar captain. Not a leader
 
W63L35 said:
So you were calling the list questionable without even being able to look at it????????
:D Thanks for making me laugh!



I am sorry, but what would you do/think if I called you ugly and fat when I have never seen you? :)

I will wait for your comments after you have looked at both lists... ODIs and T20Is.
Click to expand...

the pictures and what people see in front of them weigh a lot more than just the stats/numbers on a piece of paper. Everyone knows about Babar's incompetency and we don't need no numbers to justify otherwise.
 
Rana said:
By all means call me what you want, just like I can tell you that NO STATISTIC right now will justify Babar to continue as a captain. He is a yaara da yaar captain. Not a leader
Click to expand...

Who should be the captain of odi team?
 
ArabKnight said:
I wonder when they release the T10 format, is Rizwan going to become captain of it and play as an opener anchor specialist.
Click to expand...

Whatever it is, the time to get this over and done with is now.

Let’s leave nothing to what could have been.
 
Rana said:
Whatever it is, the time to get this over and done with is now.

Let’s leave nothing to what could have been.
Click to expand...

To save time, we can introduce multiple captains simultaneously instead of Rizwan in all 3.

Rizwan in some format, Shan in another format.

I wonder what kind of record will lead them to being dropped by the PCB for 4 years.

Perhaps an ICC trophy, consecutive 11 T20 series wins, Test Series Draw in England?
 
Rana said:
You would rather have Asif Ali as captain instead of Rizwan?
Click to expand...

I wasn’t the one calling for Asif Ali as a captain. My views are very clear on Asif Ali as a batsmen. So what’s changed for you from Asif Ali to rizwan?
 
PakEngFan said:
I wasn’t the one calling for Asif Ali as a captain. My views are very clear on Asif Ali as a batsmen. So what’s changed for you from Asif Ali to rizwan?
Click to expand...

I don’t know, I’m bored. I want Rizwan to be Barbecued by Karachi press
 
[MENTION=2016]Rana[/MENTION]

PCB making Rizwan captain is a very plausible action that could happen.

Tell me if I am correct in my assessment.

I think Rizwan will be a slightly more bearable captain than Babar. He will have the same dodgy game and play tactics. But he will be a massive improvement in communication and charisma on the field and locker room.

It might actually bearable to watch Pakistan matches with him leading the side.
 
Rana said:
No. I call the shots
Click to expand...

I can see that with Pakistan greatest wk playing for a while and one of our greatest player being our captain who both are the guys you hate the most and yet you can’t do anything about it. Come on Rana it must hurt. Be honest for once. Allah knows what’s inside the heart.
 
W63L35 said:

ODIs:
Best Win/Loss ration among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 20 or more ODIs.



T20Is:
2nd Best Win/Loss ration among all main tams Captains who have lead in 40 or more T20Is. He has better win/loss record that Dhoni, Kohli and Morgan.



With this ODI and T20I captaincy record, it would an extremely foolish/ridiculus/stupid decision by PCB and the selectors if they remove Babar from white ball captaincy.
Click to expand...


Incredible posts. It is extremely unfortunate that only fans from other nations recognize how good Babar has been for our team.
 
PakEngFan said:
I can see that with Pakistan greatest wk playing for a while and one of our greatest player being our captain who both are the guys you hate the most and yet you can’t do anything about it. Come on Rana it must hurt. Be honest for once. Allah knows what’s inside the heart.
Click to expand...

I have seen enough matches to know that Sarfraz is a true lion hearted cricketer that was unjustly dropped by PCB and replaced by non performing and selfish players of all sorts.

That is why Pakistan Cricket keeps losing series after series. Nepotism and corruption is in control.
 
ArabKnight said:
I wonder when they release the T10 format, is Rizwan going to become captain of it and play as an opener anchor specialist.
Click to expand...

We can send any tom dick or harry to play t10s. The best should be reserved for the truer formats
 
Savak said:
Team Unity is irrelevant if the results are non existent. This is not a union.
Click to expand...

Please check out post # 183 above. You will see more results than you might have ever imagined! :)

By the way, how are you? Long time.....!! :)
 
W63L35 said:

ODIs:
Best Win/Loss ration among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 20 or more ODIs.



T20Is:
2nd Best Win/Loss ration among all main tams Captains who have lead in 40 or more T20Is. He has better win/loss record that Dhoni, Kohli and Morgan.



With this ODI and T20I captaincy record, it would an extremely foolish/ridiculus/stupid decision by PCB and the selectors if they remove Babar from white ball captaincy.
Click to expand...

Very questionable use of Stats.

For T20s, If you remove minnows, Babar has the third worst W/L ratio of all captains that have captained in 40 plus matches
 
Sidilicious said:
Very questionable use of Stats.

For T20s, If you remove minnows, Babar has the third worst W/L ratio of all captains that have captained in 40 plus matches
Click to expand...

Every captain in the world has it's fair share of wins against minnows.

Plus how do you define minnow in T20s these days? Any team can beat any given day. See below a few recent results - especially BD trashing Aus/NZ and Ireland beating the world champions Eng in the WC.
 

Attachments

  • Cric-05.jpg
    Cric-05.jpg
    218.3 KB · Views: 260
Best win/loss ratio among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 100 or more international matches.
 

Attachments

  • Cric-04.jpg
    Cric-04.jpg
    239.6 KB · Views: 257
World Captains with 100 or more international matches - all formats combined.


Only 9 out of 46 captains have better Win/Loss Ratio than Babar.


.
 

Attachments

  • Cric-05.jpg
    Cric-05.jpg
    340.9 KB · Views: 257
Let babar captain WC
Shadab can be T20 captain

Test - their is no long term option at the moment. Let babar continue

Just no Shan masood please
 
I’m expecting big fireworks in the coming weeks. Most likely three captains for three formats. The Babar mafia will be out in full swing, player loyalties will be tested, cliques will form. It’s 1995 all over again, Puraana Pakistan has returned!
 
W63L35 said:
Every captain in the world has it's fair share of wins against minnows.

Plus how do you define minnow in T20s these days? Any team can beat any given day. See below a few recent results - especially BD trashing Aus/NZ and Ireland beating the world champions Eng in the WC.
Click to expand...

Bangladesh have been a decent side only for the last couple of years. And the end result is not even close. If you remove the wins against afg, Ireland, Zimbabwe, Bangladesh who habe only been a decent side recently, his w/l is the third worst captain. That completely changes the story.

Let people choose what they make of the stats. 3rd worst captain when you exclude AFG, IRL, ZIM, BAN, or 2nd best when you include those 4.

I don’t care about Babar as a captain or not. I am just pointing out how stats can be misleading.
 
Im not a fan of Babar’s captaincy, but id rather him every single day then suffer the stupidity of Shan Masood as captain

It will be azhar ali all over again but even worse. Dad’s Dream is now Yes Man, thats the only reason Sethi is pushing for him


If it happens, i hope the team revolts
 
The question shouldn’t be about just removing Babar, the question should be about who replaces him?

Pakistan cricket can never have a captain who is not performing. The idiots on this forum advocating the removal of Babar, will be the same ones attacking whoever replaces him in a few months.

Also, there is no ‘leader’ in this team nor in domestic cricket. They are all mentally weak cricketers, who are more worried about themselves and their spot rather than the team.
 
Savak said:
Team Unity is irrelevant if the results are non existent. This is not a union.
Click to expand...
At least the current team is better than previous teams, i have never seen this much consistency in short formats sunce 2007
 
pakistanigoneaussie said:
Im not a fan of Babar’s captaincy, but id rather him every single day then suffer the stupidity of Shan Masood as captain

It will be azhar ali all over again but even worse. Dad’s Dream is now Yes Man, thats the only reason Sethi is pushing for him


If it happens, i hope the team revolts
Click to expand...

Think you may have to answer to those who are saying that the new administration is run by those with the best motives.
 
It is becoming clear Babar is a selfish player/captain. He is just focused on getting runs under his belt, no matter if the team is losing.
The trait of making your best player captain has to be taken away.
 
Why is babar taking all the crap from PCB. He is a world class batsmen should come openly and say he is being forced to select such players .
 
W63L35 said:
Why? On what basis? What has Babar done worng as T20 Captain? He took us to T20 World Cup FINAL!!! Didn't he?
Click to expand...
No he didn’t it’s Netherlands who took you to final . Pakistan played crap . Lost against Zimbabwe chasing some 130 . How crap is that .
Babar only did good in 2021 t20 WC .
 
Last edited:
W63L35 said:
Best win/loss ratio among all Pakistani Captains who have lead in 100 or more international matches.
Click to expand...

Your a good poster, but this is quite a poor post that is agenda driven

So Inzimam and Imran captained Pakistan for 40 odd T20is as well?
 
ArabKnight said:
[MENTION=2016]Rana[/MENTION]

PCB making Rizwan captain is a very plausible action that could happen.

Tell me if I am correct in my assessment.

I think Rizwan will be a slightly more bearable captain than Babar. He will have the same dodgy game and play tactics. But he will be a massive improvement in communication and charisma on the field and locker room.

It might actually bearable to watch Pakistan matches with him leading the side.
Click to expand...

I think you are right but it wont be fun to watch Pakistan play because they will still lose, and your character as a captain changes with losses.
 
Not working for Babar

<div style="width: 100%; height: 0px; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.250%;"><iframe src="https://streamable.com/e/2sw57m" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="100%" allowfullscreen style="width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;"></iframe></div>
 
To further add to the OP, another feather in Babar's cap

NZ 190/6, they still manage to chase down 281/8.

How many more matches are we going to lose under Babar's captaincy?

Also sports reporters have confirmed that Sethi has enough cricket knowledge to look beyond stats, even though Babar's T-20 and ODI captaincy stats look impressive on paper, Sethi knows that tactically Babar is a very poor captain and under his leadership Pakistan has lost a lot of games they should have won and this is why the PCB wants to replace him with some other alternative because the team desperately needs a tactically astute captain and cannot afford incompetency from the Captain any further
 
Pakistan recently at home:

Lost ODI series v New Zealand
Drawn Test series v New Zealand
Lost Test series v England
Lost T20I series v England
Lost Test series v Australia
 
Im all for Shadab to take over captaincy, but you cant have people who dont merit a place in the squad (Shan) as captain.
 
Shadab is injured every third game. Honestly, Shaheen would be my preferred choice as captain.
 
Pakistan is almost always mediocre at home since the mid 90s. Be it losing test series, ODI series or t20 series. This is just normal operating procedure.
 
Does he only attend press conferences and team celebration dinners when Pakistan win?

Why is he hiding?
 
Some advice for Babar if he wants to stay relevant:

While speaking on his YouTube channel, Ramiz said that Babar Azam & Co. should take a leaf out of India’s book and try to dominate oppositions at home.

“It's tough to beat India in India. This is something to learn for other sub-continent teams, including Pakistan. It's because Pakistan have enough potential, but the home performance in terms of results or series wins is not as consistent as Team India. This is an important milestone for India in the World Cup year,”
 
Basit Ali has suggested that fast bowler Shaheen Afridi should take over as Pakistan's ODI and Test cricket captain as long as he remains fit. Another option for T20I cricket captaincy is Shadab Khan.

"Babar Azam should quit captaincy. If he leaves captaincy, he will break all records and surpass records made by greats in the game. His captaincy is affecting his performance with the bat, and he should focus on his batting," said Basit Ali.

"Shaheen Afridi should be Pakistan's captain. Shaheen can lead Pakistan in ODI and Test cricket if he remains fit. Shadab Khan could be Pakistan's choice as captain in T20I cricket," he maintained.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
PCB dismisses captaincy rumours as “baseless ” amid media speculation [Update @ post #127]
2
Replies
145
Views
6K
Savak
Savak
Ball Blazer
[EXCLUSIVE] "It would be a great injustice to end Babar Azam, Mohammad Rizwan and Shaheen Shah Afridi’s T20I career”: Tanvir Ahmed
Replies
3
Views
806
MenInG
MenInG
M
[VIDEO] PakPassion Exclusive Documentary: Babar Azam - A Decade of Promise, Sacrifice and Unfulfilled Dreams
Replies
9
Views
689
RidiculousMan
RidiculousMan
mominsaigol
Pakistan Fans, Honest Question: How would you feel if Babar Azam & Mohammad Rizwan were to make their return to the Pakistani side?
2
Replies
123
Views
5K
Ball Blazer
Ball Blazer
mominsaigol
[PICTURES] A message for Babar Azam and his fans: Focus on ODIs and retire from Test and T20I
2 3 4
Replies
311
Views
14K
BouncerGuy
BouncerGuy
Back
Top