What's new

[VIDEO] Rapists should be publicly hanged, chemically castrated: PM Imran Khan

What should be the punishment for rapists?


  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
[utube]qkIML9lDpeY[/utube]

Prime Minister Imran Khan says rapists should be handed down the most severe punishments to curb rising sexual violence in the country, such as either hanging them publicly or chemically castrating them.


The premier expressed the views during an interview with Moeed Pirzada on 92 News HD broadcast on Monday, in response to a question about the motorway gang-rape case that caused an outpouring of anger across the country and brought sexual violence against women into national focus.

Prime Minister Imran said the motorway rape had "shaken the entire nation" because the victim could have been anyone's sister or daughter.

He said he was "shocked" to find out from police that sex crimes in the country were rising greatly.

"They (rapists) should be given exemplary punishments. In my opinion, they should be hanged at the chowk (piazza)," he said, adding that this punishment should be reserved for rapists and those who abuse children.

"Unforunately, when we had the discussion, [we were] told it would not be internationally acceptable," he said of public hangings. "They said the GSP-Plus trade status given to us by the European Union will be affected."

He said another option was to "chemically or surgically castrate" rapists, according to the degree of the crime, "as is done by many countries".

Prime Minister Imran noted that the primary suspect in the motorway rape, Abid Ali, was previously involved in a gang-rape in 2013 as well. "We need fresh legislation to permanently sterlise such [criminals]," he said.

The premier regretted that there was no registry of sex offenders in the country, which led to a convicted pedophile from a European country entering Pakistan and sexually abusing children here.

He said sexual crimes should be fought by the entire society, and not just police. "World history tells when you increase fahashi (vulgarity) in the society, two things happen: sex crimes increase and the family system breaks down," he added.

Citing an example, he said the divorce rate in England shot up to 70 per cent at present as vulgarity increased there.

Compared to the West, "our family system is intact. We can fix our justice system and the institutions but if our family system breaks down, we will not be able to rebuild it," the premier stressed, saying New Delhi too has become the "rape capital" of the world due to obscenity in Bollywood.

He said he had pushed for Turkish blockbuster Ertuğrul to be broadcast on Pakistani television because he wanted to prove that Islamic and historical family programmes could be popular in the country too.

'Opportunity' to fix Karachi's woes

Among other issues discussed during the interview, the prime minister also shed light on government's efforts to resolve Karachi's municipal and infrastructure issues.

Asked about the wrangling between the federal and Sindh governments over the Rs1.1 trillion package announced for Karachi by him, Imran said: "I am not aware of Sindh government's problems. But I know after the [post-rain] devastation in Karachi, all the stakeholders sat and decided to resolve Karachi's main issues of water supply, waste disposal, sewerage, transport and cleaning nullahs."

"Karachi is Pakistan's engine of growth. When Karachi sneezes, the entire Pakistan catches cold," he added.

He said the recent losses caused by torrential rains in the city had become an "opportunity" to fix its problems, adding that all stakeholders had been given the deadline of three years to complete the tasks that are part of the Karachi Transformation Plan.

In response to a question, he said grievances regarding Karachi's census could be valid, but questioned whether now was the time for a recount of the city's population. The main issue, he added, is how to run cities like Karachi so they generate their own funds and fix their own issues.

The prime minister said Karachi was "non-functional" because the provincial government was elected from rural Sindh and controls the funds, while Karachi has no empowered system of its own.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/307909-punjabs-police-and-bureaucracy-have-been-politicised-pm-imran
 
Last edited:
Rape is a terrible thing. However what the pm is outrageous and barbaric.
 
IK is a *****, world has moved on from midevil law and order model. Who even talk about such primitive punishments in 21C ?? 🙄🙄🙄

Why more danda is default answer for Pakistanis?? - You need to build culture of self respect and dignity. You don’t need to lower your self to the level of criminals. Rest of the world has moved away from violent punishments as a means of deterrence. This has many benefits, you want to build a modern society not a midevil one.
 
Something like a kala pani confinement.

Is there an island big enough at a distance of 20-30 km away from our seashores ?

Murder is a crime case of murderer vs murdered. State can't do anything against criminal If family of murdered person forgive the murderer
Rape is a crime case of state vs culprit. Even if victim forgive the culprit, case still goes on because its a crime against state.
 
Provided only when guilt has been proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
 
IK is a *****, world has moved on from midevil law and order model. Who even talk about such primitive punishments in 21C ?? ������

Why more danda is default answer for Pakistanis?? - You need to build culture of self respect and dignity. You don’t need to lower your self to the level of criminals. Rest of the world has moved away from violent punishments as a means of deterrence. This has many benefits, you want to build a modern society not a midevil one.

But isnt a good example enough to scare people from doing this?
 
Tough jail sentence with rehabilitation. There has to be some chance of redemption, else the state is merely seeking revenge.
 
I believe rapists should be executed. I voted for death.
 
Last edited:
None of this deter would be a rapist. If hanging or anything similar would have eliminated rapist then there would be no rapist already.

Punishment and creating a database that would keep them isolated and also alert those in the vicinity, movement would restricted, all of which unlikely to happen in Pakistan, but none of this would end rape cases if this is the intention of hanging or castrating.
 
IK is a *****, world has moved on from midevil law and order model. Who even talk about such primitive punishments in 21C ?? ������

Why more danda is default answer for Pakistanis?? - You need to build culture of self respect and dignity. You don’t need to lower your self to the level of criminals. Rest of the world has moved away from violent punishments as a means of deterrence. This has many benefits, you want to build a modern society not a midevil one.

IK is a great man, please watch your words when talking about one of Pakistans greatest ever citizens.

Your idea of a modern society is one where the invidual has more rights than society.

Your modern idea is based on modern western civilisation. Peodophila is rampant in this society, you have actors, singers, politcians and even royals involved but most of these are never bought to justice.

Its backward to protect peaods as the west has been doing for decades, esp those in positions of power and influence.

Its civilised to say in a society we will not tolerate such evil people and we will make sure they are never able to hurt another child again.

It seems in your modern day civilised world, you want to protect such evil people in the name of being enlightned. Wake up, your view is backward and disgusting!
 
Last edited:
Chemically castrate for a year and then hanging. So that they suffer.
 
None of this deter would be a rapist. If hanging or anything similar would have eliminated rapist then there would be no rapist already.

Punishment and creating a database that would keep them isolated and also alert those in the vicinity, movement would restricted, all of which unlikely to happen in Pakistan, but none of this would end rape cases if this is the intention of hanging or castrating.

Nobody is talking about castration as a means of deterrence. It is being talked about as a means of punishment, so that they pay for their actions in this life only. They used their male organ as a weapon then it is only fair that they are deprived off it.
 
No amount of punishment will stop Rape.

However boys should be taught from childhood to respect the opposite sex. Boys and girls should mingle and understand each other.

Sex should not be a forbidden fruit. Only then can tapes be controlled to a great extend imo.
 
Chemically castrate for a year and then hanging. So that they suffer.

Simple but I say no to public execution that's sounds like midevil or Panchayat justice to me
 
Rape is not a good thing, before jumping up and down please read this http://www.angryharry.com/Truth-Abo...n__8V0pvJh7t69IjEZOBqQRFroqBTA7GQTPpiUD1gVAxo
What will happen, mass destruction, society will become a warzone.
Recently during lockdown below stats were presented
https://themalefactor.com/2020/05/31/unicef-fake-narrative-lockdown-domestic-violence-exposed/
So thats not the solution of the problem, education, tough jail and rehabilitation is the only way to go :)

You cannot rehabiliate a peado, the only way is to castrate them and tag their whearabouts but why waste taxpayers money when you can get a rope for $2.99 from Walmart?
 
No amount of punishment will stop Rape.

However boys should be taught from childhood to respect the opposite sex. Boys and girls should mingle and understand each other.

Sex should not be a forbidden fruit. Only then can tapes be controlled to a great extend imo.

I agree with this.

I would let them rot in a small cell with no human contact, for the rest of their lives so they get mentally insane and tortured.

I would also teach men in our society respect and remove the stigma attached with sexual crimes. Improving security for the citizens would also help.
 
You cannot rehabiliate a peado, the only way is to castrate them and tag their whearabouts but why waste taxpayers money when you can get a rope for $2.99 from Walmart?

100%. Paedophiles should never be let out or given second chances, they ruin someones' lives forever.
 
Should be hanged. Death punishment is the best for rapist. And also immediate decision if proofs are sufficient.

No point in dragging case for years and years.

Rape punishment should be strict. I agree with PM here.

For most of the people, it looks like barbaric act e.t.c e.t.c, but ask from the people who have faced such situation. When a girl is raped, her whole life gets destroyed due to these bloody animals, even animals are better than such humans.

There should not be any sort of mercy towards these people. Death penalty is best.
 
If the PM has said this then its quite outrageous he thinks this is a suitable punishment

Babaric as these crimes are the state has a duty to provide justice Not conduct or encourage violent retribution

Id have expected a lot better from someone of his standing and position
 
100%. Paedophiles should never be let out or given second chances, they ruin someones' lives forever.

Sex offender absconds from HMP Leyhill after day working in Bristol

https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/bristol-news/ronan-korby-lee-watersworth-prison-2930660

In the UK they can walk out of jail, this is the human rights we have given them, makes a mockery of the victim and society we live in.

Also why hasnt the Queen ordered Andrew to go the US and answer any questions which will help the victims and help the truth come out? The Queen is protecting an alleged Peado! [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] any answers to this?
 
IK is a great man, please watch your words when talking about one of Pakistans greatest ever citizens.

Your idea of a modern society is one where the invidual has more rights than society.

Your modern idea is based on modern western civilisation. Peodophila is rampant in this society, you have actors, singers, politcians and even royals involved but most of these are never bought to justice.

Its backward to protect peaods as the west has been doing for decades, esp those in positions of power and influence.

Its civilised to say in a society we will not tolerate such evil people and we will make sure they are never able to hurt another child again.

It seems in your modern day civilised world, you want to protect such evil people in the name of being enlightned. Wake up, your view is backward and disgusting!

Quite the reverse, it is predicated on the 2000-year Christian virtue of forgiveness.

A person commits a crime. They are given a fair trial and humanely jailed. After a time, if they are truly penitent and no longer considered a threat to society, they are released.
 
If the PM has said this then its quite outrageous he thinks this is a suitable punishment

Babaric as these crimes are the state has a duty to provide justice Not conduct or encourage violent retribution

Id have expected a lot better from someone of his standing and position

End their life and ensuring no other child is hurt is justice. What do you want, give them a good talking to and slap on the wrist? Please detail your solution to punish?
 
https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/bristol-news/ronan-korby-lee-watersworth-prison-2930660

In the UK they can walk out of jail, this is the human rights we have given them, makes a mockery of the victim and society we live in.

Also why hasnt the Queen ordered Andrew to go the US and answer any questions which will help the victims and help the truth come out? The Queen is protecting an alleged Peado! [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] any answers to this?

Have you seen Andrew's interview?

You'll be stunned at how obvious he is
 
https://www.bristolpost.co.uk/news/bristol-news/ronan-korby-lee-watersworth-prison-2930660

In the UK they can walk out of jail, this is the human rights we have given them, makes a mockery of the victim and society we live in.

Also why hasnt the Queen ordered Andrew to go the US and answer any questions which will help the victims and help the truth come out? The Queen is protecting an alleged Peado! [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] any answers to this?

The Queen doesn’t have that power.

I think the Prince should face his accusers. If he is innocent, he will clear his name. Or he may provide information to allow conviction of more offenders.
 
Quite the reverse, it is predicated on the 2000-year Christian virtue of forgiveness.

A person commits a crime. They are given a fair trial and humanely jailed. After a time, if they are truly penitent and no longer considered a threat to society, they are released.

A peado will always be a risk to society.

Please accept the green is grass and the sky is blue, along with western society has peados in high positions which are protected. Heck some of the most powerful people visited an island which has a temple dedicated to peadophila. Prince Andrew is being protected by the Queen and government.

Peadophilia is rampant and has been in the higher classes of western society for centuries. West is not moving forward or being civilised, it has taken this sick abuse to a level of acceptance in society because the elites all do it.
 
The Queen doesn’t have that power.

I think the Prince should face his accusers. If he is innocent, he will clear his name. Or he may provide information to allow conviction of more offenders.

The Queen has a moral duty to send him. Would you not send your son if he is accused of such sick crimes and would you not want him to be aquitted?Of course if you know he is guilty and protect him, you are no better than him.

How can he face his accusers if he wont go the US? Where is the public outcry, where is Tommy Robinson?
 
That's good but what about those who falsely accuse others of a rape or threaten to trap someone in a rape case if their demands are not met? There should be an equal punishment for them also. :inti
 
Have you seen Andrew's interview?

You'll be stunned at how obvious he is

Ive seen a lot of evidene against him, guilty as hell. So it Clinton imo and also there are some very high profile figures who have yet to be mentioned.

It so sad people defending such people because it might taint the free world, civilised world, land of ** etc.
 
Che. Castr is the best punishment let him live his rest of life in shame pain and mental illness
 
A peado will always be a risk to society.

Please accept the green is grass and the sky is blue, along with western society has peados in high positions which are protected. Heck some of the most powerful people visited an island which has a temple dedicated to peadophila. Prince Andrew is being protected by the Queen and government.

Peadophilia is rampant and has been in the higher classes of western society for centuries. West is not moving forward or being civilised, it has taken this sick abuse to a level of acceptance in society because the elites all do it.

Always? All? You deal in universal statements, but the world is more complex.

There is no acceptance. The crime you refer to is repugnant to most.

Prison Officers I have spoken to say that some paedophile offenders can be redeemed with psychotherapy, and some others can at least be scared into avoiding situations where they cause more harm.
 
Always? All? You deal in universal statements, but the world is more complex.

There is no acceptance. The crime you refer to is repugnant to most.

Prison Officers I have spoken to say that some paedophile offenders can be redeemed with psychotherapy, and some others can at least be scared into avoiding situations where they cause more harm.

Yes Always, we have a sex offenders register after Megans law. The courts agreed people have the right to know if a sex offender is living nearby as they will always be a potential threat.
 
[MENTION=138254]Syed1[/MENTION] [MENTION=1269]Bewal Express[/MENTION] Today in senate, opposition reactions were like Who made the motor way? Who made the testing labs? Give credits to Shehbaz Sharif for making motorway and testing lab.

Seriously? Which kind of opposition or people are these? They arent even Humans to be honest.
 
End their life and ensuring no other child is hurt is justice. What do you want, give them a good talking to and slap on the wrist? Please detail your solution to punish?

You keep them under lock and key until theyve served their sentence and are no danger to anyone else

Thats how civilised countries behave Make them face and accept their deed Make them realise the lives they have ruined If they are ill treat them

If the state starts taking lives they are no better than the rapists and murderers of this world Their should be justice not retribuition

What happens if theirs a miscarriage of justice or they have a mental issue and you castrate or kill them?

The world should be moving on from medieval practices not going bsck to them
 
No amount of punishment will stop Rape.

However boys should be taught from childhood to respect the opposite sex. Boys and girls should mingle and understand each other.

Sex should not be a forbidden fruit. Only then can tapes be controlled to a great extend imo.

Agreed
 
The Queen has a moral duty to send him. Would you not send your son if he is accused of such sick crimes and would you not want him to be aquitted?Of course if you know he is guilty and protect him, you are no better than him.

How can he face his accusers if he wont go the US? Where is the public outcry, where is Tommy Robinson?

Please don’t elevate a fascist who hates Muslims as some sort of paragon of justice. The public outcry is seen in the ostracism of the Prince by all charities and the military.

Firstly remember that the Prince has not been accused of any crime.

Secondly, HM has no power to extradite anybody. You’re thinking of the Home Secretary.
 
Quite the reverse, it is predicated on the 2000-year Christian virtue of forgiveness.

A person commits a crime. They are given a fair trial and humanely jailed. After a time, if they are truly penitent and no longer considered a threat to society, they are released.

Well said
 
You keep them under lock and key until theyve served their sentence and are no danger to anyone else

Thats how civilised countries behave Make them face and accept their deed Make them realise the lives they have ruined If they are ill treat them

If the state starts taking lives they are no better than the rapists and murderers of this world Their should be justice not retribuition

What happens if theirs a miscarriage of justice or they have a mental issue and you castrate or kill them?

The world should be moving on from medieval practices not going bsck to them

This.
 
A peado will always be a risk to society

Please accept the green is grass and the sky is blue, along with western society has peados in high positions which are protected. Heck some of the most powerful people visited an island which has a temple dedicated to peadophila. Prince Andrew is being protected by the Queen and government.

Peadophilia is rampant and has been in the higher classes of western society for centuries. West is not moving forward or being civilised, it has taken this sick abuse to a level of acceptance in society because the elites all do it.

Pero is very rampant in Pakistan and Afghanistan. What’s your point. Baacha bazi is rampant. Religious school it’s rampant.
 
In religious schools it’s rampant. All this with most women still in a controlled segregated environment. You have to teach better values to kids. No segregation . All this will help not eliminate the problem. I don’t know if we can eliminate the problem.
 
In religious schools it’s rampant. All this with most women still in a controlled segregated environment. You have to teach better values to kids. No segregation . All this will help not eliminate the problem. I don’t know if we can eliminate the problem.

Why are there rapes in western countries then? It has nothing to do with segregation.
 
Last edited:
Yes Always, we have a sex offenders register after Megans law. The courts agreed people have the right to know if a sex offender is living nearby as they will always be a potential threat.

Not what I asked. By your use of universals you seem to suggest that all elites are paedophile offenders and no redemption of any such offender is ever possible. Both these statements are false. This type of offence crosses all racial and socioeconomic groups.

Megan’s Law does not apply in the U.K. and offenders hereare not required to inform people of their presence. There is a Violent and Sex Offenders Register (ViSOR) in the U.K. which police, prison service and probation service can access.
 
As I said it can’t be eliminated. Well not so far. Nobody is denying there is no rape in other countries. Eastern or western.
 
[MENTION=138254]Syed1[/MENTION] [MENTION=1269]Bewal Express[/MENTION] Today in senate, opposition reactions were like Who made the motor way? Who made the testing labs? Give credits to Shehbaz Sharif for making motorway and testing lab.

Seriously? Which kind of opposition or people are these? They arent even Humans to be honest.

As i said to one of the guys, these losers have no humanity, they will use any tragedy to worship their crooked heroes.
 
You keep them under lock and key until theyve served their sentence and are no danger to anyone else

Thats how civilised countries behave Make them face and accept their deed Make them realise the lives they have ruined If they are ill treat them

If the state starts taking lives they are no better than the rapists and murderers of this world Their should be justice not retribuition

What happens if theirs a miscarriage of justice or they have a mental issue and you castrate or kill them?

The world should be moving on from medieval practices not going bsck to them

These kind of words only sound good in fiction books and utopian movies. In real life, victims of rape want their rapists to die a dog's death and the state owes it to them. If we start feeding the monsters in jail and rehabilitate them using the taxes which the victim pays then that would add to the agony of the victim. However, there should be better policing so that miscarriage of justice is made improbable.
 
You keep them under lock and key until theyve served their sentence and are no danger to anyone else

Thats how civilised countries behave Make them face and accept their deed Make them realise the lives they have ruined If they are ill treat them

If the state starts taking lives they are no better than the rapists and murderers of this world Their should be justice not retribuition

What happens if theirs a miscarriage of justice or they have a mental issue and you castrate or kill them?

The world should be moving on from medieval practices not going bsck to them

lol. Taking a life of a criminal esp a rapist or peado doesnt make you a criminal and esp not a rapist or peado. If you're a Muslim you will know God has ordered this too.

Its just your opinion its medieval, for me allowing them to walk again is backward.

Make better courts.

Or if your rules apply, people in a free nation should be allowed to say no to prison. Are you happy to pay my taxes too to imprison these people for 20 odd years? No you wont.
 
Please don’t elevate a fascist who hates Muslims as some sort of paragon of justice. The public outcry is seen in the ostracism of the Prince by all charities and the military.

Firstly remember that the Prince has not been accused of any crime.

Secondly, HM has no power to extradite anybody. You’re thinking of the Home Secretary.

Yes he has, victims have said the Prince abused them. Please do keep up.

Government and Queen can make him go simply by saying he should go immediatley, they havent because they are protecting a peado because many of their mates are.

You seem all to laid about this, I know you defend everything British inc the war in Afghanistan and Iraq but this is too low even for you.
 
Robert. Prince Andrew has not been accused of a crime but I am willing to Bet my house he is guilty and being protected.
 
No, that's too far. Life in prison or death sentence. Castration will just drive them mental and lead to other crimes.
 
These kind of words only sound good in fiction books and utopian movies. In real life, victims of rape want their rapists to die a dog's death and the state owes it to them. If we start feeding the monsters in jail and rehabilitate them using the taxes which the victim pays then that would add to the agony of the victim. However, there should be better policing so that miscarriage of justice is made improbable.

Death doesnt take away the crime or the pain the victim feels It offers nothing They still have to live with what happened to them

The person should have his freedom taken away and live with the guilt of the crime hes committed

If you ask most educated rape victims they would want justice ie the victim tried found guilty and locked away so that they dont commit this act again and for them to acknowledge the wrong committed the lifes destroyed and try n atone for it

Theres a release behind that redemption in that
Hanging or killing them serves no purpose for the victim
 
theres a reason why most victims want to meet their perpetrator in the west in prison To see the guilt in his\her eyes, for them to apologise and be truly sorry

Only then can most move on with their lives
 
Virginia Giuffre, please educate yourself before touching a keyboard.
Mr king please read carefully before you type your verbal diarrhea. Andrew has not been accused by the authorities of any crime yet. As I said I am sure he is guilty and is being protected. Now grow a brain before you you touch a keyboard
 
People using the standards of the west to judge this statement. Let me remind you that the west used to have firing squads, guillotines and what not, before they got to a stage where a culprit is given a nice cushy jail cell with three hot meals and a tv. Try and do that in Pakistan and the voter base will bury you for giving a nice relaxing environment to the worst culprits and that too at the expense of the tax payers.


Things have to be taken at the country's context.
 
People using the standards of the west to judge this statement. Let me remind you that the west used to have firing squads, guillotines and what not, before they got to a stage where a culprit is given a nice cushy jail cell with three hot meals and a tv. Try and do that in Pakistan and the voter base will bury you for giving a nice relaxing environment to the worst culprits and that too at the expense of the tax payers.


Things have to be taken at the country's context.

This is all down to a lack of education Which is why im surprised someone like imran khan made the statements he did
 
This is all down to a lack of education Which is why im surprised someone like imran khan made the statements he did

I would GUESS imran said this for consumption of his far right base crowd
 
Yes he has, victims have said the Prince abused them. Please do keep up.

Government and Queen can make him go simply by saying he should go immediatley, they havent because they are protecting a peado because many of their mates are.

You seem all to laid about this, I know you defend everything British inc the war in Afghanistan and Iraq but this is too low even for you.

Those are not accusation, they are allegations. Accusations are levelled in court.

Neither Home Secretary nor Queen can make anyone go anywhere without due process, because this is not a police state. A Federal judge can request extradition, and in that case the Home Secretary will decide to extradite or not based on the evidence. That’s international law. But you’ll notice that no Federal judge has done so to date.
 
People using the standards of the west to judge this statement. Let me remind you that the west used to have firing squads, guillotines and what not, before they got to a stage where a culprit is given a nice cushy jail cell with three hot meals and a tv. Try and do that in Pakistan and the voter base will bury you for giving a nice relaxing environment to the worst culprits and that too at the expense of the tax payers.


Things have to be taken at the country's context.

British cells are not cushy; prisoners have to work to qualify for a TV; there’s only one hot meal per day; they are not relaxing but scary grim places with constant threat of violence.
 
Mr king please read carefully before you type your verbal diarrhea. Andrew has not been accused by the authorities of any crime yet. As I said I am sure he is guilty and is being protected. Now grow a brain before you you touch a keyboard

Those are not accusation, they are allegations. Accusations are levelled in court.

Neither Home Secretary nor Queen can make anyone go anywhere without due process, because this is not a police state. A Federal judge can request extradition, and in that case the Home Secretary will decide to extradite or not based on the evidence. That’s international law. But you’ll notice that no Federal judge has done so to date.

Accusations have been labelled on Andrew in court documents. The allegation is he had intimate relations with a number of under age girls all at once. Check the Giselle case. I know the difference between allegation and accused in law.
 
You keep them under lock and key until theyve served their sentence and are no danger to anyone else

Thats how civilised countries behave Make them face and accept their deed Make them realise the lives they have ruined If they are ill treat them

If the state starts taking lives they are no better than the rapists and murderers of this world Their should be justice not retribuition

What happens if theirs a miscarriage of justice or they have a mental issue and you castrate or kill them?

The world should be moving on from medieval practices not going bsck to them


None sense, firstly am certain you'd have a different view if you or your family were on the receiving end quiet literally. And secondly, the 'make them face and accept their deed' and 'until they are not a danger to anyone else' sounds like something out of a bloody fairy tale! I think both of you must be sharing a Disney+ account to presume that these offenders are transformed meticulously as human beings the moment they enter and come out the other side as good little birdies, on a personal note you would know how difficult it can be to adapt or change who you are, there are tweaks we can make along the way but in the end it is all dependent on the type of person we are, I feel that is is extremely dangerous to trust authorities who are responsible for ensuring the criminal feel remorse and importantly, get rid of the poison in their mind.

The only argument which I can somewhat see is miscarriage of justice, however this is why I'd like for a process which would remove any doubt in this regard prior to the death penalty being carried out; if the law is strong and the corruption minimal, then I see no reason why those responsible should pay for what they did permanently.
 
45,000 people in Pakistan responded to a twitter poll that asked for YES or NO on capital punishment for rape and child rape, if proven guilty in a fair trial?

97% percent Yay
3% percent Nay.
 
45,000 people in Pakistan responded to a twitter poll that asked for YES or NO on capital punishment for rape and child rape, if proven guilty in a fair trial?

97% percent Yay
3% percent Nay.

Thats why in these sort of cases its not the people that judge the sentences but due law n order is followed

This is mob justice Nothing more or less
 
Thats why in these sort of cases its not the people that judge the sentences but due law n order is followed

This is mob justice Nothing more or less

Its a democracy, the people have the right to choose their own laws and sentences. Or do you want Pak to be dicatorship with you in charge?

None sense, firstly am certain you'd have a different view if you or your family were on the receiving end quiet literally. And secondly, the 'make them face and accept their deed' and 'until they are not a danger to anyone else' sounds like something out of a bloody fairy tale! I think both of you must be sharing a Disney+ account to presume that these offenders are transformed meticulously as human beings the moment they enter and come out the other side as good little birdies, on a personal note you would know how difficult it can be to adapt or change who you are, there are tweaks we can make along the way but in the end it is all dependent on the type of person we are, I feel that is is extremely dangerous to trust authorities who are responsible for ensuring the criminal feel remorse and importantly, get rid of the poison in their mind.

The only argument which I can somewhat see is miscarriage of justice, however this is why I'd like for a process which would remove any doubt in this regard prior to the death penalty being carried out; if the law is strong and the corruption minimal, then I see no reason why those responsible should pay for what they did permanently.

Great post. We have Sarah's law for this reason(sorry I wrote Megan earlier). Every parent has the right to know if the peado or sex offender is living near them. Reason, they are still a danger. Here's what the experts say.

NSPCC child sex abuse prevention expert Jon Brown said: “Offenders with a history of child sex abuse should be considered a risk for the rest of their lives. It’s so important they are closely tracked and monitored by the police.

“Reoffending rates for sex offenders have risen in recent years but until now we did not know how many involved the sexual abuse of children.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/nspcc-paedophile-probe-reveals-1000-1442631

These are evil **** and no human should ever want to be comfortable in any way.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Even public hanging will not be enough punishment for the rapist, that should be the minimum punishment .
 
[/U][/I][/B]

Even for a rapist ?

Yes even for rape. Now if he said life in prison I would be out. What he is said is pure barbaric stuff. Does he not have pr people. The press will have a field day.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">List of places that use castrations as punishments already: <a href="https://t.co/7Ff57Iw79D">pic.twitter.com/7Ff57Iw79D</a></p>— sugar kaka (@sugar_kaka) <a href="https://twitter.com/sugar_kaka/status/1305537267507888128?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 14, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Thats why in these sort of cases its not the people that judge the sentences but due law n order is followed

This is mob justice Nothing more or less

Why are you acting as though your view is a highly educated one others views which do not match up to yours are from uneducated mobs?

Just accept the majority of Pakistan cares more about the victim over the criminal.

It's because of people like you and [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] why repeat offenders exist.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">List of places that use castrations as punishments already: <a href="https://t.co/7Ff57Iw79D">pic.twitter.com/7Ff57Iw79D</a></p>— sugar kaka (@sugar_kaka) <a href="https://twitter.com/sugar_kaka/status/1305537267507888128?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 14, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

I misunderstood chemical castration . It’s totally different than what i thought it was . From what I understand it seems ok. I looked up some of those countries . They have not carried be out actual Castrations for over 3 decades and some for over 65 years.
 
Studies have shown capital punishment doesn't stop crime and sometimes has the opposite effect. It leads to what's essentially suicide by homicide (i.e. committing a crime to die).

There's also additional concerns such as punishing the wrong person (very common in places like Pakistan), dehumanizing all criminals (including those serving small sentences causing more criminal activity when they return), and changing your society's tolerance towards violent retribution.

Giving a mediocre legal system such as Pakistan's an option such as this is asking for trouble. This is the same system that can't handle the blasphemy law without getting itself twisted into knots.
 
Studies have shown capital punishment doesn't stop crime and sometimes has the opposite effect. It leads to what's essentially suicide by homicide (i.e. committing a crime to die).

There's also additional concerns such as punishing the wrong person (very common in places like Pakistan), dehumanizing all criminals (including those serving small sentences causing more criminal activity when they return), and changing your society's tolerance towards violent retribution.

Giving a mediocre legal system such as Pakistan's an option such as this is asking for trouble. This is the same system that can't handle the blasphemy law without getting itself twisted into knots.

1 - Whilst it doesn't stop crime, it sure will put second thoughts in the mind of some. More importantly, it gets rid of an undesirable creature whom can't live in a civilised manner.

2 - That's a different issue. Finding the right person is different to deciding the level of punishment.
 
Back
Top