Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
23 fifers and 22 4fers in 121 matches is an absolute champion bowler's stats. Takes wickets everywhere in the world unlike Ashwin, who doesn't have a single 5fer in SENA nations. In India he has 5 fifers in 11 matches, where Ashwin gets all his wickets. He may not have the PR like of Indian cricketers but to even suggest that Ashwin is a superior bowler than him is a joke.
For one thing Ashwin Was hardly played like Lyon was. Missed several matches as.India preferred 4 plus 1 and the 1 being Jadeja secondly india always got seamer friendly track. Ashwin totally bamboozled Smith in Australia. Lyon is a defensive bowler most of his wickets were due to batsmen rying to.attack otherwise skillwise he is far inferior. He is slightly better version of Moeen
That's about it.
Ashwin didn't miss matches, he was dropped because he's not good enough. He had got enough opportunities and has consistently failed in Sena countries, not a single 5 wickets hall speaks for itself. And forget Lyon, even Moen would have an equally good bowling record as Ashwin if Mooen would have played his cricket on the dustbowls India has been dishing out since the last few year.
He's not a media darling.
Doesn't make big statements.
Doesn't feel the need to be in the public eye all the time.
Just lets his cricket do the talking.
A fantastic cricketer.
Ashwin is vastly more skilled bowler. In addition to that with his batting alone he has won several series for India. Besides Ashwin played all 3 formats Also IPL. Thoroughly over-exposed bowler. He is still able to surprise players.
View attachment 119595
Lyon is good but not really as good as Ash. He couldn't even get rid of India's noobs like Sundar, Thakur at the Gabba. Heck he couldn't dismiss Ashwin at the SCG and India earned a famous draw. He couldn't dismiss Jack Leach and Stokes in that famous last wicket partnership. Lyon is effective only when batsman tries to attack him. Lyon has bowled 281 balls to Ashwin in Australia. 98 runs by Ashwin. Yet to dismiss him.
Don't think Ashwin has a single Motm in SENA, forget MotS. Check the difference in averages in SENA, Lyon has gotten tons of wickets in India whenever he toured with 5 or 6 5fers in like 10 matches IIRC
That is because India is greeted with seamers track and India plays 4+1. Lyon on the other hand plays in Australia almost all his matches. He is the only spinner and he gets to play every single match. Ashwin missed more than 60% of SENA matches due to this. But the wickets he took were gun wickets. During his side strain injury he was a bit off color. But he is a vastly improved bowler.Missed 6 or 7 matches in England.
Lyon is not better than Ashwin, but he is easily the second best off-spinner of this millennium.
I don’t recognize Muralitharan’s record. He was a cheat who should have been banned forever.
But it was ICC that allowed him to bowl with a chucking action, so is ICC at fault?
Lyon is a worse batsman than Ashwin but he gets picked all the time because of his bowling. The difference between Jadeja and Ashwin's bowling is too small to have Ashwin playing. If Ashwin was as good as you think he is, he'd be first name on the team sheet. He to bowling what Warner is to batting imo, great at home and below average away
"Lyon came here first in 2013. He went to Sri Lanka before that. Todd Murphy came here 10 to 50 times better than how Nathan Lyon came here on his first Test tour," Ashwin said.
"Lyon made his entire career out of bowling in the rough made by Mitchell Starc" Ashwin said in his YouTube channel.
Above statements from Ashwin in 2023. Do you think a superior bowler will ever make statements like these about his contemporary? Calling someone 10-50 times better! An insecured, petty and inferior person does that
Lyon is a worse batsman than Ashwin but he gets picked all the time because of his bowling. The difference between Jadeja and Ashwin's bowling is too small to have Ashwin playing. If Ashwin was as good as you think he is, he'd be first name on the team sheet. He to bowling what Warner is to batting imo, great at home and below average away
Don't want to get into this debate on a deeper level.
But that is a bad argument.
Indian management has made plenttyyyyy of crazy blunders.
Dropping Shami for Bhuvi in WC 2019.....and for CT 2017.
Aus dropped Head for the first test in India before bringing him back.
India dropped Ashwin after a stellar WTC Finals performance in England.
Not being in the team is no criteria for someone being good or not good.
Meh.
Same guy backed Lyon to play IPL recently.
I think the statement was more in praise of Murphy but worded weirdly but let's not get facts in the way of a good story.
Don't think Ashwin has a single Motm in SENA, forget MotS. Check the difference in averages in SENA, Lyon has gotten tons of wickets in India whenever he toured with 5 or 6 5fers in like 10 matches IIRC
If lyon played on the same wickets as Ashwin he would have had 900 test wickets.
Imagine the number of wickets he would have had if he was bowling in Asia.
Naah that's ok, it would have devalued his wickets tally. It's best to perform outside Asia and win matches for your country like Lyon does and build a strong legacy than taking easy wickets and stupid fans.
Him playing almost 100 tests without getting dropped is a testament of Lyon's reliability and cricket knowledge of Australian management to persist with him after a few underwhelming games.
When he was picked in 2011, everyone was saying he was only going to be another one in the revolving musical chair. The guy had a bowling average of around 39 if I am correct but he's overcome all the obstacles and is going to reach 500 test wickets soon. In addition, he is well suited to bowl anywhere in the world.
It begs the question, should he be regarded as an all time great? or have the batting standards against spin fallen considerably.
Lyon was pulverised by Younis Khan, the best player of spin this century
Think he'll go down as an Australian great and Australia's best offie. Like Broad is England's great.
Yes Younis was brilliant against spin but he couldn't neutralize Herath completely.
Think Herath should be an ATG but Lyon will be an Australian great.
Virendar Sehwag destroyed Herath and Murali in a single day scoring 287 runs in 2.5 sessions. He was probably the best player against spin in the 2000s. Batting against spin has regressed especially from Indians shockingly. Kohli was a great player against spin. His game against spin regressed alarmingly. Lack of participation in domestic made them forget about their game against spin. Shreyas Iyer is the best in the current side. Others are so so. Pujara also regressed big time.
Herath didn't really come into his own till 2011.
I think Tendulkar, Laxman and Dravid were better players of spin than Sehwag. Sehwag could murder spinner on flat pitches but not really everywhere. The others were much more well rounded. Sehwag had a sharp decline after 2011 wc. He looked pretty clueless against Swann and Panesar in the 2012 test series and he was pretty much done by that point.
Yes I think the likes of Root, Smith, Kane etc are at an equal level of playing spinners as the likes of Kohli and playing spinners in Tests is becoming a diminishing art. Sangakkara was probably the last best player of spin.
Absolutely not. When every Indian was struggling against Mendis Sehwagg played him with ridiculous ease. His 201 at Galle was epic. Also there was this match against pakistan where pitch became absolutely unplayable. Ball was turning square even for Afridi. Sehwag was the best on that pitch until he was run out by Gambhir. All the other players struggled ont hat pitch. Sehwag is the greatest player agianst spin in the history dare i say. I am only talking about peak. Not after his reflexes waned. That can happen to anyone.
Think he'll go down as an Australian great and Australia's best offie. Like Broad is England's great.
Yes Younis was brilliant against spin but he couldn't neutralize Herath completely.
Think Herath should be an ATG but Lyon will be an Australian great.
Already among the league of greats, Nathan Lyon now goes past the great Courtney Walsh. Can he reach the 550-wickets mark?
![]()
Better Test spinner than anyone England/NZ/SA/PAK/WI have ever produced.
"Deadly" played on wet pitches and what not and that may have skewed his record.Possible that Underwood was on par. His record is superb including in Aus/NZ/India.
He is a one format player. So the workload for him is relatively less. Does he play in BBL atleast? I am not sure. He will prolong his career as much as he can as he gets a very good annual retainer.If a player is playing till he's forty it reflects more about lack of talent depth in domestic and lack of foresight from selectors.
He has been a great servant of Aus cricket for 14 yrs but after WTC final it is time to replace him and blood Murphy in home summer. Time for the next generation.
Australia seem to have this problem across all areas.If a player is playing till he's forty it reflects more about lack of talent depth in domestic and lack of foresight from selectors.
He has been a great servant of Aus cricket for 14 yrs but after WTC final it is time to replace him and blood Murphy in home summer. Time for the next generation.