What's new

Which Pakistani players do you think have already booked their place in the World Cup squad?

TalhaSyed

ODI Debutant
Joined
Aug 16, 2006
Runs
10,987
Post of the Week
4
There is still a lot of cricket to play between now and the World Cup - however - (baring injuries) which Pakistan players do you think have already booked their place for the World Cup?

You can either post your preferred CWC2019 squad, however, what this thread is primarily for is - regardless of what you would like to see - who do you think has already booked their place in the squad (e.g. they have performed well recently, the management backs them etc.)

For me - in no particular order - the players who probably already have their names down on Inzi's CWC selection sheet are:

1. Imam ul Haq - I think his performance in the ODI series vs SA has booked his place for the CWC2019

2. Fakhar Zaman - I think Micky is a fan of his and he adds an extra dynamic at the top of our batting order

3. Babar Azam - He's done enough in limited over cricket over the past few years to guarantee his place in the squad

4. Shadab Khan - I cant see any other spin bowling option threatening Shadab's spot - specially the bonus he gives with the bat

5. Mohammad Amir - I think the management have ear-marked Amir as a SENA specialist and it's highly unlikely that he will be getting dropped from the CWC squad

6. Shoaib Malik - Senior player who the management back and has performed pretty well in recent times. Lets be serious - he ain't getting dropped

7. Mohammad Hafeez - Senior player who the management back and has performed pretty well in recent times. Lets be serious - he ain't getting dropped

I feel Hassan Ali has all but booked his place in the squad, however, there is a slim chance that it could change depending on how Shinwari, Shaheen, Junaid and even Faheem perform between now and the WC & also how many pace bowlers we include in the squad.

Another question mark at the moment is Sarfraz, however, I would be extremely shocked if he doesn't make it to the squad. The question is though - if he does get removed from the captaincy, does he retain his space in the team as a wicket keeper/batsmen or is that where Rizwan comes in?

Where do Asif Ali & Hussain Talat slot into all of this?

Realistically speaking - I think the squad we saw in the SA ODI's is pretty much the same squad we will see in England this summer. However, I think there are still a few players who can still lose their spots if they take their foot off the gas and do not perform in the ODIs vs Aus and Eng in the next few months.
 
The top four and Shaheen are a lock, I think. Hasan, Shadab and Amir will also be there irrespective of recent performance.


I think Sarfaraz is on the edge, but PCB might err in his favour only because it is too late to change captain now. If Malik has a horrendous Aus series he won't be on the plane to England, IMO.


Rizwan might be a backup option as keeper despite his exploits with the bat.



The rest will have to prove in PSL and Aus series. I just hope we get some middle order batsmen in the PSL, we desperately need 2-3 batsmen who can bat at numbers 5 and 6. We also need a genuine off-spinner or left armer.
 
Putting aside what SHOULD happen Malik, Sarfaraz and just maybe even Hafeez are not a lock
 
The top four and Shaheen are a lock, I think. Hasan, Shadab and Amir will also be there irrespective of recent performance.


I think Sarfaraz is on the edge, but PCB might err in his favour only because it is too late to change captain now. If Malik has a horrendous Aus series he won't be on the plane to England, IMO.


Rizwan might be a backup option as keeper despite his exploits with the bat.



The rest will have to prove in PSL and Aus series. I just hope we get some middle order batsmen in the PSL, we desperately need 2-3 batsmen who can bat at numbers 5 and 6. We also need a genuine off-spinner or left armer.

Think Umar Akmal should be back up wicketkeeper. I am aware of his views on that
 
Think Umar Akmal should be back up wicketkeeper. I am aware of his views on that

Maaf karo bhai... every couple of years we come back to the same topic of Umar Akmal. How many times he has to fail for people to realize how garbage he is? He not only is a severely mediocre batsmen, he is also a bad influence in the dressing room and on top of that has ATROCIOUS fitness.
 
Maaf karo bhai... every couple of years we come back to the same topic of Umar Akmal. How many times he has to fail for people to realize how garbage he is? He not only is a severely mediocre batsmen, he is also a bad influence in the dressing room and on top of that has ATROCIOUS fitness.

Right.They get influenced by his social media antics in which he is doing some gym exercise with some iconic background music.Same for Shehzad
 
Maaf karo bhai... every couple of years we come back to the same topic of Umar Akmal. How many times he has to fail for people to realize how garbage he is? He not only is a severely mediocre batsmen, he is also a bad influence in the dressing room and on top of that has ATROCIOUS fitness.
I have zero expectation of his batting prowess. He was always overrated but assuming he is fit, he is a probably a better back up than Rizwan. Not expecting more 25 to 30 per innings
 
PAK is the most settled squad for the WC. Barring injury, following players are certain to make squad of 16:

1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Shan
5. Hafeez
6. Malik
7. *Sarfraz+
8. Shadab
9. Imad
10. Fahim
11. Amir
12. Hasan
13. Shaheen
14. Usman

There are 2 or 1 (if the squad is limited to 15) spots left, which I think will go to an experienced head.
 
PAK is the most settled squad for the WC. Barring injury, following players are certain to make squad of 16:

1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Shan
5. Hafeez
6. Malik
7. *Sarfraz+
8. Shadab
9. Imad
10. Fahim
11. Amir
12. Hasan
13. Shaheen
14. Usman

There are 2 or 1 (if the squad is limited to 15) spots left, which I think will go to an experienced head.

Haris Sohail has also a guaranteed spot if he is fit, he is our best batsman after Babar Azam.
 
Yes , bring back Umar akmal and the WC2019 is for PCT to take. Mark my words !

No. he is not being brought back to win us the cup. right now we are struggling to find a keeper who can consistently score 30 runs at a strike rate of > 100.
 
I think almost all the 15 players have been selected for the WC with 1/2 changes possible.

15 Men Squad

Fakhar Zaman
Imam Ul Haq
Shan Masood
Babar Azam
Haris Sohail
Mohammad Hafeez
Shoaib Malik
Sarfraz Ahmed
Imad Wasim
Shadab Khan
Faheem Ashraf
Mohammad Amir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Afridi
Usman Shinwari

Junaid Khan has a chance to replace Usman Shinwari if he performs well in the PSL or against Australia. Faheem Ashraf can also be dropped if we can find another seam bowling all rounder through an exceptional performance in PSL.
 
This will be most probable squad

1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Haris
5. Hafeez
6. Malik
7. *Sarfraz+
8. Shadab
9. Imad
10. Fahim
11. Amir
12. Hasan
13. Shaheen
14. Rizwan (as a backup keeper)
 
Haris Sohail has also a guaranteed spot if he is fit, he is our best batsman after Babar Azam.

Don't think so, in another post I have actually dropped him from probables as well. There are two types of player with injury crisis, one is Malik type who'll get fit before the estimated time; other one is Haris type, who'll take more time than estimation. I read, he'll need 4 months to be completely fit - that's incorrect, because he is never completely fit, and he'll take lot more than 4 months to recover. This WC with 9 confirmed games in 35 days doesn't leave much luxury to carry such unfit players.
 
Putting aside what SHOULD happen Malik, Sarfaraz and just maybe even Hafeez are not a lock

If Malik has a horrendous Aus series he won't be on the plane to England, IMO.

Primarily due to the 'senior' tag I think Hafeez & Malik are a lock, however - as as you mentioned Syed1 - if Malik has a horrendous series against Aus who knows. Having said that - the chances of Malik having a horrendous serious against a relatively weak Aus in the UAE is extremely unlikely. specially given the type of form he has been in for the last wee while in limited over cricket.
 
Maaf karo bhai... every couple of years we come back to the same topic of Umar Akmal. How many times he has to fail for people to realize how garbage he is? He not only is a severely mediocre batsmen, he is also a bad influence in the dressing room and on top of that has ATROCIOUS fitness.

Speaking of which what do you make of Sarfraz's pot belly?
 
Haris Sohail has also a guaranteed spot if he is fit, he is our best batsman after Babar Azam.

Yup I think Haris & Junaid should be in the squad but I also think they have a far from guaranteed spot in the squad. In fact - given how recent squad selections have gone I would be surprised if they both make the cut.
 
Certain based on merit

Babar
Imam
Fakhar
Hafeez
Imad
Shaheen

Unfortunately certain

Sarfaraz
Malik
Amir (he has been ordinary)

Very likely Squad members

Hassan Ali
Shadab Khan


Question Marks

Shinwari (Unsatisfactory)
Shan Masood (we really don’t know do we?)
Rizwan (not good enough I’m afraid)
Harris Sohail (Worth selecting and hoping he gets fit by the crunch group matches)

Should be considered to add strength

Umar Akmal (No Better back up keeper option)
Bilal Asif (Muscle man, could be a game changer)
Junaid Khan (Underrated, delivers when needed)
Muhammad Musa (PSL will be the deciding factor. Need a young Fast bowler with wheels)
 
Primarily due to the 'senior' tag I think Hafeez & Malik are a lock, however - as as you mentioned Syed1 - if Malik has a horrendous series against Aus who knows. Having said that - the chances of Malik having a horrendous serious against a relatively weak Aus in the UAE is extremely unlikely. specially given the type of form he has been in for the last wee while in limited over cricket.

Dropping Malik/Hafeez is just part of the problem. For instance how does it help Pakistan that these guys play the next ten Odis and then get dropped. Their replacement is set up for failure. FWIW, I think Shan will take Malik’s place in the squad (and will play at 4, they will push hafeez to five)
 
Fakhar
Imam
Babar
Hafeez
Malik
Sarfraz/Rizwan
Imad
Shadab
Hasan
Shaheen
Amir

I think these guys will go. PSL will help Inzi decide a back up opener ,back up middle order batter, and back up pacers.
 
Undroppables:
Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Hafeez(seniority culture)
Imad(due to recent batting)
Shadab
Hasan Ali(big match player)
Amir(Golden boy)
Shaheen shah

See saw :
Sarfaraz(c)
Malik
Rizwan (wk)

Chances based on performance in upcoming matches :
Junaid khan
Haris Sohail
Faheem
Shinwari
Asif ali
Rizwan Hussain (psl)

Unlucky to be missed out :
Shan Masood
Mohammad Nawaz
Hussain Talat
Sohaib Maqsood
 
Dropping Malik/Hafeez is just part of the problem. For instance how does it help Pakistan that these guys play the next ten Odis and then get dropped. Their replacement is set up for failure. FWIW, I think Shan will take Malik’s place in the squad (and will play at 4, they will push hafeez to five)

I dont know man I see Malik as pretty undropable at this stage!
 
Undroppables:
Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Hafeez(seniority culture)
Imad(due to recent batting)
Shadab
Hasan Ali(big match player)
Amir(Golden boy)
Shaheen shah

See saw :
Sarfaraz(c)
Malik
Rizwan (wk)

Chances based on performance in upcoming matches :
Junaid khan
Haris Sohail
Faheem
Shinwari
Asif ali
Rizwan Hussain (psl)

Unlucky to be missed out :
Shan Masood
Mohammad Nawaz
Hussain Talat
Sohaib Maqsood

Sarfraz, Rizwan and the captaincy are big question ,arks. Sarfraz needs to have a stand out PSL and justify his spot in the team in my opinion.
 
Haris Sohail vs Shan Masood?

Who would you choose for the world cup/next ODI series? And Why? Looks like it's become a competition between the two of them if a spot frees up, so which would you pick if you could only have one in the team.

Where would you play them in the order too.
 
Who would you choose for the world cup/next ODI series? And Why? Looks like it's become a competition between the two of them if a spot frees up, so which would you pick if you could only have one in the team.

Where would you play them in the order too.

Haris Sohail definitely, he is averaging almost 60 in his last few ODIs, will play at No.4.

Still, I think both should be picked and will be picked.

Our Squad composition will be:

7 Batsmen
1 WK
2 Spinners
5 Fast Bowlers

Hence,

Fakhar Zaman
Imam Ul Haq
Shan Masood
Babar Azam
Haris Sohail
Mohammad Hafeez
Shoaib Malik

Sarfraz Ahmed

Shadab Khan
Imad Wasim

Faheem Ashraf
Mohammad Amir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Afridi
Usman Shinwari/Junaid Khan
 
I don't understand this business for people saying Shan should be in instead of Malik and hafeez. He is a specialist opener. Batting in the middle of the innings is also a specialist role
I would take Shan as the spare batter and if we had to play him would open with him and put fakhar in the middle as he can take the skin to the cleaners
 
Who would you choose for the world cup/next ODI series? And Why? Looks like it's become a competition between the two of them if a spot frees up, so which would you pick if you could only have one in the team.

Where would you play them in the order too.

haris is not going or will be coming back mid-tour.
 
I don't understand this business for people saying Shan should be in instead of Malik and hafeez. He is a specialist opener. Batting in the middle of the innings is also a specialist role
I would take Shan as the spare batter and if we had to play him would open with him and put fakhar in the middle as he can take the skin to the cleaners

right now i will take a specialist number 11 in place of shoaib malik, as a batsman
 
Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Hafeez
Shaheen
Shadab (Mickey rates him very very highly...)
Amir (because he is a ‘big-match player’)
 
Babar
Amir
Imam
Hafeez
Sarfraz
Haris Sohail (if fit)
Shaheen


These are the confirmed slots.

Ideally, we'd play Umar Akmal instead of Sarfraz as the wk/bat. 10x instant improvement!
 
These players are all but confirmed barring injury or some other unforeseen circumstance:

1) Imam ul Haq
2) ?
3) Babar Azam
4) Mohammad Hafeez
5) ?
6) ?
7) ?
8) Mohammad Amir
9) Shaheen Shah Afridi
10) Hasan Ali
11) ?

Fakhar, Malik, Shadab and Imad have a foot in the door but need to show decent form from here on out to join the rest as absolute certainties. Junaid and Haris need to get back to full fitness and put in some good performances and they should be locks as well. Sarfaraz and Rizwan are pretty much in direct competition at this point, if Sarfaraz is outclassed by his competition, Malik might captain and Sarfaraz might get a place on the bench, at best.

Fahim and Shinwari are probably out of contention by now although a couple of incredible performances can change that. Masood and Talat haven't received a chance to shine yet but given the amount of spots that are open, they should be raring to go.

My personal 15 for the World Cup (as of today) will be as follows:

1) Imam ul Haq
2) Fakhar Zaman
3) Babar Azam
4) Haris Sohail
5) Shoaib Malik (c)
6) Mohammad Hafeez
7) Mohammad Rizwan (wk)
8) Shadab Khan
9) Mohammad Amir
10) Shaheen Shah Afridi
11) Junaid Khan

12) Hussain Talat
13) Shan Masood
14) Imad Wasim
15) Hasan Ali
 
1) Imam ul Haq
2) Fakhar Zaman
3) Babar Azam
4) Mohammad Hafeez
5) Shoaib Malik
6) Sarfraz Ahmed
7) Imad Wasim
8) Shadab Khan
9) Hasan Ali
10) Shaheen Shah Afridi
11) Junaid Khan
12) Sharjeel Khan
13) Fahim Ashraf
14) Saud Shakeel
15) Mohammad Amir
 
Imam
Fakhar - will come good in English conditions
Babar 'remember the name' Azam
Talat - play him at 4 please!
Hafeez
Malik
Sarfraz
Shady
Amir
Shaheen
Hasan

Reserves - Imad, Junaid, Asif, Fahim

One of Shady/Imad should play based on opponents strength and one of Hasan/Junaid can play based on form and fitness. Faheem can be played in weak matches and can replace the spin slot on greenish surfaces. Asif can be played against strong batting line ups as a big hitting cover in place of Hafeez.

The above team has the best chance to go all the way! I hope the team management believes and strategizes well..
 
1) Imam ul Haq
2) Fakhar Zaman
3) Babar Azam
4) Mohammad Hafeez
5) Shoaib Malik
6) Sarfraz Ahmed
7) Imad Wasim
8) Shadab Khan
9) Hasan Ali
10) Shaheen Shah Afridi
11) Junaid Khan
12) Sharjeel Khan
13) Fahim Ashraf
14) Saud Shakeel
15) Mohammad Amir

It's England! Why wouldn't you play Amir?!
 
- Imam
- Fakhar (he'll play atleast 2-3 good innings in next 10 ODI's, place is almost booked)
- Babar
- Hafeez
- Malik (I really hope he fails miserbaly against AUS and gets dropped somehow, even though its unlikely)
- Sarfaraz (he'll definitely stay captain)
- Imad (one of the most improved players from current lot, will be there for WC)
- Shadab (sadly we've no other wrist spin option)
- Hasan (can't drop our half decent lone RF bowler, even if he performs badly in coming ODI's)
- Shaheen

Remaining 5 spots will be decided between Shan, Haris, Amir, Junaid, Shinwari, Faheem, Nawaz, Yamin, Abbas.
 
And Rizwan gets to enjoy watching the World Cup from the comfort of his couch.

Yup very true - the chances of both Srfraz and Rizwan being in the squad are very slim. It will need at least one of them to justify their place in the team as a specialist batsmen, and neither one of them fill me with confidence of doing that as things currently stand.

Sarfraz has really struggled with the bat, and I do not see Rizwan being given the opportunity to prove himself before the WC, and to show whether his recent Pakistan A and domestic performances are just a flash in the pan or an actual reflection of his talent.
 
Has the PSL changes anyone's minds?

Not the PSL, but Aus squad has pretty much confirmed which players are booked.

Fakhar
Imam
Babar
Hafeez
Malik
Sarfaraz (c)
Imad
Shadab
Hasan
Shaheen
Amir
Fahim

3 spots open.

2 out of Shan / Haris / Umar will be picked
1 out of Hasnain / Junaid / Shinwari / Abbas will be picked
 
I think the squad is almost certain PCB will not make too many changes ( I am just going on what I think PCB do and predict how they think) I think the final 15 will be something like this - please note if I put two names next to each other it means the PCB will pick one or the other depending on how things go from now ( reminder of PSL) and end of Aussie series

1) Fakhar Zaman
2) Imam Ul Haq
3) Shan Masood / Imad Wasim

4) Babar Azam
5) Haris Sohail
6) Sarfraz
7) Shoaib Malik
8) Mohammad Hafeez

9) Umar Akmal / Asif Ali
10) Shadab Khan
11) Faheem Ashraf

12) Mohammad Amir
13) Hasan Ali
14) Shaheen Shah
15) Junaid Khan / Mohammad Hasnain

I feel like Usman khan shinwari will not be selected not because I don't want him to be their but I feel more failure will come from him and PCB will go with either junaid khan or m Hasnain , how ever I do feel their going to go will Junaid Khan

As you saw I put Shan Masood name next Imad Wasim , this will be due to if PCB feel they need another opener in Shan Masood, I think PCB won't go that route and will take Imad Wasim to the World Cup. If in the event the openers are failing they can always promote Hafeez babar Azam Sarfraz or even Akmal and Faheem , PCB tend to think like this and I think they will stick with 2 openers

So the final squad is pretty much what you see but from the list were you see 2 names next to each other Imad , Junaid Khan, and Umar Akmal make the final cut

Again this is what I predict PCB will do because again all these players with the exception of Umar Akmal have been playing regularly and PCB like to keep it like if their gonna take a risk they will take it with someone like Umar Akmal who had international experience but had just been out of the international scene
 
We are playing a long tournament in England and all possibilities are still open. We need to remember that this is going to be tournament played in condition which will vary over the course of the tournament. Some conditions might favour spin as last year the summer in England was very sub continent like. It's a real shame we have no real off spinner in the team apart from proffersors lollipop line n length offies. I am although banking on our man Haris to play a special part again if we remember this boy was a golden chance in 2015 and we thought we had finally found a truly technical batsmen.
Only after his introduction we saw many more lefties inrtoduved into our team. The way the 50 over game is also going on today's age I think it's pivotal now that we have players who can impose and establish themselves on the opposition and maintain the attack. Imam and Fakhar have found some good momentum with the support of Babar.

Fakhars big scores have been missing lately but hopefully with a good rest we will see a some better performances from him, however if South Africa is anything to go by, we might be looking at a replacing him and bringing a solid middle order bat in.

Umar Akmal introduction hopefully turns out to be fruitful for both sides. Our team can do the world of good if we see a firing Akmal on all cylinders during the CWC19. He is a player who likes to make his name and with the respect of many opposition players he can always remain the X factor in the line up. His rivals all were given many chances and none of them really impressed or looked to cement there place so e return was only inevitable. With hafeez out and babar rested along with Fakhar. He should have sufficient bat time in the coming series. Need a few big knocks to silence many naysayers quickly.

Malik and Hafeez are the old horses in the team, there experience will be crucial and I am sure given the situation both players will always put the team first. If the management even decides to leave either or both out I am sure given the stature of the tournament and the swangsong both are wishing for they shall be our trump throughout. Number 4/5/6 is given there with Haris most likely a back up if not even Asif Ali.

Coming to the bowling I think it's a still a very open race and I think a lot places are still open for grabs and the way Inzi along with Mickey have set up this Race for places in the team is quite enticing. We all know bowling is the labourers part of the game and all of the players in contention now have a race not just to show if they play at the highest level but also to show their mettle when it now matters most. Amir has been off colour in terms of wicket taking numbers but his past success, dare I say guaranteed, in England he is porbably one of the first picks along with Hassan and Shadab in the team. Imad will most likely play the all rounders role with Faheem taking the number 9 role. Shaheen will be ahead of Shinwari looking at both bowlers abilities at the moment with SSA looking like the real deal. If Junaid passes fitness he will probably be there ahead of Abbas. Hasnian I don't think quite makes the cut as he is still quite raw and unless he performs outstandingly vs Australia I don't see him in.
 
My team so would be

Imam
Babar
Haris
Umar
Sarfraz
Malik
Imad
Shadab
Hassan Ali
Amir
Shaheen
Hafeez
Faheem
Ahmed Shehzad
Junaid
 
Last edited:
PAK is the most settled squad for the WC. Barring injury, following players are certain to make squad of 16:

1. Imam
2. Fakhar
3. Babar
4. Shan
5. Hafeez
6. Malik
7. *Sarfraz+
8. Shadab
9. Imad
10. Fahim
11. Amir
12. Hasan
13. Shaheen
14. Usman

There are 2 or 1 (if the squad is limited to 15) spots left, which I think will go to an experienced head.

I think Haris will be replacing Shan now. Faheem should keep his place considering Mickey’s passion with “all-rounder”. Who is going to be the 15th man - now I think it’s between Rizwan & JK. No way IuH is going to pick Abid Ali for a reason .....
 
My guess is that the 15th slot is between Shan and Yasir. Let's see.
 
My guess is that the 15th slot is between Shan and Yasir. Let's see.

I don't think Yasir is in contention. The coach praised him but Shadab is a firm pick and along with the likes of Malik, Imad and Hafeez, I doubt we the management or selectors will be thinking of taking to specialist spinners to England
 
From the first name on the team-sheet to those that are pretty much guranteed to miss out, as of April 2nd:

1) Babar Azam
2) Sarfaraz Ahmed
3) Hasan Ali
4) Shaheen Shah Afridi
5) Shadab Khan
6) Imam ul Haq
7) Fakhar Zaman
8) Haris Sohail
9) Imad Wasim
10) Mohammad Amir
11) Shoaib Malik
12) Mohammad Hafeez
13) Mohammad Rizwan
14) Abid Ali
15) Junaid Khan
16) Faheem Ashraf
17) Mohammad Husnain
18) Shan Masood
19) Usman Khan Shinwari
20) Abbas/Shah/Saad/Akmal
 
Last edited:
My 15

1. Babar
2. Fakhar
3. Haris
4. Sarfraz
5. Hafeez
6. Shadab
7. Asif Ali
8. Faheem Ashraf
9. Hassan Ali
10. Wahab Riaz
11. Shaheen Afridi

12. Rizwan
13. Imam
14. Umer Khan
15. Usman Khan


For this to work, Sarfraz, Shadab and Faheem need to work on their battign considerably. Selectors need to have the confidence to drop Malik, Amir and demote Imam to the bench.
 
My 15

1. Babar
2. Fakhar
3. Haris
4. Sarfraz
5. Hafeez
6. Shadab
7. Asif Ali
8. Faheem Ashraf
9. Hassan Ali
10. Wahab Riaz
11. Shaheen Afridi

12. Rizwan
13. Imam
14. Umer Khan
15. Usman Khan


For this to work, Sarfraz, Shadab and Faheem need to work on their battign considerably. Selectors need to have the confidence to drop Malik, Amir and demote Imam to the bench.

How did Wahab suddenly make the team? Awful bowler who has always been crap in ODIs
 
How did Wahab suddenly make the team? Awful bowler who has always been crap in ODIs

Current form, I know it was only 4 over spells but he looked really fit and bowled consistently aroudn 147-150 kph, we need someone that can bowl full steam even 2 3 over spells in the middle to pick up 1-2 wickets. We won't win many games if we can't pick up middle over wickets. If you look at peshawar Zalmi their bowling worked well because Wahab and Hassan complimented each other well. Hassan is starting to develop into a new ball bowler and Wahab can come on after the power play for more protection.
 
Current form, I know it was only 4 over spells but he looked really fit and bowled consistently aroudn 147-150 kph, we need someone that can bowl full steam even 2 3 over spells in the middle to pick up 1-2 wickets. We won't win many games if we can't pick up middle over wickets. If you look at peshawar Zalmi their bowling worked well because Wahab and Hassan complimented each other well. Hassan is starting to develop into a new ball bowler and Wahab can come on after the power play for more protection.

So someone who has been awful in ODIs for a number of years, has been given a lot of chances and has never performed well, should return for the World Cup on the basis of his PSL bowling?

We just tried this exact strategy on Umar Akmal. He performed in PSL but his recall proved that if you haven’t done anything in the numerous previous chances, and there is no obvious improvement to your game, then nothing will change if you are given another chance.
 
Haris Sohail definitely, he is averaging almost 60 in his last few ODIs, will play at No.4.

Still, I think both should be picked and will be picked.

Our Squad composition will be:

7 Batsmen
1 WK
2 Spinners
5 Fast Bowlers

Hence,

Fakhar Zaman
Imam Ul Haq
Shan Masood
Babar Azam
Haris Sohail
Mohammad Hafeez
Shoaib Malik

Sarfraz Ahmed

Shadab Khan
Imad Wasim

Faheem Ashraf
Mohammad Amir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Afridi
Usman Shinwari/Junaid Khan

I think this is a pretty good squad, except why only 1 WK?
What if Sarfaraz gets injured. And also I am guessing this is what you think the squad should be, if so why no M Rizwan, he is miles ahead of Sarfaraz in every way (including looks lol). In the last 3-4 games he has proved fraud sarfaraz is no match.
 
I think this is a pretty good squad, except why only 1 WK?
What if Sarfaraz gets injured. And also I am guessing this is what you think the squad should be, if so why no M Rizwan, he is miles ahead of Sarfaraz in every way (including looks lol). In the last 3-4 games he has proved fraud sarfaraz is no match.

Did you watch the last series? Rizwan is a much worse keeper. And though he might be more consistent than Sarfaraz as a batsman he has limited stroke play. Considering the keeper will bat at number 6 or 7 in the line up - Sarfaraz is more suited to that role. And also, since we are stating irrelevant facts, Sarfraz is a Hafiz and has a better voice...
 
this list is a mixture of what I keep hearing in the media about the potential squad and my personal assessment and/or bias

Imam
Fakhar
Hafeez
Malik
Imad
Babar
Harris
Sarfaraz
Afridi
Shadab
Faheem
Hasan
Shinwari

Two more spots: possibly Amir and Asif.
 
I think this is a pretty good squad, except why only 1 WK?
What if Sarfaraz gets injured. And also I am guessing this is what you think the squad should be, if so why no M Rizwan, he is miles ahead of Sarfaraz in every way (including looks lol). In the last 3-4 games he has proved fraud sarfaraz is no match.

I posted this Squad, 2 months ago when Rizwan failed terribly during the SA series. Now with the failures of Shan Masood during the Australia ODI series, he won't be selected most probably and some other player has to be taken, I am guessing it would be Mohammad Rizwan. He has no doubt performed with the bat, but at Number 4 position where he will hardly get a chance to bat now with the first choice players available, let's see how he does now.

Sarfraz Ahmed also averages in 40s, when he bats up the order.
 
From the first name on the team-sheet to those that are pretty much guranteed to miss out, as of April 2nd:

1) Babar Azam
2) Sarfaraz Ahmed
3) Hasan Ali
4) Shaheen Shah Afridi
5) Shadab Khan
6) Imam ul Haq
7) Fakhar Zaman
8) Haris Sohail
9) Imad Wasim
10) Mohammad Amir
11) Shoaib Malik
12) Mohammad Hafeez
13) Mohammad Rizwan
14) Abid Ali
15) Junaid Khan
16) Faheem Ashraf
17) Mohammad Husnain
18) Shan Masood
19) Usman Khan Shinwari
20) Abbas/Shah/Saad/Akmal

22 out of 24 ain't bad. No one could have guessed Nawaz being called up.
 
If me select the team........

1.Abid Ali.
2.Fakhar Zaman.
3.Babar Azam.
4.Shoaib Malik.
5.Sarfraz Ahmad(wk)(c).
6.Mohammad Hafeez.
7.Imad Wasim.
8.Shadab Khan.
9.Faheem Aahraf.
10.Hassan Ali.
11.Mohammad Abbas.


12.Haris Sohail.
13.Asif Ali.
14.Junaid Khan.
15.Usman Khan Shinwari.
 
If me select the team........

1.Abid Ali.
2.Fakhar Zaman.
3.Babar Azam.
4.Shoaib Malik.
5.Sarfraz Ahmad(wk)(c).
6.Mohammad Hafeez.
7.Imad Wasim.
8.Shadab Khan.
9.Faheem Aahraf.
10.Hassan Ali.
11.Mohammad Abbas.


12.Haris Sohail.
13.Asif Ali.
14.Junaid Khan.
15.Usman Khan Shinwari.

You would have Malik instead of Haris and Abbas instead of Shaheen..?
 
I think almost all the 15 players have been selected for the WC with 1/2 changes possible.

15 Men Squad

Fakhar Zaman
Imam Ul Haq
Shan Masood
Babar Azam
Haris Sohail
Mohammad Hafeez
Shoaib Malik
Sarfraz Ahmed
Imad Wasim
Shadab Khan
Faheem Ashraf
Mohammad Amir
Hasan Ali
Shaheen Afridi
Usman Shinwari

Junaid Khan has a chance to replace Usman Shinwari if he performs well in the PSL or against Australia. Faheem Ashraf can also be dropped if we can find another seam bowling all rounder through an exceptional performance in PSL.

Very good prediction even before the PSl and Australia series. It will pretty much be this squad with the only potential change - Abid or Rizwan instead of Shan.
 
Rather we should ask who are the uncertainties at the moment? Junaid, Umar Akmal, Imad, Harris and Asif Ali are major doubts to be on the flight to the UK.
 
I posted this Squad, 2 months ago when Rizwan failed terribly during the SA series. Now with the failures of Shan Masood during the Australia ODI series, he won't be selected most probably and some other player has to be taken, I am guessing it would be Mohammad Rizwan. He has no doubt performed with the bat, but at Number 4 position where he will hardly get a chance to bat now with the first choice players available, let's see how he does now.

Sarfraz Ahmed also averages in 40s, when he bats up the order.

Ah yes this explains everything. Also I did not know Sarfaraz averaged a good amount batting high, guess I was wrong in making too many judgements about him; although knowing he is the captain he should put himself up the order. All he does is keeping moving down trying to avoid responsibility. He may be good up the order, but do you think Rizwan is better than him up the order? All I think is going on is that management cannot change captain this late, although I do not mind.
 
Did you watch the last series? Rizwan is a much worse keeper. And though he might be more consistent than Sarfaraz as a batsman he has limited stroke play. Considering the keeper will bat at number 6 or 7 in the line up - Sarfaraz is more suited to that role. And also, since we are stating irrelevant facts, Sarfraz is a Hafiz and has a better voice...

Admittedly I do not think I am very good at judging skill of WK's, if it is true Sarfaraz is better than maybe his inclusion is warranted. Rizwan strokeplay is limited, he may not be able to hit big, but still his skills are invaluable in the team. Only consistent batsman we have is Babar, definitely space for Rizwan's batting. And Rizwan is so young, I think after WC throw out Sarfaraz for good; he has done his job by winning CT. Although I still believe maybe with some more training Rizwan can match the keeping skills of Sarfaraz or even better, who is no Dhoni anyway. Also irrelevant facts are my favorite :), Sarfaraz is the youngest cricketer to win Sitara-i-imtiaz .
 
Admittedly I do not think I am very good at judging skill of WK's, if it is true Sarfaraz is better than maybe his inclusion is warranted. Rizwan strokeplay is limited, he may not be able to hit big, but still his skills are invaluable in the team. Only consistent batsman we have is Babar, definitely space for Rizwan's batting. And Rizwan is so young, I think after WC throw out Sarfaraz for good; he has done his job by winning CT. Although I still believe maybe with some more training Rizwan can match the keeping skills of Sarfaraz or even better, who is no Dhoni anyway. Also irrelevant facts are my favorite :), Sarfaraz is the youngest cricketer to win Sitara-i-imtiaz .

Agreed, Sarafaraz is not an amazing keeper, but in the last series Rizwan missed a number of easy chances which Sarfaraz would have taken.

Rizwan impressed all with his batting but along with Babar at 3, Haris has cemented his place at 4. The management will play Hafeez or Malik at 5. Which leaves space in the lower order and I don’t think Rizwan has the skills to bat there. If anything it would be detrimental to his career.

Penguins can jump up to 6 feet in the air.
 
The team management and selectors seem to have decided on 13-14 names six months ago. Only a couple of places remain which I suspect will be filled by Abid Ali and Mohammed Rizwan, so expecting:

Fakhar, Imam, Abid, Babar, Haris, Hafeez, Malik, Sarfraz, Rizwan, Imad, Shadab, Hasan, Shaheen, Fahim, Junaid.

Obviously I wouldn't select Malik or Fahim but there's the senior quota, and the useless investment quota to factor in...
 
The team management and selectors seem to have decided on 13-14 names six months ago. Only a couple of places remain which I suspect will be filled by Abid Ali and Mohammed Rizwan, so expecting:

Fakhar, Imam, Abid, Babar, Haris, Hafeez, Malik, Sarfraz, Rizwan, Imad, Shadab, Hasan, Shaheen, Fahim, Junaid.

Obviously I wouldn't select Malik or Fahim but there's the senior quota, and the useless investment quota to factor in...

Why have you selected only 4 pacers of which one is Faheem? Everyone, including Sarfraz, Mickey and Azhar have said that they will take 5 pacers and in my view it is very important in a tournament which is comparatively longer than previous WCs and will be dominated by batsmen, to have pacers fresh on bench and ready to replace.

One of Abid/Rizwan should be dropped from your Squad and Amir/Shinwari included.
 
Last edited:
Why have you selected only 4 pacers of which one is Faheem? Everyone, including Sarfraz, Mickey and Azhar have said that they will take 5 pacers and in my view it is very important in a tournament which is comparatively longer than previous WCs and will be dominated by batsmen, to have pacers fresh on bench and ready to replace.

One of Abid/Rizwan should be dropped from your Squad and Amir/Shinwari included.
You clearly didn't read the part where I said it's not the squad I'd pick but the squad I expect.

Okay, if they want 5 seamers along with a 3rd opener then that means no room for a backup WK in the squad ? Unless they're willing to drop sainted senior Malik which I doubt they've the guts to do.
 
You clearly didn't read the part where I said it's not the squad I'd pick but the squad I expect.

Okay, if they want 5 seamers along with a 3rd opener then that means no room for a backup WK in the squad ? Unless they're willing to drop sainted senior Malik which I doubt they've the guts to do.

Yup, I missed that but how can you expect 4 pacers when management have clearly said they will take 5?

Yes, and one of backup keeper or third opener will have to be comprised for the sake of taking Shoaib Malik. That is why Sarfraz has said that they are looking for a middle order batsmen who can also open, in case they require third opener. This means Abid isn't going.
 
Yup, I missed that but how can you expect 4 pacers when management have clearly said they will take 5?

Yes, and one of backup keeper or third opener will have to be comprised for the sake of taking Shoaib Malik. That is why Sarfraz has said that they are looking for a middle order batsmen who can also open, in case they require third opener. This means Abid isn't going.

Well if they do that I'll be disgusted, and that's from someone who generally is supportive of Arthur/Inzy.
 
Ah yes this explains everything. Also I did not know Sarfaraz averaged a good amount batting high, guess I was wrong in making too many judgements about him; although knowing he is the captain he should put himself up the order. All he does is keeping moving down trying to avoid responsibility. He may be good up the order, but do you think Rizwan is better than him up the order? All I think is going on is that management cannot change captain this late, although I do not mind.

Yes, it's frustrating that he plays down the order when clearly he has no power game and is better at milking spinners in the middle overs preventing dot balls, but still plays at Number 6/7 finishing the innings in which he rarely ever succeeds. I guess he doesn't trust his abilities.

I don't know who is better among the 2 overall, but Sarfraz is definitely better at playing spin than Rizwan and middle overs are dominated by spinners, so Sarfraz might be more useful coming in at Number 4/5.

Still, Mohammad Rizwan has definitely improved against spinners, he was sweeping beautifully throughout the Australian series and needs to be given more chances now that he has shown some sort of form.

Coming to the last part, yes a Captain shouldn't be changed so close to the WC and only teams like Afghanistan can do such things. We can remove Sarfraz after the WC, if Pakistan fails badly and make a young player like Babar Azam, the Captain.
 
Imam
Fakhar
Babar
Hafeez
Malik
Sarfraz
Imad
Shadab
Faheem
Hasan Ali
Shaheen
Amir

I think these 12 will be in the squad for certain. Shinwari or Junaid will also certainly be in the squad.

Not sure on who the other 2 will be yet.
 
Back
Top