What's new

Who should be Pakistan's ODI captain after the 2015 World Cup?

JibranAnsari

ODI Captain
Joined
Oct 13, 2010
Runs
46,992
PCB have groomed Mohammad Hafeez for the role but if he is not able to clear his bowling action and not able to perform with the bat then we have another crisis waiting for us , a lot of power-mongers will start chiseling their claws. Shoaib Malik has been awful for a long long time and hopefully wont make a comeback. Asad Shafiq has failed continuously in this format. What are the options available to pakistan after Misbah?
Azhar Ali can be a good option but him opening with shehzad will be a nightmare , I believe that he could have scored more 100s than shehzad in odis had he played around the same number of matches. But we cant have these two opening for us.

Does anyone have a name outside of the TTFs?
 
Azhar was very good in captaining lahor lions last season when clt20 was going on. I would't mind Junaid Khan As a captain but have a fear that he may not do good with aamir.
 
Azhar Ali captained his side of unknowns like a champion to the final of the recently held Pentagular Cup.

Looked assured and aggressive, also was batting really well albeit a bit on the slow side. He needs to open and Shehzad needs to be dropped because Shehzad has zero rotation of strike and discipline issues.
 
^ Umar Amin has yet to make a postive impression in international cricket , Pakistan should give him 15 matches in a row after the world cup and if he succeeds I wouldn't mind.
 
These 3-4 players should be considered for the role of Captain and V-captain and should be handed the duty.

Azhar Ali, Fawad Alam, Sarfraz AHmed, Asad Shafiq.
 
Younus Khan, obviously. We should do everything in our power to stop his retirement as he's clearly our best option given his success as T20 Captain. People talk about Imran Khan but Younus led a much more mediocre group to WC glory in his stint as T20 captain. He's a genuine match-winner and inshaAllah he'll turn this bad patch around.


Please take the bait.
 
Younus Khan, obviously. We should do everything in our power to stop his retirement as he's clearly our best option given his success as T20 Captain. People talk about Imran Khan but Younus led a much more mediocre group to WC glory in his stint as T20 captain. He's a genuine match-winner and inshaAllah he'll turn this bad patch around.


Please take the bait.

He is a selfish man , hasnt done anything for pakistan in odis for 6 years and averaging 25 in 6 years.

Pakistan shoud get rid of this cancer.
 
give hafeez the captaincy, im sure he will clear the bowling test.. when 40 degree ajmak could clear, then obviously hafeez also can... No more hiccups... Hafeez probably the most aggressive and attacking captain, if any one would have watch the clt20 match against perth scorchers where lahore lions wants to qualify....the best shot is hafeez atm..
 
It's a tough one. It should be Azhar Ali but he has not cemented his place. Which probably means that Malik would captain and have Azhar as VC
 
I think Fawad, Azher or sirfaraz ( Based on the performance of this worldcup) but PCB is full of surprise expect any thing
 
Maqsood would be the best candidate.

But I think they'll go with malik or hafeez.
 
Who are the players guaranteed a place in the first XI regardless of conditions or opposition?
 
Azhar Ali captained his side of unknowns like a champion to the final of the recently held Pentagular Cup.

Looked assured and aggressive, also was batting really well albeit a bit on the slow side. He needs to open and Shehzad needs to be dropped because Shehzad has zero rotation of strike and discipline issues.

Unknowns?? They had a brilliant team.

Azhar would be disaster as an ODI player let alone captain. His strike rotation is just as poor as Shehzad if not worse. And unlike Shehzad he has zero power game to make it up later.
 
Malik, Asad, Azhar dont even make the XI and people are talking of making them captain.:facepalm:
 
Azhar Ali... looks like some people don't learn, they want another #3 batsman who will go at a 60SR

I'd keep Afridi around, because Pakistan cricket will need him otherwise enjoy 12 people turning up to watch an ODI game
 
plus [MENTION=138254]Syed1[/MENTION] with some responsibility his batting may improve, e.g Misbah. Either way Malik will win more games as a captain for pak then someone who is scoring runs but doesn't have a knack for leadership or is inexperienced.
 
He is a selfish man , hasnt done anything for pakistan in odis for 6 years and averaging 25 in 6 years.

Pakistan shoud get rid of this cancer.

Can't believe you of all people fell for that. Check the white text, bro. :))
 
If Hafeez can clear his action, he should be the captain, no doubt.

If not, we should bring back Malik, he has done decently well with a young team in the past. But his own performance will be a big concern :13:

The 3rd choice is a tie between Sarfraz and Azhar Ali. If we select a young captain, we will need to back him and give him at least 2 years
 
Azhar Ali is a good choice.

People need to stop looking at his SR and focus on his ability to play the new ball, leadership and brains.

Only the second batsman from PAK to average 40+ in ODIs.
Leadership experience and potential.
Solid technique against swing and pace.

All things check out.

Still too worried about SR? Good that you're not a selector. He can and WILL improve his SR if asked to.

Look at your team and tell me one man who has all of the above going for him. These are top priority things.

We nees to drop Shehzad and play Babar Azam/Amin/Sami as the second opener.
 
Azhar Ali is a good choice.

People need to stop looking at his SR and focus on his ability to play the new ball, leadership and brains.

Only the second batsman from PAK to average 40+ in ODIs.
Leadership experience and potential.
Solid technique against swing and pace.

All things check out.

Still too worried about SR? Good that you're not a selector. He can and WILL improve his SR if asked to.

Look at your team and tell me one man who has all of the above going for him. These are top priority things.

We nees to drop Shehzad and play Babar Azam/Amin/Sami as the second opener.

I have no issue if he scores now on at more than 75 SR , anything less wont be good enough.

SR is important , cant have two openers going at 60 SR.
 
I think pak is in a middle of a crisis similar to rsa in wc 2003.........going by that we should make umar akmal as the captain who is similar to smith in many ways such as

experienced
talented
young player
a surety in the team for the next years
aggressive nature
great potential

:uakmal


above all umar akmal`s raw talent will be utilized to the max and also captaincy will make him more responsible and will bring out the best him.....he is the best choice !
 
sarfaraz he has an aura of competitiveness, he should be the one
 
Shahzad I thought would be in contention, but his recent childish behaviour and lack of runs means he wont get captaincy.

Malik or Hafeez are most likely candidates.

Outside chance for Azhar Ali and Fawad Alam as well due to their experience captaining domestic sides.
 
Fawad Alam or Sarfaraz, we need a young skipper get rid of all the dead wood and actually pick new players and persist with them for 2/3 years so they can develop at this level, what will happen will probably be Malik, YK or Afridi been made skipper :facepalm:
 
Shoaib Malik will come back into the team with the BANG...he will be the next Captain I guess..
 
Shoaib Malik is the best option. He should be the captain after the cwc he is the best cricketing brain in pakistan
 
Wahab Riaz for 1-2 years until we find someone, no one in sight at the moment.
 
We can all talk about youngsters but I don't know why I have the feeling Boom Boom would be coming back (getting out of retirement) as captain for "sake of country and team".
 
NOT A TEST PLAYER! WE NEED A GOOD ODI PLAYER!!!! YOUNG... AZHAR ALI IS NOT A GOOD CHOICE! HE WILL BE THE NEXT TUK TUK! I should go with UMAR AKMAL OR SARFRAZ AHMED! YOU GUYS ALL ARE STUPID CHOSING A TEST PLAYER FOR ODI CRICKET!
 
NOT A TEST PLAYER! WE NEED A GOOD ODI PLAYER!!!! YOUNG... AZHAR ALI IS NOT A GOOD CHOICE! HE WILL BE THE NEXT TUK TUK! I should go with UMAR AKMAL OR SARFRAZ AHMED! YOU GUYS ALL ARE STUPID CHOSING A TEST PLAYER FOR ODI CRICKET!

+1
 
It is amazing how Shoaib Malik who is not able to make it into the starting 11 is being supported for the captaincy role. Only in Pakistan. You need to perform, be part of the team, have a guaranteed starting spot, and then if you have leadership qualities and are good enough in tough situations, you should be made captain. Currently, we have no one like that. Hafeez is close if his bowling action clears.
 
Malik, I am almost certain about this. It was a mistake to sack him last time & PCB should rectify a howler the did 7 years back. Ideally, Malik should have been PAK ODI Captain for 2011, 2015 & 2019 WC.

For his deputy, I 'll pick one of Amin or Haris; I don't think Shehzad has the personality to lead the side. May be a couple of years time Babar or Aamir can replace them as Malik's deputy & after 2019, one of them should replace Malik as Captain. By 2019 Babar 'll be 24, Aamir 27........ perfect age for Vice Captain & Captain.
 
Sohaib Maqsood or Fawad Alam...

and even Sarfaraz Ahmed could be an option as he captained Pakistan U19 to victory stand
 
It is amazing how Shoaib Malik who is not able to make it into the starting 11 is being supported for the captaincy role. Only in Pakistan. You need to perform, be part of the team, have a guaranteed starting spot, and then if you have leadership qualities and are good enough in tough situations, you should be made captain. Currently, we have no one like that. Hafeez is close if his bowling action clears.

wat abt :uakmal as indicated in my post ?
 
the fact is we will have the following candidates: hafeez, fawad, sarfraz, perhaps Junaid. We can ship in azhar into the squad but it would be unfair to thrust the cuptanny on him. The safest option is hafeez until we can groom either fawad, azhar or sarfraz. Personally if sarfraz shows continued promise he is the man!

Malik cant be shipped in because it will affect morale. Players who have been busting a gut for four years will ask why he should be made cuptaan when he hasn't done anything? and we all know how malik handles criticism or confrontation.
 
Azhar Ali first needs to cement his place in test side , he is very inconsistent, performs in one series and fails miserably in the nest one and i would never make the captain not even test side , he is also way too defensive
 
Malik, I am almost certain about this. It was a mistake to sack him last time & PCB should rectify a howler the did 7 years back. Ideally, Malik should have been PAK ODI Captain for 2011, 2015 & 2019 WC.

Well yes, they can't perform any worse.

---------------------

What is Fawad Alam doing in that political setting?
 
PCB will send a wrong message by bringing in malik , it would be worse decision than younis khans. What has malik done in last 5 years in international cricket to deserve a comeback. By this logic even kamran akmal should be back in the team.

Shoaib Malik ladies and gentlemen

shoaib.JPG
 
azhar and asad should be kept 10 miles away from the ODI team let alone handing them the captaincy.
i believe a sensible and dynamic guy like sarfaraz or haris sohail should be made the captain and if guys like shehzad try to do any politics against them, they should be banned for life. sarfaraz even has loads of experience of captaining domestic sides.
but i am sure malik will comeback as a captain.
 
azhar and asad should be kept 10 miles away from the ODI team let alone handing them the captaincy.
i believe a sensible and dynamic guy like sarfaraz or haris sohail should be made the captain and if guys like shehzad try to do any politics against them, they should be banned for life. sarfaraz even has loads of experience of captaining domestic sides.
but i am sure malik will comeback as a captain.

I hate to break it to you but Haris is a dud. cant play spin and cant do anything once a wise captain blocks his favoured offside scoring area. You can say what youw ant about azhar but he has a proven test record unlike haris sahib who doesnt know where his off stumo is. wait till he plays against steyn! ball slanting across will be his undoing!!
 
I hate to break it to you but Haris is a dud. cant play spin and cant do anything once a wise captain blocks his favoured offside scoring area. You can say what youw ant about azhar but he has a proven test record unlike haris sahib who doesnt know where his off stumo is. wait till he plays against steyn! ball slanting across will be his undoing!!

of course he cant play spin. in fact he cant even play fast bowling or medium pace. just another one from the over hyped brigade who has feasted on poor domestic bowling to achieve a 50+ average.
azhar ali is pure class
 
I hate to break it to you but Haris is a dud. cant play spin and cant do anything once a wise captain blocks his favoured offside scoring area. You can say what youw ant about azhar but he has a proven test record unlike haris sahib who doesnt know where his off stumo is. wait till he plays against steyn! ball slanting across will be his undoing!!

Haris is a hundred times better bat than Azhar. Already has bettered Azhar's ODI career and soon will be the case in tests as well.

As for playing Steyn, he will be okay. In the warm-up he was playing Anderson with utmost ease.
 
Malik, I am almost certain about this. It was a mistake to sack him last time & PCB should rectify a howler the did 7 years back. Ideally, Malik should have been PAK ODI Captain for 2011, 2015 & 2019 WC.

For his deputy, I 'll pick one of Amin or Haris; I don't think Shehzad has the personality to lead the side. May be a couple of years time Babar or Aamir can replace them as Malik's deputy & after 2019, one of them should replace Malik as Captain. By 2019 Babar 'll be 24, Aamir 27........ perfect age for Vice Captain & Captain.

We have had this dicussion before. Both Amin and Malik cant hold a bat to save their lives.

And no, it is not going to miraclously change overnight. They both need to get in the team, perform consistently for a substainsal period and then we can talk about captaincy.Of-course the chances of which happening are as bright as YK scoring a ton against SA the coming match.
 
I'm vouching for Shoaib Malik and I have my reasons for it, which don't need to be repeated.

I'd take Amin or Haris as vice captain.

As far as Azhar is concerned, I think one big failure of the Misbah regime was to not allow him to settle as an opener. Quality batsman, who will get some really big scores.

Throw wannabe Kohli out and get Azhar in.
 
I will make Misbah or Afridi (Afiridi being the 1st Choice) to stay at least for 1 year and groom Babar Azam for the next Captain.
 
I'm vouching for Shoaib Malik and I have my reasons for it, which don't need to be repeated.

I'd take Amin or Haris as vice captain.

As far as Azhar is concerned, I think one big failure of the Misbah regime was to not allow him to settle as an opener. Quality batsman, who will get some really big scores.

Throw wannabe Kohli out and get Azhar in.

Now suddenly Azhar is a quality bat. :)))

Azhar getting really big scores will require about two ODI innings. You critisize Fawad( for his lack of boundary hitting ability) and Shehzad( for his lack of Strike rotation) yet vouch for Azhar as an opener. Really?? :))

Azhar is way worse than both of Shehzad and Fawad. He is extremly weak in both those deparments. Horrible at strike rotation and non-existent striking ability; will a disater of epic proportions if tried in ODI's.
 
Now suddenly Azhar is a quality bat. :)))

Azhar getting really big scores will require about two ODI innings. You critisize Fawad( for his lack of boundary hitting ability) and Shehzad( for his lack of Strike rotation) yet vouch for Azhar as an opener. Really?? :))

Azhar is way worse than both of Shehzad and Fawad. He is extremly weak in both those deparments. Horrible at strike rotation and non-existent striking ability; will a disater of epic proportions if tried in ODI's.

Azhar showed great improvement vs. Australia/New Zealand. He had a slump in 2013, but came back in emphatic fashion which is the sign of a quality player, in spite of people wanting him to be dropped for good, an idea no sane person has ever entertained, because Azhar has always been a good Test batsman with excellent technique against the new ball.

One of the chief delusions these days is that Shehzad is the answer to our opening problems and we have unearthed a quality batsman. This guy is nothing against the moving ball, and is as much of an opener as Hafeez is.

Come the away tours of 2016 and he will be exposed brutally.

Azhar is comfortably the best batsman against the new ball in Pakistan and he will be a consistent run scorer everywhere. Yes his strike rotation is not good, but it can't be worse than Shehzad whose SR for the first 50 runs hovers around 65 and consumes 70% dots in PP overs. It can't get worse than that.

I've watched him the Pentangular Cups and he batted superbly and showed flair as well. I won't be judgemental and pass my verdict without giving him a fair chance, because I do think that he plenty of potential.

Its funny how domestic stats are used to defend certain favourites, yet people are turning a blind eye to the fact that he averages 50 in LA. Apparently he is not good enough after just 14 games where he averages 41.

Yes pathetic SR, but 14 games in 5 years is no sample - you can make a case for Shafiq being a proven failure in ODIs (I disagree personally, its more of a mental block in my view and there is still time for him to come good) even though he too has a LA average of 50, but he has played many matches.

Azhar hasn't had much of an opportunity.

Anyhow, I commend you for showing utmost faith in Shehzad who will always remain a mediocre batsman and has been mediocre at every level he has played, barring junior. He has similar domestic stats to Umar Amin for crying out loud, who is supposed to suck in domestic cricket.
 
Back
Top