What's new

Who was the greatest left-handed cricketer after Gary Sobers?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,520
Post of the Week
2
Without doubt Gary Sobers was simply in another league from any left-hand cricketer if not any cricketer .However who was closest or 2nd to him.This is list in my order of merit below



1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Bishen Bedi

9.David Gower

10.Neil Harvey

11.Sannath Jayasuriya

12.Saed Anwar



Wasim at the top because he was virtually the magician of fast bowling taking its' wizardry to heights unexplored and having a phenomeal combined haul of scalps in tests and ODI's.He also won or saved games with the bat.



Lara was in terms of genius as a batsmen the equal of what Wasim was with the ball who traversed regions in batting as arguably none else.No batsmen had such a penchant for amassing huge scores.A whisker below Wasim because he did not have Akram's all-round skills with both ball and bat and as succesful in ODI's and tests.



Gilchrist was the great set match-winner of his day who matched the domination of a Viv Richards.Created the impact of adynamite exploding in full flow and averegaged an incredible 60 +average for the 1st half of his career.



Graeme Pollock was in the Lara class as a batsmen. but was never given a chance to reveal his complete potential.A master in any conditions.





Clive Loyd as a leader and a player was instrumental in defining a new epoch in West Indies cricket making his nation arguably the most invincible side ever.Loyd even overshadowed the great Viv Richards often in a crisis and revealed phenomenal consistency even in his last 4 years .Played some of the best innings against sustained pace like down under in 1975-76.





Alan Border was the best or ultimate batsmen to bat for your life in his era and statistically the best batsmen of his era.Also one of the best skippers of all time who laid the base for Australia to emerge as one of the greatest cricketing sides ever by ressurecting their status as world tset champions.Displayed the same patience in knitting a bunch of scattered but talented individuals as with the bat.







Alan Davidson was the equivalent of a Wasim Akram of his era and a better batsmen.Very quick and economical with a great action.



Bishen Bedi was arguably the most complete of all spinners of his time with the most perfect arm action.In unhelpful conditions better than Derek Underwood.Instrumental in many a famous win for India beit against West Indies,England ,New Zealand or Australia.



David Gower literally took cricketing grace to regions of divinity with his golden touch.A master against great pace or on bouncy surfaces.No batsmen was as effortless in executing strokes.



Neil Harvey morally was in the class of a batsmen who averaged above 50 with his mastery on bad wickets like when scoring an unbeaten 151 in an epic match-winning run chase in the 4th innings v South Africa .



Sannath Jayasuriya gave the art of opening an innings anew dimension in ODI cricket in the 1996 world cup and played some of cricket's most squash buckling innings.



Saed Anwar was one of the most explosive openers ever but never executed his strokes at the cost of feline grace.On his day could sit with the gods of olympus.
 
Please come here viewers [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] [MENTION=538]bilal[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] @Freelance cricketer [MENTION=133315]Hitman[/MENTION]
 
Please come here viewers [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] [MENTION=538]bilal[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] @Freelance cricketer [MENTION=133315]Hitman[/MENTION]

Allan border for me because he was captain if you are looking impact wise I will go Adam Gilchrist
 
Brian Lara. Third greatest batsman of all time after Bradman and Sachin.

He asked about cricketer and not batsman. I believe you have to contribute in at least two departments.

Wasim Akram is right up there: best left handed bowler of all time, handy with the bat and a decent captain.

Sangakkara and Gilly can surely challenge him.
 
Wasim Akram. A world class bowler and one of the best ever is second in my book. Brian Lara is a very close second. I think Wasim was a slightly better bowler then Brain was a batsman moreover Wasim was a much better batsman then Brian was a bowler. When we are talking about a Cricketer as a whole their all round ability is the more important factor.
 
Wasim ahead of Sobers then Lara. Wasim could bowl, bat, field, and was a great captain. No one comes close
 
Adam Gilchrist

He revolutionized the role of wicket-keepers in cricket. For most of his career, he was averaging 50+ in tests with several clutch knocks under his belt. That's remarkable considering how hard it is to keep wickets and then perform as good as a full time batsman consistently. No team has ever enjoyed the luxury that Gilchrist provided to Australia. His World Cup success record is also 100%. 2 50s and 1 100 in 3 world finals. Batted at almost 100 SR in ODIs throughout his career. His wicket keeping never suffered due to his batting. He may not be the most athletic keeper of all time but he was very safe and seldom dropped any chance.
 
Wasim akram
He was a genius with the ball, he could swing both new and old ball both ways and had the most accurate bouncer.
He had great self-belief , passion, aggression and charisma.
Not to forget his MoM in 92 final for his all-round performance.

A close second for me was brian lara. He had tremendous natural ability with the bat and was a treat to watch
 
If only Wasim focused a bit more on his batting!! Cricket missed out on an atg all-rounder. Insanely gifted player.
 
Wasim. one of the most skillful bowlers ever and if he combine his useful batting, he becomes a valuable cricketer.
 
I agree with Wasim being at top.

Other names in no particular order:-

Adam Gilchrist
Brian Lara
Allan Border
Clive Lloyd
Kumar Sangakkara (absurd to leave him out IMO)
 
I agree with Wasim being at top.

Other names in no particular order:-

Adam Gilchrist
Brian Lara
Allan Border
Clive Lloyd
Kumar Sangakkara (absurd to leave him out IMO)

Deeply apologize for that error .I just noted it last evening forgetting earlier that Sangakaara was a left-hander.Will give a corrected list.

Why no Wasim Akram with his outstanding combined record and inexorable talent enough of him to be dubbed as the ultimate fast bowling genius?Appreciate answer.
 
Graeme Pollock but no Sangakkara? Is this serious?

Major error I deeply apologize.Sanga is high up on the list.Forgot he was a left-hander. Thanks for correction.How is this list?

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya
 
Deeply apologize for that error .I just noted it last evening forgetting earlier that Sangakaara was a left-hander.Will give a corrected list.

Why no Wasim Akram with his outstanding combined record and inexorable talent enough of him to be dubbed as the ultimate fast bowling genius?Appreciate answer.

He said Wasim is on the top read his comment.
 
I agree with Wasim being at top.

Other names in no particular order:-

Adam Gilchrist
Brian Lara
Allan Border
Clive Lloyd
Kumar Sangakkara (absurd to leave him out IMO)

Sorry

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya

Like it?Good order ?
 
Major error I deeply apologize.Sanga is high up on the list.Forgot he was a left-hander. Thanks for correction.How is this list?

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya

Some players were talented,some were impactfull,some were eye to watch but no other player was tough and fighter like AB
 
Wasim Akram. A world class bowler and one of the best ever is second in my book. Brian Lara is a very close second. I think Wasim was a slightly better bowler then Brain was a batsman moreover Wasim was a much better batsman then Brian was a bowler. When we are talking about a Cricketer as a whole their all round ability is the more important factor.

We virtually agree but it is significant that Lara's peak performances were considerably better with his great mammoth scores and his best knocks to turn games.Lara carried on his shoulders much more the burden of his team's batting than Wasim had to with the ball.Wasim has never turned a series as Lara did against Australia in 1999 single- handedly or equalled Lara's unbeaten 153 performance at Barbados.In pure test cricket Lara had the edge being marginally more impactful but overall Wasim possibly wins.In pure talent it was virtually a draw.
 
Sorry

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya

Like it?Good order ?

where is graeme smith?
 
Do come [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] and [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=538]bilal[/MENTION] [MENTION=133315]Hitman[/MENTION] I have made a corrected list including Sangakaara.Like views on my selection and order.
 
Allan border for me because he was captain if you are looking impact wise I will go Adam Gilchrist

Missed out although stats wise a giant as he was genearly a match-saver with the bat and not as flamboyant or talented as Wasim,Brian or Gilly.
 
Wasim. one of the most skillful bowlers ever and if he combine his useful batting, he becomes a valuable cricketer.

In pure test cricket I feel Lara out performed him but adding ODIs Wasim wins.agree?Who was the closest to these 2 in your opinion?
 
Missed out although stats wise a giant as he was genearly a match-saver with the bat and not as flamboyant or talented as Wasim,Brian or Gilly.

thats what i like about him even though he wasnt that eye watching but he always be there in tough situations only steve waugh and javed miandad comes close to him.
 
Last edited:
Greatness is not judged by records or talent but what impact they had on the game..

I would rate ganguly in top 10 as he changed the face of Indian cricket which if you see now is currently ruling world cricket. So he deserves a special mention over players like Saeed Anwar or Alan Davidson etc.

Top 3 are unanimous for almost everyone
1. Lara
2. Wasim
3. Gilchrist.

The rankings of these 3 can be interchanged but overall they will be the top 3 in any list. If not then that list holds no merit.
 
In pure test cricket I feel Lara out performed him but adding ODIs Wasim wins.agree?Who was the closest to these 2 in your opinion?

Greatness is not defined by records it's defined by legacy the player has left.

Wasim has inspired so many left arm Pacers around the world and in Pakistan alone there are more left hand bowlers Thane ight hand because of Wasim Akram. I would rate Wasim as a greater cricketer than Lara just slightly.

Lara might be the better performing player but as cricketing greatness goes Wasim is in top 3 ever slightly behind Tendulkar and Bradman only and ahead of Gilly and Viv.
 
Greatness is not judged by records or talent but what impact they had on the game..

I would rate ganguly in top 10 as he changed the face of Indian cricket which if you see now is currently ruling world cricket. So he deserves a special mention over players like Saeed Anwar or Alan Davidson etc.

Top 3 are unanimous for almost everyone
1. Lara
2. Wasim
3. Gilchrist.

The rankings of these 3 can be interchanged but overall they will be the top 3 in any list. If not then that list holds no merit.

Broadly agree However Not Sangakaara?Any particular reason ?I agree on Ganguly.In my top 15,
 
Broadly agree However Not Sangakaara?Any particular reason ?I agree on Ganguly.In my top 15,

Sangakara will not be in top 3.

Wasim and Gilly revolutioned something which was never seen before. Not just being pioneers in their respective roles they also inspired so many youngsters to take up the role. They changed the face of cricket.

Lara was just one of the best batsman ever to play the game so he gets a nod above samgakarra.

Sanga will rank somewhere in top 10 no doubt.
 
Sorry

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya

Like it?Good order ?

Definitely liked it.
 
This is probably a list dominated by Test performance - undoubtedly Wasim Akram. I would rather say over all he is the MVP among natural left-handers - one of very greatest fast bowlers of all time and a much better batsman at 8, compared to his stats. And, he is probably the 2nd best ODI player ever after Viv.

Apart from top few, it's really difficult to rank others, but two players I see missing in your revised list are Hayden, Shakib and Vinnu Mankad - I don't think Gower & Sanath belongs to here before them, probably Headley Verity as well, but Shakib still has few years time to make it. Lloyd is too high for me, should be below AB and Sanga, rest are probably perfect.
 
2nd: Kumar Sangakkara. 63 centuries. 145 50s. 26k+ runs. 100+ dismissals. Captained. Gave it up for the team.

The ultimate left hander after Sobers is:
who changed the game twice.
First, the fielders became spectators and the spcetators became fielders.
Then, people outside the stadium became the fielders and both fielders and spectators just watched balls fly outside the stadium. THE UNIVERSE BOSS.
 
Sorry

Revised list

1.Wasim Akram

2.Brian Lara

3.Adam Gilchrist

4.Graeme Pollock

5.Clive Lloyd

6.Alan Border

7.Alan Davidson

8.Kumar Sangakaara

9.Bishen Bedi

10..David Gower

11.Neil Harvey

12.Sannath Jayasuriya

Like it?Good order ?


Where is Christopher Henry Gayle? Still incomplete list. Can you fathom 175 notout in 20 over game? How about 2 triple centuries in test? No Man in this world can claim to have 10k in all three format. First Class, List A, T20 - except Gayle.
 
Where is Christopher Henry Gayle? Still incomplete list. Can you fathom 175 notout in 20 over game? How about 2 triple centuries in test? No Man in this world can claim to have 10k in all three format. First Class, List A, T20 - except Gayle.

You are almost right .just missed by a whisker below Jayasuriya or Anwar .Gayle the as great no doubt,
 
This is probably a list dominated by Test performance - undoubtedly Wasim Akram. I would rather say over all he is the MVP among natural left-handers - one of very greatest fast bowlers of all time and a much better batsman at 8, compared to his stats. And, he is probably the 2nd best ODI player ever after Viv.

Apart from top few, it's really difficult to rank others, but two players I see missing in your revised list are Hayden, Shakib and Vinnu Mankad - I don't think Gower & Sanath belongs to here before them, probably Headley Verity as well, but Shakib still has few years time to make it. Lloyd is too high for me, should be below AB and Sanga, rest are probably perfect.

Very well analysed. Rated Lloyd should high because of his contribution to make West Indies a super power as a leader and cricketer.Also a match winner.Gower poseses aritistrybin regions of divinity playing great bowling more effortlessly than anyone.
 
This is probably a list dominated by Test performance - undoubtedly Wasim Akram. I would rather say over all he is the MVP among natural left-handers - one of very greatest fast bowlers of all time and a much better batsman at 8, compared to his stats. And, he is probably the 2nd best ODI player ever after Viv.

Apart from top few, it's really difficult to rank others, but two players I see missing in your revised list are Hayden, Shakib and Vinnu Mankad - I don't think Gower & Sanath belongs to here before them, probably Headley Verity as well, but Shakib still has few years time to make it. Lloyd is too high for me, should be below AB and Sanga, rest are probably perfect.

How would you compare Lara with Wasim in tests and combined?Gilchrist on par?
 
How would you compare Lara with Wasim in tests and combined?Gilchrist on par?

Wasim - then Lara & Gilliy at per, with a gap. Fast bowling all-rounders are the MVP of Test game, can't compare the best of them with any batsman. In fact, Gilly probably contributed more with his game than BC, but he played for one of the teams of history for a decade, which will be a discounting factor for him, hence per with Lara. schievements.
 
Very well analysed. Rated Lloyd should high because of his contribution to make West Indies a super power as a leader and cricketer.Also a match winner.Gower poseses aritistrybin regions of divinity playing great bowling more effortlessly than anyone.

But, AB also did almost the same for AUS in their crisis time - he also took an Aussie side to Test & ODI best in 5 years time from a spot just above SRL in mid 80s.
 
Back
Top