One honest question - and I want an honest answer as well.
Q: Which is the more dumber Captaincy - MoYo at SCG (2010) or Sarfraz at Dubai (2018)?
I start with my personal opinion - Sarfraz.
Though MoYo lost that Test after a 200+ lead (only 6 times teams have lost after a 200+ lead, 3 times bowling in 3rd innings of the game, and 3 times after following on). But, he had some excuses as well - playing away & at one of the toughest place to play cricket against hosts - AUS. Then he was hard done by his WKeeper and fielders, and most importantly, AUS was setting target there in 3rd innings & Mike Hussey anchored the innings from one end. His batsmen (including himself) failed to chase 170ish target, otherwise still he could have won that Test - it was equally a batting failure as well.
Here this Sarfraz chap had 280 lead on a slow turning wicket with 200 overs left in game when his team started 2nd innings, against a team as bad as MoYo's opponent were as good in respective condition, exhausted in the desert heat, still not acclimatized with Dubai wicket & FC games (their domestic FC season hasn't started yet), under (or over) prepared from 67 overs of Iftekhar;s spin - and they had absolutely no chance of winning the game on last innings; only thing left for them was a hopeless rear guard to save the game & they did that, because of the ineptness of PAK Captain. On Day 5, it was AUS in control of the game for like 5 of the 6 hours, and Sarfraz just went through the motion, and led his side like they were trying to save the game.
Discuss pls ....