What's new

Why is Imran Khan not expanding the tax net?

Pakistanis have a long term issue with not paying taxes.
SOLUTION
COPORATION TAX & VAT
Pakistanis won't be able to dodge those(coporation taxes will require inland revenue audits to catch tax dodgers).

Charge VAT on everything, see the money flood in. Cigarettes, petrol(cng), meat, gas and electric, mobile phones and networks, internet isp etc.
Sure some of these already may have VAT, increase it!
 
Pakistanis have a long term issue with not paying taxes.
SOLUTION
COPORATION TAX & VAT
Pakistanis won't be able to dodge those(coporation taxes will require inland revenue audits to catch tax dodgers).

Charge VAT on everything, see the money flood in. Cigarettes, petrol(cng), meat, gas and electric, mobile phones and networks, internet isp etc.
Sure some of these already may have VAT, increase it!
British Pakistanis will testify to this fact.
Even in the UK they know all the tricks to avoid paying tax whilst maxing on government benefits.
A change in mindset is required and it will not happen in 4-5 years.
 
So you agree that Nawaz and Zardari has looted the nation, eh? At least, you and PTI-supporters agree on something.

You don’t want the government to get the looted money back? You know, to put the money into good use.

Every politician is corrupt including Imran, but corruption does not impede progress when you build competencies. Even if PTI recovers a few billions, you cannot expect them to put it to good use.

It will either go into the pockets of the establishment or the crooks and frauds in PTI or wasted in projects like BRT, whose mismanagement has resulted in the loss of billions of rupees.

Moreover, the corruption of Nawaz, Zardari and Imran pales in comparison to the corruption of the military top brass.
 
NS is still a convict and has begged for his life( and lied) and AZ is still behind bars. Are you saying that havent stolen money? Do you think they would be walking around if they were Saudi and China?

Zardari will be out soon and your leader will be left weeping in Bunny Gala. Let’s face it - he is not up to the task and it has been proved that he holds no real power.
 
British Pakistanis will testify to this fact.
Even in the UK they know all the tricks to avoid paying tax whilst maxing on government benefits.
A change in mindset is required and it will not happen in 4-5 years.
The self employed
In pakistan, most people are self employed - shopkeepers, rickshaw drivers, food sellers
Thereby increasing VAT on goods, fuel and meat, will help to recoup some of the missing taxes.
 
Okay buddy whatever helps you sleep at night. I can see you are taking this entire issue really personally. You must be feeling humiliated and embarrassed.

You morals are not my morals, keep loving the dynastic crooks, and make sure that you tell your children to be the ghulam of Maryam like you are with the Duffer. Tell them that is their fate!
 
Every politician is corrupt including Imran, but corruption does not impede progress when you build competencies. Even if PTI recovers a few billions, you cannot expect them to put it to good use.

It will either go into the pockets of the establishment or the crooks and frauds in PTI or wasted in projects like BRT, whose mismanagement has resulted in the loss of billions of rupees.

Moreover, the corruption of Nawaz, Zardari and Imran pales in comparison to the corruption of the military top brass.

PPP have been in power for 10 years in Sindh- tell us their great success stories! lol
 
PPP have been in power for 10 years in Sindh- tell us their great success stories! lol

To build competency you have to get the military out of the economy and out of departments like PTCL, WAPDA, PCB etc. where they get jobs simply because of their uniforms.
 
To build competency you have to get the military out of the economy and out of departments like PTCL, WAPDA, PCB etc. where they get jobs simply because of their uniforms.
Would you subscribe to all ex military personel being barred from holding any public office?
 
The self employed
In pakistan, most people are self employed - shopkeepers, rickshaw drivers, food sellers
Thereby increasing VAT on goods, fuel and meat, will help to recoup some of the missing taxes.

I’m not an economist in any sense but wouldn’t what you are saying just lead to the shopkeepers increasing prices to recoup the extra tax, thus leading to further inflationary pressure? More suffering for the average civilian.
 
I’m not an economist in any sense but wouldn’t what you are saying just lead to the shopkeepers increasing prices to recoup the extra tax, thus leading to further inflationary pressure? More suffering for the average civilian.
Possibly, but with competition, its hard for a shopkeeper to increase prices too much, as customers will seek a cheaper rival or not buy the goods. So its a fine balance for the shopkeeper.
Inflation will have to occur in pakistan when fuel and utilities are so heavily subsidised and the self employed are with holding taxes.
Its tough medicine, but if you want to improve the financial situation in pakistan, then you have to be tough or continue to go around the west and the middle east with a begging bowl.
 
Personally, i would tax weddings to the max in pakistan.
Pakistanis spend a fortune on weddings, i would charge a huge marriage certificate fee and charge wedding venues huge taxes and ban taboo guys and the use of roads and fields for wedding receptions. Also, increase the VAT on gold.
 
Every politician is corrupt including Imran, but corruption does not impede progress when you build competencies. Even if PTI recovers a few billions, you cannot expect them to put it to good use.

It will either go into the pockets of the establishment or the crooks and frauds in PTI or wasted in projects like BRT, whose mismanagement has resulted in the loss of billions of rupees.

Moreover, the corruption of Nawaz, Zardari and Imran pales in comparison to the corruption of the military top brass.

Only when the top leadership is honest and not implicit. Corruption will always impede progress when the top leadership is corrupt because there is a conflict of interest. As long as the top leadership is honest, the country can grow. So you’re right to a certain degree, but corruption will always impede growth if the top leadership is corrupt because they will always put their financial interests before that of the nation.
Deng Xiaoping, the architect behind China’s success overlooked the corruption of his ministers but he himself wasn’t corrupt and was actually quite nationalistic.

I haven’t been in Peshawar and so can’t speak much about the whole BRT disaster, but from what I’ve read, it’s a complete failure. Is that a sign of Imran’s incompetence? Absolutely.

I can however speak for Lahore. I was in Lahore this June and besides the Orange Metro and the roads(which wouldn’t have been possible without the Chinese), not much has changed since I last visited the city in 2012. Lahore is still a very bad place to live in, especially now, with regards to the pollution. So why are we fooling ourselves into believing that the Sharifs are ”corrupt but competent”?

And since you believe that Nawaz/Shahbaz and Zardari are ”corrupt but competent”, let’s put things into perspective. All three of them have been in politics for almost 40 years, what good have they done apart from building silly metros with Chinese money that puts the country into more debt? Is that a sign of their insincerity? Or is that a sign of their incompetence? Either way, those crooks won’t bring any change.

Let’s forget about Imran, he has only led the nation for a little over a year. Nawaz and Zardari have been in positions of power since the 80s, and still, poorer nations like Rwanda have made more progress in less than 10 years compared to what those lot have done in over 40 years. That’s not especially competent.

What I don’t understand is how you’re fine with supporting corrupt crooks? They haven’t changed the country for the better despite having political careers that have lasted for over 40 years. This whole notion of ”corrupt but competent” and ”Corruption won’t impede progress” is complete **. If anything, those lots are more incompetent.
 
It doesn't matter because if Imran Khan is stealing it's for the benefit of the country and he's the greatest thing even and everyone else is a chor

The article written by an absolute clown called Fakhar Durrani. I know him from Twitter, i challenge you to check his Twitter account and if you can point out single unbiased tweet then we will discuss Imran Khan's taxes. You can't tell if he is local PMLN MPA or an actual full time journalist (this is how shamelessly he runs smear campaigns along with group of half dozen Sharif die hards)

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">آپکی بھول ہے۔ سب سے زیادہ زہریلے اور بد زبان نام نہاد پڑھے لکھے یوتھیے ہیں۔ <a href="https://t.co/oH20gFz6If">https://t.co/oH20gFz6If</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196860064067473408?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 19, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">ملک کو مکمل طور پر مفلوج ہونے سےبچانے کے لیےجون 2020 سے پہلے مڈ ٹرم الیکشن ہوجانے چاہیے۔اس سے پہلے انتخابی اصلاحات لانے کے لیے کسی بھی نگران سیٹ یا ان ہاوس تبدیلی لانے کےلیے کسی بھی کوشش کو ن لیگ سپورٹ کرے گی۔ن لیگ کے رہنما احسن اقبال کی پینوگ سے گفتگو۔<a href="https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj">https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196101602949636098?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 17, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Another one said "Most famous discussion in Islamabad circles is "Only Shahbaz Speed can save Pakistan from such a disastrous situation".

Now you want me to believe these low lives??

As for Imran's taxes, this has been discussed in courts many times already. Can you tell me what is wrong with Imran's taxes though? Do you understand low income tax means he had low income? You are old enough to understand Imran Khan did NOT work in last 25 or so years and gets income from some agriculture land that he inherited. And yet you are comparing him to Sharifs or other crooks? I thought you were better than that really.
 
The article written by an absolute clown called Fakhar Durrani. I know him from Twitter, i challenge you to check his Twitter account and if you can point out single unbiased tweet then we will discuss Imran Khan's taxes. You can't tell if he is local PMLN MPA or an actual full time journalist (this is how shamelessly he runs smear campaigns along with group of half dozen Sharif die hards)

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">آپکی بھول ہے۔ سب سے زیادہ زہریلے اور بد زبان نام نہاد پڑھے لکھے یوتھیے ہیں۔ <a href="https://t.co/oH20gFz6If">https://t.co/oH20gFz6If</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196860064067473408?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 19, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">ملک کو مکمل طور پر مفلوج ہونے سےبچانے کے لیےجون 2020 سے پہلے مڈ ٹرم الیکشن ہوجانے چاہیے۔اس سے پہلے انتخابی اصلاحات لانے کے لیے کسی بھی نگران سیٹ یا ان ہاوس تبدیلی لانے کےلیے کسی بھی کوشش کو ن لیگ سپورٹ کرے گی۔ن لیگ کے رہنما احسن اقبال کی پینوگ سے گفتگو۔<a href="https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj">https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196101602949636098?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 17, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Another one said "Most famous discussion in Islamabad circles is "Only Shahbaz Speed can save Pakistan from such a disastrous situation".

Now you want me to believe these low lives??

As for Imran's taxes, this has been discussed in courts many times already. Can you tell me what is wrong with Imran's taxes though? Do you understand low income tax means he had low income? You are old enough to understand Imran Khan did NOT work in last 25 or so years and gets income from some agriculture land that he inherited. And yet you are comparing him to Sharifs or other crooks? I thought you were better than that really.

I stand corrected. I don't know much about the topic to comment. My mistake. You are most probably correct. Apologies.
 
Every journalist who shows PTI the mirror is biased, but every journalist who criticizes PMLN/PPP is impartial. I love how PTI supporters draw the line.
 
Would you subscribe to all ex military personel being barred from holding any public office?

Yes unless they have relevant educational background which most of them do not. In Pakistan, the vast majority of the people who join the military are academic failures.
 
[MENTION=149370]AdamM97[/MENTION]

I don’t think Nawaz is competent. He is actually a fool. The only competition politician in PMLN in Shehbaz, and if he were the elder brother, PMLN would have had a different outlook today. I also see good potential in Bilawal but only if he is able to step out of Zardari’s shadow. Shehbaz is dedicated and hard working. Yes he is corrupt but he has some qualities that Nawaz and Imran both lack.

The problem with PTI is that their accountability drive is a sham. They refuse to hold their own crooks accountable and more importantly, Imran himself refuses to come clean. If he has nothing to hide, he wouldn’t be running from his foreign funding case for 5 years and PTI wouldn’t be demanded secrecy in investigation.

I am regret to say this but Imran is either a con-artist or someone who suffers from severe Messiah complex and considers himself above the law. Moreover, his party is also incompetent as we have seen during their 6 years of below average governance in KP.

It is fine if people don’t want Sharifs and Bhuttos in power, but when they serve up Imran and his fake party as the alternative that would drive the country forward, they cannot be taken seriously. I call PTI a fake party because it has no roots. It is surviving on the shoulders of opportunistic crooks in the parliament who will be reabsorbed into other parties when Imran is gone. PTI has no future without Imran.
 
The article written by an absolute clown called Fakhar Durrani. I know him from Twitter, i challenge you to check his Twitter account and if you can point out single unbiased tweet then we will discuss Imran Khan's taxes. You can't tell if he is local PMLN MPA or an actual full time journalist (this is how shamelessly he runs smear campaigns along with group of half dozen Sharif die hards)

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">آپکی بھول ہے۔ سب سے زیادہ زہریلے اور بد زبان نام نہاد پڑھے لکھے یوتھیے ہیں۔ <a href="https://t.co/oH20gFz6If">https://t.co/oH20gFz6If</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196860064067473408?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 19, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="ur" dir="rtl">ملک کو مکمل طور پر مفلوج ہونے سےبچانے کے لیےجون 2020 سے پہلے مڈ ٹرم الیکشن ہوجانے چاہیے۔اس سے پہلے انتخابی اصلاحات لانے کے لیے کسی بھی نگران سیٹ یا ان ہاوس تبدیلی لانے کےلیے کسی بھی کوشش کو ن لیگ سپورٹ کرے گی۔ن لیگ کے رہنما احسن اقبال کی پینوگ سے گفتگو۔<a href="https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj">https://t.co/uF1ktfn0tj</a></p>— Fakhar Durrani (@FrehmanD) <a href="https://twitter.com/FrehmanD/status/1196101602949636098?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 17, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Another one said "Most famous discussion in Islamabad circles is "Only Shahbaz Speed can save Pakistan from such a disastrous situation".

Now you want me to believe these low lives??

As for Imran's taxes, this has been discussed in courts many times already. Can you tell me what is wrong with Imran's taxes though? Do you understand low income tax means he had low income? You are old enough to understand Imran Khan did NOT work in last 25 or so years and gets income from some agriculture land that he inherited. And yet you are comparing him to Sharifs or other crooks? I thought you were better than that really.

Actually anything The News publishes has to be taken with a barrel of salt. It is a fake news production house. Only patwaris and sons of corrupt FBR officers take them seriously.
 
To build competency you have to get the military out of the economy and out of departments like PTCL, WAPDA, PCB etc. where they get jobs simply because of their uniforms.

But who appointed the most of the workers of the SOE- Who bankrupted PSM,PIA and virtually everything they laid their hands on? Yes, you guessed it THE NOORAS AND BILLO PARTY. I asked a simple question about PPP competency and as regular readers who know, you run every time. So once again after 11 years in power in Sindh, What are their achievements?
 
Its not the leaving, its the fact that they claimed he was at deaths door( and the thick Nooras believed him) and was intensive care and they ***** was walking around yesterday and their was no Intensive care and no deaths door. Hence the humiliation for trusting the duffer. I bet you also believed he was at deaths door!

To be fair Imran Khans's own doctors checked Nawaz Sharif and agree with other doctors that Nawaz Sharif is in serious medical emergency.

But the way Nawaz Sharif has gone out it looks like all doctors (both Nawaz Sharif's and Imran Khan's) were lying. God knows what is the truth.
 
But who appointed the most of the workers of the SOE- Who bankrupted PSM,PIA and virtually everything they laid their hands on? Yes, you guessed it THE NOORAS AND BILLO PARTY. I asked a simple question about PPP competency and as regular readers who know, you run every time. So once again after 11 years in power in Sindh, What are their achievements?

A fact that these patwaris ignore is that when Mush left PIA and PSM were running profits. I'm not sure how the Railways was doing but it definitely wasn't stacking up massive annual losses like it has been doing for the past 10-12 years.
 
[MENTION=149370]AdamM97[/MENTION]

I don’t think Nawaz is competent. He is actually a fool. The only competition politician in PMLN in Shehbaz, and if he were the elder brother, PMLN would have had a different outlook today. I also see good potential in Bilawal but only if he is able to step out of Zardari’s shadow. Shehbaz is dedicated and hard working. Yes he is corrupt but he has some qualities that Nawaz and Imran both lack.

The problem with PTI is that their accountability drive is a sham. They refuse to hold their own crooks accountable and more importantly, Imran himself refuses to come clean. If he has nothing to hide, he wouldn’t be running from his foreign funding case for 5 years and PTI wouldn’t be demanded secrecy in investigation.

I am regret to say this but Imran is either a con-artist or someone who suffers from severe Messiah complex and considers himself above the law. Moreover, his party is also incompetent as we have seen during their 6 years of below average governance in KP.

It is fine if people don’t want Sharifs and Bhuttos in power, but when they serve up Imran and his fake party as the alternative that would drive the country forward, they cannot be taken seriously. I call PTI a fake party because it has no roots. It is surviving on the shoulders of opportunistic crooks in the parliament who will be reabsorbed into other parties when Imran is gone. PTI has no future without Imran.

Can you tell why us SS the "competent" guy took 100bn surplus in Punjab to a 2 trillion deficit? Can you tell what he did with that money? Your knowledge of this like your knowledge of anything else is like a primary school kid.
 
A fact that these patwaris ignore is that when Mush left PIA and PSM were running profits. I'm not sure how the Railways was doing but it definitely wasn't stacking up massive annual losses like it has been doing for the past 10-12 years.

Yaar please. This is not a fact. The last time PIA was in profit was in 2004 after that they have been in loss continuously. Mush resigned in 2008 by that time the vs 2004 there was 1666% drop in profitability for PIA.

Since 2004 PIA has been showing a negative trend in profitability. The only time this turned around was in 2013-2015 when the trend turned positive (Still incurring a loss but a decreasing YOY loss).

2018 has been the worst year on record in terms of profitability for PIA.

Under Musharraf, Shukar Aziz tried to privatize PSM was privatized and I think almost 75% of it was sold off resulting in major losses so much so that a bail out package was agreed. The mill was nationalized by Gillani in 2011 resulting in an expanded capacity for the mill
 
These Noora's and the Billoo Rani's are the most badniyat people on this planet even more than their leaders. When NS was in Prison, they criticized IK for political victimization, for lacking empathy, for violating human rights, for endangering NS's health and now that IK agreed to let him for his health, these people are making fun of him for being a Wuss and not behaving like a dictator. Thats all these Noora's and Billoo Rani's are good for, running their mouths mindlessly, making fun of the premier but offering zilch solutions for the countries problems.

Personally i am dissapointed in IK, he should have behaved like a dictator from Day 1. Dictatorship is not always bad, if Muhattir Muhammad can do it for Malaysia, if Fidel Castro can do it for Cuba, why can't IK do it for Pakistan?
 
Every journalist who shows PTI the mirror is biased, but every journalist who criticizes PMLN/PPP is impartial. I love how PTI supporters draw the line.

If you're using that logic, then don't bother calling out people who quote the likes of Sabir Shakir for their 'news'.

Bias is bias, either way.
 
Pakistan uses tech to boost tax ratio

Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio has remained stagnant at around 11% for the past two decades. To overcome the chronic fiscal weakness, the government has decided to accelerate unconventional drive of deploying technology like point of sales (POS) at retail outlets over the next six months.

The government has targeted to deploy around 8,500 electronic devices like POS at retail outlets by end of December 2020 with the primary objective of bringing vendors into the taxpayers net and document financial transactions and the economy.

“The narrow tax base has been expanded by bringing retailers into the tax net and successful installation of point of sales (POS) system at 6,616 retail outlets with the aim to increase the number to 15,000 by December this year,” Federal Minister for Industries and Production Hammad Azhar said while presenting the budget for FY21 at the national assembly the other day. “The efforts (including policy reforms) have so far produced encouraging results with a promising future,” he said.

Therefore, the federal government has proposed in the budget for FY21 to decrease the rate of sales tax to 12% for retailers registered with POS from 14% at present. “This (rate cut) will give relief to common man and to business (including from Covid-19 effects). The measure will help in documentation of economy.”

“Today Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio stands at 11% which is the lowest among emerging countries. Regrettably this key indicator of fiscal strength has remained stagnant over the past 20 years,” Azhar said.

The government has targeted to collect Rs4.9 trillion in taxes during the next fiscal year starting July. That is around 26% higher than the estimated collection of Rs3.9 trillion in the outgoing fiscal year 2020.

Other measures to improve tax-to-GDP ratio include the recent launch of a tax return mobile app to facilitate individuals and salaried persons. The application has helped in increasing the number of income tax return filers by 37%, the minister said.

Besides, an automated system of payment of taxes through online platforms has been introduced.

“To broaden the tax base, the condition of CNIC was introduced in Finance Act 2019, since persons involved in furtherance of taxable activity need to be captured through such measures. However, in order to ease compliance cost, it is being proposed that the threshold may be enhanced from Rs50,000 to Rs100,000,” he said.

Moreover, successful anti-smuggling and enforcement drives have been carried out which led to increase in seizures from Rs19 billion to 30 billion. The crackdown against smugglers would also help in increasing the number of taxpayers and collection of revenue in taxes.

The revenue collection during the pre-covid period has also been commendable. The domestic taxes had witnessed a growth of 27% and collection from import grew by 7%. But the expected growth in revenues was marred initially by the structural adjustments in the economy and then by the pandemic, which has indiscriminately affected all countries of the world.

Resultantly, the revenue target for fiscal year 2020 of Rs5.5 trillion which was revised to Rs4.8 trillion in view of policy induced import compression was further revised downwards to Rs3.9 trillion. “However, this did not deter us from taking steps to avert possible economic shocks of this pandemic,” he added.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2246940/2-pakistan-uses-tech-boost-tax-ratio/
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">FBR's tax collection was increasing at a rate of 17% in the ongoing fiscal year 2019-20 by February 2020. Due to the lockdown and partial closures caused by COVID-19 pandemic, FBR incurred an estimated revenue loss of Rs 800 billion in the remaining 4 months. <a href="https://t.co/LAxjS6cKEQ">pic.twitter.com/LAxjS6cKEQ</a></p>— Pakistan Economy (@EconomyNowPK) <a href="https://twitter.com/EconomyNowPK/status/1275692098302414849?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 24, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Sindh government stops collection of withholding tax for Centre

The Sindh government has officially halted tax collection for the Centre, a day after Chief Minister Sindh Murad Ali Shah said that the province had conveyed the message to the federal government in this regard.

The Sindh Excise and Taxation Department’s Motor Registration wing has halted the collection of withholding taxes, it said on Wednesday.

Sindh Minister for Excise and Taxation and Narcotics Control and Parliamentary Affairs Mukesh Kumar Chawla said that the tax collection has been stopped under a decision taken by the Sindh Cabinet.

Chawla said that the federal government "should now make the mechanism for collecting the withholding tax by itself".

Centre failed to help Sindh: CM Shah

A day earlier, Shah had announced that the provincial government would not collect advance income tax on behalf of the federal government.

According to a report by The News, Shah urged the federal government to take better care of citizens as the public would no longer tolerate how important national issues were being handled by the Centre.

In his address to the Sindh Assembly, Shah was of the view that the federal government had handled the issues of sugar, flour, petrol and the recent crisis of locusts to the utter disadvantage of the people of the country.

He informed the House that the federal government had a separate ministry for national food security and research, and another dedicated agency for plants that must deal with the locust emergency, but these institutions were yet to come into action against the emerging problem threatening the food security of Pakistan.

He said the federal authorities had not fulfilled their obligations regarding aerial spray to be conducted against the locust swarms in the province. He added that the Centre had also not lived up to its commitment to provide aircraft for conducting aerial spray against locusts in Sindh.

The chief minister maintained that his government had been compelled to take such a decision after the federal government unilaterally took an adverse decision regarding the levy of the income tax.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/295799-sindh-government-stops-tax-collection-on-behalf-of-centre
 
K-P achieves Rs17b revenue target for FY20

PESHAWAR: The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Revenue Authority (KPRA) claimed on Thursday to have successfully achieved its revenue target of Rs17 billion for the fiscal year 2019-20 that ended on June 30.

The KPRA showed 63.4 per cent growth rate in revenue collection compared to the fiscal year 2018-19, despite the catastrophic impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the overall economy and business activities in the province.

In the fiscal year 2018-19, the revenue authority had collected Rs10.4 billion, which shows 63 per cent growth rate in the year 2019-20.

All the regions of the authority successfully completed their revenue targets showing tremendous growth compared to the previous year.

The major part of the collection came from Peshawar, with over Rs11.4 billion in revenue in both corporate and non-corporate sectors.

Similarly, revenue collection from Mardan was about Rs284 million, the north region Rs172 million, while the recently established south region collected Rs208 million in fiscal 2019-20.

About Rs1.2 billion were generated from the sales tax on services on oil and gas sector, while Rs1.95 billion were collected from withholding agents.

Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) Finance Minister Taimur Khan Jhagra and Director-General KPRA Fayyaz Ali Shah appreciated the efforts of the revenue authority’s employees for achieving these revenue targets in such extraordinary circumstances.

Minister Jhagra congratulated DG KPRA and his team for their performance, and helping the government gather funds for financing its developmental projects.

He said that the KPRA was an outcome of the present government's reforms, and hoped that the authority would show more improvement with even more promising results by the end of the next fiscal year.

“Achieving these revenue targets in the current circumstances is really a proud moment for us. We are thankful for the support and encouragement of the K-P government, particularly the finance minister who made this possible," said DG KPRA.

"We are committed to not only continuing on the current growth rate but to further increase it in the new fiscal year. We have to build a tax culture in the province and our aim is to make Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa fiscally self-reliant," he added.
https://tribune.com.pk/story/2252931/k-p-achieves-rs17b-revenue-target-for-fy20
 
Sindh government stops collection of withholding tax for Centre

The Sindh government has officially halted tax collection for the Centre, a day after Chief Minister Sindh Murad Ali Shah said that the province had conveyed the message to the federal government in this regard.

The Sindh Excise and Taxation Department’s Motor Registration wing has halted the collection of withholding taxes, it said on Wednesday.

Sindh Minister for Excise and Taxation and Narcotics Control and Parliamentary Affairs Mukesh Kumar Chawla said that the tax collection has been stopped under a decision taken by the Sindh Cabinet.

Chawla said that the federal government "should now make the mechanism for collecting the withholding tax by itself".

Centre failed to help Sindh: CM Shah

A day earlier, Shah had announced that the provincial government would not collect advance income tax on behalf of the federal government.

According to a report by The News, Shah urged the federal government to take better care of citizens as the public would no longer tolerate how important national issues were being handled by the Centre.

In his address to the Sindh Assembly, Shah was of the view that the federal government had handled the issues of sugar, flour, petrol and the recent crisis of locusts to the utter disadvantage of the people of the country.

He informed the House that the federal government had a separate ministry for national food security and research, and another dedicated agency for plants that must deal with the locust emergency, but these institutions were yet to come into action against the emerging problem threatening the food security of Pakistan.

He said the federal authorities had not fulfilled their obligations regarding aerial spray to be conducted against the locust swarms in the province. He added that the Centre had also not lived up to its commitment to provide aircraft for conducting aerial spray against locusts in Sindh.

The chief minister maintained that his government had been compelled to take such a decision after the federal government unilaterally took an adverse decision regarding the levy of the income tax.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/295799-sindh-government-stops-tax-collection-on-behalf-of-centre

Sindh Govt can't refuse to collect tax on behalf of Centre: Ismail

ISLAMABAD: Sindh Governor Imran Ismail Thursday said the provincial government could not refuse to collect tax on behalf of the Federal Government as it could create a crisis in the country.

There was a ruling of the Supreme Court under which no provincial government could deny collecting tax, he said while talking to a private news channel.

Governor Ismail said Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah was a senior politician, who would review the decision.

The Federal Government, however, had many options to resolve the issue, if the Sindh government did not take a correct decision, he added.

https://www.brecorder.com/news/4000...use-to-collect-tax-on-behalf-of-centre-ismail
 
‘Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio not very low as compared to other regional countries’

LAHORE: Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio of 14 percent is not very low as compared to other countries of the region, including Sri Lanka (13 percent), India (18 percent), and Bangladesh (8.5 percent), said the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) sources.

They said this ratio can vary by as much as 15 percentage points even in advanced countries, adding that both the government and donors have established a misleading narrative that Pakistan has a tax-to-GDP ratio lower than some other countries.

Sources said the current target of the IMF for a tax-to-GDP ratio of 16.7 percent by FY 2021-22 is unrealistic and cannot be achieved without enhancing the taxable capacity of the country. Yet curiously the design of the target and measures to achieve it has stifled economic activity. As in the rest of the world, for revenues to increase we need economic growth. Yet policy is killing transactions through arbitrary taxes and the costly documentation drive.

They said not only is our tax policy not based on conceptual clarity but it is also being changed continuously to meet unrealistic targets. The tax rates are high and keep changing several times a year through exemptions and SROs in mini budgets, they added and pointed out that the uncertainty due to continuous tax changes is a huge drag on investment which, as a percentage of GDP, is already among the lowest in the world.

Similarly, they said, the sales tax base is fragmented with services subject to taxes at the provincial level and goods at the federal level. There is also a variation in rates (from 1 percent to 17 percent), in addition to several exemptions. The standard rates on services also vary between provinces. In Balochistan and KPK it is 15 percent, in Punjab it is 16 percent, and in Sindh it is 13 percent. Such fragmentation and exemptions also add to the existing uncertainty, sources added.

Sources have criticised the government’s focus on increasing the tax-to-GDP ratio regardless of how this has become the cornerstone of policy. They said Pakistan’s tax policy is not based on well-known and clear principles. Section 5 of the Federal Board of Revenue Act legitimizes a Tax Policy Board/Committee to sketch tax policy independent of FBR. Unfortunately, that board convened only once after reconstitution. The finance bills that continually add ad-hoc tax measures in frequent mini-budgets have developed a complex tax system that confounds the principles of rational tax policy, they added.

It is worth noting that every mobile phone user (i.e. 90 percent of population) is paying income tax in withholding form under the current withholding tax regime. Data shows that policy consistently pushes for an unrealistic tax-to-GDP ratio, setting FBR to chase the number with arbitrary measures that kill transactions.

For decades now, they said, the policy has given priority to increasing the tax-to-GDP ratio leaving growth and employment to an outcome perhaps of some projects funded by the Public Sector Development Programs (PSDP). Expenditures are never reviewed or rationalized for efficiency, they added.

According to sources, public sector employment is guaranteed, and annual wage increases are held sacrosanct while operational expenditures are regularly cut. Arbitrary and frequent tax changes have created an environment of uncertainty while cuts in operational expenditure have led to austerity.
https://www.brecorder.com/news/4001...y-low-as-compared-to-other-regional-countries
 
FBR unearths tax evasion of Rs 4.36bn

The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) ha unearth a tax evasion of Rs. 4.36 billion during a raid on a food manufacturing unit.

Under the direction of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), all field offices are working to prevent tax evasion and tax fraud and are continuing operations. In this regard, Director Intelligence and Investigation IR Lahore has raided a food manufacturing unit and caught a case of tax evasion and tax fraud.

After scrutiny of the records of the registered manufacturing unit located in Lahore, it was found that the registered unit hid its actual production and sales by committing tax fraud and evaded the due sales tax of Rs. 4.36 billion.

Under Section (37) 2 of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, not only Rs 4.36 billion is owed to the manufacturing unit in terms of sales tax but also a default surcharge of Rs 2.45 billion and a penalty of Rs 4.36 billion.

The case has been forwarded to the field office for recovery of outstanding sales tax. Directorate of Intelligence and Investigation has stepped up operations to prevent and recover tax evasion and tax fraud.

https://www.brecorder.com/news/40013690/fbr-unearths-tax-evasion-of-rs-436bn
 
I just wish people had fear in their heart for FBR like people in Canada have for the CRA or in US have for IRS.


If there is one government department you don't want to be on the bad books off are these tax agencies, they can literally make your life a living hell.
 
Back
Top