Will Pakistan's next selection committee take 'A' team performances into consideration?

[b.lesner]

After world there will be new selector will he consider A team performances of some players like:-
1. Adil Amin hit England lions with 10 odd sixes scored 120 at strike rate 130+ , took mark wood ti the cleaners. He also bowls decent ofspin took 3 or 4 wickets in 1 game.

2. Khushdil Shah finished alot of games against England lions , New Zealand A and in one game in U-23 Asia cup single handedly won pakistan the game as he scored 63 odd of 30 deliveries. He has hit mohammad irfan and Zulfikar babar for long sixes down the ground in their peak. I think he was highest wicket taker in A games took 3 wickets in almost every game , gave a break through when needed

3. Waqas maqsood bowled really economical and took some five wicket hauls. He may not be good but deserves some ODI or test games , he isn't a t20 bowler as he is low on pace

4. Amad butt has also done fair bit in A games especially in t20 A games

5. Abid Ali scored heavily , he is already selected

 

[b.lesner]

[MENTION=136113]Barragan[/MENTION] [MENTION=138980]TalentSpotterPk[/MENTION] [MENTION=133120]ShahidDar[/MENTION] 08 @Theo_ 14 [MENTION=133532]Ottoman[/MENTION] [MENTION=134359]Cricket lover 27[/MENTION] [MENTION=140234]DRsohail[/MENTION] [MENTION=57576]MRSN[/MENTION] [MENTION=31948]hur rizvi[/MENTION] @Saj

 

[Markhor]

A team performances in 2016 also got Shadab Khan and Hasan Ali on selectors radar.

Shan Masood recently was also impressive for the A team before being recalled.

I'd rather we picked top players from the A side instead of rewarding those with little domestic experience who just turn out a few decent PSL performances in one campaign.

 

[b.lesner]

A team performances in 2016 also got Shadab Khan and Hasan Ali on selectors radar.

Shan Masood recently was also impressive for the A team before being recalled.

I'd rather we picked top players from the A side instead of rewarding those with little domestic experience who just turn out a few decent PSL performances in one campaign.

But how will the new selectors know

Tawseef ahmed being one of the selector was with A team he say how Adil hit sixes against mark wood and 10 or 11 sixes against England lions in 120 runs with strike rate over 130 he praised him a lot


But but but.......... New selectors wouldn't know

 

[MT786]

Just look at Adil Amin's List a record. He's not good enough

 

[Markhor]

But how will the new selectors know

Tawseef ahmed being one of the selector was with A team he say how Adil hit sixes against mark wood and 10 or 11 sixes against England lions in 120 runs with strike rate over 130 he praised him a lot


But but but.......... New selectors wouldn't know

Who's reporting there'll be a new selection panel after the WC ?

 

[DRsohail]

Adil Amin was impressive and should have been given chances.

 

[b.lesner]

Just look at Adil Amin's List a record. He's not good enough

46.6 average isn't enough for you
5 hundreds aren't enough

Reality check Abid Ali list A recored average 39 with 5 hundreds
Both performed in A games

 

[b.lesner]

Who's reporting there'll be a new selection panel after the WC ?

Already inzamam contract was extended that means he has been selector already twice

 

[Barragan]

Pak genuinely are going to struggle in ODI's for quite some time because there are hardly any batsmen with the ability to finish an innings, too many middle order batsmen.

Batsmen with the ability to finish games in A games should be fast tracked into the national team, but the selectors must identify those batsmen first.

I don't know what positions Khushdil and Adil were batting at, but if it wasn't at 6 and finishing games, then their selection won't make much of a difference because there are a plethora of batsmen with the same ability in the middle already.

 

[b.lesner]

Pak genuinely are going to struggle in ODI's for quite some time because there are hardly any batsmen with the ability to finish an innings, too many middle order batsmen.

Batsmen with the ability to finish games in A games should be fast tracked into the national team, but the selectors must identify those batsmen first.

I don't know what positions Khushdil and Adil were batting at, but if it wasn't at 6 and finishing games, then their selection won't make much of a difference because there are a plethora of batsmen with the same ability in the middle already.

Adil bats 4-5 while khushdil bats number 6

 

[Barragan]

Adil bats 4-5 while khushdil bats number 6

Then they might be worth checking out, especially Khusdil if he can bat 6 and finish the innings.

Pak are in desperate need for a no. 6 batsman.

 

[b.lesner]

Then they might be worth checking out, especially Khusdil if he can bat 6 and finish the innings.

Pak are in desperate need for a no. 6 batsman.

Khushdil finished some games in 'A' tours , single handedly won games i remember 65 odd of 30 balls and also took wickets every game he was 2nd highest wicket taker with his left arm spin , kashif bhatti and irfan's weren't getting wickets but khushdil was.