Syed1
ODI Captain
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2015
- Runs
- 46,041
- Post of the Week
- 3
India's soft power is directly the reason for deterioration in pakistan' s ties with Saudi..
What?

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
India's soft power is directly the reason for deterioration in pakistan' s ties with Saudi..
Pakistan can ill-afford to cut ties with Saudi at the present moment, Kashmir or not. The Saudis fund a lot of Madrassas and other charities in Pakistan, not to mention the millions of Pakistani expatriates in Saudi who send remittances home.
I wonder what Pakistan's religious right will think of this? They must be torn between supporting Kashmiris on one had, and condemning the Saudis on the other.
KSA funding Madrassah's is an 80's concept. Maybe even early 90's. Moreover, funding Madrassah's and Charities has nothing to go with the government. Not sure what point you're trying to make here but you couldn't be more wrong.
The only valid point you've made is regarding the remittances. However, I don't expect that to change regardless of the stance of the government.
Saudis are twisting the arm. Dont go by the brave statements online. Actually the pak army chief is running to Riyadh to get some money and help normalise relationship.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020...arabia-quest-smooth-ties-200813055310566.html
And people call this taming KSA?
Time to update your knowledge. Not just 90s, but noughties as well. Didn't you follow wikileaks?
Not taming, but he is not going there to repair relations either. In Pakistan foreign policy right now is under joint control of civilians and Army. If Querishi said something the Army did not want said, then he would have been sacked.
They used Querishi as “bad cop”, and now Bajwa will be “good cop” and say the same thing that Querishi said in a different manner.
Not taming, but he is not going there to repair relations either. In Pakistan foreign policy right now is under joint control of civilians and Army. If Querishi said something the Army did not want said, then he would have been sacked.
They used Querishi as "bad cop", and now Bajwa will be "good cop" and say the same thing that Querishi said in a different manner.
What is the requirement of good cop, bad cop though in this scenario?
Its just putting the countries together against one cause.
No one is taking out any confrontation. It's ok to stand on either side.
The good cop/bad cop routine is used by people with leverage and authority on suspects that are nervous and seem under pressure .. not on regional behemoths like Saudi Arabia who pays your bills and is a de facto godfather to the Pak state.
The truth is Imran took a punt and it backfired massively. You’ll have to do as you are told by the saudis. If MBS is in a good mood, he’ll let you off lightly with a warning to the visiting general.
As in what Querishi publicly said, Bajwa will privately say. Either raise the Kashmir issue in the OIC, or Pakistan will have other Muslim countries (like Turkey, Iran, Malaysia) host a summit on Kashmir.
On this issue Pakistan has leverage. Pakistan wants a summit on Kashmir in the OIC, which the Saudis are blocking. Other Muslim countries are willing to host one for Pakistan outside the OIC. So Pakistan does not need Saudi Arabia in this regard.
So thats the message Bajwa will give the Saudis.
What can the Saudis do? Take their loan back, and end the deferred payment for oil. Not a problem for Pakistan. They needed the loan in 2018, they dont need it now.
The only thing they could do to hurt Pakistan, would be to stop using Pakistani labor, as Pakistan needs the remittances. But they did not stop when Pakistan refused to support Saudis in the Yemen war, so its unlikely that they will be that mad to stop it now.
No he is not. The Army completely backed his statement otherwise he would have been sacked.
The relationship has been changing as now Iran is the Saudis biggest enemy, and Pakistan wants to remain neutral in there feud.
The only thing that Pakistan needs to make sure is that relations dont go bad, as millions of Pakistanis work there.
As in what Querishi publicly said, Bajwa will privately say. Either raise the Kashmir issue in the OIC, or Pakistan will have other Muslim countries (like Turkey, Iran, Malaysia) host a summit on Kashmir.
Saudis are rattled. There ambassador in Pakistan is busy meeting with irrelevant politicians from the government.
On this issue Pakistan has leverage. Pakistan wants a summit on Kashmir in the OIC, which the Saudis are blocking. Other Muslim countries are willing to host one for Pakistan outside the OIC. So Pakistan does not need Saudi Arabia in this regard.
So thats the message Bajwa will give the Saudis.
What can the Saudis do? Take their loan back, and end the deferred payment for oil. Not a problem for Pakistan. They needed the loan in 2018, they dont need it now.
The only thing they could do to hurt Pakistan, would be to stop using Pakistani labor, as Pakistan needs the remittances. But they did not stop when Pakistan refused to support Saudis in the Yemen war, so its unlikely that they will be that mad to stop it now.
Saudis are rattled, thats why your army chief is running to Riyadh.?
Pakistan is still on IMF bailout. It desperately needs money.
Which countries are going to support pakistan on Kashmir? What leverage do they have over India?
Saudis have a lot of religious and economic leverage over pakistan.
What can the Saudis do? Take their loan back, and end the deferred payment for oil. Not a problem for Pakistan. They needed the loan in 2018, they dont need it now.
Dynamics of Pakistan-Saudi/gulf ties are way different than what is generally perceived by outsiders.
These things cannot be viewed in isolation. Few months ago, there were reports of a coup attempt against MBS from within family which was defused by Pakistan army troops there. Raheel Shareef is not playing bantay there. He is a well respected figure there who is heading an army of multiple nations. Pakistan's military is the most reliable and loyal force in ME that has protected many rulers of different kingdoms in gulf. Neither Israel nor America can provide what Pakistan can to these rulers and they respected that in the past hence all the economic assistance to Pakistan.
But the current westernized Sheikhs, these MBS types need a reality check which is why Bajwa is visiting.
Indians generally have zero idea of the affairs of middle east and Afghanistan. They keep parroting lines from Times now etc 'BAJWA RUNS TO KSA', 'MASTERS ARE NOT HAPPY'. Your opinions on these matters means zilch.
Source of your information?
[/B]
Care to explain this leverage ?
No Saudi leader can remove a single Pakistani soldier guarding Macca and Medina. I am sure you and many Indians are surprised to hear this given that you have been fed this master slave narrative.
Dynamics of Pakistan-Saudi/gulf ties are way different than what is generally perceived by outsiders.
These things cannot be viewed in isolation. Few months ago, there were reports of a coup attempt against MBS from within family which was defused by Pakistan army troops there. Raheel Shareef is not playing bantay there. He is a well respected figure there who is heading an army of multiple nations. Pakistan's military is the most reliable and loyal force in ME that has protected many rulers of different kingdoms in gulf. Neither Israel nor America can provide what Pakistan can to these rulers and they respected that in the past hence all the economic assistance to Pakistan.
But the current westernized Sheikhs, these MBS types need a reality check which is why Bajwa is visiting.
Indians generally have zero idea of the affairs of middle east and Afghanistan. They keep parroting lines from Times now etc 'BAJWA RUNS TO KSA', 'MASTERS ARE NOT HAPPY'. Your opinions on these matters means zilch.
Lol. Every respected media outlet has reported that Bajwa has gone to Saudi to soothe the frayed feathers.
Pakistan has provided services in return of economic assistance. If the regimes so decide that keeping Pakistan involved is detrimental to them they will go the other way.
Arab oil states have plenty of money to buy protection. Plus any attempt to remove a pro American regime will bring US into play and Pakistan is in no position to go to war with US.
The Saudis, the Emiratis etc have too many allies for Pakistan to even think of doing anything.
The only opinion that matters is that of the saudis. Not pakistanis.
Again you are parroting the same old narrative. It is usually a waste of time to engage with Indians on these issues so I will pass.
Just a few weeks ago you were telling me that Pak doesn't recognize Israel because you need saudi money. Now you say they don't matter. You are more confused than Imran Khan.
The only thing they could do to hurt Pakistan, would be to stop using Pakistani labor, as Pakistan needs the remittances. But they did not stop when Pakistan refused to support Saudis in the Yemen war, so its unlikely that they will be that mad to stop it now.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/625769-coup-plot-suspected-saudi-arabia-arrests-king-s-brother-two-princes
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/mbs-crackdown-prompted-arrest-saudi-royals-200311143707752.html
You have to take my word on our army's role in these matters.
Heh? Your words only?
So all these posts are based upon your imaginations only?
If I want to watch a drama, I'll switch on the TV lol. Good material for a novel, but hey, your words have no credibility. I don't even know you who you are. You are just a random person in a random forum. Why I'll trust you?
According to almost every article, your army chief is going to Riyadh to soothe the frayed feathers.
Malaysia has already kicked out Mahathir and the new govt worked overtime to restore economic ties with India.
What influence Iran or Turkey have over India?What leverage do they have?
India is one of the few countries still putting some money in Iran.
Pakistan is still on IMF bailout. It desperately needs money.
Which countries are going to support pakistan on Kashmir? What leverage do they have over India?
Saudis have a lot of religious and economic leverage over pakistan.
yeah it’s almost like some of these guy have a script they follow. I wonder if these guys think they are “hurting” Pakistan by using these juvenile phrases lol.Dynamics of Pakistan-Saudi/gulf ties are way different than what is generally perceived by outsiders.
These things cannot be viewed in isolation. Few months ago, there were reports of a coup attempt against MBS from within family which was defused by Pakistan army troops there. Raheel Shareef is not playing bantay there. He is a well respected figure there who is heading an army of multiple nations. Pakistan's military is the most reliable and loyal force in ME that has protected many rulers of different kingdoms in gulf. Neither Israel nor America can provide what Pakistan can to these rulers and they respected that in the past hence all the economic assistance to Pakistan.
But the current westernized Sheikhs, these MBS types need a reality check which is why Bajwa is visiting.
Indians generally have zero idea of the affairs of middle east and Afghanistan. They keep parroting lines from Times now etc 'BAJWA RUNS TO KSA', 'MASTERS ARE NOT HAPPY'. Your opinions on these matters means zilch.
That seems very unlike where Pakistan can start a rebel against KSA among muslim community.
. Not to mention, the silence of Pakistan in case of China won't go well. It may portray Pakistan as voice only on selective issues and goes missing when it is time to voice against "friends". Intetion of Pakistan will be in more doubt than KSA.
I would never expect an Indian to trust me anyways. Enjoy your dramas on NDTV.
Saudis can and will remove every Pakistani from saudia if they are deemed a threat to the regime.
And replace them with Hindutva soldiers from India maybe? Or maybe Shia soldiers who you were advocating as acceptable Muslims in India not so long ago?![]()
Wait.... Why Human rights department is criticizing FM? it is unprofessional to go into public criticizing another department of the same gov. There's proper channel for it and should have gone that way instead of telling everything in the media.
Army chief arrives in Saudi Arabia
![]()
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] its sad when people cant see how the job of the ambassador or foreign minister (who are appointed by the govt) is being done by not only the coas but also the dg isi.
Insulting for any democratic govt.
And yet many here think these two are there to give a befitting reply when in reaoity they are their to appease salman apologise and beg.
In the other thread you mentioned that opposition dont have to do anything as the current govt itself is crumbling. However i disagree. The opposition has to deal with the army someway to get back into power
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] its sad when people cant see how the job of the ambassador or foreign minister (who are appointed by the govt) is being done by not only the coas but also the dg isi.
Insulting for any democratic govt.
And yet many here think these two are there to give a befitting reply when in reaoity they are their to appease salman apologise and beg.
In the other thread you mentioned that opposition dont have to do anything as the current govt itself is crumbling. However i disagree. The opposition has to deal with the army someway to get back into power
Or may be we dont take your word on these matters and trust respected media outlets more.
Opposition is dying a slow death. People have seen through the loot khasoot group and are no more willing to come out on streets for them.
Our journey towards a better, stronger Pakistan has started. Your rona dhona is punishment for supporting crooks that plundered this country.
Each time PPP came in opposition the same was said.
THey aint dieing yet
Each time PPP came in opposition the same was said.
THey aint dieing yet
Wake up PPP are finished, the youth of Pakistan will never vote for a bloke who cant even speak Urdu.
Time to move on, you've made enough money through corruption, let others have some justice now.
PPP never won from Karachi, except for one area Lyari. Last time Bilawajah Bhutto went there for election campaigning he got boo'ed and heckled, had to run away. They have zero presence in Punjab now. Heck they couldn't even find candidates for Punjab seats in 2018. They are just present in interior Sindh.
Each time PPP came in opposition the same was said.
THey aint dieing yet
Wake up PPP are finished, the youth of Pakistan will never vote for a bloke who cant even speak Urdu.
Time to move on, you've made enough money through corruption, let others have some justice now.
Saudi Arabia and Pakistan: A partnership too important to fail
https://www.arabnews.com/node/1720441
Some key points from the article suggest that the Saudis are blaming Querishi for an "emotional outburst".
Querishi is too seasoned a politican to make the statement without at least some backing. So the question is did both Imran Khan and Bajwa back his comments, or just one of them?
From the article:
"Unfortunately, since then, the Foreign Ministry under Mr. Qureshi has been unable to build upon this initial success in international diplomacy on Kashmir. So, one plausible explanation for his frustrating bid to blame the OIC is to cover up his own failure in Kashmir.
By bringing such differences into the public domain, as FM Qureshi did through his emotional outburst over OIC’s position on Kashmir or the unverified media reports did on the Saudi economic support to Pakistan, we allow the forces inimical to the interests of both nations to sabotage their historic partnership.
Where does FM Qureshi’s diatribe stand after this? Will PM Imran Khan remind him to be careful in future, as any damage to our brotherly ties goes against our respective national interests and public aspirations?"
Doesn't look good for the FM qureshi to be honest. He is getting criticized from right, left and even inside the party.
If he is sacked it would be the second time as FM. He was sacked over the Raymond Davis issue by PPP, and pretty much kicked out of the party. He then joined PTI.
They need to move on from Bilawal if they want a chance at a comeback. Maybe go for Aseefa. But before they launch her, they should make sure her Urdu is fluent.
Doesn't look good for the FM qureshi to be honest. He is getting criticized from right, left and even inside the party.
Benazir's own urdu wasn't that good.
Bilawal needs to take more charge and have his own party members accountable.
my prediction is he isnt going anywhere. The outburst was not random. Saudis and pakistan will remain relatively close but the clock is now ticking and they know it. They have been given a shot across their bow. It also allows Pakistan the ability to reject pressure from saudi by saying "sure we'll do what you want after you release a statement on kashmir and call an OIC conference for it" knowing full well they cant.
This also gives Pakistan the freedom to plough their own road. AT the same time the relationship goes on through the military. But purely as more of a defence of the holy land issue.
In short Saudi has lost Pakistan. They just dont know it yet.
I hope IK doesnt succumb to the pressure and continues this brave policy.
Bilawal needs to be arrested or exiled and the PPP disbanded or replaced. It is a traitorous rump of a party and must be eliminated to ensure the survival of Pakistan.
Well, the general who was to be given a medal is back empty handed after being snubbed by MBS. Would be interesting to see how this plays out and could have major ramifications for the region.
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Breaking: Pakistan Army Chief Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa & DG ISI Gen Faiz Returned to Pakistan Without Meeting Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad Bin Salman. What happened in Kingdom? <br>Inside story with <a href="https://twitter.com/AmirMateen2?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AmirMateen2</a> <br>��<a href="https://t.co/95IENlU7r3">https://t.co/95IENlU7r3</a> <a href="https://t.co/dMSa4oejZA">pic.twitter.com/dMSa4oejZA</a></p>— Rauf Klasra (@KlasraRauf) <a href="https://twitter.com/KlasraRauf/status/1295709925063241729?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">August 18, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Breaking: Pakistan Army Chief Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa & DG ISI Gen Faiz Returned to Pakistan Without Meeting Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad Bin Salman. What happened in Kingdom? <br>Inside story with <a href="https://twitter.com/AmirMateen2?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AmirMateen2</a> <br><a href="https://t.co/95IENlU7r3">https://t.co/95IENlU7r3</a> <a href="https://t.co/dMSa4oejZA">pic.twitter.com/dMSa4oejZA</a></p>— Rauf Klasra (@KlasraRauf) <a href="https://twitter.com/KlasraRauf/status/1295709925063241729?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">August 18, 2020</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Benazir's own urdu wasn't that good.
Bilawal needs to take more charge and have his own party members accountable.
Heh .. this looks like a badly written episode of HBO's 'The Brink. Just when everybody here was reassuring us about Pakistan's iron bond with Saudi Arabia, MBS slams the door on Bajwa. These are not good signs for Pakistan.![]()
Heh .. this looks like a badly written episode of HBO's 'The Brink. Just when everybody here was reassuring us about Pakistan's iron bond with Saudi Arabia, MBS slams the door on Bajwa. These are not good signs for Pakistan.![]()
I am confused by all the drama, Bajwa went their to meet his counterpart and did. Why would he even meet MBS?
If true, this could be humiliation for the general..
Earlier, Chief of General Staff General Fayyadh Bin Hamed Al Ruwaili welcomed COAS Qamar Javed on his arrival and the COAS was presented guard of honour.
https://nation.com.pk/18-Aug-2020/coas-reaches-saudi-arabia-meets-military-top-brass
Doesn’t really seem like a humiliation. He went there on a scheduled visit, got a guard of honour and met the army chief. Why would he randomly meet the prince?