What's new

Young girls being sold in India to repay loans, says human rights body

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,863
Young girls in the northern Indian state of Rajasthan are being sold as “repayment” for loans their parents cannot afford, the national body that protects human rights has said.

The National Human Rights Commission has issued a notice to the state government demanding a police inquiry and answers within a month to what it called an “abominable” practice.

People living in many rural areas in India often have to borrow money from fellow villagers when a family member falls seriously ill and needs medical treatment.

Local media reports say that in half a dozen districts around Bhilwara, if a family cannot repay a loan, the aggrieved creditor has complained to the “caste panchayats” or caste councils.

By way of “settlement”, the councils have ordered the family to hand over their daughter – sometimes more than one depending on the size of the loan – so that the creditor can sell her to a trafficker to recoup his money.

In its notice, the commission said that if the family refuses to sell their daughter, “their mothers are subjected to rape on the diktats of caste panchayats for the settlement of disputes”.

Among the cases highlighted by the commission is that of a man who borrowed 1.5m rupees (£15,800) from a neighbour who was forced by the panchayat to sell his sister and 12-year-old daughter to settle the debt.

In another, a man who borrowed 600,000 rupees (£6,300) when his wife fell ill and needed hospital treatment was unable to repay it. The panchayat compelled him to hand over his young daughter to the creditor, who later sold her to a trafficker in Agra. From there, “she was sold three times and became pregnant four times”, the commission said.

The commission has sent an official to Rajasthan to investigate the cases. The Bhilwara district collector, Ashish Modi, said the crimes were the first of their kind. “They are total illegal. The police are investigating and we will make sure the victims get justice and the guilty are punished,” Modi said.

Panchayats are often a profoundly regressive force in rural India, acting as kangaroo courts. They have ordered so-called honour killings of couples who have defied tradition by marrying into a different caste or faith or ordered brutal punishments for couples suspected of adultery.

Get a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development team

Kavita Srivastava, a veteran women’s rights activist in Jaipur, Rajasthan, said it was well known that caste panchayats informally regulated villagers’ personal matters such as marriage, inheritance or custody. If people defy their orders, they are ostracised and shunned by the rest of the community.

“But what is new in these cases is that they seem to have expanded their ambit to settle loan disputes in this way,” Srivastava said.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...pay-loans-human-rights?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other
 
And the govt there is trying to defend this by talking about "economic policies" of Modi.
 
And the govt there is trying to defend this by talking about "economic policies" of Modi.

"The panchayat compelled him to hand over his young daughter to the creditor"

Surely this is illegal in India? Why are these panchayats allowed to make their own rulings which are not only illegal but highly immoral?

India is the worst place for a female to be born in, another example.
 
"The panchayat compelled him to hand over his young daughter to the creditor"

Surely this is illegal in India? Why are these panchayats allowed to make their own rulings which are not only illegal but highly immoral?

India is the worst place for a female to be born in, another example.
Pakistan is lower on the gender inequality index than India India is pretty low also. India is the 10t worst country and Pakistan 3rd I think 2021
 
Panchayats are often a profoundly regressive force in rural India, acting as kangaroo courts. They have ordered so-called honour killings of couples who have defied tradition by marrying into a different caste or faith or ordered brutal punishments for couples suspected of adultery.

——-
Sums up the issue, and when people try to change the society the conservatives cry and whine about culture.
 
Considering India's population much worse stuff is probably also happening but that's the drawback of having such a large population. Similar stuff probably also happens in other countries on a smaller scale.
 
Why only Rajasthan?. Millions of girls are sold in India or forced in to prostitution every day. The ignorant and cruel Arab's are well known to visit Deccan Hyderabad to buy poor girls mostly Muslim ones for a day or two. They do nikaah with them then divorce them after a few days after using them. Shameful.
 
Panchayats are often a profoundly regressive force in rural India, acting as kangaroo courts. They have ordered so-called honour killings of couples who have defied tradition by marrying into a different caste or faith or ordered brutal punishments for couples suspected of adultery.

——-
Sums up the issue, and when people try to change the society the conservatives cry and whine about culture.

Do Hindu villages also have these Panchayats?

I always assumed it was a tribal Muslim thing.
 
The word “panchayat” itself should hold a hint.

Yeah fair enough and I guess it was a dumb question :))

Just so used to hearing about panchayats in Pak Punjab that I completely forgot about their common occurence across the whole region.

My apologies for brain fade !
 
This has been going on for decades in India , its not something new. Where poverty exists such things happen. It happens indirectly in western countries as well.
 
Tragic story for many families. They are one illness away from going bankrupt as a family.

Government does not have the resources to bailout the millions of families that need financial help.
 
This has been going on for decades in India , its not something new. Where poverty exists such things happen. It happens indirectly in western countries as well.

Social security and Government handouts keep the families from selling their children.

Even with all the help, many give up their children for adoption as they cannot afford to have kids. Even before having kids many are financially broke. But they still have kids which in itself is a tragedy.
 
Pakistan is lower on the gender inequality index than India India is pretty low also. India is the 10t worst country and Pakistan 3rd I think 2021

I can give you many research which shows India as no.1

But simple logic. The population of India is so huge, there are 10's of millions of women either raped, abused, into prostitution or not even lucky to be born because of their sex.
 
I can give you many research which shows India as no.1

But simple logic. The population of India is so huge, there are 10's of millions of women either raped, abused, into prostitution or not even lucky to be born because of their sex.
I am quoting UNited nations numbers . Also. Yes india has a bigger population than Pakistan. So might have more victims. But you do know what is “percentage” right. All those studies are based on percentage . You do know that right. ?
 
Back
Top