do you think he is more talented than u akmal?
Doesn't matter what I think; both are extremely talented, but 'll fade out unless nurtured properly.
Fundamental difference between Batsman & Bowler is that, bowling is more about natural ability & instinctive, while batting is more technical, methodical & process oriented. Bowling is more of a physical effort, while batting is mostly mental aspects. I think, you are born as a great bowler, but developed into a great batsman. Whenever a talented young batsman starts his career, often he starts with a bang; great shots, sparkling strokes, eye catching flairs. But after few matches, opposition starts to work on the youngster, study him & exploits the weaknesses, when the real test starts.
I was fortunate to see almost ball by ball Faisal Iqbal's debut Test & can safely say, in 16 years career, NO ENGLISHMAN had ever played Shane that confidently like him. But, from next innings Shane had him confused & caught off-guard. Same story goes for most PAK young batsmen - Md. Wasim, Imran Nazir & Taufique Umar, had brilliant career starts for first 1/2 years, but never could improve their game or work on weaknesses through the "Kiss & Hug" style novices appointed by PCB as "Coach". Since 90s, when ECB restricted foreigners quota in English County, apart from naturally gifted Inzi (who was fortunate to have the greatest motivator as guide at the start) only 2 world class batsmen came from PAK, YK & MoYo, who were lucky that they had Bob for a considerable period.
Having said that, both Shehzad & Umar are extremely talented (Actually Amin as well, trust me), but it depends how much they can take their game to next level, with the help of a Pro coach & how much discipline & hungry they are. Dav can take all three to highest level (At NCA Bangalore, Virat, Rohit, Puzara, Raina & Rahne worked with him for few years & Sakib was almost hand picked by him at 17), if they become a good cricket students. Keep MHK for 2 more years Shehzad 'll hardly get the chance, Amin 'll be gone in wilderness & Umar 'll become a cross-breed between Nazir & Afridi.
If you ask me to pick in orders, mine 'll be Shehzad, Umar & then Amin.
Last edited: