What's new

All Time Asia XI vs All Time ROW XI in ODIs

Unbiased-Fan

Unbiased-Fan

Local Club Captain
Joined
Oct 25, 2021
Runs
2,233
My All time Asia ODI XI looks like thik,
(I select atleast one player from each asian team)

Sachin Tendulkar
Sanath Jayasuriya
Virat Kohli
Kumar Sangakkara
Inzamam Ul Haq
Shakib Al Hasan
MS Dhoni (w) *
Rashid Khan
Wasim Akram
Waqar Younis
Muttiah Muralitharan
12thman- Kapil Dev

My All time Asian ODI has 3 players each from India, Pakistan and Srilanka and 1 each from Afghanistan and Bangladesh.


Now, take a look at my All Time Rest of the World ODI XI,
(Select atleast one player from each SENAW nation)

Brian Lara
Adam Gilchrist (w)
Viv Richards
Ricky Ponting *
Ross Taylor
AB de Villiers
Lance Klusener
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Joel Garner
Glenn McGrath
12th man- Jacques Kallis

4 players from Australia, 3 from Windies, 2 from RSA, 1 each from Newzealand and England makes my all time ROW XI.


If 3 match ODI series is being played between these two sides, which team will lift the cup?
(12th man can be used as per venues)

Venues -
1. Dubai
2. London
3. Perth
 
Unbiased-Fan said:
My All time Asia ODI XI looks like thik,
(I select atleast one player from each asian team)

Sachin Tendulkar
Sanath Jayasuriya
Virat Kohli
Kumar Sangakkara
Inzamam Ul Haq
Shakib Al Hasan
MS Dhoni (w) *
Rashid Khan
Wasim Akram
Waqar Younis
Muttiah Muralitharan
12thman- Kapil Dev

My All time Asian ODI has 3 players each from India, Pakistan and Srilanka and 1 each from Afghanistan and Bangladesh.


Now, take a look at my All Time Rest of the World ODI XI,
(Select atleast one player from each SENAW nation)

Brian Lara
Adam Gilchrist (w)
Viv Richards
Ricky Ponting *
Ross Taylor
AB de Villiers
Lance Klusener
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Joel Garner
Glenn McGrath
12th man- Jacques Kallis

4 players from Australia, 3 from Windies, 2 from RSA, 1 each from Newzealand and England makes my all time ROW XI.


If 3 match ODI series is being played between these two sides, which team will lift the cup?
(12th man can be used as per venues)

Venues -
1. Dubai
2. London
3. Perth
Click to expand...

for the asian xi - i swap jayasuriya for saeed anwar and i'll take out shakib and replace with yuvraj singh / razzaq and allow dhoni to bat at no.6. Im 50/50 on having rashid khan or saqlain mustaq.

for your world xi - i'll swap taylor with michael bevan and bat AB at no.5 and i'll have greme smith over lara as a opener and i am very biased here- garner out for shane bond
 
finalfantasy7 said:
for the asian xi - i swap jayasuriya for saeed anwar and i'll take out shakib and replace with yuvraj singh / razzaq and allow dhoni to bat at no.6. Im 50/50 on having rashid khan or saqlain mustaq.

for your world xi - i'll swap taylor with michael bevan and bat AB at no.5 and i'll have greme smith over lara as a opener and i am very biased here- garner out for shane bond
Click to expand...

I tried to select atleast one player from each country
 
Tendulkar , Kapil Dev , Wasim Akram , Saqlain Mushtaq , Waqar Younis , Sangakara ( WK ) are must here
 
Unbiased-Fan said:
My All time Asia ODI XI looks like thik,
(I select atleast one player from each asian team)

Sachin Tendulkar
Sanath Jayasuriya
Virat Kohli
Kumar Sangakkara
Inzamam Ul Haq
Shakib Al Hasan
MS Dhoni (w) *
Rashid Khan
Wasim Akram
Waqar Younis
Muttiah Muralitharan
12thman- Kapil Dev

My All time Asian ODI has 3 players each from India, Pakistan and Srilanka and 1 each from Afghanistan and Bangladesh.


Now, take a look at my All Time Rest of the World ODI XI,
(Select atleast one player from each SENAW nation)

Brian Lara
Adam Gilchrist (w)
Viv Richards
Ricky Ponting *
Ross Taylor
AB de Villiers
Lance Klusener
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Joel Garner
Glenn McGrath
12th man- Jacques Kallis

4 players from Australia, 3 from Windies, 2 from RSA, 1 each from Newzealand and England makes my all time ROW XI.


If 3 match ODI series is being played between these two sides, which team will lift the cup?
(12th man can be used as per venues)

Venues -
1. Dubai
2. London
3. Perth
Click to expand...

If the caveat for at least one guy from each nation is removed,

I'd have IK instead of shakib and make him the captain.
- have Aravinda instead of Sanga.
- have Saqlain instead of Rashid - his ODI figures are legendary.
- Jads would be 12th man. In fact - i'd have Jads as Universal 12th man for any XI any format.

For SENAW all time -
id replace klusener with chris cairns
Dale steyn for flintoff or maybe even starc

12th man wold be Jonty.
 
CrIc_Mystique said:
If the caveat for at least one guy from each nation is removed,

I'd have IK instead of shakib and make him the captain.
- have Aravinda instead of Sanga.
- have Saqlain instead of Rashid - his ODI figures are legendary.
- Jads would be 12th man. In fact - i'd have Jads as Universal 12th man for any XI any format.

For SENAW all time -
id replace klusener with chris cairns
Dale steyn for flintoff or maybe even starc

12th man wold be Jonty.
Click to expand...

Jads means Jadeja??
 
Ross Out, Buttler In. AB bats at 5.

Instead of picking Flintoff at 8, better pick Hadlee or S Pollock( extremely economical) or Starc or even Boult(if you want a modern era kiwi).
 
Last edited:
ROW XI :-

Gilchrist
Lara
Ponting(c)
Viv
ABD
Buttler(wkt)
Cairns
Starc
Warne
Garner
McGrath
 
Asain XI
Jayasuriya
Tendulkar
Kohli
Sangakara
Inzamam-ul-haq
Yuvaraj
Dhoni
Wasim Akram
Waqar
Akhtar
Muralitharan
 
Inspired from ATG Bharat-Pakistan ODI XI thread.

ATG #AsianBloc ODI XI

Sachin Tendulkar 🇮🇳
Rohit Sharma 🇮🇳
Virat Kohli 🇮🇳
Kumar Sangakkara 🇱🇰
Yuvraj Singh 🇮🇳
MS Dhoni 🇮🇳
Kapil Dev 🇮🇳
Jasprit Singh Bumrah 🇮🇳
Shoaib Akhtar 🇵🇰
Mohammad Shami 🇮🇳
Saqlain Mushtaq 🇵🇰
 
All time ODI Asia XI:

Tendulkar
Jayasuriya
Kohli
Sangakara (wk)
Inzamam
Imran Khan (c)
Kapil Dev
Wasim
Murali
Vaas
Bumrah

======================

All time ODI ROW XI:

Hayden
Gilchrist (wk)
Viv Richards
Ponting (c)
Lara
Stokes
Bevan
Shaun Pollock
Shane Warne
Brett Lee
McGrath.
 
sweep_shot said:
All time ODI Asia XI:

Tendulkar
Jayasuriya
Kohli
Sangakara (wk)
Inzamam
Imran Khan (c)
Kapil Dev
Wasim
Murali
Vaas
Bumrah

======================

All time ODI ROW XI:

Hayden
Gilchrist (wk)
Viv Richards
Ponting (c)
Lara
Stokes
Bevan
Shaun Pollock
Shane Warne
Brett Lee
McGrath.
Click to expand...
From 90s
Asia:
Tendulkar
Jayasuriya
Kohli
Yuvraj
Shakib
Dhoni
Razzaq
Rashid khan
Akram
Saqlain
Bumrah
12th man: Sehwag

ROW:
Hayden
Gilchrist
Lara
Ponting
ABDV
Stokes
Cairns
Kluesner
Warne
Pollock
Mcgrath
12th man: Warner
 
sweep_shot said:
All time ODI Asia XI:

Tendulkar
Jayasuriya
Kohli
Sangakara (wk)
Inzamam
Imran Khan (c)
Kapil Dev
Wasim
Murali
Vaas
Bumrah

======================

All time ODI ROW XI:

Hayden
Gilchrist (wk)
Viv Richards
Ponting (c)
Lara
Stokes
Bevan
Shaun Pollock
Shane Warne
Brett Lee
McGrath.
Click to expand...
Vaas? Naaww
Get waqar or shami in instead.
 
South Asia XI : 1) Jayasuriya 2) Tendulkar 3) Kohli 4) Sangakkara 5) Abbas 6) Yuvraj 7) Dhoni*+ 8) Wasim 9) Waqar 10) Bumrah 11) Murali.
 
Australia 🇦🇺 XI : 1) Gilchrist+ 2) Watson 3) Ponting* 4) Jones 5) Symonds 6) Bevan 7) Maxwell 8) Lee 9) Warne 10) Starc 11) McGrath
 
An Asia XI would look like this
Sehwag
Sachin
Rohit
Kohli(VC)
Yuvraj
Dhoni(C)
Pandya
Kapil
Wasim
Bumrah
Muralitharan
 
Van_Sri said:
South Asia XI : 1) Jayasuriya 2) Tendulkar 3) Kohli 4) Sangakkara 5) Abbas 6) Yuvraj 7) Dhoni*+ 8) Wasim 9) Waqar 10) Bumrah 11) Murali.
Click to expand...
Bowling Attack : Wasim and Bumrah shares the New Ball, Followed by Waqar and Murali, Jayasuriya, Yuvraj and Sachin. Pretty Solid Attack.
 
Van_Sri said:
South Asia XI : 1) Jayasuriya 2) Tendulkar 3) Kohli 4) Sangakkara 5) Abbas 6) Yuvraj 7) Dhoni*+ 8) Wasim 9) Waqar 10) Bumrah 11) Murali.
Click to expand...
Jayasuriya is a Good Allrounder useful with Spin Bowling and an Aggressive Opening Batsman who don’t flop like Rohit in Important Matches, Tendulkar and Kohli are the Best ODI Batsman of their Generation, Sangakkara gives Stability to the Team coming at No 4 and good player under pressure, Zaheer Abbas was the best ODI Batsman of Asia in Late 70s and early 80s with a Good Strike Rate, Yuvraj and Dhoni are good lower order batsman with Yuvraj you have a good spinner. Bowling : Don’t want to compromise with anyone Mediocre - Wasim, Waqar, Bumrah and Murali - Big Four of South Asian Cricket.
 
ASIA XI

Sachin Tendulkar
Saeed Anwar
Virat Kohli
Inzamam
Yuvraj Singh
MS Dhoni
Kapil Dev
A. Razzak
Wasim Akram
S. Mustaq
W.Younis
 
Subcontinent XI using atleast 1 player from every major Asian Team :

1.Sachin Tendulkar
2.Sanath Jayasuriya
3.Virat Kohli
4.Shakib Al Hasan
5.MS Dhoni (WK)
6.Imran Khan (C)
7.Kapil Dev
8.Rashid Khan
9.Wasim Akram
10.Jasprit Bumrah
11.Muttiah Muralitharan

SENAW with one from each side :

1.Mark Waugh
2.Brian Lara
3.Ricky Ponting (C)
4.Viv Richards
5.AB De Villiers (WK)
6.Michael Bevan
7.Andrew Flintoff
8.Brett Lee
9.Shane Warne
10.Shane Bond
11.Joel Garner
 
Rest of the world dominate and easily in a test match

In odi can go either way but slight advantage to ROW.
 
mominsaigol said:
Rest of the world dominate and easily in a test match

In odi can go either way but slight advantage to ROW.
Click to expand...
Are you kidding Asia XI is pretty strong in Test Matches too. 1) Anwar 2) Gavaskar 3) Dravid 4) Sachin 5) Sangakkara+ 6) Shakib 7) Imran* 8) Kapil 9) Wasim 10) Bumrah 11) Murali
 
Bhaijaan said:
Inspired from ATG Bharat-Pakistan ODI XI thread.

ATG #AsianBloc ODI XI

Sachin Tendulkar 🇮🇳
Rohit Sharma 🇮🇳
Virat Kohli 🇮🇳
Kumar Sangakkara 🇱🇰
Yuvraj Singh 🇮🇳
MS Dhoni 🇮🇳
Kapil Dev 🇮🇳
Jasprit Singh Bumrah 🇮🇳
Shoaib Akhtar 🇵🇰
Mohammad Shami 🇮🇳
Saqlain Mushtaq 🇵🇰
Click to expand...


Revised Team after slight change of heart :-

ATG #AsianBloc ODI XI

Sachin Tendulkar 🇮🇳
Rohit Sharma 🇮🇳
Virat Kohli 🇮🇳
Inzamam ul Haq 🇵🇰
Yuvraj Singh 🇮🇳
MS Dhoni 🇮🇳
Kapil Dev 🇮🇳
Wasim Akram 🇵🇰
Jasprit Singh Bumrah 🇮🇳
Mohammad Shami 🇮🇳
Saqlain Mushtaq 🇵🇰
 
Bhaijaan said:
Revised Team after slight change of heart :-

ATG #AsianBloc ODI XI

Sachin Tendulkar 🇮🇳
Rohit Sharma 🇮🇳
Virat Kohli 🇮🇳
Inzamam ul Haq 🇵🇰
Yuvraj Singh 🇮🇳
MS Dhoni 🇮🇳
Kapil Dev 🇮🇳
Wasim Akram 🇵🇰
Jasprit Singh Bumrah 🇮🇳
Mohammad Shami 🇮🇳
Saqlain Mushtaq 🇵🇰
Click to expand...
India 🇮🇳 Pakistan 🇵🇰 XI : 1) Rohit 2) Sachin 3) Anwar 4) Kohli 5) Yuvraj 6) Dhoni+ 7) Imran* 8) Kapil 9) Wasim 10) Saqlain 11) Bumrah
 
Van_Sri said:
View attachment 150261
Click to expand...
1) Anwar - Best Batsman of Pakistan in 90s 2) Afridi - An Unpredictable Batsman, Good Spinner to support Saqlain 3) Yousuf - Best Batsman of Pakistan in 2000s, 4) Miandad - Best Batsman of Pakistan in 1980s, 5) Inzamam - Second Best Batsman of Pakistan in 90s and 2000s, 6) Imran - Best Captain and Allrounder from Pakistan 7) Razzaq - Best Bowling Allrounder of Pakistan after Imran, 8) Moin Khan - Best Wicket Keeper Batsman to come at No 8 (1999 World Cup Second Best Batsman of Pakistan who took the team to Finals), 9) Wasim, Saqlain and Waqar - Best Bowlers from South Asia. Can India 🇮🇳 All Time ODI XI can dominate this Pakistan 🇵🇰 XI ?
 
IMG_4070.jpegPakistan 🇵🇰 All Time ODI XI : 1) Anwar 2) Fakhar 3) Yousuf 4) Miandad 5) Inzamam 6) Rizwan+ 7) Imran* 8) Wasim 9) Saqlain 10) Waqar 11) Shoaib
 
IMG_4086.jpegPakistan 🇵🇰 All Time ODI XI : 1) Anwar 2) Fakhar 3) Babar 4) Rizwan+ 5) Inzamam 6) Imran* 7) Razzaq 8) Afridi 9) Wasim 10) Saqlain 11) Waqar - A Much More Well Balanced Team with 6 Bowlers and 9 Batsman. Hope to see Fakhar, Babar and Rizwan do well in the ODI’s to cement their place in an All Time XI.
 
World XI batting line up will have a tough time battling Bumrah, Wasim, Waqar, Shami. At their peak 4 of the greatest ODI pacers of all time.
 
IMG_4020.jpegAll Time South Africa 🇿🇦 ODI XI : 1) de Kock+ 2) Amla 3) Kallis 4) de Villiers 5) Cronje* 6) Miller 7) Pollock 8) Klusener 9) Ntini 10) Tahir 11) Donald - Probably the Strongest Bowling lineup for any All Time ODI XI - Pollock, Ntini, Donald, Klusener, Tahir, Kallis, Cronje.
 
IMG_4039.jpegAll Time New Zealand 🇳🇿 ODI XI : 1) Guptill 2) McCullum+ 3) Williamson* 4) Crowe 5) Taylor 6) Cairns 7) Oram 8) Hadlee 9) Vettori 10) Bond 11) Boult. A Well Balanced Team.
 
IMG_4055.jpegAll Time England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ODI XI : 1) Roy 2) Bairstow 3) Root 4) Morgan* 5) Stokes 6) Buttler+ 7) Flintoff 8) Botham 9) Woakes 10) Swann 11) Gough. A Well Balanced Team with 7 Players from 2019 World Cup Winning Team.
 
All time Asia XI

1/Saeed Anwar
2/Sachin Tendulker
3/Babar Azam
4/Virat Kohli
5/Javed Miandad
6/Inzamam ul Haq
7/Kumar Sangakkara
8/Abdul Razzaq
9/Wasim Akram
10/Waqar Younis
11/Saqlain Mustaq

waterboy: Shakib Al Hasan :inti
 
Captains for World Cup 🏆 with All Time ODI XI : 1) Ricky Ponting 🇦🇺 2) Eoin Morgan 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 3) Kane Williamson 🇳🇿 4) Hansie Cronje 🇿🇦 5) Imran Khan 🇵🇰 6) MS Dhoni 🇮🇳 7) Arjuna Ranatunga 🇱🇰 8) Clive Lloyd 🇬🇾
 
Bhaijaan said:
World XI batting line up will have a tough time battling Bumrah, Wasim, Waqar, Shami. At their peak 4 of the greatest ODI pacers of all time.
Click to expand...
Yeah with Bumrah, now we have solid ATG Ind-Pak 11 against ROW, I always thought we were behind ROW(thanks to great windies and Aussie teams), specially in tests. That's why fast bowlers are the MVPs in cricket.
 
Van_Sri said:
View attachment 150716Pakistan 🇵🇰 All Time ODI XI : 1) Anwar 2) Fakhar 3) Babar 4) Rizwan+ 5) Inzamam 6) Imran* 7) Razzaq 8) Afridi 9) Wasim 10) Saqlain 11) Waqar - A Much More Well Balanced Team with 6 Bowlers and 9 Batsman. Hope to see Fakhar, Babar and Rizwan do well in the ODI’s to cement their place in an All Time XI.
Click to expand...
This Team will kick the ass of any ODI XI at Sharjah
 
All-Time Asia XI
#1 Saeed Anwar
#2 Parthiv Patel
#3 Virat Kohli
#4 Kumar Sangakkara
#5 Javed Miandad
#6 Yuvraj Singh
#7 Ms Dhoni (wk)
#8 Imran Khan
#9 Wasim Akram
#10 Muttiah Muralitharan
#11 Jasprit Bumrah

All-Time World XI
#1 Adam Gilchrist (wk)
#2 Boeta Dipenaar
#3 Ricky Ponting
#4 AB de Villiers
#5 Eoin Morgan (c)
#6 Michael Bevan
#7 Lance Klusener
#8 Shane Warne
#9 Trent Boult
#10 Courtney Walsh
#11 Glenn McGrath
 
Varun said:
All-Time Asia XI
#1 Saeed Anwar
#2 Parthiv Patel
#3 Virat Kohli
#4 Kumar Sangakkara
#5 Javed Miandad
#6 Yuvraj Singh
#7 Ms Dhoni (wk)
#8 Imran Khan
#9 Wasim Akram
#10 Muttiah Muralitharan
#11 Jasprit Bumrah

All-Time World XI
#1 Adam Gilchrist (wk)
#2 Boeta Dipenaar
#3 Ricky Ponting
#4 AB de Villiers
#5 Eoin Morgan (c)
#6 Michael Bevan
#7 Lance Klusener
#8 Shane Warne
#9 Trent Boult
#10 Courtney Walsh
#11 Glenn McGrath
Click to expand...
Parthiv Patel and Boeta Dipennar 🤣
 
Bhaijaan said:
World XI batting line up will have a tough time battling Bumrah, Wasim, Waqar, Shami. At their peak 4 of the greatest ODI pacers of all time.
Click to expand...
And Asia 11 would have trouble dealing with

1) Mcgrath
2) Warne
3) Richard Hadlee
4) Joel Garner
5) Micheal Holding
6) Allan Donald
7) Curtley Ambrose
8) Dale Steyn
9) Dennis Lillie

And so on and so forth. Rest of world 11 dominated and dominated badly.
 
Varun said:
All-Time Asia XI
#1 Saeed Anwar
#2 Parthiv Patel
#3 Virat Kohli
#4 Kumar Sangakkara
#5 Javed Miandad
#6 Yuvraj Singh
#7 Ms Dhoni (wk)
#8 Imran Khan
#9 Wasim Akram
#10 Muttiah Muralitharan
#11 Jasprit Bumrah

All-Time World XI
#1 Adam Gilchrist (wk)
#2 Boeta Dipenaar
#3 Ricky Ponting
#4 AB de Villiers
#5 Eoin Morgan (c)
#6 Michael Bevan
#7 Lance Klusener
#8 Shane Warne
#9 Trent Boult
#10 Courtney Walsh
#11 Glenn McGrath
Click to expand...
Joke list, both of em
 
mominsaigol said:
And Asia 11 would have trouble dealing with

1) Mcgrath
2) Warne
3) Richard Hadlee
4) Joel Garner
5) Micheal Holding
6) Allan Donald
7) Curtley Ambrose
8) Dale Steyn
9) Dennis Lillie

And so on and so forth. Rest of world 11 dominated and dominated badly.
Click to expand...

Yes but Bumrah has to an extent balanced things out slightly in #AsianBloc favour now. Before that we had Wasim and Waqar and then we were putting all hopes on an erratic Shoaib Akhtar as our 3rd seamer who has a history of being a no show in big matches.

Now Shami and Bumrah are there and together with the Ws and Rawalpindi Express we can finally say #AsianBloc has everything covered in pace attack. We have Wasim’s magic, Shami’s impeccable seam bowling, Waqar’s crazy reverse swing, Bumrah’s freakiness, and Akhtar’s temperamental intimidating speed bowling. All that and we still have Kapil Dev at #7
 
mominsaigol said:
And Asia 11 would have trouble dealing with

1) Mcgrath
2) Warne
3) Richard Hadlee
4) Joel Garner
5) Micheal Holding
6) Allan Donald
7) Curtley Ambrose
8) Dale Steyn
9) Dennis Lillie

And so on and so forth. Rest of world 11 dominated and dominated badly.
Click to expand...

Tendulkar will nullify McGrath/Warne/Donald. McGrath will be a good boy to remember ICC Knock Out 2000 when Tendulkar smashed him out of the equation. The same strategy that didn’t work in 2003 but worth the try. It’s all that you can do against what was literally a pinpoint precision bowling machine bro. You know that.

Indy bhai will take care of Ambrose/Holding/Lillee. Remember Big Inzy got all the time in the world.

Yuvi will flick Steyn to the stands bro. It’s one day cricket.

We got Kapil paaaji at #7 who will blow away the entire opposition bowling. Remember the best pure striker in the history of cricket.
 
Bhaijaan said:
Yes but Bumrah has to an extent balanced things out slightly in #AsianBloc favour now. Before that we had Wasim and Waqar and then we were putting all hopes on an erratic Shoaib Akhtar as our 3rd seamer who has a history of being a no show in big matches.

Now Shami and Bumrah are there and together with the Ws and Rawalpindi Express we can finally say #AsianBloc has everything covered in pace attack. We have Wasim’s magic, Shami’s impeccable seam bowling, Waqar’s crazy reverse swing, Bumrah’s freakiness, and Akhtar’s temperamental intimidating speed bowling. All that and we still have Kapil Dev at #7
Click to expand...
All time world 15

1) Adam Gilchrist (WK)
2) Brian Lara
3) Ricky Pointing (C)
4) Viv Richards
5) Ab de Villers
6) Micheal Bevan
7) Shaun Pollock
8) Lance Klusner
9) Dennis Lillie
10) Shane Warne
11) Glenn Mcgrath

12) Richard Hadlee
13) Joel Garner
14) Mattew Hayden
15) Waugh

^^ You can put these 4 in the 11, I'm listing them all put of order.

All time Asia 15

1) Sachin Tendulkar
2) Saeed Anwar
3) Virat Kohli
4) Kumar Sangakkara
5) Yuvraj Singh
6) MS Dhoni (WK)(c)
7) Imran Khan
8) Wasim Akram
9) Waqar Younis
10) Jasprit Bumrah
11) Murli

12) Virender Sehwag
13) Kapil Dev
14) Mohammad Shami
15) chaminda vaas
 
mominsaigol said:
All time world 15

1) Adam Gilchrist (WK)
2) Brian Lara
3) Ricky Pointing (C)
4) Viv Richards
5) Ab de Villers
6) Micheal Bevan
7) Shaun Pollock
8) Lance Klusner
9) Dennis Lillie
10) Shane Warne
11) Glenn Mcgrath

12) Richard Hadlee
13) Joel Garner
14) Mattew Hayden
15) Waugh

^^ You can put these 4 in the 11, I'm listing them all put of order.

All time Asia 15

1) Sachin Tendulkar
2) Saeed Anwar
3) Virat Kohli
4) Kumar Sangakkara
5) Yuvraj Singh
6) MS Dhoni (WK)(c)
7) Imran Khan
8) Wasim Akram
9) Waqar Younis
10) Jasprit Bumrah
11) Murli

12) Virender Sehwag
13) Kapil Dev
14) Mohammad Shami
15) chaminda vaas
Click to expand...
Rohit Sharma over Tendulkar in ODIs
 
Bhaijaan said:
Tendulkar will nullify McGrath/Warne/Donald. McGrath will be a good boy to remember ICC Knock Out 2000 when Tendulkar smashed him out of the equation. The same strategy that didn’t work in 2003 but worth the try. It’s all that you can do against what was literally a pinpoint precision bowling machine bro. You know that.

Indy bhai will take care of Ambrose/Holding/Lillee. Remember Big Inzy got all the time in the world.

Yuvi will flick Steyn to the stands bro. It’s one day cricket.

We got Kapil paaaji at #7 who will blow away the entire opposition bowling. Remember the best pure striker in the history of cricket.
Click to expand...
Tendulkar will nullify McGrath/Warne/Donald.

No he wont, that was a one off where mcgrath had a bad day against everyone, sachin only scored 38 that day, Mcgrath was getting smacked at the end and didnt take any wicjet and got tonked for 61 runs.

Bumrah got beaten black and blue y england in 2019, by travis in 2023 and by Fakhar in 2017 but that doesnt mean hes a bad bowler and that these batters will neutralise him(excluding maybe travis), 99% of the time he'll have their number.

Mcgrath has owned Sachin in odi more times then Sachin has owned Mcgrath. The truth is Sachin would have had more centuries if mcgrath wasn't bossing him around 24/7 in icc world cup events.

Indy bhai will take care of Ambrose/Holding/Lillee. Remember Big Inzy got all the time in the world.

Inzi aint doing anything to Lillie/Holding/Ambrose in pressure moments. He's a goat batsmen but was a mental midget under pressure. You have to assume that their in a relaxed casual bi laterals series for inzi to work, and even then Lillie will likely get rid of him.

Yuvi will flick Steyn to the stands bro. It’s one day cricket.

We got Kapil paaaji at #7 who will blow away the entire opposition bowling. Remember the best pure striker in the history of cricket.

Major Cap.
 
RidiculousMan said:
Rohit Sharma over Tendulkar in ODIs
Click to expand...
Sachin batted in a harder era and I have memories of Dale steyn wrecking rohit the game after rohit scored a double century.

Rohit can't play quality swing for the life of him. Sehwag was a better batsmen then he was. And rohit is also bang avg against spin.

No one in that era avg 50+ at the top order had a 100+ SR due to the odi rules. Saeed Anwar is a better minnow basher and a more technical adept batsmen then rohit but stats don't reflect it due to eras. 194 back then is equivalent to 240 to 260 now.

Sachin was a clown against mcgrath excluding one offs but he was quality against mcgrath, pollock and many other bowlers of his era.

Rohit would avg 30 something in that era. He's benefitted from the early PP rules.

I like rohit, but he is overrated as a batsmen. It's just he makes pakiatani current crop look like a bunch of toddlers.
 
Head to Head

Tendulkar & Hitman beat any combination of openers the ROW can come up with

#AsianBloc wins battle of openers

Ponting, Richards, Lara, ABD win it for ROW XI in the middle order. Bunch of assassins really.

#ROW wins battle of middle order

Kapil Dev beat anyone ever as an AR

#AsianBloc wins battle of AR


The 2Ws + Bumrah beats the ROW pace attack.

#AsianBloc wins battle of pace


Saqi bhai wins the spin battle vs Warne bhai

#AsianBloc wins battle of spin
 
Bhaijaan said:
Head to Head

Tendulkar & Hitman beat any combination of openers the ROW can come up with

#AsianBloc wins battle of openers

Ponting, Richards, Lara, ABD win it for ROW XI in the middle order. Bunch of assassins really.

#ROW wins battle of middle order

Kapil Dev beat anyone ever as an AR

#AsianBloc wins battle of AR


The 2Ws + Bumrah beats the ROW pace attack.

#AsianBloc wins battle of pace


Saqi bhai wins the spin battle vs Warne bhai

#AsianBloc wins battle of spin
Click to expand...
You're 100% incorrect on all fronts here.

Tendulkar & Hitman beat any combination of openers the ROW can come up with


Hitman is a complete clown on neutral venues and can't place swing for the life of him. He played in a 2 new ball era which is easier. Saeed anwar in comparison is a much better minnow basher then Hitman and had Rohit played in the older era, He wouldn't have even made it into the Indian side as sehwag would have kept him out.

Sehwag's innings against aus in 2003 being the lonely warrior ahainat a quality attack is > Anything hitman has ever done as he's a certified circus clown. Thankfully tests has changed. Test is a solid reflection of how Rohit would have fared in odi's one ball era.

Both saeed and Sehwag keep rohit out of Indian 11.

Rohit is not better then gilly or Lara as an opener. Anyone who thinks otherwise has lost his marbles.

Kapil Dev beat anyone ever as an AR

I agree on the kapil dev part alongside Imran Khan, it's whatever but he alone isn't making a difference.

The 2Ws + Bumrah beats the ROW pace attack.

No they don't. McGrath, Garner, Hadlee, Dennis Lillie > Bumrah in odi. Bumrah is only > these guys in tests excluding Mcgrath who's > Bumrah in tests. Row has a much deadlier pace attack even though I'm a huge fan of wasim, Bumrah and waqar.

Saqi bhai wins the spin battle vs Warne bhai

Saqlain doesn't even make it into Asian 11, and he's nowhere close to Warne. But murli is > Warne, that is agree with.
 
mominsaigol said:
You're 100% incorrect on all fronts here.

Tendulkar & Hitman beat any combination of openers the ROW can come up with


Hitman is a complete clown on neutral venues and can't place swing for the life of him. He played in a 2 new ball era which is easier. Saeed anwar in comparison is a much better minnow basher then Hitman and had Rohit played in the older era, He wouldn't have even made it into the Indian side as sehwag would have kept him out.

Sehwag's innings against aus in 2003 being the lonely warrior ahainat a quality attack is > Anything hitman has ever done as he's a certified circus clown. Thankfully tests has changed. Test is a solid reflection of how Rohit would have fared in odi's one ball era.

Both saeed and Sehwag keep rohit out of Indian 11.

Rohit is not better then gilly or Lara as an opener. Anyone who thinks otherwise has lost his marbles.

Kapil Dev beat anyone ever as an AR

I agree on the kapil dev part alongside Imran Khan, it's whatever but he alone isn't making a difference.

The 2Ws + Bumrah beats the ROW pace attack.

No they don't. McGrath, Garner, Hadlee, Dennis Lillie > Bumrah in odi. Bumrah is only > these guys in tests excluding Mcgrath who's > Bumrah in tests. Row has a much deadlier pace attack even though I'm a huge fan of wasim, Bumrah and waqar.

Saqi bhai wins the spin battle vs Warne bhai

Saqlain doesn't even make it into Asian 11, and he's nowhere close to Warne. But murli is > Warne, that is agree with.
Click to expand...
@Bhaijaan The only area that Asian 11 beats ROW on is that they have better allrounders (imran + kapil) and both allrounders have sharp cricketing brains which can function as captains and leaders.

And the fact that they have murli who's the only spinner > Warne. And that they have Tendulkar who in odi is > Lara + Gilly as a batter.

However sehwag or saeed is below lara and gilly.

And row is jam packed with a scary middle and lower order while sanga, Yuvi/inzi, Dhoni aren't anywhere near that caliber and aren't surviving against the pace attack.

And row's pace attack blows Asian 11 attack out of the water.

At their peaks, Lillie, Mcgrath, Hadlee/Garner would have a field day against row. Tendulkar is literally the only threat in this lineup and he's one man who's been a bunny against mcgrath in odis excluding one off outliers where mcgrath was having an off day against everyone.

The rest are getting destroyed by lillie and hadlee
 
I think Asia XI will win some games and ROW XI will also win some games. Rest will be depending on where the matches are played.
 
IMG_4109.jpegAustralia 🇦🇺 All Time ODI XI : 1) Gilchrist+ 2) Watson 3) Ponting* 4) Jones 5) Symonds 6) Bevan 7) Maxwell 8) Lee 9) Warne 10) Starc 11) McGrath. Australia has the most powerful team - 2 Aggressive Openers, Dominant No 3, Powerful Middle Order with Jones, Symonds and Bevan, Aggressive Lower Order Hitman Maxwell, Good Tail who can bat with Lee, Warne and Starc. Australia XI is better than World XI as they don’t need any other team players to make the team stronger. Bowling : McGrath, Starc, Lee, Warne, Watson, Symonds and Maxwell.
 
I think Asia is stronger now

1. Rohit
2. Tendulkar
3. Kohli
4. Zaheer abbas
5. Inzi
6. Dhoni (wk and c)
7. Imran
8. Wasim
9. Bumrah
10. Murali
11. Rashid Khan

I think if we compare to rest of the world, I think only Inzi, zaheer, imran and one bowler for McGrath would lose their place to put in a ROW cricketer.
 
ads101 said:
I think Asia is stronger now

1. Rohit
2. Tendulkar
3. Kohli
4. Zaheer abbas
5. Inzi
6. Dhoni (wk and c)
7. Imran
8. Wasim
9. Bumrah
10. Murali
11. Rashid Khan

I think if we compare to rest of the world, I think only Inzi, zaheer, imran and one bowler for McGrath would lose their place to put in a ROW cricketer.
Click to expand...
Not really Australia XI is very Strong
 
Van_Sri said:
View attachment 150738Australia 🇦🇺 All Time ODI XI : 1) Gilchrist+ 2) Watson 3) Ponting* 4) Jones 5) Symonds 6) Bevan 7) Maxwell 8) Lee 9) Warne 10) Starc 11) McGrath. Australia has the most powerful team - 2 Aggressive Openers, Dominant No 3, Powerful Middle Order with Jones, Symonds and Bevan, Aggressive Lower Order Hitman Maxwell, Good Tail who can bat with Lee, Warne and Starc. Australia XI is better than World XI as they don’t need any other team players to make the team stronger. Bowling : McGrath, Starc, Lee, Warne, Watson, Symonds and Maxwell.
Click to expand...
I agree but in what world does Maxwell make an all-time Australian ODI XI ahead of Hayden, Martin, M Waugh, Clarke, Warner, Hussey etc? Based on one 201* against Afghanistan? If you are looking for all-round ability remember even M Waugh bowled competent Off-Spin
 
giri26 said:
I agree but in what world does Maxwell make an all-time Australian ODI XI ahead of Hayden, Martin, M Waugh, Clarke, Warner, Hussey etc? Based on one 201* against Afghanistan? If you are looking for all-round ability remember even M Waugh bowled competent Off-Spin
Click to expand...
Maxwell is better than all of them you mentioned at No 7, and also a part time spinner.
 
ads101 said:
I think Asia is stronger now

1. Rohit
2. Tendulkar
3. Kohli
4. Zaheer abbas
5. Inzi
6. Dhoni (wk and c)
7. Imran
8. Wasim
9. Bumrah
10. Murali
11. Rashid Khan

I think if we compare to rest of the world, I think only Inzi, zaheer, imran and one bowler for McGrath would lose their place to put in a ROW cricketer.
Click to expand...
No they are not 🤣.

1) Lara
2) Gilly
3) Pointing
4) Viv
5) de villers
6) Bevan
7) Pollock
8) Lance Klusner
9) Dennis Lillie
10) Warne
11) Mcgrath

12) Hadlee
13) Garner
14) Steve waugh
15) Mattew Hayden

Row is blowing Asia out of the water lol
 
If it comes to all time asia vs ROW 11, i think Row 11 has a better crop and they might be unbeatable....who knows
 
BouncerGuy said:
If it comes to all time asia vs ROW 11, i think Row 11 has a better crop and they might be unbeatable....who knows
Click to expand...
They have a much better crop. It's not even fair. The only thing Asia 11 has is that they have better spinners and better allrounders as kapil dev and Imran are > Any bowling allrounder from row Pollock included.

And murli is > Warne.

But their batting is pathetically weak compared to the pace bowlers they have to face
 
mominsaigol said:
No they are not 🤣.

1) Lara
2) Gilly
3) Pointing
4) Viv
5) de villers
6) Bevan
7) Pollock
8) Lance Klusner
9) Dennis Lillie
10) Warne
11) Mcgrath

12) Hadlee
13) Garner
14) Steve waugh
15) Mattew Hayden

Row is blowing Asia out of the water lol
Click to expand...
Asia’s whole top 3 are better. 4 and 5 row wins. Dhoni is at least as good as Bevan as well as captaincy and a wicketkeeper so overall I’d give it to Dhoni. Plus it allows to play a better opener than Gilchrist. Klusener is better than imran. McGrath is a better pace bowler than all but not sure the rest are better than Wasim and bumrah (never saw Lillie play). Murali is better than Warne.

So yeah row get 4 spots.

But Asia having a comfortably better top 3, a better captain and a finisher and Murali gives them the advantage. Batting wise games are often decided by the top 3 anyway in LOI. But even if Asia wins in more departments/positions than row there is one huge factor. That is Murali. Honestly Murali alone, having him in LOI is a giant advantage, there’s no other spinner really who had quite that impact in LOI. A quality mystery spinner just exerts so much impact on the match. And Murali was the best one by some distance.
 
ads101 said:
Asia’s whole top 3 are better. 4 and 5 row wins. Dhoni is at least as good as Bevan as well as captaincy and a wicketkeeper so overall I’d give it to Dhoni. Plus it allows to play a better opener than Gilchrist. Klusener is better than imran. McGrath is a better pace bowler than all but not sure the rest are better than Wasim and bumrah (never saw Lillie play). Murali is better than Warne.

So yeah row get 4 spots.

But Asia having a comfortably better top 3, a better captain and a finisher and Murali gives them the advantage. Batting wise games are often decided by the top 3 anyway in LOI. But even if Asia wins in more departments/positions than row there is one huge factor. That is Murali. Honestly Murali alone, having him in LOI is a giant advantage, there’s no other spinner really who had quite that impact in LOI. A quality mystery spinner just exerts so much impact on the match. And Murali was the best one by some distance.
Click to expand...
No their not. First of your 11 is flawed.

Hitman is extremely overrated as an odi batsmen who benefitted from bashing in the 2 new ball era. He's the definition of a HTB and a FTB.

Sehwag is a better batter then he is. Sehwag's innings in 2003 final against a top quality bowling attack is >>>>>>>> Anything hitman has done.

Tests are a proper reflection of how rohit would have fared in the one ball era. Infact saeed Anwar is a better Flat track basher then rohit is, but due to eras it doesn't seem that way. Rohit would sit out for sehwag and saeed.

To argue that rohit is > Lara and Gilly as an odi opener is comical. Tendulkar is better then these 2 that I agree.

Zaheer Abass at 4 ahead of Sanga is Laughable. In odi's he was a 30 to 33 avg batter against every single opposition in every country with a sr of 65. He played most of his odi games in England and pakistan where he bashed oppositions and performed in world cups. He's literally a 2 ground HTB and his record would have been exposed had he played more then 60 pdi games since he was really bad in other countries in both tests and odi.

I'm fine with inzi at 5, I'd prefer Yuvi due to bowling but inzi is a better batter so it's cool and 6 and 7 are good.

And what is rashid Khan doing batting at 11? When he's a better batsmen then waqar, bumrah and murli?

Now to discuss

Rohit, Sanga/zaheer, and inzi are no where near lara, Pointing, Viv, or de villers as one day batters.

And Dhoni is nowhere close to Bevan, Bevan in the 1990's was being compared to Tendulkar as a batsmen. He's easily the best no 6 of all time and Dhoni is damn near useless in overseas conditons excluding one offs.

Mcgrath, Lillie, Hadlee, Garner are all massively > Bumrah, Imran, wasim and waqar. Bumrah is not a great odi bowler. He's very good but he doesn't play odi that often and it's his weakest format compared to test and t20. Wasim and Imran are coated but not > Mcgrath, Lillie, Hadlee or Garner. Waqar is doing nothing.

Murli is > Warne however rashid Khan is useless. Morgan, and Indian batters have spanked him multiple times. The quality batting lineup that row has would ensure that they'd bash rashid too
 
ROW XI
Mark Waugh
Gilchrist
Viv
ABD
Clive LLoyd
Symonds
Klusener
Starc
Warne Garner Mcgrath

Asian XI
Sachin
Jaysuriya
Kohli
Abbas
De Silva
Yuvaraj
Dhoni
Kapil
Wasim
Saqlain
Bumrah
.
All other places are more or less equal, But RoW with Viv and ABd at 3 and 4 pulls away. They are 1 and 2 in my greatest loi batsmen ranking.
 
IMG_4128.jpegAustralia 🇦🇺 All Time ODI XI : 1) Gilchrist+ 2) Waugh 3) Ponting* 4) Jones 5) Symonds 6) Bevan 7) Watson 8) Lee 9) Warne 10) Starc 11) McGrath
 
mominsaigol said:
And Dhoni is nowhere close to Bevan, Bevan in the 1990's was being compared to Tendulkar as a batsmen. He's easily the best no 6 of all time and Dhoni is damn near useless in overseas conditons excluding one
Click to expand...
Bevan has more not out/innings than Dhoni but scoring runs in his era was tough and he introduced the concept of great finishing in ODI
 
Non asian xi:
Gilchrist (wk)
Amla
Ponting (c)
Viv
Villiers
Klusnar
Hadlee
Warne
McGrath
Donald
Garner
 
IMG_4174.jpegWest Indies 🏝️ All Time ODI XI : 1) Greenidge 2) Gayle 3) Lara 4) Richards 5) Hooper 6) Lloyd* 7) Hope+ 8) Holding 9) Roberts 10) Garner 11) Ambrose
 
Bhaijaan said:
Only on flat pitches because they’re loaded with assassins who destroy bowling attacks on flat pitches.

Give us a bouncy track, our bowling will blow away the ROWs.
Click to expand...
Bouncy track would be Australia.

Wasim, waqar and bumrah are not outperforming Mcgrath, Lillie or Garner in such conditons.

Garner is a nightmare on bouncy wickets and wasim or bumrah ain't bowling better then Lillie and Mcgrath on such pitches lol.
 
Bhaijaan said:
Only on flat pitches because they’re loaded with assassins who destroy bowling attacks on flat pitches.

Give us a bouncy track, our bowling will blow away the ROWs.
Click to expand...
South Asia XI : 1) Jayasuriya 2) Tendulkar 3) Kohli 4) Sangakkara 5) Inzamam 6) Yuvraj 7) Dhoni*+ 8) Wasim 9) Waqar 10) Murali 11) Bumrah
 
mominsaigol said:
Bouncy track would be Australia.

Wasim, waqar and bumrah are not outperforming Mcgrath, Lillie or Garner in such conditons.

Garner is a nightmare on bouncy wickets and wasim or bumrah ain't bowling better then Lillie and Mcgrath on such pitches lol.
Click to expand...

Wasim, Akhtar outperformed McGrath, Lee, Gillespi in 2002-03 when Pakistan won 2-1 in Australia.

Add peak Waqar, Bumrah and Shami to the above and you’re talking about #AsianBloc bringing the storm to the ROW batting line-up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
All time T20 XI that has never played T20s
Replies
9
Views
274
Mute Witness
M
Unbiased-Fan
Bangladesh All Time Test XI
Replies
10
Views
2K
BouncerGuy
BouncerGuy
R
Could Jasprit Bumrah make it into Pakistan's all-time XI, assuming he were a Pakistani cricketer?
Replies
75
Views
2K
RyanRyan10
RyanRyan10
M
  • Poll Poll
Would Younis Khan be included in all-time India Test XI if he was from India?
2
Replies
139
Views
7K
Van_Sri
Van_Sri
R
Spoiler Alert - India vs Pakistan games in Asia cup will be closer than many expect
2 3
Replies
170
Views
6K
Vikram1989
V
Back
Top