What's new

Bangladesh vs Pakistan | 1st Test | Day 2 | Hafeez and Azhar put Pakistan on top

TheNightWatchman said:
That wasn't even close. WHERE WAS THE CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE THAT IT WAS OUT. Similarly WHERE WAS THE CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE that Sami's was out??
Click to expand...

Hafeez was given out, so there has to be conclusive evidence that it was not out, which with the technology available, isn't really possible. I'm not complaining though :D Sami's was marginal, but yeah, benefit of the doubt should have gone to him and the umpire's original decision
 
angrypathan said:
Hafeez was given out, so there has to be conclusive evidence that it was not out, which with the technology available, isn't really possible. I'm not complaining though :D Sami's was marginal, but yeah, benefit of the doubt should have gone to him and the umpire's original decision
Click to expand...

The conclusive evidence for Hafeez was that there was no deflection. Since there is no snicko or hotspot we can only rely on deflection. Since there wasn't a deflection it was not out.
Sami's wasn't even close to conclusive.Basing his decision on a shadow rather than deflection
 
TheNightWatchman said:
That wasn't even close. WHERE WAS THE CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE THAT IT WAS OUT. Similarly WHERE WAS THE CONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE that Sami's was out??
Click to expand...

Stop being a moron. Read your earlier post. Where was the conclusive evidence it was not out? Hence why should the on-field decision be overturned?
 
Need to keep this RR. We have to get 500+ here which means a double ton by one batsman.

I'm excited to see the next few to bat. YK, Misbah, Shafiq & SARF
 
Dios said:
Stop being a moron. Read your earlier post. Where was the conclusive evidence it was not out? Hence why should the on-field decision be overturned?
Click to expand...

The conclusive evidence for Hafeez was that there was no deflection. Since there is no snicko or hotspot we can only rely on deflection. Since there wasn't a deflection it was not out.
Sami's wasn't even close to conclusive.Basing his decision on a shadow rather than deflection
 
Early tons dont help pakistan batsmen.. atleast the new ones. I am happy that sami aslam didnt score a ton. He will understand the early struggle.

Azhar and asad got their tons relatively late but doing pretty well. Guys like yasir hameed umar akmal mohammad wasim fell off. :yk and :miandad did well though.
 
TheNightWatchman said:
The conclusive evidence for Hafeez was that there was no deflection. Since there is no snicko or hotspot we can only rely on deflection. Since there wasn't a deflection it was not out.
Sami's wasn't even close to conclusive.Basing his decision on a shadow rather than deflection
Click to expand...

There not being a deflection is not conclusive evidence. Does the tiniest edge cause a deflection? So why should the on-field umpire's decision be overturned?
 
TheNightWatchman said:
The conclusive evidence for Hafeez was that there was no deflection. Since there is no snicko or hotspot we can only rely on deflection. Since there wasn't a deflection it was not out.
Sami's wasn't even close to conclusive.Basing his decision on a shadow rather than deflection
Click to expand...

I'm not saying Sami was out 100%. I'm just saying if Hafeez's decision can be overturned so can Sami's.
 
Captain is on the dance floor, RR to take a nosedive and we will commit same mistake which Bang committed, but for now i can take this approach because tea is approaching, and going to tea without any more wickets lost is premium motive for now.
 
Dios said:
There not being a deflection is not conclusive evidence. Does the tiniest edge cause a deflection? So why should the on-field umpire's decision be overturned?
Click to expand...

So what is?? Ofcourse there is no snicko. No hotspot. The only way the umpire could no it is notout is through deflection of the ball which did not happen. Add to that the fact that Hafeez reviewed immediately. Hafeez is not an idiot. If he knew he nicked it he wouldn't have gone for a review.
 
Mr. Ali the tuk tuk, some tuk tuk is find but don't take it a level where hackfeez get furrstated and throw his wicket away so plz get a move on and atleast give strike to minnow basher regularly.
 
TheNightWatchman said:
So what is?? Ofcourse there is no snicko. No hotspot. The only way the umpire could no it is notout is through deflection of the ball which did not happen. Add to that the fact that Hafeez reviewed immediately. Hafeez is not an idiot. If he knew he nicked it he wouldn't have gone for a review.
Click to expand...
That's just stupid. As I said not every nick causes a deflection. Just because there isn't a deflection that doesn't confirm the absence of an edge. In the absence of snicko and hotspot you just leave the decision with the on-field umpire that's my point. And I don't know how to respond to your second point. So umpires should now be influenced by player's actions? So everyone around the bat seemed convinced there was an edge as well. Should the third umpire now review their character profiles to see who's more honorable.
 
Zeshan547 said:
Mr. Ali the tuk tuk, some tuk tuk is find but don't take it a level where hackfeez get furrstated and throw his wicket away so plz get a move on and atleast give strike to minnow basher regularly.
Click to expand...

It's a test match genius.
 
Dios said:
That's just stupid. As I said not every nick causes a deflection. Just because there isn't a deflection that doesn't confirm the absence of an edge. In the absence of snicko and hotspot you just leave the decision with the on-field umpire that's my point. And I don't know how to respond to your second point. So umpires should now be influenced by player's actions? So everyone around the bat seemed convinced there was an edge as well. Should the third umpire now review their character profiles to see who's more honorable.
Click to expand...

Everyone around the bat has a job to appeal. Ofcourse they will appeal whether they are convinced or not. Hafeez just went for it straight away. It's nothing to do with honesty. Hafeez was well and truly convinced that technology will prove he is not out. Since he is the batsman he would be the guy to know if he edged it.
There was no noise either so there is absolutely nothing there to support the onfield umpire. No deflection No noise Not out
 
Zeshan547 said:
Mr. Ali the tuk tuk, some tuk tuk is find but don't take it a level where hackfeez get furrstated and throw his wicket away so plz get a move on and atleast give strike to minnow basher regularly.
Click to expand...

This was cute. Sounded like a little baby wrote it.
 
2.2 in last 10 overs.

I want to win the test, not draw. So its important to go over 3.5
 
Where is our very own [MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] , The ultimate cricket Pundit of Pp.
 
angrypathan said:
Bangladeshis often pronounce 's' rather differently. Masrafe they pronounce "Mashrafe", Taskin they pronounce "Tashkin" and Soumya they pronounce "Shoumya". Guess it's the other way around for :shakib
Click to expand...

wait my bad, Mashrafe is pronounced the way it's spelled
 
Zeshan547 said:
not strange because it's coming from a Shehzad fan. So salute you sir, keep your love affair going,
Click to expand...

lol I wasn't even thinking about Shehzad when I wrote that. Haters are more obsessed with Shehzad than his fans are.
 
RR nosedived From 4.2 to 3.1, and let's see where this free fall stop. Azhar is hire of misbah in truest sense.
 
Pakistani fans are the worst. Complaining about RR when it's not even that bad for tests. Why did I ever come on this site?
 
And this session also belong to Pakistan, keep it up boys, next target 200 runs till end of today's play, and don't lose more than 2 wickets in next session at worst.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

FearlessRoar
Pakistan reach 109/3 at the end of Day 2 of the first Test against the West Indies, with a lead of 202 runs
4 5 6
Replies
465
Views
10K
Amjid Javed
Amjid Javed
The Bald Eagle
Zimbabwe tour of Bangladesh (2025)
2 3
Replies
215
Views
6K
nish_mate
N
FearlessRoar
Pakistan reach 64/3 in reply to South Africa's 615 at the end of Day 2 of the second Test, trailing by 551 runs
6 7 8
Replies
590
Views
13K
aqua99
A
The Bald Eagle
1st Four-Day match between Pakistan Shaheens (367/4d) and Bangladesh A (122 & 153/5) ends in a draw
Replies
72
Views
4K
zarak
Z
The Bald Eagle
Pakistan’s batting struggles persist as they finish Day 2 of the second Test at 76/4 in pursuit of 254 against the West Indies
7 8 9
Replies
668
Views
12K
Mamoon
Mamoon
Back
Top