Rana
Hall of Famer
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2006
- Runs
- 90,952
How am I derailing the thread when I am talking about YK at no.3 in ODI cricketDo not derail the thread. You claim YK as a ‘proper’ ODI batter. Tell us how.
Hahahhahaahhhaha
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
How am I derailing the thread when I am talking about YK at no.3 in ODI cricketDo not derail the thread. You claim YK as a ‘proper’ ODI batter. Tell us how.
You are talking about the strongest 3-5 batters and also bringing in legends like Inzi & MoYo in the discussionHow am I derailing the thread when I am talking about YK at no.3 in ODI cricket
Hahahhahaahhhaha
Of course I am. We work as a unit. You want to discuss the importance of a player in a format, these factors always matter.You are talking about the strongest 3-5 batters and also bringing in legends like Inzi & MoYo in the discussion
I am still waiting for your explanation on how is YK a proper ODI batter
Why are you acting like a troll? When did I claim Younis is the greatest ODI number 3?Younis is greatest ODI batter at number 3 now for obvious reasons.... Run before it turns toxic... run
Read your own post for a change buddyWhy are you acting like a troll? When did I claim Younis is the greatest ODI number 3?
How about you learn to read properly firstRead your own post for a change buddy
You claimed him to be a ‘proper’ ODI no.3. There is nothing in his stats to suggest that. I am asking you to enlighten us with your theory.How about you learn to read properly first
Where did I claim YK is the greatest ever no.3?
Younis achieved greatness in test cricket, and he brought honour to the country by winning the T20 WC.
He is a certified GOAT in the top tier of Pakistan cricket.
Babar is tier 3. He did have the potential to be a tier 1, and could still finish tier 2. But he has zero test performances that matter, very little ODI big innings and T20 he needs to produce the goods in a WC.
On the contrary when it comes to WK Bats Rizwan has formed a solid legacy for Pakistan. His test performances are often better than Babars too.
Your chachu Rana claimed YK to be a proper ODI batter. Be brave and either agree to his claim or disagree. Dont sit on the fence.No one claimed Younis Khan was a great ODI batsman.
But if I was you, I wouldn’t be ridiculing him when you have Rizwan as your choice of display pic. The less said about his batting, the better.
Your chachu Rana claimed YK to be a proper ODI batter. Be brave and either agree to his claim or disagree. Dont sit on the fence.
And by the way dont use <><><><>vs<><><> as it will not add any value.
If your emotional speech is over can we get back to the topic of the thread. It doesn’t matter what you think about posters. The point is do you agree that YK was a proper ODI batter.It’s not only Rana among the respected posters who views Younis Khan as a competent ODI batsman. Mamoon, whom you yourself hold in high regard, shares that opinion too. Please don't take this the wrong way, but I’m being straightforward, compared to them, you and Raja Ishtiaq fall into the bottom tier of posters, so naturally my perspective isn’t going to align with yours.
If your emotional speech is over can we get back to the topic of the thread. It doesn’t matter what you think about posters. The point is do you agree that YK was a proper ODI battet.
Spoke like a top tier posterYK was not a proper ODI "battet". Happy now?

I think they are having some fun with you guys. Overall they don't believe that Babar is better than Younis across all cricket formats.Well put, brother. This had to be addressed, because according to @gazza619 and @Raja Ishtiaq, Babar isn’t just considered great but supposedly superior to Younis Khan - this is up there among the most ridiculous takes in PP history.
Pakistan have had too many years of turbulence, politics and infighting as soon as Inzimam stepped away and then you had a slow crawl in of players like Misbah, whilst a drama queen like Hafeez was getting louder and louder with his stuck up attitude! Shoaib Malik as usual doing his “cloak and dagger” politics whilst falling out with everyone. Yousuf continuously living in a delusion of royalty within his head
All of these (although good cricketers) were kept in line during the Inzimam+Woolmer era! They were all let loose like a bunch of wild, toxic pendus and it basically ruined what could have been a great era for Pakistan cricket because the players were still top quality as they had fine batsmen and top class fast bowlers.
Misbah didn’t handle anyone!What hypocrisy! You want to credit inzi for handling difficult characters like Malik, Afridi, Hafeez, Yusuf and YK but when I credit Misbah for the same thing, you deny it. Too many double standards in your opinions
+if anything, the guy who was doing all the hard and tough work such as player management and dealing with the b.s was Waqar Younis the head coach. He was the one who I suppose Misbah was hiding behind. A lot of the players hate Waqar Younis, they probably didn’t see Misbah as the authority who was making the key decisions!Misbah didn’t handle anyone!
Hafeez was from his agency. They were both represented by Moghees. Yousuf never played under Misbah and found it an insult to be compared to him. Younis Khan has had public/dressing room spats with Misbah and was once about to lose his temper at some tv host comparing him to Misbah. Shahid Afridi may have been respectful towards him on his face but we saw how his own daughter publicly disgraced him for his slow, rubbish batting against India. Shoaib Akhtar didn’t cross paths with him as a skipper but the way he tore him to shreds for his rubbish captaincy and strategy in the 2015 World Cup is for all to see. Malik and him seem to get along fine. Malik brought him in instead of Yousuf for the 2007 T20 World Cup and that’s where he gained some fame…and Misbah backed him at a time when Malik was ostracised and hated by quite a few players in the Pakistan team. He may also be from Misbah’s agency but I’m not sure about this.
Misbah didn’t handle anyone!
Hafeez was from his agency. They were both represented by Moghees. Yousuf never played under Misbah and found it an insult to be compared to him. Younis Khan has had public/dressing room spats with Misbah and was once about to lose his temper at some tv host comparing him to Misbah. Shahid Afridi may have been respectful towards him on his face but we saw how his own daughter publicly disgraced him for his slow, rubbish batting against India. Shoaib Akhtar didn’t cross paths with him as a skipper but the way he tore him to shreds for his rubbish captaincy and strategy in the 2015 World Cup is for all to see. Malik and him seem to get along fine. Malik brought him in instead of Yousuf for the 2007 T20 World Cup and that’s where he gained some fame…and Misbah backed him at a time when Malik was ostracised and hated by quite a few players in the Pakistan team. He may also be from Misbah’s agency but I’m not sure about this.
He tends to make certain posters his abu.If your emotional speech is over can we get back to the topic of the thread. It doesn’t matter what you think about posters. The point is do you agree that YK was a proper ODI batter.
He tends to make certain posters his abu.
Mohammed Yousuf, Shoaib Akhtar and Younis Khan fell out with multiple players during their days as players and as pundits. Yousuf was bitter that he was dropped from WT20 for Misbah. Shoaib pretty much accuses the whole of Pakistan of lack of jazba apart from him, Wasim, Waqar.Misbah didn’t handle anyone!
Hafeez was from his agency. They were both represented by Moghees. Yousuf never played under Misbah and found it an insult to be compared to him. Younis Khan has had public/dressing room spats with Misbah and was once about to lose his temper at some tv host comparing him to Misbah. Shahid Afridi may have been respectful towards him on his face but we saw how his own daughter publicly disgraced him for his slow, rubbish batting against India. Shoaib Akhtar didn’t cross paths with him as a skipper but the way he tore him to shreds for his rubbish captaincy and strategy in the 2015 World Cup is for all to see. Malik and him seem to get along fine. Malik brought him in instead of Yousuf for the 2007 T20 World Cup and that’s where he gained some fame…and Misbah backed him at a time when Malik was ostracised and hated by quite a few players in the Pakistan team. He may also be from Misbah’s agency but I’m not sure about this.
Care to highlight those differences?Him and Misbah had their differences but both tried to hide them from the public.
No youReally you're bringing in Shahid Afridi's daughter as a cricket expert?
I swear that’s how you people treat Rizwan??Uptil 2008, fans treated Younis (in odi) like how they treated players like M. Harris or Haider Ali, where they would say that dont worry Younis will perform and eventually Younis would perform on the flatest of wickets, especially if we were playing against Sri Lanka or a minnow team
Thread is about YK the ‘proper ODI batter’I swear that’s how you people treat Rizwan??
Pot calling the kettle black is a culture it seems
The top tier chachas of this forum.Avg around 32 , SR 75, 6 100s in 250+ games , the guy was a proper ODI batsman just because a deluded gang thinks so
I have a challenge for you. If you can meet the challenge I will join you in this anti RizBar journey.The thread isn’t about your double standards either.
You don’t have an issue with a poster claiming YK fans were treating him like Haider Ali when it’s the same people doing it for Rizwan.
Next time, do not tell me what the thread is and isn’t about. Tere abbey ka forum nahi hai! The mods will do their job. Know your role, and stay in your Lane. Got it?
Avg around 32 , SR 75, 6 100s in 250+ games , the guy was a proper ODI batsman just because a deluded gang thinks so
Was a proper ODI batter though, as per some.YK was a Test legend.
He wasn't that great in ODI.
Was a proper ODI batter though, as per some.
Yes and whatever success Pakistan had in ODIs had nothing to do with YK.During those days, Pakistan had Inzi, Mohammad Yousuf etc.
YK wasn't the main batter.
Here was a typical Pakistani ODI XI at that time:
Afridi
Salman Butt
Inzi
Yousuf
YK
Shoaib Malik
Kamran Akmal
4 bowlers.
What about Zaheer Abbas , Miandad , Malik played together ?Of course I am. We work as a unit. You want to discuss the importance of a player in a format, these factors always matter.
I argue again, the middle order of YK, MoYo and Inzimam is the STRONGEST ever middle order in Pakistan’s 50 over history.
Prove me wrong. Tell me a stronger middle order that Pakistan has played that was appropriate to the era it featured in.
He has 7249 runs @31.24 with strike rate of 75.Your chachu Rana claimed YK to be a proper ODI batter. Be brave and either agree to his claim or disagree. Dont sit on the fence.
And by the way dont use <><><><>vs<><><> as it will not add any value.
Of course I am. We work as a unit. You want to discuss the importance of a player in a format, these factors always matter.
I argue again, the middle order of YK, MoYo and Inzimam is the STRONGEST ever middle order in Pakistan’s 50 over history.
Prove me wrong. Tell me a stronger middle order that Pakistan has played that was appropriate to the era it featured in.
I think Pakistan had a better middle order in the 90's.
This was a typical Pakistan's XI in the 90's:
Saeed Anwar
Aamir Sohail
Ijaz Ahmed
Inzamam
Azhar Mahmood
Moin Khan
Shahid Afridi
Wasim
Waqar
Saqlain
Shoaib Akthar
YK debuted in 2000. So, he wasn't a part of that legendary 90's side.
This XI is not possible , you have packed it with bowlers. Just four specialist batters.I think Pakistan had a better middle order in the 90's.
This was a typical Pakistan's XI in the 90's:
Saeed Anwar
Aamir Sohail
Ijaz Ahmed
Inzamam
Azhar Mahmood
Moin Khan
Shahid Afridi
Wasim
Waqar
Saqlain
Shoaib Akthar
YK debuted in 2000. So, he wasn't a part of that legendary 90's side.
This XI is not possible , you have packed it with bowlers. Just four specialist batters.
What number did Abbas bat?What about Zaheer Abbas , Miandad , Malik played together ?
really? Who was the top scorer in England v Pak 2006 ODI series in England?Uptil 2008, fans treated Younis (in odi) like how they treated players like M. Harris or Haider Ali, where they would say that dont worry Younis will perform and eventually Younis would perform on the flatest of wickets, especially if we were playing against Sri Lanka or a minnow team.
Loved Moyo’s reaction to Misbah comparison and I was so glad Younis clarified it on that show.Yousuf never played under Misbah and found it an insult to be compared to him. Younis Khan has had public/dressing room spats with Misbah and was once about to lose his temper at some tv host comparing him to Misbah.
Malik, Yousuf and Inzi was strongerOf course I am. We work as a unit. You want to discuss the importance of a player in a format, these factors always matter.
I argue again, the middle order of YK, MoYo and Inzimam is the STRONGEST ever middle order in Pakistan’s 50 over history.
Prove me wrong. Tell me a stronger middle order that Pakistan has played that was appropriate to the era it featured in.
Bunch of lunatics lol.Avg around 32 , SR 75, 6 100s in 250+ games , the guy was a proper ODI batsman just because a deluded gang thinks so
Exactly. Just like how the current failiures Haider Ali.Was a below average player in this format.
After every good test knock/series of him you believed he will do well also in ODI's. But that really never happened.
Moreover, he also underperformed in some very crucial matches.
Younis had this habit of rona dhona since his earlier days, but many of us did not see it.Mohammed Yousuf, Shoaib Akhtar and Younis Khan fell out with multiple players during their days as players and as pundits. Yousuf was bitter that he was dropped from WT20 for Misbah. Shoaib pretty much accuses the whole of Pakistan of lack of jazba apart from him, Wasim, Waqar.
Younis was annoyed by some of the comparisons. As a player he should have been getting compared with MIandad but his name became intertwined with Misbah. But we should note that it's the same Younis Khan who feels disrespected everywhere he goes, gets into fights with comedians on TV because he doesn't feel respected as a senior player, and has been accused of putting a knife to the throat of a coach.
They are not saints, has anyone really handled them?
Rana doesn't think like people that have been watching cricket for a long time. He doesn't think Babar is a good player and thinks Asif Ali should be Captain.Agreed. But who can convince @Rana who thinks YK was a proper ODI batter.
yes but i think you missing a specialist batter somewhere . In 1999 Salim Malik or Yusuf would come in , and waqar will not be there.What? Afridi and Azhar Mahmood were batting all-rounders during the 90's.
Afridi used to open batting.
Azhar scored 2 Test centuries in South Africa.
What number did Abbas bat?
yes but i think you missing a specialist batter somewhere . In 1999 Salim Malik or Yusuf would come in , and waqar will not be there.
One of your best cricket related post in a long time !
Naa, it’s pretty much how much I value your input.One of your best cricket related post in a long time !
I gave you no input. I gave my input related to the thread. People can agree or disagree, no worry.Naa, it’s pretty much how much I value your input.
The team you wrote was very simillar to what pakistan played in 199 WC. Mahmood is a very underrated player. Should have played more.I was referring to 1990's in general. You can say a rough estimation.
Those players I mentioned were regulars in the 1990's but there were other players too. For example, Pakistan often rotated between Rashid Latif and Moin Khan. Among pacers, there were Mohammad Akram, Wasim Akram, Waqar, Aaqib Javed, Azhar Mahmood, Abdul Razzaq, Shoaib Akthar etc.
Did Zaheer, Miandad and Saleem Malik regularly bat together at 3-5?First down.
He's very self centred man he has a big ego.Younis Khan thought he should had been sold for money compared to KP and Flintoff loll
Thats a proper performance by a proper ODI batter.People here are underestimating how bad an odi batsman Younis Khan was. It was criminal he managed to play that much.
His Overall stats are quite bad but they don't even tell half the story.
His average/SR combo vs some good teams :
Australia : 16/57
England : 26/71
New Zealand : 27/70
South Africa : 26/67
West Indies : 27/66
That's an Overall 125 innings.
Nice to hear that but I would rather YK was a bad guy on and off the field with some opposition killing performances.He's very self centred man he has a big ego.
But I tell you what. To fans he is always decent and respectful, happy to take pictures and chat, discuss with kids, laughs and jokes.
Probably the nicest player I've met and I've met and chatted to most of the old lot.
Guys like Afridi, Yousuf, and especially Inzi didn't give fans the time of day.
Younis and Umar gul top men when it comes to fans.
YK‘s career sr spanned from 2000-2015YK’s undue insistence on being included in 2015 wc squad and opening ultimately hurt his legacy. His SR of 75 is not good by any means but not as bad as it looks now either.
Based on my research listening to his interviews, he carried a lot of frustration. A feeling of being unjustly treated by PCB over the years. That built up and eventually made him act in the way he did vis-à-vis his ODI inclusion.
For me his low ODI average is the more disappointing aspect than his lowish SR in the format.