Imran Khan vs MS Dhoni vs Ricky Ponting - Who is the better leader?

[Itachi]

Ohh.. you don't count CT as a cup.. but teams participating in that did.. or they also took it lightly ? India won the WC in Eng and home both..so not sure what you mean by tiger at home.. and in 96, SL in SF beat us or in finals, Aus would have beaten us...

How you came to conclusion that Aus would have beaten us? In SF, '96, SL got walk over.

How did you arrive at 50% figure for Dhoni while batting first ? In WC SF, he batted first and beat Pak.. in QF, he did not contribute with the bat.. in fact apart from final he didn't play well at all.. it was his captaincy which put India through.

again missing the point. Dhoni, the player has nothing to do with Dhoni, the leader. Otherwise Tendu should haven been the greatest leader of all time. But he was the worst.

Ashish Nehra/Munaf Patel/Sreesanth/Piyush Chawla/Yuvraj/Raina as bowlers.. you just look at the list to appreciate the meaning of limited

What bowler afridi had in disposal except ajmal? (I am not even talking about batting here....) Afridis resources were 1/2 times than Dhoni

....

 

[vicky_iisc]

How you came to conclusion that Aus would have beaten us? In SF, '96, SL got walk over.

Because they also beat us in the league game.. honestly India had a pathetic side with only one great batsman and other bits and pieces performers. Before SL got walk over, India was 120-8 chasing 250, you are telling me, last two wickets would have fought ?


again missing the point. Dhoni, the player has nothing to do with Dhoni, the leader. Otherwise Tendu should haven been the greatest leader of all time. But he was the worst.

When I say Dhoni batted first, it means his team.. not he in particular.


What bowler afridi had in disposal except ajmal? (I am not even talking about batting here....) Afridis resources were 1/2 times than Dhoni

Dhoni didn't even have a bowler of ajmal's class..and I heard Mohali SF was called battle b/w Indian batting and Pak bowling ? You are telling that Pak bowling resources were 1/2 of India?

 

[Strike Rate]

Is this comparison based on odi or tests also?

 

[Abdullah719]

 

[Hasan123]

MSD is the best leader out of these 3.