What's new

India v Pakistan | 4th ODI | Gwalior | 15/11/07 [Pak Inngs]

Status
Not open for further replies.
the ball pitched outside the line of the wkts and then hit very marginally in-line of the off stump. Under this circumstance the doubt should be given to the batsman.
There are many not out decisions where the ball is shown to go hit the stumps but it is still not out. You go figure
 
rahulrulezz said:
Hawkeye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.
Click to expand...
Hawkeye doesn (cannot) factor in whether the ball hit the pad outside the line or whether the batsman was 10 yards down the pitch etc.
 
Two decent commentators (only 2 available in the series) on air at the moment ... Aamir Sohail is a very good analyser of the game and more importantly communicates it in the right way to the audience ...
 
rahulrulezz said:
Hawkeye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.
Click to expand...
Hawkeye showed the ball would have hit the stumps. Does hawkeye show where the ball hit the batsman. No! What the hell is wrong with you? Is this your first time watching a match?
 
placement is good

wow. I didn't think it was that good. Crowd has gone quiet.
 
What a gloriously timed shot through the covers from Moyo - for 4

Effortless!
 
As per usual Noddy bhais analysis is spot on!

You should be in commentary box instead of rameez raja :)
 
All you Afridi fanboys stop whining about how Afridi was unjustly given out, he played a frikin stupid shot to get off the mark, that as swipe thought he was playing the fiftieth over the game with a shot like that, when it was only the 31st over. That kind of premeditated shot at that stage of the innings is just appalling, and he got served for playing such a ridiculous shot. Quit blaming the umpires and get on with it.
 
Afridi is a hit n miss batsman who will play one good innings in 10 matches. why on earth the management send this retard before Misbah when there were 20 overs left.
 
Moyo is starting to show his class with his timing and placement.
we need these kind of 4s every over
 
Oxy said:
Nodderick - even the shot to get off the mark was a dodgy, cross bat effort that could have bowled him.

He had 20 overs!!! 20 overs!!
Click to expand...
Who wants to play 20 overs! All Afridi fans want him to score 9 of 6 balls including a massive six, that would be pure entertainment, who wants to build an innings?
 
Good running fdrom Moyo - put pressure on Teendu who misfields

2 moe

159-4
 
iafzal said:
the ball pitched outside the line of the wkts and then hit very marginally in-line of the off stump. Under this circumstance the doubt should be given to the batsman.
There are many not out decisions where the ball is shown to go hit the stumps but it is still not out. You go figure
Click to expand...
Keep crying.. did it hit in line? Yes.. Was it hissting the stumps.. Ohh Sure.. was height an issue, absolutely not.. what does Hawk eye say.. OUT.
 
iafzal said:
the ball pitched outside the line of the wkts and then hit very marginally in-line of the off stump. Under this circumstance the doubt should be given to the batsman.
There are many not out decisions where the ball is shown to go hit the stumps but it is still not out. You go figure
Click to expand...


Yousuf had 3 close calls all hitting around middle stump in the second match. None of them given by Gould. Marginal calls can go either way. Playing across the line will always get severe punishment as you use pad a second line of defense to play your shot which won't be viewed by umpire kindly.
 
Last over by the 5th bowling option ... COMON Ganguly ... dont give more than 12 runs now :-(
 
LightSpeedGT said:
Hawkeye showed the ball would have hit the stumps. Does hawkeye show where the ball hit the batsman. No! What the hell is wrong with you? Is this your first time watching a match?
Click to expand...

I guess u didnt hear me..

HawkEye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.

P.S. Stop whining dude
 
Moyo's timing is simply amazing, and how can it not be, he is in top five.
 
nedian21 said:
Afridi is a hit n miss batsman who will play one good innings in 10 matches. why on earth the management send this retard before Misbah when there were 20 overs left.
Click to expand...
Yea I questioned that too. I guess they were hoping he'd play a 200 SR or a 1st odi type 75.
 
Misbah is a far better batsman than Afridi. The positive thing here is that we have a better batsman at the crease. Still a couple of batsman to come who are capable of hitting big.....Kamran and Tanvir. 250+ is still very possible. May not be enough but will give us a fighting chance.
 
rahulrulezz said:
Hawkeye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.
Click to expand...

When it hits outside the line of off stump it doesn't matter if it's going on to hit the wicket.

Still, this was always going to happen (Indian umpire).

I still blame Afridi... He's an idiot.
 
Hash said:
Misbah is a far better batsman than Afridi. The positive thing here is that we have a better batsman at the crease. Still a couple of batsman to come who are capable of hitting big.....Kamran and Tanvir. 250+ is still very possible. May not be enough but will give us a fighting chance.
Click to expand...

yup i completly agree. alot is possible. lets hope we can pull this one out. inshallah
 
nedian21 said:
Afridi is a hit n miss batsman who will play one good innings in 10 matches. why on earth the management send this retard before Misbah when there were 20 overs left.
Click to expand...
It was a good idea as India were bowling their fifth bowler. Just didn't come off. But a good tactical move nonetheless. And hindsight is a great thing, isn't it?
 
iZeeshan said:
Yea I questioned that too. I guess they were hoping he'd play a 200 SR or a 1st odi type 75.
Click to expand...


Some one had started a thread "how to take pressure off afridi" So they are trying by sending him at different positions :))
 
10 overs ... 2 for 52 ... is a great effort by the part timers ... Now, its upto the regular bowlers to keep their lines and lengths and end the innings on a good note ...
 
It's not a bad bowling wicket to be honest. Quite sluggish. Playing Afridi on this track will be difficult.

I'm worried about Rao Saab though... He might get plundered if he doesn't bowl intelligently
 
guys afridi is out simple !
the way he is playing these days he can get out every moment. with respect to ganguly but getting out to him ? ? ?

İ can understand malik he might have hoped that afridi will ckick anyways i hope misbah plays a good knock because he is a very good player !
 
JosheelaKaptan said:
Keep crying.. did it hit in line? Yes.. Was it hissting the stumps.. Ohh Sure.. was height an issue, absolutely not.. what does Hawk eye say.. OUT.
Click to expand...
If you are not able to understand what I am saying then please says so it is ok I will understand
 
rahulrulezz said:
I guess u didnt hear me..

HawkEye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.

P.S. Stop whining dude
Click to expand...
Am not whining. Just stating rules of the game which you obviously are not aware of. Try to use your head more rather than ummm...hawkeye this and that...blah blah. I'm sure you're smarter than that.

Pak need 270 min to win.
 
10 overs 51/2 by part timers.. excellent effort.. on a batting beauty.. wow..
Couldnt have asked for more..
This pitch is quickening up a bit.. now
 
There are no ifs and buts in cricket! Stop crying over whatever has happened, whether it was in line or outside the line is not a point of discussion, so move on to the game
 
I reckon we should bowl Akhtar in 3 shortish spells 4-overs to open, then 2-3 in the middle to get rid off - probably Dhoni and Yuvi - The na few towards the death with Gul
 
LightSpeedGT said:
It was a good idea as India were bowling their fifth bowler. Just didn't come off. But a good tactical move nonetheless. And hindsight is a great thing, isn't it?
Click to expand...

with Afridi all tactics and intelligence goes down the drain
 
rahulrulezz said:
Hawkeye showed that he was plumb out. End of discussion.
Click to expand...

Ummmnn, are you even aware of a little requirement that the ball has to hit the pad inline with the stumps before you can consider if it was going to hit or not. The replay showed that ball hit the pad 3-4 inches outside the line of the off-stump and about 3 meters away from them. Anyone who thinks that was in line has not really seen it well. Whatever your bias is, you should at least know the definition of the phrase "plumb out."
 
India have 7 batsman and Pathan.. 270 isnt much considering the dew thing.. In dewy conditions, I havent seen people defending even 300 in India in this last decade.. almost all the time chasing side has won.. so Pakistan is to stop india from Taking series today, they have to go blazing now..
 
Pak's inability to put away Indian spin bowlers has been our undoing...
 
Pak 178/4 after 40 overs

we need atleast 85-90 runs in last 10 overs here!
 
i think misbah is doing well giving strike to moyo for now. he can wait a bit longer and give him support. then he can start hitting out
 
Misbah is playing a very effecient inning. 19 from 19 balls with only 2 4s.
Not too many dot balls. Moyo after 75 balls still wasting a few
 
OXY

our sunday in front of the TV hanging in the balance. Can already see Mrs Oxy lining up the DIY if we lose the series today
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Oxy
  • Locked
India v Pakistan | 4th ODI | Gwalior | 15/11/07 [Ind Inngs]
5 6 7
Replies
528
Views
21K
JammydodgA
JammydodgA
E
  • Locked
India v Pakistan | 2nd ODI | Mohali | 8/11/07 [Ind Inngs]
8 9 10
Replies
731
Views
25K
Safar55
S
Back
Top