What's new

Is Ajinkya Rahane's ODI career over?

razabbas

ODI Debutant
Joined
May 9, 2013
Runs
9,115
India have an awesome bench strength when it comes to batting so i think he will be replaced by any decent batsman.

Just like pujara now their will be a tag on Rahane "Only Test player"

Rahane was doing quite good as an opener , rohit should have come at 5th spot IMO
 
The intent was pathetic tbh he must have learn something from elloit and anderson

Today he just batted like our batsman

Anderson and Elliot were batting with 5rpo needed and less runs. If rahane batted aggressively and got out he'd be called irreponsible.

Kohli Sharma and raina bottled this. He was bringing them back nicely with MS the designated hitter.
 
Anderson and Elliot were batting with 5rpo needed and less runs. If rahane batted aggressively and got out he'd be called irreponsible.

Kohli Sharma and raina bottled this. He was bringing them back nicely with MS the designated hitter.

he was just going nowhere with his batting chasing 330 and batting with a SR of 60 is just not acceptable
 
This is the guy that Misbah wouldn't have been able to replace? Yeah, right.
 
Always maintained that Pujara, Vijay and Rahane should be test specialists.
 
Rahane is a superb player, but like I always said, middle order is not the position for him.

He has to open for India in ODIs, because of course he can't bat at 3.

One of Rohit/Dhawan will have to be dropped to accommodate Rahane.
 
He shouldn't play in the middle but open for India. Play Rohit at 3 and Kohli at 4.
 
Depends on this year's ipl tbh. If rahane doesnt perform there i can see him being dropped ( & he should be imo ).
 
India have an awesome bench strength when it comes to batting so i think he will be replaced by any decent batsman.

Just like pujara now their will be a tag on Rahane "Only Test player"

Rahane was doing quite good as an opener , rohit should have come at 5th spot IMO
Sharma will always open , he is like Sehwag , will not always click . When he does , he will get you to winning positions.
 
Dhoni : [Players improved?] Rahane is one, right through the Tests, ODIs, he's improved his batting a lot.
 
He is not going anywhere.
How many matches did Rohit get before he became successful in the ODIs?
 
This is one of the funniest thread I have ever seen on PP :)))

There is nothing funny about this thread. India have a great bench strength when it comes to batting Rahane is more suitable for opening position then 4th spot.
 
There is nothing funny about this thread. India have a great bench strength when it comes to batting Rahane is more suitable for opening position then 4th spot.

Dont think our selectors will make too many changes in the team. Maybe Jadeja will get dropped, Dhoni will be rested for some series if he doesn't retire. Rahane will continue to get chances under Kohli and will turn the corner as an ODI batsman as well.
 
Dont think our selectors will make too many changes in the team. Maybe Jadeja will get dropped, Dhoni will be rested for some series if he doesn't retire. Rahane will continue to get chances under Kohli and will turn the corner as an ODI batsman as well.

There is no doubt about rahane's talent but the standard India have set is too high they can easily find a replacement of rahane or Rahane should open and rohit should come in middle order IMO.

Rahane stats as an opener is quite exceptional
 
Dont think our selectors will make too many changes in the team. Maybe Jadeja will get dropped, Dhoni will be rested for some series if he doesn't retire. Rahane will continue to get chances under Kohli and will turn the corner as an ODI batsman as well.

Nope sir will stay & rahane will be dropped if he fails in the ipl.
 
yIf ou had paid attention to how Indians groom their batsmen, you won't start such threads. Look at hoe many chances they gave to Rohit dude. Look at how they stuck to Dhawan despite being in poor form for the last 6 months.

Rahane is too classy a player to not play for Indians in future in ODI. He has already played some gems in Tests at good clip and he did play a gem against SA in this WC itself.
 
yIf ou had paid attention to how Indians groom their batsmen, you won't start such threads. Look at hoe many chances they gave to Rohit dude. Look at how they stuck to Dhawan despite being in poor form for the last 6 months.

Rahane is too classy a player to not play for Indians in future in ODI. He has already played some gems in Tests at good clip and he did play a gem against SA in this WC itself.

In odis you need to hit boundaries at will without taking risks & keep scoreboard moving.

Rahane lacks that skill. He can hardly hit the ball over the 30yard circle on his best day & cant even work the fields.

No-hit was different. He could hit boundaries & sixes. His main issue was always lack of temparament & consistency..
 
It's not over but there are probably better options at that position. Kedar Jadhav is one name in particular that comes in mind. Rahane has been persisted with moatly because of his excellent fielding and that he's a hardbworker, and has been trying to improve on his ODI game. I just think he's a better top order bat than a middle order bat.

I'd like to see Jadhav get a longer rope now.
 
In odis you need to hit boundaries at will without taking risks & keep scoreboard moving.

Rahane lacks that skill. He can hardly hit the ball over the 30yard circle on his best day & cant even work the fields.

No-hit was different. He could hit boundaries & sixes. His main issue was always lack of temparament & consistency..

I think he will come good. Early days for him. I feel he looks very unsettled when comes out to bat. This fellow has played some gutsy knocks in Test and looking at his range of shots, I don't see why he can't do well in ODI. He needs to settle down a bit. He is not going to be a power hitter but he has enough range to do well even in ODI. I rate him as the best current Asian batsman in non-Asian conditions in tests right now so I may be bit biased here.
 
One failure and it's over for him? Lol.

He is a fantastic player and will prove his worth in time. He showed his quality against SA this very WC. Having said that, Rayudu is perhaps a more natural option for the position Rahane is being sent in. I haven't seen him much, but I think Rayadu is better equipped to deal with difficult pressure situations.
 
Can't believe this thread. Rahane is probably the best batsman in India right now. Technically sound, plays spin and pace well. Only batsman from India who did well in NZ, England, Oz and South Africa.

He needs to be persisted with.
 
I think he will come good. Early days for him. I feel he looks very unsettled when comes out to bat. This fellow has played some gutsy knocks in Test and looking at his range of shots, I don't see why he can't do well in ODI. He needs to settle down a bit. He is not going to be a power hitter but he has enough range to do well even in ODI. I rate him as the best current Asian batsman in non-Asian conditions in tests right now so I may be bit biased here.

He is has performed great in tests so far no doubt. But when setting / chasing a total of 300+ you cant have players with sr < 80.

Imo this years ipl is important for him. He needs to show the selectors his range of shots & the mental strenght.
This will buy him some more time in the national team so he can re-establish.

If he doesnt show significant improvement in the ipl he is living on borrowed time & his future may well be in the hands of the selectors.
 
Jadhav Tiwary are better ODI players.

Jadhav should be in our ODI team.

Explosive lower order guy who we desperately need.

Not convinced about Tiwari.

Never get the feeling he has the game to make it work in international cricket.

Do you think he is good stats aside?
 
World cup is over.. time to experiment a lot... slot in sanju Samsung as batsman and kuldeep yadav as spinner ..

Rest ashwin,jadeja, etc

Time to move on to young breed
 
Great player, I like him. Should be persisted with. Better suited for the opener's role, IMO.
 
Probably.

His List A average is 35, compared to FC average of 58 (well over 60 excluding Test). I think, he doesn't like the format. Going forward, I think best solution for IND is to drop Rahane from ODI, play MSD as specialist bat at 5 (& Captain) & select a good WK batsman to bat at 6, while Raina can bat at 4.
 
If you are done with him, send him over here.

But honestly, should bat at 3. His style more conducive to that position. Can't bat lower than 4 cause he is not a power player. At same time though, your best bat should be at 4. Kohli is more able to bat at 4 cause he can consolidate or accelerate.
 
He needs to sit out for a while and others like Pandey, Uthhapa etc should be given a chance. Or may be just may be get Gambhir back ;)
 
God knows why he was selected for India A that too as captain

Vihari 92 (83)
Iyer 65 (47)

Rahane 91 (117) :amla

Rahane shouldn't be allowed in a 1,000 km radius of India/ India A ODI team
 
God knows why he was selected for India A that too as captain

Vihari 92 (83)
Iyer 65 (47)

Rahane 91 (117) :amla

Rahane shouldn't be allowed in a 1,000 km radius of India/ India A ODI team

He is selected as the designated driver of the group.

Iyer should have been captain. Even Kishan is very good captain.
 
Rahane's LoI career should not have started in the first place. He lost India last WT20 almost single handedly.

In ODIs, except for those 2 innings, 1 in Eng and 1 in WC'15 against SA, he has done next to nothing. Now even in test cricket, he is faltering.
 
God knows why he was selected for India A that too as captain

Vihari 92 (83)
Iyer 65 (47)

Rahane 91 (117) :amla

Rahane shouldn't be allowed in a 1,000 km radius of India/ India A ODI team

It's ok you need one experienced international who can guide these kids around.. he should play more like a mentor.. For India A or U-19 players seeing a well established international player prepare for a match is a big learning deal.. Cricket is not just played on the ground it's played as much off the ground as on the ground.

This is the reason why IPL is very important as it allows kids to share dressing room with superstars and learn from them and get confidence.


As long as it's only 1 player and rest are new youngsters it's ok. Problem would have been if there were 10 players in India A like Rahane and only 1 youngster..
 
It's ok you need one experienced international who can guide these kids around.. he should play more like a mentor.. For India A or U-19 players seeing a well established international player prepare for a match is a big learning deal.. Cricket is not just played on the ground it's played as much off the ground as on the ground.

This is the reason why IPL is very important as it allows kids to share dressing room with superstars and learn from them and get confidence.


As long as it's only 1 player and rest are new youngsters it's ok. Problem would have been if there were 10 players in India A like Rahane and only 1 youngster..

I get what you are saying. However, I would still not want Rahane as the captain, nor as opener. If he has to groom players he can do that preferably sitting in the dug out or batting in the middle order.

More over, I don't trust his ODI game awareness and would not want any youngster to imbibe his ODI acumen.
 
Fail thread. Rahane is as classy as they come. He is here to stay.

i have to disagree with you , i think jinx is done with odis, gill will take that spot in the middle order very soon. While jinx is classy, hes been given tons of chances and not made it his own in odis
 
I get what you are saying. However, I would still not want Rahane as the captain, nor as opener. If he has to groom players he can do that preferably sitting in the dug out or batting in the middle order.

More over, I don't trust his ODI game awareness and would not want any youngster to imbibe his ODI acumen.

He might be grooming youngsters for captaincy.. At the end of the day as long as he involved juniors in decision making they will learn and can give their views which will only make them stronger in decision making.

Regarding other points I suppose it would have been better if he doesn't play all matches and acts more off a mentor than the main batsmen..

Anyways point I was trying to make was that it's not as big a deal, there are still some positives with him being in A team.
 
Before the AUS series he declared in an interview that he will play the WC. He also claimed to be a very aggressive batsman. There is a denial mode and then there is a Rahane mode.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
He is not built for modern power game. Not good enough for India level.
Sad because he is an excellent fielder and seems to be a very good team man
 
Still don't get why Iyer keeps being ignored while average batsmen like Karthik and Rayadu are selected.
 
He is not built for modern power game. Not good enough for India level.
Sad because he is an excellent fielder and seems to be a very good team man

Not good enough for any team. Avg of 35 at 78 SR are just pathetic numbers.
 
Just not good enough for modern ODI cricket. All of India's batsman have the ablity to play at a good strike rate but Rahane can't.
 
I remember Rahane scoring a IPL century at 200 strike rate, thrashed a red hot SA bowling attack in 2015 WC clearing MCG boundaries with ease, not sure what went wrong after that.
 
Lack of acceleration skills. What he does is he starts briskly. Then he will get slower and slower as the match goes on.
 
time to move on from him. 78 strikerate batsman is not acceptable for today's 50 over cricket.
With shaw,gill,iyer,pant are already in waiting line no chance of rahane making comeback in odi squad.
He should focus more on test cricket from now on.
 
For Ajinkya Rahane, the 2020 Indian Premier League (IPL) will be a new start. Captain of Rajasthan Royals for major part of the 2019 edition, Rahane was traded to Delhi Capitals for two spinners. It came after a long hiatus from limited-over cricket that saw him missing last year’s World Cup in England. Rahane’s last ODI was in February, 2018. But as another edition of IPL beckons, Rahane fancies his chances of a return to the limited overs team.

“I am hopeful of making a comeback in white ball cricket. If you see my record before getting dropped in ODIs, it was really good actually. People talk about strike rate and averages. Before getting dropped from 50-over cricket, it was really good. I have faith in myself rather than what people are saying,” said Rahane, in a Zoom call from Dubai.

Rahane opened for Rajasthan Royals but at Delhi Capitals there will be competition for that slot. The Capitals have a power-packed opening combo in Shikhar Dhawan and Prithvi Shaw. They also have in their ranks Jason Roy and Shimron Hetmyer. “We are still in quarantine, so I don’t know what role I am going to play. Once training starts and the communication within the group happen, we will be aware. I have enjoyed opening the batting but it’s up to the team management,” said Rahane, 32.

“If there is a situation where I have to bat at No. 5 and 6, I will do it. That way I can explore a new aspect about my game. Once the role is clear it will help. You need at least need five to six sessions to settle in depending on where in the batting order you are.”

Capitals coach Ricky Ponting joined the team on Thursday. The Capitals will have their first training session on Saturday.

“Playing under Ricky Ponting, I am excited. It is the best opportunity to take my game one step forward. We all know him as a player. Obviously, this time due to the Covid rules, the interactions may not happen that much but I can always call him. I have been following Delhi Capitals since the last two years. We have a fantastic bunch of players. Looking forward to play with them,” he said.

“Once I was back from the New Zealand series in February, I started preparing for the IPL. But then the lockdown happened. We did not know when cricket will start again. I used that time to be with my daughter Arya.

“I have not batted for five to six months. I was only doing visualisation, meditation but no cricketing skills. I think the attitude and work ethics will be really important this time. Also, discipline and following all the rules on and off the field is going to be a challenge.”

https://www.hindustantimes.com/cric...nkya-rahane/story-x7rmBlX521HRa9p1xq6tiM.html
 
He's not a post-2010s ODI player. Doesn't have the dynamism in his game to make a good ODI team these days.

Basically a rich man's Mohammad Kaif.

Actually he should take a leaf out of Pujara's book and get a county contract.
 
Not sure how good a test player is he let alone ODIs.

Azhar Ali level?
 
Rahane is a superb player, but like I always said, middle order is not the position for him.

He has to open for India in ODIs, because of course he can't bat at 3.

One of Rohit/Dhawan will have to be dropped to accommodate Rahane.

Haha good one. "India should drop Sharma/Dhawan for Rahane in ODI'S"

The usual overrating of average indian players.
 
Rahane should be kept at a arm's length from our limited overs' teams. We already have too many tuk tukers in our LoI setup.

In fact he needs to do all he can to save his test spot.
 
Back
Top