What's new

Is Rohit Sharma the greatest captain of all time in T20Is?

Is Rohit Sharma the Greatest T20I Captain ever

  • Yes

    Votes: 10 58.8%
  • No

    Votes: 7 41.2%

  • Total voters
    17

Sir Alex

Tape Ball Captain
Joined
May 6, 2010
Runs
1,169
Is Rohit Sharma the Greatest Captain of All Time?

In 62 T20Is he has captained India, he has led them to wins in 50 matches.

He is the first and only Captain to record half century of wins in the shortest format. But what makes his record truly stupendous is that his win Loss ratio of 4.17 is unmatched by anyone (except those who have played vs associate teams mostly - Afg before being made test nation).

He has also rounded off his epic captaincy career with a World cup win.

1000206210.jpg
 
Rohit is very good but he has a plethora of resources.

I still think what Sammy did was better.

But rohit is defo a top tier captain. He's extremely underrated and at times overhated by his fans
 
before this tournament he also reached the semi final in 2022.
Babar reached in semi-final and final in 2 consecutive years but no one rates him high.

But yes. Rohit has dominated overall. His record is unmatched and the trophy is icing on the cake.

Darren Sammy was also a beast in WCs because windies are always a team you should be afraid of in limited over format.
 
Even in ODIs he has decent captaincy record

Top 10 with W/L ratio (minimum of 10 ODIs) in the order of W/L ratio

Warne has won 10 out of 11 ODIs captained
Botha 8 out of 10
Cummins 12 out of 15
Lloyd 64 out of 84
Rohit 34 out of 45
Ponting 165 out of 230
Gilly 12 out of 17
Cronje 99 out of 138
Faf 28 out of 39
Kohli 65 out of 95

Having said that he has committed some blunders in some matches.
 
Babar reached in semi-final and final in 2 consecutive years but no one rates him high.

But yes. Rohit has dominated overall. His record is unmatched and the trophy is icing on the cake.

Darren Sammy was also a beast in WCs because windies are always a team you should be afraid of in limited over format.
Babar in 2021 wasn't that bad when it came to his own performance and his sticking to the formula strategy worked until Australia disrupted it and exposed the fact that Babar is clueless once his sticking to the formula strategy fails as his one tactic won't work every game.

2022 was mostly luck but 2021 wasn't that bad. Infact it's his best stint as captain.

People forget that Babar has deteriorated and lost form in everything from fitness to fielding to batting to captaincy.

They have forgotten his earlier free flow performance and think he was always trash when his decline started in 2022.
 
Babar in 2021 wasn't that bad when it came to his own performance and his sticking to the formula strategy worked until Australia disrupted it and exposed the fact that Babar is clueless once his sticking to the formula strategy fails as his one tactic won't work every game.

2022 was mostly luck but 2021 wasn't that bad. Infact it's his best stint as captain.

People forget that Babar has deteriorated and lost form in everything from fitness to fielding to batting to captaincy.

They have forgotten his earlier free flow performance and think he was always trash when his decline started in 2022.
Babar won nothing. 0 ICC trophies while time and time again (in T20) it was their for the taking.

Batting wise he has been a joke for a good 2 years now.
 
Babar won 2017 CT. He was in the XI in that final (CT 2017 final).
With all due respect, CT is not WC. Plus Babar cannot ride on the coattails of that solitary win forever. He has been extremely mediocre in the last few years, especially considering these should have been his prime years and his performance will only go down from here.
 
Babar won nothing. 0 ICC trophies while time and time again (in T20) it was their for the taking.

Batting wise he has been a joke for a good 2 years now.
I said the exact same thing so idk why you're oversimplifying what I said
 
Only stats can't define legacy. Asghar Afghan have even better stats than Rohit.
I personally rate Dhoni as the best ever limited overs captain.
 
LOL at "highly competitive franchise cricket".

When it comes to T20, only World T20 matters.

Darren Sammy is the best T20 captain of all time. 2 World T20 trophies as a captain.

Samuels played 2 clutch final knocks. No one says he is a better batsman than Kohli, Warner.

Dhoni won WT20 and Asia cup (T20 format)
Rohit won WT20 and Nidihaas and has a stellar bilateral record.

On top of that IPL is tougher than world cups where we don’t have minnow teams like Bangladesh etc, so I rate winning it higher.

So yes. Maybe Sammy a close 2nd, I will not debate it.
 
‘On par with Dhoni’: Shastri’s big call on Rohit Sharma as captain

Ravi Shastri has lauded Rohit Sharma as ‘one of the all-time greats’ and believes his captaincy is at least on par with India great MS Dhoni.

Rohit Sharma’s stint as India’s T20I skipper was a memorable one. He overtook Dhoni as the most successful T20I captain with 49 wins in 62 matches. Dhoni had 41 victories from 72 games.

Shastri places the two on equal footing, calling Rohit ‘one of the best captains ever alongside Dhoni’ with both showing great tactical acumen in white-ball cricket.

“As a tactician, let's not forget that he's been an outstanding guy. He'll go down as one of the best captains ever alongside Dhoni,” Shastri said on the latest episode of The ICC Review.

“If you ask me who's better, I'd say both are on par when it comes to tactics in the white-ball game. I can't pay a bigger compliment to Rohit than that because you know what MS has done and the titles he has won.”

Rohit captained India to their first T20 World Cup title since 2007 in Barbados in June, where India were unbeaten in the whole campaign. They won eight out of their nine matches with one ending without a result.

“Rohit is not far behind and I thought tactically he was just outstanding in this year's (T20) World Cup,” Shastri continued. “Just the calmness, the ability to get a (Jasprit) Bumrah or a (Hardik) Pandya, or even an Axar Patel at just the right time when needed was great to see.”

Bumrah’s two tight overs, Pandya’s important wickets, and Suryakumar Yadav’s sensational catch of David Miller all orchestrated under Rohit’s captaincy secured them their second title.

Shastri was all praise for Rohit, the batter too, who signs off from T20 Internationals leaving a big void behind.

Rohit is “a giant in white-ball cricket”. His 14,846 runs, three double hundreds, 33 hundreds, and 87 fifties in ODIs and T20Is combined confirm Shastri’s claim. To add to that, he is a two-time ICC Men’s T20 World Cup (2007 and 2024) and ICC Champions Trophy winner and holds the record for most sixes in the shortest format.

“I think a giant in the white-ball game,” said Shastri. “One of the all-time greats. One of the best who have ever played. Will walk into any white-ball team they pick, irrespective of the era. Just because of the dynamic ability he has at the top.

“The thing with Rohit Sharma is he plays the big shots, he scores quickly, but they're all cricketing shots. What amazes me, there's not an element of sloppiness. I mean, it just shows how much time he has on his hands to play the best and the power – people forget that this man is explosive. He's got power.”

This power game has helped him smash the joint-most T20I centuries (five) alongside dynamic Australia all-rounder Glenn Maxwell.

“Just see the scores in that period of time. Three double hundreds in the one-day game. He's got hundreds in T20 cricket,” Shastri noted.

Shastri then clarified what sets Rohit apart from the others – his explosiveness. His exploits against the short ball are part of the cricket lore but his ability to destroy the spinners completes him.

“Compared to Virat Kohli, you know, Virat Kohli is more finesse, he's starts along the ground,” said Shastri. “This man is explosive. He's got the power to clear any ground in the world and take on the fast bowlers. He's got the shots for the quicks and he can destroy spin as well.

ICC
 
Dhoni has become like Imran Khan, people have to glorify him no matter what.
He was good but he dragged on way past his expiry and caused multiple heartbreaks for us.
Do we forget the multiple whitewashes handed out in tests, abysmal pathetic T20 World Cups of 2009, 2010 and 2012.
There is no contest, True revolution for Indian cricket started post-Dhoni. "Thala for a reason" :facepalm:
Captaincy : Rohit >> Kohli>> Dhoni.. its crystal clear

Win %DhoniKohliRohit
Tests27/60 (45%) 18 losses40/68 (59%) 17 losses10/16 (62%) 4 losses
ODI110/200 (55%)65/98 (67%) 34/45 (76%)
T20I41/72 (57%)30/50 (67%)50/62 (79%)
‘On par with Dhoni’: Shastri’s big call on Rohit Sharma as captain

Ravi Shastri has lauded Rohit Sharma as ‘one of the all-time greats’ and believes his captaincy is at least on par with India great MS Dhoni.

Rohit Sharma’s stint as India’s T20I skipper was a memorable one. He overtook Dhoni as the most successful T20I captain with 49 wins in 62 matches. Dhoni had 41 victories from 72 games.

Shastri places the two on equal footing, calling Rohit ‘one of the best captains ever alongside Dhoni’ with both showing great tactical acumen in white-ball cricket.

“As a tactician, let's not forget that he's been an outstanding guy. He'll go down as one of the best captains ever alongside Dhoni,” Shastri said on the latest episode of The ICC Review.

“If you ask me who's better, I'd say both are on par when it comes to tactics in the white-ball game. I can't pay a bigger compliment to Rohit than that because you know what MS has done and the titles he has won.”

Rohit captained India to their first T20 World Cup title since 2007 in Barbados in June, where India were unbeaten in the whole campaign. They won eight out of their nine matches with one ending without a result.

“Rohit is not far behind and I thought tactically he was just outstanding in this year's (T20) World Cup,” Shastri continued. “Just the calmness, the ability to get a (Jasprit) Bumrah or a (Hardik) Pandya, or even an Axar Patel at just the right time when needed was great to see.”

Bumrah’s two tight overs, Pandya’s important wickets, and Suryakumar Yadav’s sensational catch of David Miller all orchestrated under Rohit’s captaincy secured them their second title.

Shastri was all praise for Rohit, the batter too, who signs off from T20 Internationals leaving a big void behind.

Rohit is “a giant in white-ball cricket”. His 14,846 runs, three double hundreds, 33 hundreds, and 87 fifties in ODIs and T20Is combined confirm Shastri’s claim. To add to that, he is a two-time ICC Men’s T20 World Cup (2007 and 2024) and ICC Champions Trophy winner and holds the record for most sixes in the shortest format.

“I think a giant in the white-ball game,” said Shastri. “One of the all-time greats. One of the best who have ever played. Will walk into any white-ball team they pick, irrespective of the era. Just because of the dynamic ability he has at the top.

“The thing with Rohit Sharma is he plays the big shots, he scores quickly, but they're all cricketing shots. What amazes me, there's not an element of sloppiness. I mean, it just shows how much time he has on his hands to play the best and the power – people forget that this man is explosive. He's got power.”

This power game has helped him smash the joint-most T20I centuries (five) alongside dynamic Australia all-rounder Glenn Maxwell.

“Just see the scores in that period of time. Three double hundreds in the one-day game. He's got hundreds in T20 cricket,” Shastri noted.

Shastri then clarified what sets Rohit apart from the others – his explosiveness. His exploits against the short ball are part of the cricket lore but his ability to destroy the spinners completes him.

“Compared to Virat Kohli, you know, Virat Kohli is more finesse, he's starts along the ground,” said Shastri. “This man is explosive. He's got the power to clear any ground in the world and take on the fast bowlers. He's got the shots for the quicks and he can destroy spin as well.

ICC
 
Rohit is reaping the rewards of the team built by Virat just like Dhoni reaped rewards of the team built by Ganguly & Dravid.

India since T20Is started have most wins & a staggering win loss ratio even against top 8-9 teams. Good now they have 2 T20 World Cups to show for all those victories.
 
Rohit Sharma led the Indian team to lose the third and final ODI against Sri Lanka, resulting in a 0-2 series defeat.

This makes Sharma the third Indian captain, after Sachin Tendulkar (1997) and Mohammad Azharuddin (1993), to lose an ODI bilateral series to Sri Lanka.
 
The most striking thing in that table is Asghar Stanikzai's piloting of Afghanistan from division 5 all the way upto the world T20.

He is undoubtedly the best T20I captain of all time
 
Among these names, AB de Villiers wins pretty easily.

He excelled in two biggest formats more than others and was a perception great in 20 overs cricket too. He set up the style of batting in such a way via his 360° game that it basically became the formula of succeeding in T20s which set up the tone for the likes of Buttler, SKY and hence is often regarded as a great of the game in this format too despite an unsuccessful T20I record.

Additionally, he is a great ambassador of the game and a kind of player who would fit in every team being an excellent fielder as well as a good keeper. Pietersen and Warner are not the kind of characters that would fit in every team. In the shortest format, they can be more intimidating than de Villiers on a given day due to the kind of character they are which might work within a 30 ball bracket but as an all format batter and being a more realist to the actual world wanting someone around your corner for a long term association, you have to put your bet on ABDV.

If you go on a war with these guys on your side, you never know when the likes of Warner or Pietersen change their colour and backstab you but characters like AB will always be there on your side and willing to contribute keeping their ego aside until that environment becomes a poison for himself then he will leave away politely without making much fuss.
 
Among these names, AB de Villiers wins pretty easily.

He excelled in two biggest formats more than others and was a perception great in 20 overs cricket too. He set up the style of batting in such a way via his 360° game that it basically became the formula of succeeding in T20s which set up the tone for the likes of Buttler, SKY and hence is often regarded as a great of the game in this format too despite an unsuccessful T20I record.

Additionally, he is a great ambassador of the game and a kind of player who would fit in every team being an excellent fielder as well as a good keeper. Pietersen and Warner are not the kind of characters that would fit in every team. In the shortest format, they can be more intimidating than de Villiers on a given day due to the kind of character they are which might work within a 30 ball bracket but as an all format batter and being a more realist to the actual world wanting someone around your corner for a long term association, you have to put your bet on ABDV.

If you go on a war with these guys on your side, you never know when the likes of Warner or Pietersen change their colour and backstab you but characters like AB will always be there on your side and willing to contribute keeping their ego aside until that environment becomes a poison for himself then he will leave away politely without making much fuss.
Lol ab was a racist. He is not role model.

And he is also a bonafide choker. No thanks.

He is great only in tests. In odi too but he failed din crucial games to take his team over.
 
Rohit is reaping the rewards of the team built by Virat just like Dhoni reaped rewards of the team built by Ganguly & Dravid.

India since T20Is started have most wins & a staggering win loss ratio even against top 8-9 teams. Good now they have 2 T20 World Cups to show for all those victories.
India and West indies are the best t20 sides of all time

In odi it's aus then big gap then india and west indies etc in terms of history.

But right now I would say india aus are similar in level in odi. Followed by England and then SA

Sorry SA then england
 
Samuels played 2 clutch final knocks. No one says he is a better batsman than Kohli, Warner.

Dhoni won WT20 and Asia cup (T20 format)
Rohit won WT20 and Nidihaas and has a stellar bilateral record.

On top of that IPL is tougher than world cups where we don’t have minnow teams like Bangladesh etc, so I rate winning it higher.

So yes. Maybe Sammy a close 2nd, I will not debate it.
Kohli is the loser in LOI huh? Should have sacked him years back.
 
Lol ab was a racist. He is not role model.

And he is also a bonafide choker. No thanks.

He is great only in tests. In odi too but he failed din crucial games to take his team over.
Looks like I posted in wrong thread. No, that's incorrect statement. He was the last and least benefited member of clique group. If anything the real beneficiary and the main person in crime was Mark Boucher who should not have played 147 tests by default. But because he is a great mate with Smith and build great camaradie with Pollock and Kallis, they formed a clique group and he benefited the most of it. Otherwise, AB could have played entire career as keeper batsman and they could have picked another specialist batsman.

Boucher and Smith are actually the real racists and were intimidating person who would do whatever they want. AB was just a nice bloke who had all the talent and played the game like a gentleman but found himself in a wrong place and faced the wrath of a poisonous environment after the quick retirement of other members of clique group- Smith, Kallis, Boucher all in 2013-14.
 
Rohit is the greatest????

Till yesterday, wasn't Dhoni the greatest of all time for India???

What changed???
 
Looks like I posted in wrong thread. No, that's incorrect statement. He was the last and least benefited member of clique group. If anything the real beneficiary and the main person in crime was Mark Boucher who should not have played 147 tests by default. But because he is a great mate with Smith and build great camaradie with Pollock and Kallis, they formed a clique group and he benefited the most of it. Otherwise, AB could have played entire career as keeper batsman and they could have picked another specialist batsman.

Boucher and Smith are actually the real racists and were intimidating person who would do whatever they want. AB was just a nice bloke who had all the talent and played the game like a gentleman but found himself in a wrong place and faced the wrath of a poisonous environment after the quick retirement of other members of clique group- Smith, Kallis, Boucher all in 2013-14.
Not sure about that. He was part of the clique too.

Pollock Smith were definitely racists. Pieces of crap. Boucher yes. Not sure about kalis.

Reports said pretty nasty things about what ab said
Lot of colloquial slurs etc were used against black players. Calling them quota picks etc on top of that. Like kaffer etc.

Plus he is a choker anyway. No wonder saffer couldn't win squat in LOi. They were a great test team but even then they lost at home.
 
May or may not be for India but definitely not for some cowards who score at less than a run in t20s and do fake cramps or do acting on field


For example, Rishabh Pant who has a SR of 127 in T20Is in spite of being glorified day and night for his aggressive batting, and started doing acting in the WT20 Final to slow down the game when Klaasen was making curry out of Indian spinners.

If Rizwan is a coward for having a SR of 126 in T20Is, then so are Pant (SR 127) and Dhoni (SR 126).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Happy to agree with the OP and other Indians who want to assert that Rohit is the GOAT T20 captain if they are so happy to agree that Babar was a better captain than Dhoni as per the table.

If you are going to hide behind statistics then you can’t pick and choose whatever suits your argument.
 
Not sure about that. He was part of the clique too.

Pollock Smith were definitely racists. Pieces of crap. Boucher yes. Not sure about kalis.

Reports said pretty nasty things about what ab said
Lot of colloquial slurs etc were used against black players. Calling them quota picks etc on top of that. Like kaffer etc.

Plus he is a choker anyway. No wonder saffer couldn't win squat in LOi. They were a great test team but even then they lost at home.
If you put all your favourite Australian players in that SA setup, they will look much bigger racists than the Saffers. When you play in a team, you have to make decisions in the interest of the team and whatever seems beneficial and worth a reward is what you will choose. That South African team did great because they played as a team and went on to win test series in England vs strong England side, Australia vs good Australian side and drew vs good Indian side away from home. They won in Pakistan/UAE and Sri Lanka as well alongwith showing dominance in New Zealand and West Indies. No team achieved this much success away from home than West Indies or Australian side at their peak.

If you gonna now say that you rate individuals based on performance of individual than team, ABD averages 60+ at SR of 110+ and only comparable to Viv in WCs and is also the only batsman to average 50+ and SR of 100+ in ODIs despite the rules being changed almost 15 years back. Nobody has come and reached that height yet.
 
If you put all your favourite Australian players in that SA setup, they will look much bigger racists than the Saffers. When you play in a team, you have to make decisions in the interest of the team and whatever seems beneficial and worth a reward is what you will choose. That South African team did great because they played as a team and went on to win test series in England vs strong England side, Australia vs good Australian side and drew vs good Indian side away from home. They won in Pakistan/UAE and Sri Lanka as well alongwith showing dominance in New Zealand and West Indies. No team achieved this much success away from home than West Indies or Australian side at their peak.

If you gonna now say that you rate individuals based on performance of individual than team, ABD averages 60+ at SR of 110+ and only comparable to Viv in WCs and is also the only batsman to average 50+ and SR of 100+ in ODIs despite the rules being changed almost 15 years back. Nobody has come and reached that height yet.
If you are part of the clique and spout racist crap then you are a racist. Period lol. Abd is a proven racist. They won everywhere except india where they drew. But they also lost at home to England, Australia twice iirc under Smith. They also drew once vs eng at home I believe. If you win away it great but you can't let yourselves get conquered at home.

Abd a choker when it matters. You can bring up all sorts of stats. I too can do that to make a player look good. But at the end of the day, he couldn't take SA over the line despite having a great formidable side.

He never performed well in t20 kos.


In odi I did say he is a good player but again just couldn't get it done. If he played for a fodder side then I would excuse the loss but he was in a great team. Like steyn he dint get the job done when it mattered. To be a great player you need to perform when it matters.

Steyn is a bonafide choker in LOI too.
 
Greatest Indian T20 captain of all time is Dhoni. Greatest T20 captain of all time is Darren Sammy.
 
Rohit has captained the most dominant World T20 side though. Regardless of whether he's the greatest or not.
 
Greatest Indian T20 captain of all time is Dhoni. Greatest T20 captain of all time is Darren Sammy.
Dhoni is overrated. His wt20 victory was at a time when the game was at its infancy. He choked against SL in 2014 wt20 final. The decision to send yuvraj backfired. His captaincy in 2016 wt20 was abysmal - we only reached the semis due to Kohli's brilliance. Rohit in comparison already has a wt20 in the modern era. I would rate him over Dhoni.
 
Back
Top