Major
Test Star
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2013
- Runs
- 36,230
- Post of the Week
- 7

This news will affect the Islamabad United team big time.
Lets see what happens, but are they ban from PSL or not for now?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
How would it be fair on them if savior Amir continues to play in the national side?
Poor or not,you have fast bowlers right? That is not an excuse. What about the ones toiling in domestics,shouldn't they move up the pecking order no matter how good or average they are.
Yes I have no problem with Amir's comeback and definitely have no holier than thou attitude in his case but the fact he is jumped up the pecking order based on past reputation as a bowler and cut the queue despite coming back from a major punishment is what people have criticized.
In the 5 years during his ban, he used to come for interviews every week on some channel. He was always portrayed as the innocent victim and people could not wait till he was back. Every day people used to say things like - once Amir is back, etc.
I do think Butt and Asif would be back soon too
Jail isn't a punishment for fixing. Most of the others didn't go to jail, the trio got unlucky there. What people will not do next time is to fix in England.
The cricketing punishment was five years out of the game. That's not a strong deterrent. Even the jail time, it was a short jail sentence. If I were in that position I would take a five year ban with a year or so jail time over a life ban. The latter spells the end of your career.
You can not compare this to even an average criminal let alone murders. Those who go to jail find it difficult to get any job. Companies don't want them. Yet these trio are back in domestic cricket, and one into international cricket. If you steal from a bank, they won't rehire you. Yet that's what's happened here.
The trio all deserved a second chance. But not in cricket. There's more to life than just cricket. But it just sets a bad precedent to cricket, and if we are to rid cricket of fixing we have to adopt a no tolerance policy. I would have had life bans of all forms of cricket for Butt and Asif, and a 5 year ban from cricket and a life international ban for Amir (which is showing some tolerance tbh).
We're just bending the rules generally because Amir was so talented. If it were some other cricketer who wasn't very good, I'm sure those same supporters would have wanted him to be banned for life. Representing your country is an extremely high honour, it isn't to be taken lightly.
Let's hope so lool. Man this is just heartbreaking.Perhaps the bookies lured Sharjeel with a bit of biryani and Pakoreh, he just ate the food and went about his business no harm done. Sharjeel just wanted the food he had no interest in doing anyone favoursbit like when I attend certain events due to the tasty free food otherwise I have no interest in the other stuff
[MENTION=47617]Red Devil[/MENTION]
thats really serious..
BTW this is probably the first time ever our board caught fixers? Great stuff by PCB.
If the death penalty becomes a law in Canada then should people who commuted such a crime befire it's not implementation also be killed? Don't think this should be used as an excuse to bash Amir
Hey hey there. Don't declare them guilty without being proven.
So according to you, these two saw how Amir was banned for five years and came back, thought hey if we do this and are caught we'll be banned but will still be allowed back? Sharjeel is 28, Latif is 31. A 5 year ban would be as good as a life ban for them. Jails and bannings never act as deterrent. If they did crimes pertaining to fraud, cheating etc would vanish overnight. Greedy people will cheat regardless.
They ought to be banned for life if anything comes out of it.
Hey hey there. Don't declare them guilty without being proven.
Amir has to be banned for life. And so is Butt and Asif. Its the right thing to do.
lets not pretend here.
if they have been suspended then there is a reason. Being suspended is a big deal and dont think pcb would take such a decision without having some good conclusion.
This wont be a 5 year ban, at max will be 1 year. So 1 year of publicity, lots of interview, money from fixing, etc and then direct comeback to international team. Win-win
Indian cricket was full of fixing for a long time, after life ban for Azhar and Jadeja it reduced a lot after that
Why should they be banned for life when its just a league and not even international cricket?
This wont be a 5 year ban, at max will be 1 year. So 1 year of publicity, lots of interview, money from fixing, etc and then direct comeback to international team. Win-win
Indian cricket was full of fixing for a long time, after life ban for Azhar and Jadeja it reduced a lot after that
Either ur new to Pakistan cricket, or you 'still' don't know PCB.
i feel Pcb shouldn't even have made this public and done their investigations 'in' silence before coming out and Sethi's statements are just as useless as himself.
Just when we found a good opener![]()
lets not pretend here.
if they have been suspended then there is a reason. Being suspended is a big deal and dont think pcb would take such a decision without having some good conclusion.
Either ur new to Pakistan cricket, or you 'still' don't know PCB.
i feel Pcb shouldn't even have made this public and done their investigations 'in' silence before coming out and Sethi's statements are just as useless as himself.
An hour after the news broke and we are on post number 110 with about 100 posts bashing the two players senseless without any idea of what happened![]()
I don't know whether it was poor wording by Sethi or he literally meant that. "felt" is not conclusive evidence.
You dont just send a top player like Sharjeel home from the biggest league in the country without anything significant.
Not after being allowed back. This law should be implemented for people who get caught for fixing after it
being allowed back was the wrong decision. PCB should rectify the past mistake by banning the trio now for life.
Najam Sethi's conversation certainly suggests that they are pretty much guilty. They just want to give them time to defend themselves.
You dont just send a top player like Sharjeel home from the biggest league in the country without anything significant.
being allowed back was the wrong decision. PCB should rectify the past mistake by banning the trio now for life.
I don't know whether it was poor wording by Sethi or he literally meant that. "felt" is not conclusive evidence.
You dont do a lot of things which South Asian cricket boards have been doing for many years
Look - I'm not saying the two players are innocent. However, at this stage, I think it would be equally unfair to deem them guilty. The PCB should not have released a statement or made things public until their investigation was done IMO.
I know many people dont want to listen to the truth here, but lets not pretend that nothing has happened here.If they are guilty of fixing then they should be banned for life. Enough of this nonsense. However, let's not put the horse before the cart, no need of labeling them guilty etc.
PCB did the right thing here. Its only day 2 of PSL and they have found this out.You dont do a lot of things which South Asian cricket boards have been doing for many years
Look - I'm not saying the two players are innocent. However, at this stage, I think it would be equally unfair to deem them guilty. The PCB should not have released a statement or made things public until their investigation was done IMO.
They were seen mingling with a few members of the syndicate therefore PCB suspended them. At the moment PCB doesn't know whether they have done spot fixing or were going to do spot fixing. That is what Sethi implied in his statement. They are being sent back and come clean whether have done it or were going to do it or were just enjoying a fancy meal for free.
It is right. Its the only way to save Pakistan cricket.That isn't right
It is right. Its the only way to save Pakistan cricket.
? are you for real?
This has to be made public, so that others who are upto no good are warned
many might not like this, but i think what PCB has done here is top notch.
THey have shown by example that there will be zero tolerance. The leagues reputation is really important, or it could end up like the Bangladesh Premier League which is full of fixing.
If the players have been warned of the people not to mingle with then why do it?
What if there is nothing serious ? just an approach ? and they are 'free' to play again?
I agree. Pakistan cricket is at a low anyway, might as well weed out the shady characters while the expectations are low. If other leagues want to turn a blind eye to what's going on let them. PCB has my full support on this.
No concrete evidence has been given,from the exact wordings of Sethi :
-We have reason to believe they 'may' have slipped up
-We have 'sufficient reason to believe they 'could' -'might' have damaged the league
-We meet the duo and took this decision and which is to "suggest" its the right decision.
Wasn't there a thing last year about Sharjeel and a blackmail attempt, or am I imagining this?
If true maybe it has something to do with that.
There was, my first reaction was that this isn't the first time I'm hearing Sharjeel get linked to this mess, but I'm not able to recall anything more than that.
Some Indian media reporting it as spot fixing.
Two good openers. I was wondering just today why Latif hadn't figured in Australia.
Anyway, par for the course with Pakistan cricket. Might as just wind the game up there and turn out the lights.
Uhhh.. How thick you could be to do fixing now.. I mean shrajeel is going to have a lot of offers from t20 leagues around the world and after what happened with the three fixers how could anyone now think of involving in such an activity.
According to PCB sources, both the players were caught by PCB’s security and anti-corruption officer Col Azam on Thursday night while connecting with suspected people.
Sources said both the players have confessed to be in contact with the suspected people, with their international careers now at verge of being ended.
gotta feel for Misbah. Whenever crap happens, he is left to do the clean up
get your facts right man. Hyderabad is not a small city..
you can say it only in terms of cricketing history.
Khalid Latif is part of Karachi mafia so I would not be surprised if he is indeed involved in fixing.
The shocking one is Sharjeel who is from a small city Hyderabad; the big lights has gone to his head and is moving in wrong crowd.