What's new

Muslims in Mumbai organize an anti-Pakistan Protest after attack on soldiers in IOK

There's nothing to make out. Most Indian Muslims (apart from some edgy kids in university) are as patriotic as anyone else.
 
They don’t really have to do it tbh. No one in their right mind questions their allegiance
 
What a bunch of wannabe Patriots :facepalm:

Howcome these Indian Muslims never take on the streets to protests against the atrocities of Indian Army on their Muslim Brothers in Kashmir ?
 
KingKhanWC said:
Living in fear makes people do stupid things.
Click to expand...

Or maybe, just maybe, they're perfectly happy with their lives in India and are appalled by Pakistan's actions.

I'm not sure where this narrative of Muslims in India living in fear comes from.
 
Sachin136 said:
Or maybe, just maybe, they're perfectly happy with their lives in India and are appalled by Pakistan's actions.

I'm not sure where this narrative of Muslims in India living in fear comes from.
Click to expand...

1992 Bombay riots when Shiv Sena attacked Muslims is just one example.

The Indian Muslims should be honest as their religion demands. They should ask for India to stop it's occupation of Kashmir and then ask Pakistan to find peace and do it's best to help keep India safe.

If Muslims cannot care for other Muslims, they dont even know their own religion.
 
KingKhanWC said:
1992 Bombay riots when Shiv Sena attacked Muslims is just one example.

The Indian Muslims should be honest as their religion demands. They should ask for India to stop it's occupation of Kashmir and then ask Pakistan to find peace and do it's best to help keep India safe.

If Muslims cannot care for other Muslims, they dont even know their own religion.
Click to expand...

Individual events like those don't say much. There have been many incidents where Hindus were killed too. Does that mean that Hindus live in fear too? If you're not a Muslim living in India, it's best not to make up rubbish.

And these people are sentient human beings who can think for themselves. They will decide themselves who they want to support.
 
Same happened in my state today. Funny some Pakistanis haven't stepped foot in India, and yet know everything about the psyche of Indian muslims and the reason behind their actions.
 
Sachin136 said:
Individual events like those don't say much. There have been many incidents where Hindus were killed too. Does that mean that Hindus live in fear too? If you're not a Muslim living in India, it's best not to make up rubbish.

And these people are sentient human beings who can think for themselves. They will decide themselves who they want to support.
Click to expand...

lol Hindus are the majority, it would be funny if they lived in fear against a minority.

It's clearly obvious these Indian Muslims in Mumbai are doing this to show their patriotisim out of fear and backlash. Hindu extremists are strong in their part of the world.
 
Rafa said:
What a bunch of wannabe Patriots :facepalm:

Howcome these Indian Muslims never take on the streets to protests against the atrocities of Indian Army on their Muslim Brothers in Kashmir ?
Click to expand...

Because they recognize themselves as Indians first, and they act in the interests of India like we do.
 
Poor guys, desperate to prove their Indianess. But they need to know that there is nothing they can do that will convince the Hindu majority that they are loyal patriots.
 
Bewal Express said:
Poor guys, desperate to prove their Indianess. But they need to know that there is nothing they can do that will convince the Hindu majority that they are loyal patriots.
Click to expand...

A Pakistani living in Britain who seems to know all about Muslims and Hindus in India. Where have I seen this before?
 
Sad they should had taken permission from British-Pakistanis before organizing a protest.
 
Rafa said:
What a bunch of wannabe Patriots :facepalm:

Howcome these Indian Muslims never take on the streets to protests against the atrocities of Indian Army on their Muslim Brothers in Kashmir ?
Click to expand...

So Indian Muslims should be loyal to the Islam first? Please.

Country > Religion.
 
Bewal Express said:
Poor guys, desperate to prove their Indianess. But they need to know that there is nothing they can do that will convince the Hindu majority that they are loyal patriots.
Click to expand...

I think as Hindu extremism grows in India, the Muslims will be more and more alienated.

In the Bombay riots of 1992 Hindu leaders said stuff such as 'Send Muslims to Allah' and many were butchered in cold blood. Afaik no Hindu leader has been convicted of inciting hatred.
 
Pakistanis dunno how to react to such news. :))

Its sad and hilarious to see ppl being so gullible.

If someone agrees with u, they are balanced/sensible/sane.

If not, they are crazy.

Not referring to all obviously.
 
sensible-indian-fan said:
Pakistanis dunno how to react to such news. :))

Its sad and hilarious to see ppl being so gullible.

If someone agrees with u, they are balanced/sensible/sane.

If not, they are crazy.

Not referring to all obviously.
Click to expand...

Isn't that true with almost every discussion regardless of your nationality?
 
Pakistanis don't care about Indian Muslims. Kashmiris aren't Indian Muslims and got nothing to with them so they don't count.
 
Pakistanian said:
Pakistanis don't care about Indian Muslims. Kashmiris aren't Indian Muslims and got nothing to with them so they don't count.
Click to expand...

I'm afraid I'm not following here. Kashmir is in India, and Kashmir has many Muslims living there. So by definition, they're Indian Muslims.
 
Sachin136 said:
I'm afraid I'm not following here. Kashmir is in India, and Kashmir has many Muslims living there. So by definition, they're Indian Muslims.
Click to expand...

It's disputed and they don't consider themselves Indian muslims and they are culturally and historically different from most indians.
 
KingKhanWC said:
1992 Bombay riots when Shiv Sena attacked Muslims is just one example.

The Indian Muslims should be honest as their religion demands. They should ask for India to stop it's occupation of Kashmir and then ask Pakistan to find peace and do it's best to help keep India safe.

If Muslims cannot care for other Muslims, they dont even know their own religion.
Click to expand...

Indian muslims dont need your certificates. They are patriotic nationalist Indians supporting their country.

God will judge them not you.
 
Bewal Express said:
Poor guys, desperate to prove their Indianess. But they need to know that there is nothing they can do that will convince the Hindu majority that they are loyal patriots.
Click to expand...

Plenty of marches today all over India by every community. All supporting their country.

Seems the idea of loyalty towards the country is a foreign idea to people like you.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Indian muslims dont need your certificates. They are patriotic nationalist Indians supporting their country.

God will judge them not you.
Click to expand...

You're on British Pakistani website, we are not under Indian occupation here and can say what we like. They are scared, this is my view.
 
Rafa said:
What a bunch of wannabe Patriots :facepalm:

Howcome these Indian Muslims never take on the streets to protests against the atrocities of Indian Army on their Muslim Brothers in Kashmir ?
Click to expand...

Because those atrocities would be unleashed on them instead if they dared to protest on behalf of Kashmiri Muslims.

Do you forget following the Gujarat massacres there were interviews where Muslims were confessing to putting Hindu avatars on their houses to avoid being burned to the ground? This is an act of self preservation for these Muslims, and those who live in Pakistan or abroad should show some sympathy for their plight.
 
KingKhanWC said:
You're on British Pakistani website, we are not under Indian occupation here and can say what we like. They are scared, this is my view.
Click to expand...

They rejected the idea of Pakistan in 1947. That should tell you what they think of you and your opinion.

Your views dont matter in India.
 
So if any Hindus in Pakistan protest against India, then they are doing out of fear or prove themselves they are patriots?

What a twisted mindset.

Indian Muslims are as patriotic as any other in India
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
This isn't India. His views count for more than yours on this site.
Click to expand...

So his view saying that Indian Muslims live in fear counts for more than Indian Muslims themselves going against that?

Do you guys want Indian Muslims to live in fear? Just so you can get some upper hand over India (not that Pakistan's treatment of minorities is any good in the first place)? Disgusting.
 
Sachin136 said:
So his view saying that Indian Muslims live in fear counts for more than Indian Muslims themselves going against that?

Do you guys want Indian Muslims to live in fear? Just so you can get some upper hand over India (not that Pakistan's treatment of minorities is any good in the first place)? Disgusting.
Click to expand...

The most laughable thing is that almost no Muslim from India tries immigrating to Pakistan. That tells everything.
 
From the BBC: In the wake of the attack, authorities have imposed a curfew in parts of Hindu-majority Jammu city after an angry mob vandalised cars in a largely Muslim neighbourhood.

It is clear why these protests are happening. Indian muslims don't want to become targets
 
Something said:
From the BBC: In the wake of the attack, authorities have imposed a curfew in parts of Hindu-majority Jammu city after an angry mob vandalised cars in a largely Muslim neighbourhood.

It is clear why these protests are happening. Indian muslims don't want to become targets
Click to expand...

There are protests all over India (the video here is from Bombay) and you think it's because of one incident in Jammu? The lengths people go to...
 
Something said:
From the BBC: In the wake of the attack, authorities have imposed a curfew in parts of Hindu-majority Jammu city after an angry mob vandalised cars in a largely Muslim neighbourhood.

It is clear why these protests are happening. Indian muslims don't want to become targets
Click to expand...

There you go. Poor people must be very scared. Its all over Indian history, riots against Muslims and it must be more worrying for them the PM is the butcher of Gujrat atm. :(
 
"Banning Pakistan is not the focus now, destruction of Pakistan is," says Kangana Ranaut on #PulwamaTerrorAttack.

Lol at these actors/actresses trying to show their loyalty.
If a war does happen they'll be the first ones to go abroad.
Bunch of hypocrites
 
Hitman said:
The most laughable thing is that almost no Muslim from India tries immigrating to Pakistan. That tells everything.
Click to expand...

Why will they? Their forefathers made a intelligent decision 70yrs back and they helped build this nation.

Thing is some Pakistanis dont understand the fact that people love their country. For them its all about religion.
 
Sachin136 said:
There are protests all over India (the video here is from Bombay) and you think it's because of one incident in Jammu? The lengths people go to...
Click to expand...

It's not one incident. Muslims in India live in fear. They've become scapegoats in the past and have been attacked various times. 1964 Kolkota, Gujarat since partition, 1987 Hashimpura, etc etc.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Why will they? Their forefathers made a intelligent decision 70yrs back and they helped build this nation.

Thing is some Pakistanis dont understand the fact that people love their country. For them its all about religion.
Click to expand...

Then those who criticize India as Indian Muslims are told to go to Pakistan?

Who are you fooling?
 
Hitman said:
The most laughable thing is that almost no Muslim from India tries immigrating to Pakistan. That tells everything.
Click to expand...

You are telling this as most Pakistani do not understand the current Pakistan's situation.

Do Pakistani want India Muslims to migrate to Pakistan, majority will say NO, Pakistan can't afford to.

But Hindus of India need to stop getting worked up when a Indian Muslim criticize India, to which Hindu India tell them to move to Pakistan.
 
slipcatch said:
Then those who criticize India as Indian Muslims are told to go to Pakistan?

Who are you fooling?
Click to expand...

Why do i need to fool anyone? Who is that important here?

Criticize India? Plenty of people criticize India, including muslims. The constitution gives them the right.
 
a_tahir said:
"Banning Pakistan is not the focus now, destruction of Pakistan is," says Kangana Ranaut on #PulwamaTerrorAttack.

Lol at these actors/actresses trying to show their loyalty.
If a war does happen they'll be the first ones to go abroad.
Bunch of hypocrites
Click to expand...

It is amazing that most Indian believe that Indian army can sustain or win a war against Pakistan.

What are they being fed on daily basis?
 
cricketjoshila said:
Why do i need to fool anyone? Who is that important here?

Criticize India? Plenty of people criticize India, including muslims. The constitution gives them the right.
Click to expand...

LOL

Then why are Indian Muslims told to go to Pakistan when they criticize India?

Why are Kashmiri Muslims are arrested for flying Pakistani flag?

If Hindu of India has that much confident then why not let them be?
 
That fact that the protest was organized by a Muslim community says it all. What has religion got to do with this? Couldn't they just protest inclusively with other Indians? This is a national issue, not a religious one.

These people are just saving their backsides, nothing more.
 
This is embarrassing for goodness sake. Why do they feel the need to take out a Muslim only protest!? I couldn't care less about Indian Muslims although it is clear that this this carried out of fear so that Hindu fundo's don't attack them. Of course Indian Muslim's love India just like Pak non-Muslims love Pak. I have never liked or cared about Indian Muslims at all.
 
PakLFC said:
This is embarrassing for goodness sake. Why do they feel the need to take out a Muslim only protest!? I couldn't care less about Indian Muslims although it is clear that this this carried out of fear so that Hindu fundo's don't attack them. Of course Indian Muslim's love India just like Pak non-Muslims love Pak. I have never liked or cared about Indian Muslims at all.
Click to expand...

I've been reading your posts. You seem to be one of those illogical jingoistic dimwit who doesn't understand politics much. I even wondered if you were a Pakistani for a few minutes there. In which way does this incident help Pakistan? If you say, it gives you satisfaction, then you are exactly who I thought you are, a jingoistic dimwit. If you are unable to answer my question, then I will understand you are a patriotic dimwit atleast who is concerned about his country's well being.
 
slipcatch said:
LOL

Then why are Indian Muslims told to go to Pakistan when they criticize India?

Why are Kashmiri Muslims are arrested for flying Pakistani flag?

If Hindu of India has that much confident then why not let them be?
Click to expand...

Lol. No one goes anywhere bevause someone asked them to. This isnt a military dictatorship.

Pakistan is an enemy and supporting an enemy is treason in every country.
 
It is show off. Muslims in India live a life of third class citizens and have to constantly prove their nationalism by saying something bad about Islam or Pakistan on regular basis. If they don't do that, they are harassed to no end by extremist hindus.

The chudha and the chaamaar who are the lowest sections of hindu society as per hindu caste system (not me i feel everyone is equal), even they have more wealth and political support in India than muslims.

It is sad being a muslim in India. I fully blame Jinnah for the state of muslims in India today. Had he not sold his soul to the half baked idea of Pakistan and ran away he would have been the leader of entire subcontinent muslims and saved half of them from the humiliation they have endured in 6-7 decades in India.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Old enough to know that a country with Indias economy can sustain a war longer than a country thays running on bailouts.
Click to expand...

That was a question for someone else to answer.

But You can answer this question.

Why are you such a sad individual?

Why are you such a bitter individual?

And why do you always try to come off as a tough guy, what are you trying to compensate?

India can’t sustain a war long enough to win anything unless you join an army with your gold plated bombs and guns and with your bling bling grill in your mouth. How’s that compliment for your ego, you big internet Indian soldier with big $$$ bills?
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
This isn't India. His views count for more than yours on this site.
Click to expand...

I believe everyone has an equal say. The views that count more are those with better logical reasoning NOT those from people with specific backgrounds.

If y'all believe that this forum is created by British Pakistanis and their opinions hold a higher ground then perhaps have a closed discussion only among y'all and do a happy circle jerk. If you want to entertain opposing viewpoints (which some of you do) then all opinions with logic hold equal ground.
 
mustang said:
I believe everyone has an equal say. The views that count more are those with better logical reasoning NOT those from people with specific backgrounds.

If y'all believe that this forum is created by British Pakistanis and their opinions hold a higher ground then perhaps have a closed discussion only among y'all and do a happy circle jerk. If you want to entertain opposing viewpoints (which some of you do) then all opinions with logic hold equal ground.
Click to expand...

I believe you’re missing the context of the person you quoted.
 
mustang said:
Can you explain how one person's view should hold more ground than another person's?
Click to expand...

How knowledgeable that person is regarding that particular view?

But keeping the context of this thread, any radicalized views, that promote more violence should be immediately shut down, either with sensible comments or insults.
 
Rafa said:
What a bunch of wannabe Patriots :facepalm:

Howcome these Indian Muslims never take on the streets to protests against the atrocities of Indian Army on their Muslim Brothers in Kashmir ?
Click to expand...

Bro the majority community in Jammu city attacked muslims and torched their vehicles. More than 30 vehicles. Its a riot like situation. No wonder the Indian muslims have to do these kinds of acts to stay safe.

What a visionary Mr. Jinnah was.
 
slipcatch said:
It is amazing that most Indian believe that Indian army can sustain or win a war against Pakistan.

What are they being fed on daily basis?
Click to expand...

India can win war against Pakistan but it comes at a huge cost because of nuclear weapons. Direct war will never end well between two nuclear states.
 
Balthazar said:
India can win war against Pakistan but it comes at a huge cost because of nuclear weapons. Direct war will never end well between two nuclear states.
Click to expand...

What is your definition of win? Please define it.

Nobody wins a nuclear war.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Lol. No one goes anywhere bevause someone asked them to. This isnt a military dictatorship.

Pakistan is an enemy and supporting an enemy is treason in every country.
Click to expand...

But you are on a Pakistani forum and seem pretty friendly with us, by being here you are supporting 'an enemy' are you a traitor by your own definition? Or is this just selective?
 
Madplayer said:
What is your definition of win? Please define it.

Nobody wins a nuclear war.
Click to expand...

The chances of Nuclear war is Zero in this day and age. How can people be ignorant to the fact that war is going to be a financial one in 21st century. Choke the enemy with sanctions and halt their progress.
 
MenInG said:
But you are on a Pakistani forum and seem pretty friendly with us, by being here you are supporting 'an enemy' are you a traitor by your own definition? Or is this just selective?
Click to expand...

I have said this time and again,my problem lies with the Pakistani state, not its people. I do not have any benefits to reap here.
 
Last edited:
rhony said:
The chances of Nuclear war is Zero in this day and age. How can people be ignorant to the fact that war is going to be a financial one in 21st century. Choke the enemy with sanctions and halt their progress.
Click to expand...

I was responding to the poster who mentioned nuclear war.
 
slipcatch said:
You are telling this as most Pakistani do not understand the current Pakistan's situation.

Do Pakistani want India Muslims to migrate to Pakistan, majority will say NO, Pakistan can't afford to.

But Hindus of India need to stop getting worked up when a Indian Muslim criticize India, to which Hindu India tell them to move to Pakistan.
Click to expand...
Siddhu has been asked to move to Pakistan since the time he accepted Imran Khan’s invitation to travel to Pakistan. Is he a Muslim as well?
 
Madplayer said:
What is your definition of win? Please define it.

Nobody wins a nuclear war.
Click to expand...

Winning means total annihilation of an enemy. Pakistan's territory is negligible compared to India's vast lands. I am just speaking hypothetically. The poster said it's not possible for India to win in a war, but it can be easily achievable.
 
Bewal Express said:
Poor guys, desperate to prove their Indianess. But they need to know that there is nothing they can do that will convince the Hindu majority that they are loyal patriots.
Click to expand...

Exactly. Looks very desperate the whole protest. Well, thats what you have to do when any attack automatically puts you in the scope of Hindu extremists.
 
The fact that the protest was Muslim-only and that they arent protesting together with other Indians is enough to show that they are scared of Hindus attacking them. Poor fellas :(
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

The Bald Eagle
[VIDEO] "All illegal activities in Jammu & Kashmir happened at behest of Narendra Modi and Amit Shah": Indian soldiers hint at Inside job in Pahalgam
2
Replies
92
Views
3K
Champ_Pal
C
Cpt. Rishwat
Did the Ghar Wapsi movement fail in India?
2
Replies
88
Views
2K
Cpt. Rishwat
Cpt. Rishwat
msb314
[Reports] Pakistan Air Force intercepted Rafael Jets on April 29th forcing them to abandon their mission
Replies
30
Views
1K
Romali_rotti
Romali_rotti
The Bald Eagle
Curfew in Maharashtra’s Nagpur after clashes over reports of Quran burning
2 3
Replies
207
Views
5K
Cpt. Rishwat
Cpt. Rishwat
m.shah
Blessings in Pahalgam Attack
2
Replies
138
Views
5K
Farhan The Man
F
Back
Top