Outrage in India over video of teacher telling kids to slap Muslim student

[cricketjoshila]

Why is it false? Because you say so. The Inds claim to be a super power so why not take the BBC to court and get them to retract but you and all the readers know that the BBC would have done their Homework.
The Hindus died because the Muslims didn't take it lying down, but 4* as many Muslims died, why was that? Modi wanted this, got it and used it as a launching pad to become PM. The criminal has blood on his hand.

The UK PM replied anc distanced the UK government from BBC's claims. The statement was made in the house of commons.

BBC produced a false documentary about India and it was banned from India and the courts didn't revoke the ban. Thats the end of that in India.


Muslims burned alive 59 hindu pilgrims in a train. It was bound to have reactions from Hindus.

Modi is a member of RSS and its not a crime in India to be a member of the RSS. So i don't know why you keep whining about it.

Lastly, unlike other former colonies of UK, India is a military and Economic power.So, western NGOs or the likes of BBC who think they should tell former colonies how to behave and if they don't behave as per them, then they villified, should rethink their position in India. In today's India, the government doesn't give two hoots to Western agenda.

 

[ex-q-zit]

I absolutely agree that generalisation is not right, but the very act of publicly condemning such vile acts demonstrates the mindset of an incumbent government, in this case, the GOI.

The fact there is no public condemnation by the GOI against attacks on Muslims in India sends a clear message of legitimising religious violence/hatred towards Muslims whilst galvanising Hindutva.

Lets not pretend Modi is not influential. He can convince 100s of Millions as he has done under his premiership, and if he was really interested in unity within India then he would speak up against religious violence and his followers would take note and religious violence would decline.

If Modi and senior BGP politicians condemned such acts then it's not lip service, but rather a demonstrations that India is a secular nation and the Government will not tolerate religious division.

Simply put, Modis words - the act of speaking - translate to public reaction.

In cases of large scale violence like Manipur or Nuh you can seek condemnation from Modi but not for individual cases. This was not a case of an organized crime but an individual act. Such things happened under every government in most states especially in case of Dalits. Last year a dalit boy was beaten to death by a teacher for drinking water from a pot. Its impossible for any government to control people of such mindset. Those with an inherent hatred would do it no matter what whether Modi condemns it or not. We have punishments for crime but still people do commit crimes right. If punsihments dont act as detrrents how do you expect condemnation to be.

The education department has issued show cause notice to the school. The children are being arranged to be transferred to other schools so that their education is not hampered.

You can only understand how India society works and the dynamics between religions and castes if you live here. India isn't a homogenous society. Here even within hinduism inter caste marraiges are frowned upon. Society is deeply fragmented but still we have learned to live together, In such a complex society such stray incidents are bound to happen. Looking at them through a Magnifying glass from outside and concluding that muslims are being persecuted is absurd.

As for Modi being influent

 

[Technics 1210]

In cases of large scale violence like Manipur or Nuh you can seek condemnation from Modi but not for individual cases. This was not a case of an organized crime but an individual act. Such things happened under every government in most states especially in case of Dalits. Last year a dalit boy was beaten to death by a teacher for drinking water from a pot. Its impossible for any government to control people of such mindset. Those with an inherent hatred would do it no matter what whether Modi condemns it or not. We have punishments for crime but still people do commit crimes right. If punsihments dont act as detrrents how do you expect condemnation to be.

The education department has issued show cause notice to the school. The children are being arranged to be transferred to other schools so that their education is not hampered.

You can only understand how India society works and the dynamics between religions and castes if you live here. India isn't a homogenous society. Here even within hinduism inter caste marraiges are frowned upon. Society is deeply fragmented but still we have learned to live together, In such a complex society such stray incidents are bound to happen. Looking at them through a Magnifying glass from outside and concluding that muslims are being persecuted is absurd.

As for Modi being influent

When there is a case of individual mass shooting or knife crime in the USA/UK, the Politicians condemn it. Why? Gun related crime is a big problem in the USA, and knife crime is also a huge problem in the UK, just like religious violence is a big problem in India right now.

It seems to me you are not in favour of condemnation be it at the national or individual level.

It is absolutely possible to influence (and ultimately control) the mindset of the public, be it in India, UK, USA etc, and that is through the media. Why doesn't the GOI control the media narrative on national channels? It is quick to block platforms and articles, then why not promote the right moral message too?

You cannot eradicate crime, you cannot change people overnight, but you can influence change through the right leadership and messaging, because headlines make the new today, but its effect are known many years later.

 

[ex-q-zit]

When there is a case of individual mass shooting or knife crime in the USA/UK, the Politicians condemn it. Why? Gun related crime is a big problem in the USA, and knife crime is also a huge problem in the UK, just like religious violence is a big problem in India right now.

It seems to me you are not in favour of condemnation be it at the national or individual level.

It is absolutely possible to influence (and ultimately control) the mindset of the public, be it in India, UK, USA etc, and that is through the media. Why doesn't the GOI control the media narrative on national channels? It is quick to block platforms and articles, then why not promote the right moral message too?

You cannot eradicate crime, you cannot change people overnight, but you can influence change through the right leadership and messaging, because headlines make the new today, but its effect are known many years later.

Are you serious in equating this to a mass shooting or knife attack? This is a one-on-one case and a stray incident. How many muslim children have been slapped or faced what this kid faced in the past 10 years? If religious violence is the big problem right now how many muslims have sought asylum in Pakistan or any other country for that matter. If India opens it gates today not just minorities but even muslims will be ready to come over considering the economic situation. You are making a mountain out of a molehill. People like this lady teacher are those who might have grudges aginst a community and thesetypes will not listen to condemnation no matter where it comes from.

Violence against 20 crore people is not possible. you pick up stray incidents and try to make a case as if muslims are persecuted enmasse. As I said earlier unless you visit India and see how this society functions you will never know. India is a complex society of different castes and religions. Muslims in UP are different from muslims in Kerala In kerala everyone irrespective of their religion speak Malayalam and celebrate Onam in their own irrespective of religion. You cannot look at India in a single prism.

What media reports from Uttar Pradesh is what this teacher did but what media doesn't show is that muslims in Uttar Pradesh also celebrate Holi with joy and happiness

[YOUTUBE]

Most Pakistanis still believe Kashmir is in a lockdown and curfew but the current situation is completely opposite. You are free to believe what you wish to. I rest my case.

 

[cricketjoshila]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1696380590873067746

 

[FPresidential]

The UK PM replied anc distanced the UK government from BBC's claims. The statement was made in the house of commons.

BBC produced a false documentary about India and it was banned from India and the courts didn't revoke the ban. Thats the end of that in India.


Muslims burned alive 59 hindu pilgrims in a train. It was bound to have reactions from Hindus.

Modi is a member of RSS and its not a crime in India to be a member of the RSS. So i don't know why you keep whining about it.

Lastly, unlike other former colonies of UK, India is a military and Economic power.So, western NGOs or the likes of BBC who think they should tell former colonies how to behave and if they don't behave as per them, then they villified, should rethink their position in India. In today's India, the government doesn't give two hoots to Western agenda.

You've just presented historical facts which is known to everyone on this forum but it does not negate the fact that RSS and Hindutva anti-Muslim mandate is probably the top 3 priority for the current ruling party.

Good on India for becoming an economic powerhouse, it does give an opportunity to mask the bigotry among RSS and Hindutva.

Of course religious radicalism isn't a crime in India as long as it perpetrated against Muslim minorities, that would defeat the purpose of RSS and Hindutva.

 

[Technics 1210]

Are you serious in equating this to a mass shooting or knife attack? This is a one-on-one case and a stray incident. How many muslim children have been slapped or faced what this kid faced in the past 10 years? If religious violence is the big problem right now how many muslims have sought asylum in Pakistan or any other country for that matter. If India opens it gates today not just minorities but even muslims will be ready to come over considering the economic situation. You are making a mountain out of a molehill. People like this lady teacher are those who might have grudges aginst a community and thesetypes will not listen to condemnation no matter where it comes from.

Violence against 20 crore people is not possible. you pick up stray incidents and try to make a case as if muslims are persecuted enmasse. As I said earlier unless you visit India and see how this society functions you will never know. India is a complex society of different castes and religions. Muslims in UP are different from muslims in Kerala In kerala everyone irrespective of their religion speak Malayalam and celebrate Onam in their own irrespective of religion. You cannot look at India in a single prism.

What media reports from Uttar Pradesh is what this teacher did but what media doesn't show is that muslims in Uttar Pradesh also celebrate Holi with joy and happiness

[YOUTUBE]

Most Pakistanis still believe Kashmir is in a lockdown and curfew but the current situation is completely opposite. You are free to believe what you wish to. I rest my case.

A gunman (or knifeman) killing people in a town or one location is not classified as mass killing in geographical terms, but is always classified as an isolated incident. The term 'mass' relates to 5 or more people dying. And please stop pretending isolated incidents are rare in India.

I do not need to visit a country to recognise religious violence, especially given the history of India; likewise I do not need to live in Amreeka to understand the country has a gun problem, and not because of isolated incidences, but because of their constitution - a deep rooted problem just like in India where Hindus feel they have a right to murder, maim, and torture religious minorities because Hindus feel a sense of entitlement after 5000 years.

Do you live in India or the West? If you live in the West then your suggestion of living in India, also applies to you. Unless of course you resign to the fact that Modi is the spearhead of Saffron terrorism and you are High-fiving from the side lines.

If you claim India cannot be viewed from a single prism, then take the Indian constitution that claims to be a united secular nation and flush it down the toilet cos it is not worth the paper it is codified on.

You can rest your case, but fact is you do no not condemn the violence yourself, nor do you want Modi and his religious extremist government to condemn the violence, both of which are clear as daylight from the excuses you are spewing.

 

[cricketjoshila]

You've just presented historical facts which is known to everyone on this forum but it does not negate the fact that RSS and Hindutva anti-Muslim mandate is probably the top 3 priority for the current ruling party.

Good on India for becoming an economic powerhouse, it does give an opportunity to mask the bigotry among RSS and Hindutva.

Of course religious radicalism isn't a crime in India as long as it perpetrated against Muslim minorities, that would defeat the purpose of RSS and

RSS is a hindu nationalist organisation and such religious nationalist organisations exist all over the world.

The oft repeated phenomenon of playing victim card when in minority and becoming a Islamic nation and trampling on others isn't going to work.

A section of Muslims around the world have issues with non Muslims, a part of them live in India too.

The main problem is that, since BJP wins without the majority of Muslims voting for it, the political veto of muslim politicians is gone and they along with the leftists are propogating an agenda that Muslims are under threat from RSS.

Truth is that Hindu and Muslims have issues for centuries. There have been hindu Muslim riots since centuries. This is nothing new. And unfortunately there will be issues of sporadic violence between both sides in future too.

 

[Bewal Express]

The UK PM replied anc distanced the UK government from BBC's claims. The statement was made in the house of commons.

BBC produced a false documentary about India and it was banned from India and the courts didn't revoke the ban. Thats the end of that in India.


Muslims burned alive 59 hindu pilgrims in a train. It was bound to have reactions from Hindus.

Modi is a member of RSS and its not a crime in India to be a member of the RSS. So i don't know why you keep whining about it.

Lastly, unlike other former colonies of UK, India is a military and Economic power.So, western NGOs or the likes of BBC who think they should tell former colonies how to behave and if they don't behave as per them, then they villified, should rethink their position in India. In today's India, the government doesn't give two hoots to Western agenda.

The documentary wasn't false, it hit hard. A false documentary would have ended up in court and this didn't. So that lie has been exposed. The UK PM doesn't control the BBC, infact any attempt to control it would lead humiliation for him.

Ind is no superpower. It has 700mn people in poverty, it is and remains a poor country, poorer than Albania, infact 3 times poorer

 

[FPresidential]

RSS is a hindu nationalist organisation and such religious nationalist organisations exist all over the world.

The oft repeated phenomenon of playing victim card when in minority and becoming a Islamic nation and trampling on others isn't going to work.

A section of Muslims around the world have issues with non Muslims, a part of them live in India too.

The main problem is that, since BJP wins without the majority of Muslims voting for it, the political veto of muslim politicians is gone and they along with the leftists are propogating an agenda that Muslims are under threat from RSS.

Truth is that Hindu and Muslims have issues for centuries. There have been hindu Muslim riots since centuries. This is nothing new. And unfortunately there will be issues of sporadic violence between both sides in future too.

You've replied with historical facts with re-defining the organization name to mask the bigotry. It is like reading the advertisement of a product where you know words are just placed to look appealing.

A vast majority of Muslims have issue with bigotry and violence against Muslims.

Violence and marginalization of Muslims isn't sporadic in India it is carefully planned which most Hindutva support.

No matter how any supporter of RSS and Hindutva try to present historical facts but as long as RSS and Hindutva exist, the citizen of India will always be forced to defend bigotry or find an excuse for it.

A 3rd world country with a Gucci belt.

 

[FPresidential]

The documentary wasn't false, it hit hard. A false documentary would have ended up in court and this didn't. So that lie has been exposed. The UK PM doesn't control the BBC, infact any attempt to control it would lead humiliation for him.

Ind is no superpower. It has 700mn people in poverty, it is and remains a poor country, poorer than Albania, infact 3 times poorer

Anyone with two pulse knows documentary was not fake. As it is evident by now it is the only narrative they are left to propagate. Modi would have sued and even a hardcore Indian fan of Modi could have sued BBC for millions.

Masking bigotry is almost a full time sport for the most Modi supporters.

 

[ex-q-zit]

The documentary wasn't false, it hit hard. A false documentary would have ended up in court and this didn't. So that lie has been exposed. The UK PM doesn't control the BBC, infact any attempt to control it would lead humiliation for him.

Ind is no superpower. It has 700mn people in poverty, it is and remains a poor country, poorer than Albania, infact 3 times poorer

No get your facts right India is poorer than Pakistan. We are not even able to pay electricity bills. Our inflation has hit the roof. We aren't a 3.5 trillion economy. Our reserves of 650 billion is no where near the borrowed mighty 6.5 billion. Our rupee has breached 300 against the dollar. Hope we too put our children in madrassas so that they can learn that the earth is flat ans static and sun revolves around the earth so that we can launch a moon mission in the future. We are so poor that srilanka had to lend us money to bail us out.

 

[cricketjoshila]

You've replied with historical facts with re-defining the organization name to mask the bigotry. It is like reading the advertisement of a product where you know words are just placed to look appealing.

A vast majority of Muslims have issue with bigotry and violence against Muslims.

Violence and marginalization of Muslims isn't sporadic in India it is carefully planned which most Hindutva support.

No matter how any supporter of RSS and Hindutva try to present historical facts but as long as RSS and Hindutva exist, the citizen of India will always be forced to defend bigotry or find an excuse for it.

A 3rd world country with a Gucci belt.

Your opinion on an organisation doesn't define it. Historical facts do.

Ofcourse Muslims have problems with violence against muslims. On this very forum if Turkey transforms Hagia Sofia to a mosque its a celebration. Because Turkey is a muslim majority country going back to its roots. But Hindus trying to build temples at their site of pilgrimage is bigotry.

You can keep denying it, but the truth is that, Hindus and Muslims have had a centuries long history of disputes and violence and it will unfortunately continue.

Hindu Muslim riots have happened in post Independent India under almost every prime minister. Its the truth.

 

[RexRex]

What a corrupt bunch of people in UP govt and police. Just a god-forsaken state in every sense.

UP police book Alt News’ Mohammed Zubair for sharing video of Muslim boy being beaten

The Uttar Pradesh police have filed a case against journalist Mohammed Zubair, co-founder of Alt News on Monday, August 28, for sharing the video of a Muslim ki

www.thenewsminute.com

 

[cricketjoshila]

The documentary wasn't false, it hit hard. A false documentary would have ended up in court and this didn't. So that lie has been exposed. The UK PM doesn't control the BBC, infact any attempt to control it would lead humiliation for him.

Ind is no superpower. It has 700mn people in poverty, it is and remains a poor country, poorer than Albania, infact 3 times poorer

Ended up in court? It did end up in court and the court refused to overturn the ban.

The Indian government banned the documentary in India. It doesn't need to do anything.

The UK PM represents the government of UK, not the BBC.

Post a stat for this 700mn poor people claim.

Lastly, India doesn't take sermons from a country that is known to invade,loot, kill and occupy other countries.

 

[cricketjoshila]

What a corrupt bunch of people in UP govt and police. Just a god-forsaken state in every sense.

UP police book Alt News’ Mohammed Zubair for sharing video of Muslim boy being beaten

The Uttar Pradesh police have filed a case against journalist Mohammed Zubair, co-founder of Alt News on Monday, August 28, for sharing the video of a Muslim ki

www.thenewsminute.com

Since Zubair is a muslim he can break laws?

 

[FPresidential]

Your opinion on an organisation doesn't define it. Historical facts do.

Ofcourse Muslims have problems with violence against muslims. On this very forum if Turkey transforms Hagia Sofia to a mosque its a celebration. Because Turkey is a muslim majority country going back to its roots. But Hindus trying to build temples at their site of pilgrimage is bigotry.

You can keep denying it, but the truth is that, Hindus and Muslims have had a centuries long history of disputes and violence and it will unfortunately continue.

Hindu Muslim riots have happened in post Independent India under almost every prime minister. Its the truth.

Ahh, the cliché response in support of bigoted organization, not surprised at all.

Turkey was wrong so is Hindutva, lol.

Yea, the violence has happened, and it probably will continue to, but it is Hindutva and RSS who are justifying and promoting it against Muslims as it gives them false sense of superiority.

Notice, I never denied historical facts just as I am not denying Hindutva and RSS as a bigoted organization. Some Indians do not like that fact to be out in open despite them fully aware of it.

 

[ex-q-zit]

Poster never mentioned India being poorer than Pakistan.

Well I wanted to mention Pakistan as its closer to home and our hearts

 

[cricketjoshila]

Ahh, the cliché response in support of bigoted organization, not surprised at all.

Turkey was wrong so is Hindutva, lol.

Yea, the violence has happened, and it probably will continue to, but it is Hindutva and RSS who are justifying and promoting it against Muslims as it gives them false sense of superiority.

Notice, I never denied historical facts just as I am not denying Hindutva and RSS as a bigoted organization. Some Indians do not like that fact to be out in open despite them fully aware of it.

Again. Your opinion. Not facts.

But but Turkey was celebrated here.

You write Hindutva so many times, can you tell its meaning?

There is no promotion of violence. The division has been the same, always.

Just that the left leaning media and opposition politicians highlight it more to take political advantage and keep BJP on the backfoot.

There has been Hindu Muslim riots under every PM, yet only Gujarat is highlighted. Why?

The worst targeted riot in India which also had elements of government support was the Anti Sikh riots of 1984, Yet not one Journalist will question the congress.

Its all politics.

Under BJP neither Hindus have gained more power, nor have Muslims become more vulnerable. They are the same, only reporting has changed.

 

[Technics 1210]

The documentary wasn't false, it hit hard. A false documentary would have ended up in court and this didn't. So that lie has been exposed. The UK PM doesn't control the BBC, infact any attempt to control it would lead humiliation for him.

Ind is no superpower. It has 700mn people in poverty, it is and remains a poor country, poorer than Albania, infact 3 times poorer

Only the delusional claim India is a superpower.

The fact is despite the claims, more Indians are desperate to flee India for a better world elsewhere. This is down to religious persecution, economic hardship, caste system discrimination, and lots more.

When a nation is a superpower, even an economic powerhouse, its citizens do not want to flee en-mass, and their leader (Modi) does not beg other nations to increase immigration quotas for Indians, from nations he was banned from entering (the ban will be reinstated once Modi is no longer PM).

 

[Bewal Express]

Ended up in court? It did end up in court and the court refused to overturn the ban.

The Indian government banned the documentary in India. It doesn't need to do anything.

The UK PM represents the government of UK, not the BBC.

Post a stat for this 700mn poor people claim.

Lastly, India doesn't take sermons from a country that is known to invade,loot, kill and occupy other countries.

It banned the documentary because it had no leg to stand. So pathetic was the response that they had to intimidate the BBC with fake tax raids

 

[ex-q-zit]

Only the delusional claim India is a superpower.

The fact is despite the claims, more Indians are desperate to flee India for a better world elsewhere. This is down to religious persecution, economic hardship, caste system discrimination, and lots more.

When a nation is a superpower, even an economic powerhouse, its citizens do not want to flee en-mass, and their leader (Modi) does not beg other nations to increase immigration quotas for Indians, from nations he was banned from entering (the ban will be reinstated once Modi is no longer PM).

Went through the thread and didn't see anyone claiming India is a superpower. India is nowhere near being a superpower but we have our long term plans. Our first milestone is to be a developed nation by 2047. But even in the current situation India is a part of most important groups be it G20, BRICS, SCO, BIMSTEK, QUAD. Atleast India is no longer a pushover that can be dictated at. We make decisions based on our interests.

 

[FPresidential]

Again. Your opinion. Not facts.

But but Turkey was celebrated here.

You write Hindutva so many times, can you tell its meaning?

There is no promotion of violence. The division has been the same, always.

Just that the left leaning media and opposition politicians highlight it more to take political advantage and keep BJP on the backfoot.

There has been Hindu Muslim riots under every PM, yet only Gujarat is highlighted. Why?

The worst targeted riot in India which also had elements of government support was the Anti Sikh riots of 1984, Yet not one Journalist will question the congress.

Its all politics.

Under BJP neither Hindus have gained more power, nor have Muslims become more vulnerable. They are the same, only reporting has changed.

Just as RSS, Hindutva and BJP are celebrated when they marginalize Muslims of India.

Remind of this saying, "agar woh building sy jump kar rha hai tu tum kyu" lol

All the rest of the queries is whataboutism, basically lots of Indians are more upset about people questioning BJP, RSS and Hindutva more than congress. This is rather immature defense.

One can define Hindutva as you wish but now a days it is synonymous with violence, bigotry, superiority, and extremism against Muslims and no one is to blame but RSS and Hindutva.

 

[cricketjoshila]

It banned the documentary because it had no leg to stand. So pathetic was the response that they had to intimidate the BBC with fake tax raids

It banned a fake documentary and despite approaching the courts, the ban was not lifted.

Lies of western propoganda has no place in India and unlike most other former UK colonies, India isn't going to be bullied by anyone.

Fake tax raids? Thats why BBC accepted that they hid nearly $5mn income to pay lower taxes.

BBC admits `tax evasion` in India; underreported $4.8mn income: Report - India News

Around $4.8 million (Rs 40 crore) is believed to have been underreported by the British broadcaster, funded by the UK government

www.wionews.com

Tax cheat BBC was probably thinking this was 1947 or that they don't need to follow laws former colonies.

 

[FPresidential]

It banned a fake documentary and despite approaching the courts, the ban was not lifted.

Lies of western propoganda has no place in India and unlike most other former UK colonies, India isn't going to be bullied by anyone.

Fake tax raids? Thats why BBC accepted that they hid nearly $5mn income to pay lower taxes.

BBC admits `tax evasion` in India; underreported $4.8mn income: Report - India News

Around $4.8 million (Rs 40 crore) is believed to have been underreported by the British broadcaster, funded by the UK government

www.wionews.com

Tax cheat BBC was probably thinking this was 1947 or that they don't need to follow laws former colonies.

Could have counter it instead of banning it if it was false.
Indian courts banning a documentary does not make it disappear nor it counter it with facts, rather it shows credibility of Indian courts and validate it for the rest of the world.

Every dictator, authoritarian and religious extremist have always banned truth and this is the historical fact.

 

[Technics 1210]

Went through the thread and didn't see anyone claiming India is a superpower. India is nowhere near being a superpower but we have our long term plans. Our first milestone is to be a developed nation by 2047. But even in the current situation India is a part of most important groups be it G20, BRICS, SCO, BIMSTEK, QUAD. Atleast India is no longer a pushover that can be dictated at. We make decisions based on our interests.

Why go just through this thread and not the number of threads on PP, in fact, scour social media? Why do you insist on pigeon holing?

You are seriously suggesting Indians are not claiming to be the next superpower, let alone dreaming about it, especially with the Chandrayaan-3 moon landing?

Your last sentence reveals the psyche of India. British rule still haunts India, and rulers before that, which goes back to my point of sense of entitlement. Guess what, India was not the only country to be ruled by foreigners.

Make no mistake, the only reason why India is no longer a push over is because of the sheer market size. Russia, China, Iran to name but a few are not push overs either, and 2 of them have a smaller economy than India - so its not always about the money.

 

[Bewal Express]

It banned a fake documentary and despite approaching the courts, the ban was not lifted.

Lies of western propoganda has no place in India and unlike most other former UK colonies, India isn't going to be bullied by anyone.

Fake tax raids? Thats why BBC accepted that they hid nearly $5mn income to pay lower taxes.

BBC admits `tax evasion` in India; underreported $4.8mn income: Report - India News

Around $4.8 million (Rs 40 crore) is believed to have been underreported by the British broadcaster, funded by the UK government

www.wionews.com

Tax cheat BBC was probably thinking this was 1947 or that they don't need to follow laws former colonies.

So you use a source is Ind channels that are also being blackmailed probaby for tax evasion. Give me some source outside Ind or something from the BBC accounts and I will consider it.
It makes no difference if you ban it, the news is fact, Modi is a paid up member of the RSS, he played a full role in the murder of 1000 Muslims.
As far as the 1947 jibe, well you could ask your people to stay at home. I get contacted by them to rent homes in my area. Surely if you and your govt had so much ghairat they would keep them at home

 

[ex-q-zit]

Why go just through this thread and not the number of threads on PP, in fact, scour social media? Why do you insist on pigeon holing?

You are seriously suggesting Indians are not claiming to be the next superpower, let alone dreaming about it, especially with the Chandrayaan-3 moon landing?

Your last sentence reveals the psyche of India. British rule still haunts India, and rulers before that, which goes back to my point of sense of entitlement. Guess what, India was not the only country to be ruled by foreigners.

Make no mistake, the only reason why India is no longer a push over is because of the sheer market size. Russia, China, Iran to name but a few are not push overs either, and 2 of them have a smaller economy than India - so its not always about the money.

India is not a superpower now Period. but whats wrong if someone claims India will be a super power in future. India may or may not no one knows what the future holds. Our plan is to become top 3 economy in next 5 years. But being a super power is not just about economy. It needs to excel in all fields. We have just started taking steps in those directions. Scientifically Chandrayaan was our step with others to follow. Sporting wise we have just started winning medals in other sporting activities than cricket. Our movies won 2 oscars this year. Movies like KGF and RRR were a huge hit amongst native japanese and korean audiences. Culturally India has provided the world with Yoga in addition to cinema. Its a long and lengthy journey but atleast we are moving in the right direction.

Its not about British rule haunting us and neither did we say we were the only country ruled by foreigners. We look after our own interests. The US blocked Iran and Venezuela and even asked not to buy from Russia. Why shouldthats not a pushover? we not when europe does teh same? Did anyone say India is the only country? In fa ct in this region Iran, Afghanistan, China and India boldly look after their own interests except one country that neighbours all these countries. Finally regarding money I have already answered above its about all round capability. If its just about money middle easter countries would ahve been ruling the world.

 

[Technics 1210]

India is not a superpower now Period. but whats wrong if someone claims India will be a super power in future. India may or may not no one knows what the future holds. Our plan is to become top 3 economy in next 5 years. But being a super power is not just about economy. It needs to excel in all fields. We have just started taking steps in those directions. Scientifically Chandrayaan was our step with others to follow. Sporting wise we have just started winning medals in other sporting activities than cricket. Our movies won 2 oscars this year. Movies like KGF and RRR were a huge hit amongst native japanese and korean audiences. Culturally India has provided the world with Yoga in addition to cinema. Its a long and lengthy journey but atleast we are moving in the right direction.

Its not about British rule haunting us and neither did we say we were the only country ruled by foreigners. We look after our own interests. The US blocked Iran and Venezuela and even asked not to buy from Russia. Why shouldthats not a pushover? we not when europe does teh same? Did anyone say India is the only country? In fa ct in this region Iran, Afghanistan, China and India boldly look after their own interests except one country that neighbours all these countries. Finally regarding money I have already answered above its about all round capability. If its just about money middle easter countries would ahve been ruling the world.

Being a super power and being in the top 5 economies are 2 very different things. Japan and Germany are in the top 5 economies of the world, but will never be a superpower not do they aspire too. Sure dream about being a superpower, but a superpower is not about being the largest economy, it is about influencing and policing the world - the West will never allow a nation from the SC to be a superpower, or Asia for that matter.

I am just pointing out that you claiming India is no longer a push over clearly demonstrates that India was a push over during foreign rule, otherwise you wouldn't have said it. Let it go, no one cares, history is just that, the past. You will gain no sympathy.

Every nation has its interests, but India does NOT think for itself with all the boasting, quite the opposite, India is ticking the check boxes of successful nations in the past, in other words playing catch up. If you want to be independent nation, then India should think independently, and start achieving goals that other nations have not achieved.

And speaking of culturally, Yoga? Really? Is that it in 5000 years? As for Cinema? You having a laugh? How about the Kama Sutra? Isn't that a contribution from Indian culture? Seriously, Hinduism didn't stretch around the globe in 5000 years, unlike Christianity or Islam has within 1000 years. This speaks volumes of Indian cultural exports.

I am going to go back to what I said, Hindus in India today feel they now have a sense of entitlement. The entitlement to boast, chest thump, rule over minorities (as Indians were in the past).

Not to mention, no one (Modi supporters) has answered the question on why Indians are desperate to flee a nation that is progressing (allegedly) both socially and economically? Does not make sense.

India's tune is the same - they did it, so why can't we. You want to be bold, be different.

 

[YousafTheBeast]

Corporal punishment is not allowed in India. So the teacher has to face the law.

Not a communal incident as the person who recorded the video, who is a relative of the boy has also confirmed that the boy was punished for not doing his homework.

Does everyone get slapped by other students for not doing their homework?

 

[ex-q-zit]

Being a super power and being in the top 5 economies are 2 very different things. Japan and Germany are in the top 5 economies of the world, but will never be a superpower not do they aspire too. Sure dream about being a superpower, but a superpower is not about being the largest economy, it is about influencing and policing the world - the West will never allow a nation from the SC to be a superpower, or Asia for that matter.

I am just pointing out that you claiming India is no longer a push over clearly demonstrates that India was a push over during foreign rule, otherwise you wouldn't have said it. Let it go, no one cares, history is just that, the past. You will gain no sympathy.

Every nation has its interests, but India does NOT think for itself with all the boasting, quite the opposite, India is ticking the check boxes of successful nations in the past, in other words playing catch up. If you want to be independent nation, then India should think independently, and start achieving goals that other nations have not achieved.

And speaking of culturally, Yoga? Really? Is that it in 5000 years? As for Cinema? You having a laugh? How about the Kama Sutra? Isn't that a contribution from Indian culture? Seriously, Hinduism didn't stretch around the globe in 5000 years, unlike Christianity or Islam has within 1000 years. This speaks volumes of Indian cultural exports.

I am going to go back to what I said, Hindus in India today feel they now have a sense of entitlement. The entitlement to boast, chest thump, rule over minorities (as Indians were in the past).

Not to mention, no one (Modi supporters) has answered the question on why Indians are desperate to flee a nation that is progressing (allegedly) both socially and economically? Does not make sense.

India's tune is the same - they did it, so why can't we. You want to be bold, be different.

Hinduism didn't spread around the globe as it doesn't ask to preach the word of god all over. there is no actual process to become a hindu. If you are interested you can just go to a temple and pray irrespective of which religion you are from.

When we say India is no longer a pushover we mean the earlier era when Nehru went running to UN due to Gandhian non-violence philosophy when the army needed just 3 more days to push back the tribals. Next India was offered a permanent UN Security Council seat but again he refused saying he will not take it at teh cost of China. His famous Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai came back biting him in the butt in teh form of 1962 Indo-sino war. This is what I meant not sure why to went back into pre-independence era.

If India wanted to tick the check boxes of successful we wouldn't go aginst the whole western block and buy Russian oil. India didn't support Israel and US in voting for Jeruselem as teh capital.

Whats wrong in using Yoga and Cinema as soft power? Today emminent filmakers like James Cameron and Steven Speilberg have spoken about how the interval scene of RRR stole their breath away. Today when Pakistanis open a restaurant outside pakistan they call it Indian restaurant. Why do you think so?

Indians who go abroad are mainly IT people. India produces such a high number of engineers every year that the competition is very high and demanding. Hence many go abroad. there is a difference between fleeing due to being unable to pay an electricity bill and going for opportunities. Even when we go we hear about Indians when they becomes CEOs of companies while just recently we a heard a US doctor jailed for 18 years due to terror activities. No prizes for guessing from which country the doctor hailed from.

Pakistanis being in denial is the biggest asset for India. We have seen where both teh countries are headed after 75 years. You can live in your bubble that Indian muslims are living in hell.

 

[Technics 1210]

Hinduism didn't spread around the globe as it doesn't ask to preach the word of god all over. there is no actual process to become a hindu. If you are interested you can just go to a temple and pray irrespective of which religion you are from.

When we say India is no longer a pushover we mean the earlier era when Nehru went running to UN due to Gandhian non-violence philosophy when the army needed just 3 more days to push back the tribals. Next India was offered a permanent UN Security Council seat but again he refused saying he will not take it at teh cost of China. His famous Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai came back biting him in the butt in teh form of 1962 Indo-sino war. This is what I meant not sure why to went back into pre-independence era.

If India wanted to tick the check boxes of successful we wouldn't go aginst the whole western block and buy Russian oil. India didn't support Israel and US in voting for Jeruselem as teh capital.

Whats wrong in using Yoga and Cinema as soft power? Today emminent filmakers like James Cameron and Steven Speilberg have spoken about how the interval scene of RRR stole their breath away. Today when Pakistanis open a restaurant outside pakistan they call it Indian restaurant. Why do you think so?

Indians who go abroad are mainly IT people. India produces such a high number of engineers every year that the competition is very high and demanding. Hence many go abroad. there is a difference between fleeing due to being unable to pay an electricity bill and going for opportunities. Even when we go we hear about Indians when they becomes CEOs of companies while just recently we a heard a US doctor jailed for 18 years due to terror activities. No prizes for guessing from which country the doctor hailed from.

Pakistanis being in denial is the biggest asset for India. We have seen where both teh countries are headed after 75 years. You can live in your bubble that Indian muslims are living in hell.

What are you going on about? Why are you asking "Whats wrong in using Yoga and Cinema as soft power?" when you mention in a post above "Culturally India has provided the world with Yoga in addition to cinema"? I tell you what is wrong with this lubricious statements, you are confusing soft power with cultural exports. Funny how you ignore the Kama Sutra.

Yes when it comes to Hinduism, there is no unanimous agreement even within Hindus on what Hinduism means and what it stands for. That is why the Hindutva mob are carving a version out for themselves and do indeed kill in the name of religion - do not need a religiius book to murder in the name of 100s of Gods! You call Hinduism a lifestyle and culture, well, failed as an export.

Don't compare yourself to Pakistan, if you do, it means Pakistan lives in your mind, and your Hindutva brethren's mind, rent free, just like the British do - no greater win for Pakistanis. LOL on India starting to win sporting medals, Pakistan were doing so long time before Modi was PM. Again, India is playing catch up. All you need to remember is Pakistan, carved India into 3 pieces.

The only ones in denial are Indians, like you, living in the West, and claiming India is progressing. Again, why are Indians desperate to leave India despite the bold claims of economic and social progression in India? Ahh that's right, Indians are becoming CEOs of Western companies owned by western share holders because they rather be subservient to the white man than use their skills to help develop their motherland, India. Says everything about what Indians think of their motherland.

 

[Cricket Warrior]

If India is progressing so well ok... then why hasn't it been able to improve the conditions of its people? The majority of Indians still live below the poverty line. What's the use of such progress?

Doesn't it appear to be a game of scoring points in the name of development?

 

[Technics 1210]

When the 100s of millions of poor Indians have nothing, they have nothing to lose hence they also resort to religious violence at the command of Modi - so hey can feel they stand for something and be valued! Of course depending on their caste.

The reality is that the majority are still haunted by British rule, they will not be push over, but they are desperate to migrate to the West for a better life under the rule of the "white" man. Stockholm syndrome at another level.

 

[ex-q-zit]

All the crying about Indian muslims while this is happening in Gilgit Baltistan.

[YOUTUBE]

 

[Technics 1210]

Unless Hindutva supporters can answer the question why millions of Indians are desperate to migrate to the West despite claims of India progressing socially and economically, then there'a no reason to believe the myth India is developing. If it India is not good enough for indigenous Indians, then there is nothing to believe.

Not to mention the very fact Hindutva supporters speak of social progression but refuse to condemn religious violence against minorities, you can forget social progression, this isn't even mental progression.

I am reminded of a meme I read a few days ago in relation to India's moon landing, a depiction of a graphical sprite from Galaga on the moon, with a wave of aliens above, and the title "The most expensive CGI movie at $75Million".

 

[cricketjoshila]

Could have counter it instead of banning it if it was false.
Indian courts banning a documentary does not make it disappear nor it counter it with facts, rather it shows credibility of Indian courts and validate it for the rest of the world.

Every dictator, authoritarian and religious extremist have always banned truth and this is the historical fact.

Government of India has other important works than countering a colonial mouthpiece and its agenda.

Anything in India is under the jurisdiction of Indian courts. Neither India or its courts or its people are looking at foreigners to validate how Indians run their country.

Everytime a leader of a former colony of the West has refused to follow the western agenda, western propoganda mouthpieces target him. In 70s it was Indira then Vajpayee in 90s and now Modi.And citizens of our rival countries try to take advantage of it. Alas, it fails miserably.

 

[Major]

Corporal punishment is not allowed in India. So the teacher has to face the law.

Not a communal incident as the person who recorded the video, who is a relative of the boy has also confirmed that the boy was punished for not doing his homework.

and what about the fact that the teacher was letting other kids do beat him?

 

[cricketjoshila]

So you use a source is Ind channels that are also being blackmailed probaby for tax evasion. Give me some source outside Ind or something from the BBC accounts and I will consider it.
It makes no difference if you ban it, the news is fact, Modi is a paid up member of the RSS, he played a full role in the murder of 1000 Muslims.
As far as the 1947 jibe, well you could ask your people to stay at home. I get contacted by them to rent homes in my area. Surely if you and your govt had so much ghairat they would keep them at home

Lol. First you falsely claimed that BBC was being intimidated by false raids, when your lie is exposed you now say all Indian media is being blackmailed.

)

Fact is no court in India found Modi guilty of any wrongdoing.

Fact is neither India or its courts are begging for validation of BBC or Pakistanis.

Fact is that RSS is a nationalist organisation. Pakistanis can keep hating it. Doesn't make a difference.

My people are near the top of the economic ladder in UK, while yours are near the bottom. India is the second largest FDI source for UK. The UK government is running to get a trade deal with India.

The government of UK represents the official voice of the country, neither you nor BBC.

 

[cricketjoshila]

and what about the fact that the teacher was letting other kids do beat him?

As per the police FIR and media, the teacher is handicapped and hence she asked another student to slap the kid for her.

Either way thats wrong and she must face the law.

 

[cricketjoshila]

If India is progressing so well ok... then why hasn't it been able to improve the conditions of its people? The majority of Indians still live below the poverty line. What's the use of such progress?

Doesn't it appear to be a game of scoring points in the name of development?

I guess you need to get yourself updated.

NEW DELHI: Around 415 million people exited poverty within a span of just 15 years between 2005 to 2021 in India, according to the latest Global Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI). India is also one of the 25 countries that have successfully halved their global MPI values within 15 years.

India Poverty Reduction: UN report says 415 million people exited poverty in India in 15 years | India News - Times of India

India News: Around 415 million people exited poverty within a span of just 15 years between 2005 to 2021 in India, according to the latest Global Multidimensiona

m.timesofindia.com

Less than 15 per cent of Indian population is under the povery line.

One-tenth of India's population escaped poverty in 5 years - government report

Nearly 135 million people, around 10% of India's population, escaped poverty in the five years to March 2021, a government report found on Monday.

www.reuters.com

I believe there is actual progress and not point scoring in India's progress.

Ofcourse the facts dont go well with the agenda on hand.

 

[Bewal Express]

Lol. First you falsely claimed that BBC was being intimidated by false raids, when your lie is exposed you now say all Indian media is being blackmailed.

)

Fact is no court in India found Modi guilty of any wrongdoing.

Fact is neither India or its courts are begging for validation of BBC or Pakistanis.

Fact is that RSS is a nationalist organisation. Pakistanis can keep hating it. Doesn't make a difference.

My people are near the top of the economic ladder in UK, while yours are near the bottom. India is the second largest FDI source for UK. The UK government is running to get a trade deal with India.

The government of UK represents the official voice of the country, neither you nor BBC.

So the BBC exposes your fascist and suddenly the tax investigation starts. Me thinks this isn't a coincidence

Then where is the independent verification of your the reports. The Indian media is a 161st in the media freedom index

Modi would not have been anything without the Gujarat massacre, which he not only instigated but played a full part in.

 

[cricketjoshila]

So the BBC exposes your fascist and suddenly the tax investigation starts. Me thinks this isn't a coincidence

Then where is the independent verification of your the reports. The Indian media is a 161st in the media freedom index

Modi would not have been anything without the Gujarat massacre, which he not only instigated but played a full part in.

Modi was exonerated by courts in 2012. 2 years before he became PM. That's what matters in India.

BBC has been under the lens for a long time and has been banned in India previously too.

Independent verification? Who will do it? You?

Who made this index? Which NGO?

Modi was the CM of a state before the riots. You can claim anything. It will have zero affect on India and Modi.

 

[cricketjoshila]

JAMMU
: A Class X student had to be hospitalised after being severely beaten, allegedly by the Muslim principal and a teacher of a

school
in Jammu’s Kathua district, for writing “Jai Shri Ram” on the blackboard, triggering protests that forced a shutdown of the institution

Class X student beaten for writing 'Jai Shri Ram' on school blackboard in Jammu’s Kathua - Times of India

A Class X student had to be hospitalised after being severely beaten, allegedly by the Muslim principal and a teacher of a school in Jammu’s Kathua district, for writing “Jai Shri Ram” on the blackboard, triggering protests that forced a shutdown of the institution.

m.timesofindia.com

This child has been hospitalized.

But ofcourse this news won't find any place here.

 

[Bewal Express]

JAMMU
: A Class X student had to be hospitalised after being severely beaten, allegedly by the Muslim principal and a teacher of a

school
in Jammu’s Kathua district, for writing “Jai Shri Ram” on the blackboard, triggering protests that forced a shutdown of the institution

Class X student beaten for writing 'Jai Shri Ram' on school blackboard in Jammu’s Kathua - Times of India

A Class X student had to be hospitalised after being severely beaten, allegedly by the Muslim principal and a teacher of a school in Jammu’s Kathua district, for writing “Jai Shri Ram” on the blackboard, triggering protests that forced a shutdown of the institution.

m.timesofindia.com

This child has been hospitalized.

But ofcourse this news won't find any place here.

But this was all over twitter. And the Hindutuva were all over it. Did the reporter that expose this story also get charged?

 

[KingKhanWC]

MP News: Hindu Women Beat Up Muslim Book Vendor At Ujjain Fest After He Asks Contact Details For Home Delivery; WATCH

A video has also emerged featuring the victim, Waqar Saleem, explaining the circumstances.

www.freepressjournal.in

Why dont they fight back?

 

[KingKhanWC]

Bihar: Muslim minor girl recounts horrific past as school director’s son raped her for two years

A minor school girl was allegedly raped and sexually abused multiple times for 12 months by the son of a school director in Bihar’s Saharsa.

maktoobmedia.com

It seems Indian schools have become extremist Hindutva hellholes.

Poor girl, the trauma and pain she went through for 2 years is beyond understanding.

 

[Hassan A]

Deeply saddened by this.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1699413271210774984

 

[FPresidential]

Indian constitution is secular.
India had a Muslim President.
Rapes and murder are crimes and happened all over the world.
I have many Muslim friends who have done well in India, we celebrate each other holidays. lol
Compare to Pakistan, Bharat muslims are treated way better.

Some of the repeated excuses from BJP and RSS apologist.

 

[cricketjoshila]

But this was all over twitter. And the Hindutuva were all over it. Did the reporter that expose this story also get charged?

Which reporter got charged for reporting?

 

[Hitman]

Why do you think any Indian needs to give excuses to Pakistanis?

Why?

Some of them believe we owe them explanations on what happens in our country.

A person commits a crime, he will be punished according to the law. Simple!

 

[Bewal Express]

Which reporter got charged for reporting?

The guy that broke the story

 

[KingKhanWC]

Indian constitution is secular.
India had a Muslim President.
Rapes and murder are crimes and happened all over the world.
I have many Muslim friends who have done well in India, we celebrate each other holidays. lol
Compare to Pakistan, Bharat muslims are treated way better.

Some of the repeated excuses from BJP and RSS apologist.

This is ignorance or you like other pro BJP fans/posters are knowingly lying.

From your PM, to your BJP government to hundreds of millions of Hindus, extremism and hate for Muslims is flowing their veins like water in the ganges.

Vast majority of such hate incidents are never reported or never known. Its fair to assume every day hundreds of such incident take place, only a very small amount ever make it to the news. If it werent for social media, they would be surpressed.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Some of them believe we owe them explanations on what happens in our country.

A person commits a crime, he will be punished according to the law. Simple!

Yes we saw how the law was applied when former Muslim MP Ehsan Jafri was chopped to pieces by sword wielding mobs during the Gujarat riots while the police stood watching.

 

[Hitman]

Yes we saw how the law was applied when former Muslim MP Ehsan Jafri was chopped to pieces by sword wielding mobs during the Gujarat riots while the police stood watching.

What about those 59 Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya who were burnt to death in a train in Godhra by some of those saintly muslims, due to which the riots took place in the first place?

 

[KingKhanWC]

What about those 59 Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya who were burnt to death in a train in Godhra by some of those saintly muslims, due to which the riots took place in the first place?

Do you seriously believe MORE Hindus are discriminated, attacked and abused compared to Muslims in Shining Bharatstan?

 

[FPresidential]

This is ignorance or you like other pro BJP fans/posters are knowingly lying.

From your PM, to your BJP government to hundreds of millions of Hindus, extremism and hate for Muslims is flowing their veins like water in the ganges.

Vast majority of such hate incidents are never reported or never known. Its fair to assume every day hundreds of such incident take place, only a very small amount ever make it to the news. If it werent for social media, they would be surpressed.

Bro, I think you did not quite read my post. I am neither Indian nor BJP/RSS fan.

I put RSS/Hindutva in the same category as other far right radicalized extremist groups such as Taliban, al-qaeda, Nazi, KKK etc,. the RSS/Hindutva India's radicalized group supported by majority of Indian that has the ability to buy a Gucci belt.

 

[Hitman]

Do you seriously believe MORE Hindus are discriminated, attacked and abused compared to Muslims in Shining Bharatstan?

You’d be better off worrying about the electricity bills that your people are having to pay these days. Whatever our problems are, we’ll deal with them ourselves. I don’t discriminate my countrymen, nor have I been ever discriminated by anyone till date.

 

[FPresidential]

What about those 59 Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya who were burnt to death in a train in Godhra by some of those saintly muslims, due to which the riots took place in the first place?

Another RSS/Hindutva driven response, to anyone from outside of India or anyone who do not subscribe to RSS/Hindutva ideology would leave their head scratching as to wondering what the hell kind of excuse is that?

When Hindu does it then it is a crime but when an Indian Muslim does it then it is terrorism against the rest of the Indian. Hindu retaliating against any Muslim should be acquitted but Muslim should be killed. Sound almost similar to hate group.

 

[FPresidential]

You’d be better off worrying about the electricity bills that your people are having to pay these days. Whatever our problems are, we’ll deal with them ourselves. I don’t discriminate my countrymen, nor have I been ever discriminated by anyone till date.

Your comments reveals a lot.

 

[FPresidential]

You’d be better off worrying about the electricity bills that your people are having to pay these days. Whatever our problems are, we’ll deal with them ourselves. I don’t discriminate my countrymen, nor have I been ever discriminated by anyone till date.

Why can't a person worry about 2 issues at the same time? Most Pakistani are calling out Pakistan, also.

Is this is the best response y'all can come up with? which is always, What about in Pakistan, lol

 

[Hitman]

Why can't a person worry about 2 issues at the same time? Most Pakistani are calling out Pakistan, also.

Is this is the best response y'all can come up with? which is always, What about in Pakistan, lol

The issue arises when people onboard a sinking ship on course to go down to the bottom of the Atlantic starts giving sermons to other countries regarding their internal matters.

 

[FPresidential]

The issue arises when people onboard a sinking ship on course to go down to the bottom of the Atlantic starts giving sermons to other countries regarding their internal matters.

Another BS, weak and lazy excuse.

Why can't a person from a sinking ship highlight the ignorance and hate of others?

It is just an excuse from you a lot when y'all can't defend bigotry and hate emitting toward minorities, particularly Muslims in India.

As I said, some of y'all comments are revealing.

Would it be okay for American, Denmark, Norway, etc citizens to highlight bigotry and hate of Indian? if not, then what is the excuse there? lol

 

[cricketjoshila]

The guy that broke the story

No he didn't.

Someone broke the law by posting the identity of the child and he was charged.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Another RSS/Hindutva driven response, to anyone from outside of India or anyone who do not subscribe to RSS/Hindutva ideology would leave their head scratching as to wondering what the hell kind of excuse is that?

When Hindu does it then it is a crime but when an Indian Muslim does it then it is terrorism against the rest of the Indian. Hindu retaliating against any Muslim should be acquitted but Muslim should be killed. Sound almost similar to hate group.

A Muslim mob burned a train full of Hindu pilgrims. A hindu mob retaliated.

Thats the simple fact.

A mob of Muslims, incited by politicians believed they would scare Hindus and show muscle and street power. Hindus retaliated.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Another BS, weak and lazy excuse.

Why can't a person from a sinking ship highlight the ignorance and hate of others?

It is just an excuse from you a lot when y'all can't defend bigotry and hate emitting toward minorities, particularly Muslims in India.

As I said, some of y'all comments are revealing.

Would it be okay for American, Denmark, Norway, etc citizens to highlight bigotry and hate of Indian? if not, then what is the excuse there? lol

We are not interested in how pakistanis or americans or danes or Norwegians run their country. Nor are we oblidged to answer them or listen to them.

Any person commits a crime, irrespective of religion, he or she has to be punished.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Bro, I think you did not quite read my post. I am neither Indian nor BJP/RSS fan.

I put RSS/Hindutva in the same category as other far right radicalized extremist groups such as Taliban, al-qaeda, Nazi, KKK etc,. the RSS/Hindutva India's radicalized group supported by majority of Indian that has the ability to buy a Gucci belt.

Wrong category. BJP/RSS extremists/terrorists were actually VOTED in by hundreds of millions of Hindu. No other extremist minded party/group has ever achieved this.

 

[KingKhanWC]

You’d be better off worrying about the electricity bills that your people are having to pay these days. Whatever our problems are, we’ll deal with them ourselves. I don’t discriminate my countrymen, nor have I been ever discriminated by anyone till date.

I live in the UK, my lights are on more longer than all slums in Bombay.

Lets not digress. Please answer the question.

Do you seriously believe MORE Hindus are discriminated, attacked and abused compared to Muslims in Shining Bharatstan?

 

[Bewal Express]

No he didn't.

Someone broke the law by posting the identity of the child and he was charged.

are you saying his parents didnt give permission, and where is your source for that?

 

[KingKhanWC]

Student with disability allegedly thrashed by ABVP members in JNU

The National Students' Union of India (NSUI) in JNU alleged that a Astudent with disability was attacked by some students of Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP).

www.indiatoday.in

Hindu extremist are so extremely brave they will also attack disabled people. Will their Lord be proud of them?

 

[FPresidential]

We are not interested in how pakistanis or americans or danes or Norwegians run their country. Nor are we oblidged to answer them or listen to them.

Any person commits a crime, irrespective of religion, he or she has to be punished.

Yea! You lot are very much interested in what other think of y’all. It is the front y’all put up for the rest of the India, but y’all care and if y’all didn’t y’all be openly supporting RSS and BJP goons.

No one asked any of you to answer any of us. I just highlighted as most of us already are aware of the reality of India.

Comments amd arguments aren’t made y’all obliged to asnwer, you aren’t government official and neither am I, so please stop pretending

 

[Hitman]

I live in the UK, my lights are on more longer than all slums in Bombay.

Lets not digress. Please answer the question.

Do you seriously believe MORE Hindus are discriminated, attacked and abused compared to Muslims in Shining Bharatstan?

I wasn’t speaking of you. I was speaking of your people who definitely are not in the UK.

 

[cricketjoshila]

are you saying his parents didnt give permission, and where is your source for that?

There is no option of parents giving permission. Identify of minors cannot be disclosed.

Section 74 Juvenile justice act applies here.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Yea! You lot are very much interested in what other think of y’all. It is the front y’all put up for the rest of the India, but y’all care and if y’all didn’t y’all be openly supporting RSS and BJP goons.

No one asked any of you to answer any of us. I just highlighted as most of us already are aware of the reality of India.

Comments amd arguments aren’t made y’all obliged to asnwer, you aren’t government official and neither am I, so please stop pretending

My government's opinion is very clear. We don't answer to outsiders on internal matters.

Your opinion doest make anyone terrorists or goons. Its your opinion.

Millions of Indians are members of RSS and BJP. our western neighbour not liking an organisation isn't something Indians think much about.

 

[FPresidential]

My government's opinion is very clear. We don't answer to outsiders on internal matters.

Your opinion doest make anyone terrorists or goons. Its your opinion.

Millions of Indians are members of RSS and BJP. our western neighbour not liking an organisation isn't something Indians think much about.

Members of Nazi didn’t think they were terrorists either.

Al Qaeda thought they weee figuring a religious war.

Kkk thought they were figuring a gods war.

RSS isn’t different either.

In their time, each of those organization were accepted by majority of their fellow countrymen just as you support RSS .

Again, well established, it is a forum, filled with opinions, lol. I don’t understand how is that an argument against India’s RSS documented evidence riddled bigotry, but it continues to highlight one thing, majority of Hindutva/RSS uses similar argument when their bigotry is highlighted, it’s almost expected that 90% of the RSS will come up with similar response and it helps rest of us identify them not that matter to any RSS because they got buying power of the Gucci belt

 

[Bewal Express]

There is no option of parents giving permission. Identify of minors cannot be disclosed.

Section 74 Juvenile justice act applies here.

That's interesting. Can you explain the naming of this Dalit boy and the Muslim boy.

Dalit boy beaten to death for touching water pot | NCPCR asks Rajasthan government to take strict action

Indra Meghwal, a student of a private school in Surana village of Rajasthan's Jalore district, was beaten up by his teacher on July 20 and succumbed to his injuries at a hospital in Ahmedabad on August 13.

www.thehindu.com

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

What about those 59 Hindu pilgrims and karsevaks returning from Ayodhya who were burnt to death in a train in Godhra by some of those saintly muslims, due to which the riots took place in the first place?

Even if that were true - and let's remember, every single Hindu led rampage has always been followed by a claim by hindutvas that the Muslims committed one first which led to retaliation - the point still stands. To crow about the successful law enforcement in a nation where the police stand by watching their fellow hindutvas rampage through minority districts is a joke.

 

[cricketjoshila]

That's interesting. Can you explain the naming of this Dalit boy and the Muslim boy.

Dalit boy beaten to death for touching water pot | NCPCR asks Rajasthan government to take strict action

Indra Meghwal, a student of a private school in Surana village of Rajasthan's Jalore district, was beaten up by his teacher on July 20 and succumbed to his injuries at a hospital in Ahmedabad on August 13.

www.thehindu.com

The name was revealed as the dalit boy expired. Also the name was revealed the RSCPCR.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Members of Nazi didn’t think they were terrorists either.

Al Qaeda thought they weee figuring a religious war.

Kkk thought they were figuring a gods war.

RSS isn’t different either.

In their time, each of those organization were accepted by majority of their fellow countrymen just as you support RSS .

Again, well established, it is a forum, filled with opinions, lol. I don’t understand how is that an argument against India’s RSS documented evidence riddled bigotry, but it continues to highlight one thing, majority of Hindutva/RSS uses similar argument when their bigotry is highlighted, it’s almost expected that 90% of the RSS will come up with similar response and it helps rest of us identify them not that matter to any RSS because they got buying power of the Gucci belt

Al Qaida is a UN sanctioned organisation.

NAZIs were waging wars.

I know our neighbours don't like RSS because its a Hindu organisation and a nationalist organisation.

Problem is that this won't make them a terrorist organisation. No matter how much our neighbours whine. Last time the PM of that country was ranting on twitter as everyone ignored their narrative on India and RSS.

 

[Hassan A]

Hey guys, so I've been reading up on the RSS, with open mind. While they've done their share of social work, some things bug me. Like, their whole Hindutva vibe feels a bit exclusive to non-hindus? Plus, their ties to the BJP and that whole history bit with Godse is kinda sus. And what's up with the content in their schools and those training sessions?