What's new

Pak Vs England:4th ODI @Trentbridge - Score updates [8/9/06]

Status
Not open for further replies.
yk said:
replay was flawed, says athers.

Yes it is. But unfortunately at the moment thats the way the law works - benefit of the doubt goes to the batsmen. Whether the doubt comes from foreshortening or not. If the umpires couldn't be 100% sure it gets reffered.

The law is an ass. Its got nothing to do with biased umpires. Try and see the bigger picture.
 
Rob H said:
as he is a resident 3rd umpire in international cricket?

he understands the brodcasting industry better than the 3rd umpire and has obviously researched into replays, coming to the conclusion that they are flawed.
 
Irrespective of whether it was out or not out, would anybody here have said "OUT" on the basis that the camera may be deceiving the eye? Would be one hell of a brave call, almost of Darell Hair proportions.
 
yk said:
Yeah, Athers is DEFINATELY rite, becoz of his experience as a 1st slipper for many years. If umpire was so good, why did he refer it to the 3rd umpire?

Atherton is definitley right because he's taken slip catches is he? Well so have I and say it was not out, so am I 'DEFINITLEY' right?
 
yk said:
Yeah, Athers is DEFINATELY rite, becoz of his experience as a 1st slipper for many years. If umpire was so good, why did he refer it to the 3rd umpire?
what on earth are you on about? The 3rd Umpire isn't an umpire? When saying "respect the umpire's decision" he means the 3rd umpire. YK i suggest you really you more than 1 brain cell before posting.

As for Big mac. Give over, he reiiterated it about 5 times and said it before you.
 
evertonfan said:
Atherton is definitley right because he's taken slip catches is he? Well so have I and say it was not out, so am I 'DEFINITLEY' right?

no becoz ure crap at cricket. athers was an interabtional captain, are u? athers was 1st class player, ure not. ATHERS IS RIGHT!!!!
 
yk said:
no becoz ure crap at cricket. athers was an interabtional captain, are u? athers was 1st class player, ure not. ATHERS IS RIGHT!!!!
you only agree with what you want to agree with.
 
The vidoe replays werent clear, benefit goes to batsmen.

end of story.
 
yk said:
no becoz ure crap at cricket. athers was an interabtional captain, are u? athers was 1st class player, ure not. ATHERS IS RIGHT!!!!

lol well that definitley wins the arguement.
 
yk said:
no becoz ure crap at cricket. athers was an interabtional captain, are u? athers was 1st class player, ure not. ATHERS IS RIGHT!!!!

You call me crap at cricket when you haven't seen me play? Goes to show that you are very shallow-minded indeed. Grow up soon please.

Umpire gave it not-out so you can argue all you want about it but the fact is, it wasn't given out.
 
Rob H said:
what on earth are you on about? The 3rd Umpire isn't an umpire? When saying "respect the umpire's decision" he means the 3rd umpire. YK i suggest you really you more than 1 brain cell before posting.

As for Big mac. Give over, he reiiterated it about 5 times and said it before you.

Do u really want me to MERC u? Strauss was out, he's not man enuf to admit it, just like u English fans.
 
yk said:
Do u really want me to MERC u? Strauss was out, he's not man enuf to admit it, just like u English fans.

take it easy man, Strauss probably wasnt sure and he didnt take Inzy's word, that's fair enough. The replay want conclusive so he wasnt out.
 
asif not bowling well here..
he has to be better bowler to left handers
 
evertonfan said:
You call me crap at cricket when you haven't seen me play? Goes to show that you are very shallow-minded indeed. Grow up soon please.

Umpire gave it not-out so you can argue all you want about it but the fact is, it wasn't given out.

u call me stupid wen u don't even know me, i can call u whatever i want. ure not even worth a 2 pence piece. u and ure captain are not man enuf to admit that it was OUT. wen will u learn, cheating isn't gonna win u games.
 
evertonfan said:
You call me crap at cricket when you haven't seen me play? Goes to show that you are very shallow-minded indeed. Grow up soon please.

Umpire gave it not-out so you can argue all you want about it but the fact is, it wasn't given out.



do you play international cricket?
 
yk said:
Do u really want me to MERC u? Strauss was out, he's not man enuf to admit it, just like u English fans.

Idiot.

I have a very strong feeling that if Inzamam or MoYo had been the batsmen you would be applauding the umpire for a brilliant decision. Once again I suggest you grow up and watch your cricket with a pinch of salt.
 
Rob H said:
what on earth are you on about? The 3rd Umpire isn't an umpire? When saying "respect the umpire's decision" he means the 3rd umpire. YK i suggest you really you more than 1 brain cell before posting.

As for Big mac. Give over, he reiiterated it about 5 times and said it before you.


Check the time that was posted. Athers said it 5 times in 30 seconds after the decision was given?
 
yk said:
Do u really want me to MERC u? Strauss was out, he's not man enuf to admit it, just like u English fans.
Come on! As if one of our batsmen would been given not out, would you been crying then aswell?
 
yk said:
u call me stupid wen u don't even know me, i can call u whatever i want. it that it was OUT. wen will u learn,ure not even worth a 2 pence piece.

Hypocrisy at it's best. ::J
 
yk said:
Do u really want me to MERC u? Strauss was out, he's not man enuf to admit it, just like u English fans.
Your rants are hilarious. Now when your temper tantrum is over i might be willing to have an adult conversation with you.
 
overlord said:
do you play international cricket?

Nope, but I have 24 slip catches and counting to my name on some poor pitches. I know as much about slip catching as any other.
 
evertonfan said:
Idiot.

I have a very strong feeling that if Inzamam or MoYo had been the batsmen you would be applauding the umpire for a brilliant decision. Once again I suggest you grow up and watch your cricket with a pinch of salt.


iirc Banger took a slip catch in Pakistan that this lot all cried about and refused to acknowledge the existence of a foreshortening effect despite my best efforts to educate them.
 
Rob H said:
Your rants are hilarious. Now when your temper tantrum is over i might be willing to have an adult conversation with you.

I think that's physically impossible to be honest Rob.

And as yk would say, he is being 'merk'd' here.
 
Big Mac said:
Check the time that was posted. Athers said it 5 times in 30 seconds after the decision was given?
Ok, say you said it first if it gives you pleasure. Quite convenient you both said the same thing though ;-)
 
Big Mac said:
iirc Banger took a slip catch in Pakistan that this lot all cried about and refused to acknowledge the existence of a foreshortening effect despite my best efforts to educate them.

I thank you for your post. It shows that not all Pakistan fans are ignorant fanboys.

Bad decisions happen for your side and against your side, but it's part of the game. A lot of people on these boards need to learn that.
 
Pakistan Zindabad!!!
Pakistan Zindabad!!!
Pakistan Zindabad!!!
Pakistan Zindabad!!!
Pakistan Zindabad!!!
 
evertonfan said:
I thank you for your post. It shows that not all Pakistan fans are ignorant fanboys.
yes, big mac is correct in 99% of things. You must really try and have an arguement with him in time. It's a load of fun! :D
 
Rob H said:
Ok, say you said it first if it gives you pleasure. Quite convenient you both said the same thing though ;-)


Yeah, I'll come clean with the truth. I heard Athers say it on TV and thought it sounded clever so I spent the next 30 years of my life developing a time machine so I could go back to that moment in time and post it first to try and seem clever and impress a total bunch of strangers on the internet.

Nothing gets past you does it?
 
Rob H said:
Your rants are hilarious. Now when your temper tantrum is over i might be willing to have an adult conversation with you.

Go on then, present ure argument, ure not gonna win. The ball CLEARLY went into Inzi's hands. His fingers were under the ball, otherwise it wud have popped out.
 
yk said:
Staruss was out.

You seen the scoreboard lately? It's actually Joyce who is out. Strauss is still there. Your not blind as well as stupid are you? Poor chap.
 
Still choking at Holding trying to claim there's a mark on the ground where the ball bounces.

Unfortunately he's can't see that the same mark is on the ground before the ball ever gets to Inzi.
 
personally akmal should have gone for that....its hard to give the bat out on inzi catch....rem during the winter series...we were fuming when tresco and colly took similar catches and umpires gave them out...and we know they weren't out....although its unlucky that umpires never go our way....but then that why we are brown
 
evertonfan said:
You seen the scoreboard lately? It's actually Joyce who is out. Strauss is still there. Your not blind as well as stupid are you? Poor chap.

IDIOT, i posted that 2 overs before joyce was out, silly DUNGAR!!!

ure the one who's blind, silly girl.
 
Big Mac said:
Still choking at Holding trying to claim there's a mark on the ground where the ball bounces.

Unfortunately he's can't see that the same mark is on the ground before the ball ever gets to Inzi.

Init, holding is just an IDIOT!!!
 
Ranas lack of control has been a problem thru his whole career, yes he takes wkts but hes got to improve his economy!
 
yk said:
IDIOT, i posted that 2 overs before joyce was out, silly DUNGAR!!!

ure the one who's blind, silly girl.

I know it was, the wicket fell whilst I was posting. And i'm am an A* student who is in fact male and in full control of his vision.

MERKED!!

What a stupid phrase.
 
The way the ball is swinging for Rana into Strauss, better off putting fine leg on the boundary.
 
evertonfan said:
I know it was, the wicket fell whilst I was posting. And i'm am an A* student who is in fact male and in full control of his vision.

MERKED!!

What a stupid phrase.

SILLY GIRL!! thats who u are. go 2 ure mum and cry in her arms becoz England will lose.

A* :))) yeah and i have a PHD, and pigs can fly.

Boasting about ure own achievements, that shows how silly u are, and how much of a girl u are, u need to announce ureself on the seen, i EARN respect not beg for it.
 
Last edited:
we need some maiden over..

Pakistan bowling is bowling a bit short here...
 
yk said:
SILLY GIRL!! thats who u are. go 2 ure mum and cry in her arms becoz England will lose.

A* :))) yeah and i have a PHD, and pigs can fly.

Would you like to see my report and results card?

Somehow I get the feelign that you would argue with solid facts and hard evidence.

You are the most childish poster I have ever come across. Even your insults are childish.

It really is comical reading your 'posts'.

And I don't live with my mum, and England will lose. There, I said we'd lose, now go and hug up to your teddy bear and suck on your thumb.
 
yk said:
SILLY GIRL!! thats who u are. go 2 ure mum and cry in her arms becoz England will lose.

A* :))) yeah and i have a PHD, and pigs can fly.

Boasting about ure own achievements, that shows how ure silly u are, and how much of a girl u are, u need to announce ureself on the seen, i EARN respect not beg for it.


He can spell though.
 
evertonfan said:
Would you like to see my report and results card?

Somehow I get the feelign that you would argue with solid facts and hard evidence.

You are the most childish poster I have ever come across. Even your insults are childish.

It really is comical reading your 'posts'.

And I don't live my mum, and England will lose. There, I said we'd lose, now go and hug up to your teddy bear and suck on your thumb.


Try to be a bit more optimistic
 
evertonfan said:
Would you like to see my report and results card?

Somehow I get the feelign that you would argue with solid facts and hard evidence.

You are the most childish poster I have ever come across. Even your insults are childish.

It really is comical reading your 'posts'.

And I don't live with my mum, and England will lose. There, I said we'd lose, now go and hug up to your teddy bear and suck on your thumb.

Boasting about ure own achievements, that shows how silly u are, and how much of a girl u are, u need to announce ureself on the seen, i EARN respect not beg for it.
 
yk said:
Boasting about ure own achievements, that shows how silly u are, and how much of a girl u are, u need to announce ureself on the seen, i EARN respect not beg for it.

Yet you aren't earning much respect at the moment. ::J

And you posted that twice...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top