Ravindra Jadeja vs Shahid Afridi - Who is a better ODI all-rounder?

[RexRex]

Both are known for choking with bat and ball, but can do some solid work in the field.

 

[MP2011]

As a batsman alone: Afridi is better even after accounting for his countless 0 (1).

As a bowler alone, Afridi is comfortably better than Jadeja.

As a fielder alone, Jadeja comfortably beats Afridi.

So there you go, Afridi trumps Jadeja in 2/3 disciplines in LoIs.

 

[marlonbrowndo]

Jadeja is probably the greatest all round fielder ever. But I would take Afridi over Jadeja any day in LOIs especially in a team that is already strong.