What's new

Rishabh Pant : Performance Watch

Sanju Samson is still the best wicket keeper batsman in India. This guy is a level below him. Samson bats a lot like Rohit Sharma and is very good across formats. He has some temperamental issues but hopefully he’ll sort that out soon. Heard he’s practising Yoga and meditation at a famous Yoga centre.

I don’t know why people here ignore him. He’s head and shoulders above ‘Pant the leg side hack’ as a batsman and keeper.

Samson can’t buy a run in Ranji trophy where Pant hits 6s for fun. Has himself to blame, fluffed so many chances for India A. Will need a big FCseason to come back in the reckoning. At 24, he is still young and have age on his side.
 
As a batsman, in tests this year, Pant has scored better than Bairstow, Watling, De Kock, Paine, Dowrich, Dickwella and Sarfaraz. Only Foakes and Mushfiqur have been better. Not bad for a ‘leg side hack’.
 
Samson can’t buy a run in Ranji trophy where Pant hits 6s for fun. Has himself to blame, fluffed so many chances for India A. Will need a big FCseason to come back in the reckoning. At 24, he is still young and have age on his side.

I hope he makes a strong comeback. It’s a treat to watch him bat when he’s in form. He’s getting married this month.
 
Sanju Samson is still the best wicket keeper batsman in India. This guy is a level below him. Samson bats a lot like Rohit Sharma and is very good across formats. He has some temperamental issues but hopefully he’ll sort that out soon. Heard he’s practising Yoga and meditation at a famous Yoga centre.

I don’t know why people here ignore him. He’s head and shoulders above ‘Pant the leg side hack’ as a batsman and keeper.

He has moved himself way down in the peking order. Wont get chance before pant, kishan, dk are tried out and failed.
Now one good season wont do for him, needs 2 back to back great seasons.
 
Ends his debut year (rather first 6 months) with the best dismissals per innings of 2.6 and anew record for an Indian keeer in a test series with 20 dismissals. Also most runs in this calendar year by any wk-batsman

8 tests, 537 runs@39 and 42 dismissals

His 537 runs and 42 dismissals are already the most in a calendar year by all Indian keepers other than Dhoni.
 
Sanju Samson is still the best wicket keeper batsman in India. This guy is a level below him. Samson bats a lot like Rohit Sharma and is very good across formats. He has some temperamental issues but hopefully he’ll sort that out soon. Heard he’s practising Yoga and meditation at a famous Yoga centre.

I don’t know why people here ignore him. He’s head and shoulders above ‘Pant the leg side hack’ as a batsman and keeper.

his keeping is not good, but he's a very good batsman but often throw his wicket away..
 
Anyone being harsh on this guy must remember just a year back everyone thought of him as a slogger who would play some IPL and might not even make it to Indian team.

The IPL 2018 changed it all and him coming into the test side was a huge surprise.

To his credit he’s shown a lot of promise in his first year. Give him some time to develop the keeping skills.

With the bat he is confortably the best wicket keeper in India.
 
his keeping is not good, but he's a very good batsman but often throw his wicket away..

Because most of his test career, he’s batted with the worst tail in the world. Good thing technically, he’s shown many glitches and has looked to become more comfortable vs the pacers.
 
Anyone being harsh on this guy must remember just a year back everyone thought of him as a slogger who would play some IPL and might not even make it to Indian team.

The IPL 2018 changed it all and him coming into the test side was a huge surprise.

To his credit he’s shown a lot of promise in his first year. Give him some time to develop the keeping skills.

With the bat he is confortably the best wicket keeper in India.

There was no surprise on his test chance. He has dominated in Ranji trophy.
 
He has scored his runs without any fuss. Looks at ease while batting. I didn't think he's this good. But again, my opinion as based on hismany headless chicken innings in T20Is
 
Ends his debut year (rather first 6 months) with the best dismissals per innings of 2.6 and anew record for an Indian keeer in a test series with 20 dismissals. Also most runs in this calendar year by any wk-batsman

8 tests, 537 runs@39 and 42 dismissals

His 537 runs and 42 dismissals are already the most in a calendar year by all Indian keepers other than Dhoni.

Great record given how his first two tours are some of the toughest Test Cricket has to offer.
 
It was fairly obvious what I meant, but it is also obvious that you are only interested in having an argument. I will take the bait, but only partially.

He is obviously not a finished article yet because of his inexperience, but it is very clear to anyone with a half-decent understanding of the game that he is extremely gifted. His ability to strike the ball, his bat speed and timing are so good. He is not very balanced at the crease but that can be worked on.

Of course talent alone is not everything, but he also has the fearless attitude to back it up and India very rarely lets talented players go to waste. All he needs to do is to develop more composure and he will be devastating.

They have a gem at their hands who could potentially serve them in all three formats for the next 10 years.

If you look at the WK batsmen produced by Asian teams since Dhoni emerged in 2004-05, he has a higher ceiling than all of them.

Since the retirement of Dhoni, in spite of being the number one team, India’s WKs were not big contributors with the bat in Test cricket.

Saha was brilliant with the gloves, but a substandard batsman who could only block on a good day, while Karthik has always been mediocre.

Having a WK who could come in after their top class batting lineup and smash a rapid 100 is something that they have missed for a while. Pant is going to bring that dimension to their lineup.

Not seeking any argument. Just pointing out the typical lofty but unsubstantiated claims you're always making around here to keep with the persona ;)

All that you've highlighted is based on conjecture rather than facts. Also, apart from all the generic catch phrases, what do you even mean when you say "he has a higher ceiling than all of them"? :))) If that is all that you can come up with to back your typically OTT claim, then I have nothing to say.

Also, we've heard all what you said about many players (including Indians). However, it doesn't change the fact that a 3 ODI sample size (that too with a mighty average of 20 something) is not even remotely sufficient to form any sort of hypothesis.

He might be talented, but that's where the hype the ends for now.

I hope you learned something today.
 
My post earlier today on another thread for Pant : Just 21 & a hugely exciting prospect . He needs to hone his keeping skills a bit & if he can reach the Saha level as far as keeping goes , we have someone who would be a Champ for next 10-12 years easily .
 
some fans were advocating for Sanju Samson,someone who doesn't even keep for his state side now and has failed badly with the bat in Ranjis


those who consider Pant just an "IPL superstar" don't follow Indian domestic cricket or junior level cricket
Pant has come through the domestic system and deserved his place in the test side
 
He is also the second visiting keeper in history to score hundreds in both England and Australia.

The only other player being Jeff Dujon in 1980s for Windies
 
Highest scores by Asian WKs outside sub-continent

159 R PANT, SCG, 2019
159 Mushfiqur Rahim, Wellington, 2017
137 Moin Khan, Hamilton, 2003
126 D Chandimal, Chester-le-Street, 2016
 
Another OTT thread by the OP. He is an average batsman. Making 10 balls 20 runs in test cricket won't make him look like an aggressive batsman. He has zero game awareness. He should improve it first.

you are lacking game awareness, maybe you should take a break and improve it first
 
you are lacking game awareness, maybe you should take a break and improve it first
It took you so long to respond to my post. How about you improve your forum and thread awareness? :inti

As I said earlier, I am hoping that this performance will help him get back into the indian ODI and world cup team.
 
lol

your blind hatred for IPL is clouding your judgement

As predicted way before the Aus series, KL Rahul did nothing in this test series. If he has, kindly show me the highlights.

And I wasn't the one who dropped Rishabh Pant from the ODI team either. May be one of the selector let his IPL hatred cloud his judgement regarding exclusion of Pant? :inti
 
His keeping in Tests leaves lot be desired.

Rewind exactly 15 years back, an exciting teenager debuted in England and came to Australia with the team (India). He missed crucial chances and India could not win the Sydney test. He never recovered from there, nor did India came close to winning the series in Australia.
 
His keeping in Tests leaves lot be desired.

Rewind exactly 15 years back, an exciting teenager debuted in England and came to Australia with the team (India). He missed crucial chances and India could not win the Sydney test. He never recovered from there, nor did India came close to winning the series in Australia.

Pant is a very fine keeper, happy to know how many chances has he missed in his short test cricket career? If you are going to come up with a number like 1/2/3, then don't bother. Even Gilchrist would miss 1-2 chances every 5 test matches. People who are criticizing Pant have no real basis for it, some flimsy arguments.

And if you haven't figured out yet the difference between quality and confidence level of Parthik Patel and Pant, then what can one say.
 
I am old enough to know the hype, Parthiv Patel was hyped good enough. Gilchrist era had just started and people were not expecting wicket keepers to blaze away with batting then.

My comment was about wicket keeping only. His major job is to keep wickets. In important matches chances missed will change the course of the game. Its good to have a good batsman but taking regulation catches is very important for a keeper.
 
It took you so long to respond to my post. How about you improve your forum and thread awareness? :inti

As I said earlier, I am hoping that this performance will help him get back into the indian ODI and world cup team.

Man you are highly biased poster. You always look down on IPL stars and make very immature comments about them. Once they perform on high stage you don't even have the class to admit you were wrong.
 
Superb batting display by Pant today. Great young Talent. hope he becomes the regular keeper for India. A potential Match winner
 
Man you are highly biased poster. You always look down on IPL stars and make very immature comments about them. Once they perform on high stage you don't even have the class to admit you were wrong.

Don't talk about class here. Because I have a class to post in this thread even when he is performing good once in 5-6 innings but I don't see guys like you anywhere near this thread when he performs badly. Shows your class and how consistent some of you are. :inti
 
Just a matter of time before he overtakes Mushfiqur Rahim as the best Asian wicket keeper batsman and with his ceiling he has what it takes to reach or perhaps go beyond what Gilchrist achieved in his career. You could see from his FC stats prior to his international debut that this guy is something special.
 
Don't talk about class here. Because I have a class to post in this thread even when he is performing good once in 5-6 innings but I don't see guys like you anywhere near this thread when he performs badly. Shows your class and how consistent some of you are. :inti

cut the c*** about performing once in 5-6 innings. He has performed with bat in most of his test inningses. He has two hundreds, two fifties and many twenties and thirtees. He was hyped for his batting prowess and he has lived up to it until. Don't say he hasn't. He is a top seven player and some of the shots he played oozed class yesterday. See his cover and on drives. There wasn't a time in whole series when any of the bowlers hurried him. These are the bowlers bowling at 145+. So he is hyped for a reason and whenever he was given fair chances he has delivered.
 
cut the c*** about performing once in 5-6 innings. He has performed with bat in most of his test inningses. He has two hundreds, two fifties and many twenties and thirtees. He was hyped for his batting prowess and he has lived up to it until. Don't say he hasn't. He is a top seven player and some of the shots he played oozed class yesterday. See his cover and on drives. There wasn't a time in whole series when any of the bowlers hurried him. These are the bowlers bowling at 145+. So he is hyped for a reason and whenever he was given fair chances he has delivered.
Yes he is hyped. And most of the time people who hype players are the first ones to abuse them too. Recent example is KL Rahul.

Hopefully you will continue your participation in this thread in the near future as well. Till then you can enjoy his 20s and 30s. :inti
 
Yes he is hyped. And most of the time people who hype players are the first ones to abuse them too. Recent example is KL Rahul.

Hopefully you will continue your participation in this thread in the near future as well. Till then you can enjoy his 20s and 30s. :inti

In 10 odd tests, he already got a test century in Eng and Aust. Only 2nd keeper after Dujon to have a test century in 1st tour of Aust. How is he hyped again?
 
I am old enough to know the hype, Parthiv Patel was hyped good enough. Gilchrist era had just started and people were not expecting wicket keepers to blaze away with batting then.

My comment was about wicket keeping only. His major job is to keep wickets. In important matches chances missed will change the course of the game. Its good to have a good batsman but taking regulation catches is very important for a keeper.

And I ask again, please tell how many regulation catches has he missed until now? Some objectivity would add a lot of value to this debate than some generic statements. Just like you are old enough to know the hype, I am experienced enough to say that Pant is here to stay, he ain't going anywhere. There are some players who make it obvious that they are destined for bigger things, and Pant is that case.
 
I have to be honest. If pant was playing against Warne or Brett lee or heck even Gillespie he would have been feasted upon. He got lucky that he was playing with handicap bowlers who are no where near the goat Australian bowlers from the 90’s and late 2000.
 
I have to be honest. If pant was playing against Warne or Brett lee or heck even Gillespie he would have been feasted upon. He got lucky that he was playing with handicap bowlers who are no where near the goat Australian bowlers from the 90’s and late 2000.

Isn't that true for pretty much every single batsman out there including the likes of Kohli, Williamson or this this criteria is to be applied selectively?
 
Yes he is hyped. And most of the time people who hype players are the first ones to abuse them too. Recent example is KL Rahul.

Hopefully you will continue your participation in this thread in the near future as well. Till then you can enjoy his 20s and 30s. :inti

His consistent 30s with 159 in one innings has put him as third highest scorer in this series.
 
I have to be honest. If pant was playing against Warne or Brett lee or heck even Gillespie he would have been feasted upon. He got lucky that he was playing with handicap bowlers who are no where near the goat Australian bowlers from the 90’s and late 2000.

So may be he should go back in time and play against Warne or Brett Lee but since he can't go back in time, so he should not score runs now? What exactly is the logic and that you think you are honest about it, worries me about you. Cricketers will come and go, the worst thing you could do is to loose your mind over it and imagine some weird logics.
 
I have to be honest. If pant was playing against Warne or Brett lee or heck even Gillespie he would have been feasted upon. He got lucky that he was playing with handicap bowlers who are no where near the goat Australian bowlers from the 90’s and late 2000.

You mean the brett Lee that Parthiv patel man handled in the sydney test? lol
 
Pant
Shaw
Gill

That's quite a collection of talent India have in their reserves.
 
Will be interesting to see how he does in this T20I series. Team line-up they sent out slotted him at No. 3.
 
78 from Risabh Pant today for Delhi Capitals vs Mumbai
 
India needs Pant to fire all cylinders in the IPL to make it to the CWC squad.
 
Virat Kohli Reveals Why Dinesh Karthik Was Picked Over Rishabh Pant In India World Cup Team

India World Cup 2019 team was announced last month with couple of selections going on to become major talking points. One of them was Dinesh Karthik's inclusion as the second wicketkeeper ahead of young sensation Rishabh Pant. And while chief selector MSK Prasad made it amply clear it was unfortunate that Rishabh Pant missed out, the decision was taken keeping in mind Dinesh Karthik's experience. Now, India captain Virat Kohli has stressed on the same point, saying Karthik's experience and composure in crunch situations helped him pip Rishabh Pant.


MS Dhoni will be India's designated first-choice wicketkeeper in England and Wales with MSK Prasad making it clear that the 33-year-old Karthik will only play if Dhoni gets injured during the World Cup 2019.

Teams can change players until May 23 and several former players believe India will miss 21-year-old Rishabh Pant in the showpiece which gets underway on May 30.

"In pressure situations, he's shown composure," Virat Kohli told the Times of India about Karthik. "It was something that everybody on board was convinced about.

"He has the experience. If, god forbid, something happens to MS (Dhoni), Karthik can be immensely valuable behind the wickets. As a finisher, he's done well.

"So, it was the overall exposure to a tournament of this magnitude that was taken into primary consideration."

The 33-year-old Karthik, from Tamil Nadu, made both his white and red-ball debuts for the national side before MS Dhoni.

This is only the second time that he has made it to the 15-man squad for the World Cup, the first time being in 2007.

Karthik made his one-day international debut in 2004 and has played 91 matches for India in the format, compared with left-handed batsman Pant who has played just five after making his 50-over debut last October.

Karthik, who has also played 26 Tests for India, has the ability to bat anywhere in the batting order which makes him a limited-overs asset.

"We can very well imagine there's more than an opinion in place that some capable guys have missed out," India coach Ravi Shastri added. "Heart goes out to them.

"Picking 15 from an immensely talented pool is never easy. I'd say to these guys: Keep going the way you have. Be prepared, in case there's an unforeseen requirement that pops up."

India begin their bid for a third World Cup title against South Africa in Southampton on June 5.

https://sports.ndtv.com/world-cup-2...abh-pant-in-india-2019-world-cup-team-2038000
 
lol at Kohli. No wonder we're doomed even before the start of this WC.
 
So Pant makes his way to the squad after all although not quite in the way Indian man’s wished.

Replacing Dhawan is going to be a huge task.

I would play him in the XI. Definitely an asset who doesn’t belong on the bench.

Play him strategically at #4

He is a match winner.

Let’s hope Rahul takes on the opening role with no problem.
 
MS Dhoni ruled himself out of the upcoming tour of West Indies and that paved the way for Rishabh Pant to be included in the India squad as the lone wicketkeeper-batsman. The selection committee, led by MSK Prasad on Sunday announced the squads for the Windies tour with Pant being picked for all the three formats for India. During the announcement, chief selector, MSK Prasad said that they (selectors) are looking to groom Rishabh Pant for the future while keeping an eye on his workload. The chief selector also stressed on the fact that Pant will be playing in all three formats.

The selection committee has also granted MS Dhoni his request for a break from the West Indies tour. Dhoni had made himself unavailable for the tour as he decided to take a two-month break and serve his army regiment. Dhoni is an Honorary Lieutenant Colonel in the Parachute Regiment of the Territorial Army.

"He (Dhoni) is unavailable for this series. We had certain roadmaps till World Cup and we subsequently have some plans and we want to groom Pant and that is the plan right now. Pant hasn't done anything wrong for his non-inclusion in the playing XI," said MSK Prasad while announcing the squad.

"Rishabh Pant will be playing all the three formats so we will have to look about his workload management. Saha and KS Bharat will come into picture at some point," MSK Prasad added.

The chief selector also highlighted that Andhra's wicketkeeper-batsman KS Bharat was very close to being picked in the squad but since Wriddhiman Saha was fit, he got the nod.

"In the longer format, KS Bharat was very, very close to get selected. We have an unwritten norm when a senior cricketer is injured, he should get a comeback opportunity. That's what we have given to Saha," said Prasad.

The BCCI chief selector further said that the squads for the West Indies tour have been announced keeping in consideration the performances of the players who are playing for India 'A' in the Caribbean Islands.

Shreyas Iyer, Manish Pandey, Rahul Chahar, Navdeep Saini and Krunal Pandya are among the ones who have been playing for India 'A' against West Indies 'A'.

"We have taken India 'A' performances into consideration," said Prasad. All-rounder Hardik Pandya, who suffered from a groin injury during the World Cup, has been rested for the entire tour.

Pant was not included in the initial World Cup squad and was then called in as a replacement for Shikhar Dhawan, who got injured during India's league stage match against Australia. Prasad said that the 21-year-old was drafted into the World Cup squad on the insistence of the team management who felt the need of a left-handed batsman at the top of the order.

"I don't do press conference in between any series and that has led to speculations. When Dhawan got injured, we already had a third opener in KL (Rahul). We didn't have a left-hander at top so the team management had requested for a left-hander and we had no option other than Pant. It confused many why middle-order came in for opener," said Prasad.

ndia's tour of West Indies will take place from August 3 to September 3 and will be held in the Caribbean islands and the US.

The tour kicks off with two T20Is at the Broward County Stadium in Florida, US -- played on August 3 and 4. Both teams will then travel to Guyana to play the final T20I on August 6 at the Guyana National Stadium.

After that, both the teams play the first ODI of the three-match series at the same ground in Guyana on August 8, followed by the remaining two 50-over matches to be played at the Queen's Park Oval in Trinidad on August 11 and 14.

The two Tests, which are part of the ICC Test Championship, will be played at the Vivian Richards Cricket Ground in Antigua (August 22-26) and at Sabina Park in Jamaica (August 30-September 3).

https://sports.ndtv.com/west-indies...atsman-says-chief-selector-msk-prasad-2072942
 
This is his chance to prove his mettle as Windies have good pace bowlers who have troubled English batsmen last time.
 
Not picked for the 1st Test vs SA - Saha preferred over him.
 
What kind of decision is this?
He avgs 45 in tests and has done what no ind wktkeeper ever did.
This is a joke.

He avgs 92 in india.

But i am not much worried coz ultimately pant will be back.
 
He needs some time off, he will comeback though. Good decision to bring back Saha. Next level keeper
 
Great decision by Indian selectors. He should go back to domestic cricket and learn to play responsibly.

Also I find it funny that some of his fans were bringing in his test stats to justify his selection in LOI's but here he has been replaced by Saha who was dropped unfairly after his injury. :inti
 
What kind of decision is this?
He avgs 45 in tests and has done what no ind wktkeeper ever did.
This is a joke.

He avgs 92 in india.

But i am not much worried coz ultimately pant will be back.

Btw Saha has just scored 52 runs with bat in his last 7 innings at an average of 13 before injury.
Rishabh Pant, who had a bad WI tour still scored 58 runs at 19.33 before all those 100s in Australia & England.
Now don't come at me & say that Saha deserved the chance.
 
So pant dropped from tests due to poor batting in ODIs?

Rohit Sharma to open in tests due to brilliant performance in LOIs.

Saha 34 replaces Pant 22.

Sharma is 32 and he will likely delay or shut the door on two immensely talented 20yr olds.

God save indian cricket.
 
Btw Saha has just scored 52 runs with bat in his last 7 innings at an average of 13 before injury.
Rishabh Pant, who had a bad WI tour still scored 58 runs at 19.33 before all those 100s in Australia & England.
Now don't come at me & say that Saha deserved the chance.

Saha was dropped after getting injured. He deserves this last chance. Stop crying for once. :inti
 
So pant dropped from tests due to poor batting in ODIs?

Rohit Sharma to open in tests due to brilliant performance in LOIs.

Saha 34 replaces Pant 22.

Sharma is 32 and he will likely delay or shut the door on two immensely talented 20yr olds.

God save indian cricket.

Well what goes around comes back around. His fans were using his test stats as the basis of his selection in LOI's. As soon as someone critcised him they used to show those two hundreds out of which one was useless.

Now he is dropped from the test team after poor showing in test series against West Indies and LOI series against South Africa. Team management and selectors did the right thing. They should have done the same with KL Rahul too but they kept delaying it and waiting for him to come back to form. :inti
 
So pant dropped from tests due to poor batting in ODIs?

Rohit Sharma to open in tests due to brilliant performance in LOIs.

Saha 34 replaces Pant 22.

Sharma is 32 and he will likely delay or shut the door on two immensely talented 20yr olds.

God save indian cricket.

Pant is dropped because Kaptaan Kohli doesn't want him to end up like KL Rahul. It's time for Pant to go back to first class and score runs its as simple as that. Pant needs a mentor.

Saha adds a lot of value with his keeping and his chemistry with Jadeja and Ashwin. India was still winning Test matches with Saha.

Sharma had to be given chance or else Kohli had max couple of years as captain. Sharma has massive fan following and media is responsible for his return or else there are good upcoming openers, really good ones.
 
Btw Saha has just scored 52 runs with bat in his last 7 innings at an average of 13 before injury.
Rishabh Pant, who had a bad WI tour still scored 58 runs at 19.33 before all those 100s in Australia & England.
Now don't come at me & say that Saha deserved the chance.
This selection shows that this team management doesn't know how to nurture young talent. Sad days for indian cricket.

We lost three icc tourneys in finals due to these old "has beens" and now we are heading towards the same in tests.
And yes raina is also coming back.
All hail CSK.Chinna thala.
 
This selection shows that this team management doesn't know how to nurture young talent. Sad days for indian cricket.

We lost three icc tourneys in finals due to these old "has beens" and now we are heading towards the same in tests.
And yes raina is also coming back.
All hail CSK.Chinna thala.

We will not win anything under Virat Kohli. He is too self centered and too egoistic.
 
Pant is dropped because Kaptaan Kohli doesn't want him to end up like KL Rahul. It's time for Pant to go back to first class and score runs its as simple as that. Pant needs a mentor.

Saha adds a lot of value with his keeping and his chemistry with Jadeja and Ashwin. India was still winning Test matches with Saha.

Sharma had to be given chance or else Kohli had max couple of years as captain. Sharma has massive fan following and media is responsible for his return or else there are good upcoming openers, really good ones.
Pant's keeping was fabulous during windies series. He didn't even drop a single clear chance, what else does the team expect.

Secondly, pant averages 51 in first class cricket.
He's still in the squad so don't why you think he will be sent back to domestics.
 
This selection shows that this team management doesn't know how to nurture young talent. Sad days for indian cricket.

We lost three icc tourneys in finals due to these old "has beens" and now we are heading towards the same in tests.
And yes raina is also coming back.
All hail CSK.Chinna thala.
Lol you change your opinions like a chameleon.

This is what you were saying in the other Rishabh Pant thread 3-4 days ago about Ravi Shastri who is also part of this team management.
Finally, the coach has declared that pant will be backed to the hilt.
He is a very special player its good that both kohli and ravi believe in him.

So for all the haters:
Pant will be backed until he becomes consistent, it might take 30 or 40 or 80 matches, doesn't matter. He is the chosen one.

Can you see your hypocrisy clearly now? Lol at the chosen one. :inti
 
I agree with dropping Pant. But bringing back Saha must be a joke.

India does not look to the future. Why not Samson or Kishan?

Saha is pathetic with the bat. He lengthens our tail even more. If it is just about keeping abilities, then Pant did pretty well in West Indies Tests behind the wickets. So obvioulsly this is about batting failures of Pant. But bringing Saha as replacement is a joke.

Shastri must go. His penchant for oldies is terrible.
 
Pant's keeping was fabulous during windies series. He didn't even drop a single clear chance, what else does the team expect.

Secondly, pant averages 51 in first class cricket.
He's still in the squad so don't why you think he will be sent back to domestics.

Correct! It is about Pant's batting, if Kohli and his friend Shastri mismanage Pant then they will be heavily criticised by media. Yes media influence is massive in Indian cricket. Kaptaan has done lab experiments with KL Rahul, mainly because of pathetic IPL media hype.

Its not about how much he averages in domestics, its about coming back mentally stronger. Selectors will be looking out for how he performs in certain situations.

Setbacks are integral part of player development. This is more of an intervention program for Pant.
 
A terrible, negative decision. Pant is a phenomenal talent who needs full backing from Kohli and the selectors. He needs a new dimension to this Indian team and elevates them.

Saha is a wonderful keeper but is bog average with the bat and has minimal impact on the game.

Hopefully this decision will backfire because that is what India deserves.
 
So pant dropped from tests due to poor batting in ODIs?

Rohit Sharma to open in tests due to brilliant performance in LOIs.

Saha 34 replaces Pant 22.

Sharma is 32 and he will likely delay or shut the door on two immensely talented 20yr olds.

God save indian cricket.

It's disgusting what is happening . I'm not against Saha but dropping pant after 1 test series is just lame. Not to mention opening with that test match ttf.
 
Back
Top