What's new

Unlike theocratic states like Pakistan and America, India is secular, says Indian Defence Minister

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
He also said children of Jammu and Kashmir are "nationalists" and "sometimes they are motivated in the wrong direction."

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh on Wednesday said Indian values consider all religions equal, and that is why “the country is secular and never became a theocratic state like Pakistan.”

Speaking at the NCC Republic Day Camp in Delhi, Mr. Singh said: “We (India) said we would not discriminate among religions. Why did we do that? Our neighbouring country has declared that their State has a religion. They have declared themselves a theocratic State. We didn’t declare so.”

“Even America is a theocratic country. India is not a theocratic country. Why? Because our saints and seers did not just consider the people living within our borders as part of the family, but called everyone living in the world as one family,” the Minister said.

Mr. Singh underlined that India had never declared its religion would be Hindu, Sikh or Buddhist and people of all religions could live here.

“They gave the slogan of ‘Vasudev Kutumbakam’ — the whole world is one family. This message has gone to the whole world from here only,” he added.

He also said children of Jammu and Kashmir are "nationalists" and shouldn’t be seen in any other way. "Sometimes they are motivated in the wrong direction," he added, when asked about his kids in the State who are being motivated to join the National Cadet Corps.

“Youngsters are youngsters. Sometimes, the way they should be motivated, people do not motivate them. In fact, they are motivated in the wrong direction. That is why the kids should not be blamed for this. The ones who are motivating them in wrong direction are the culprits,” the Defence Minister added.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...ecular-says-rajnath-singh/article30622613.ece
 
Comparing India favourably to the US kind of kills the argument. Should have just stuck with the usual Pakistan obsession, it would have been more credible. Though barely.
 
Comparing India favourably to the US kind of kills the argument. Should have just stuck with the usual Pakistan obsession, it would have been more credible. Though barely.

Fully agree. While Pakistan isn't a full-blown theocracy, parallels can be made.

The US is fully secular, just that there is a lot of Christian bias and elements which are prevalent in certain areas.

Laughable statement.
 
Fully agree. While Pakistan isn't a full-blown theocracy, parallels can be made.

The US is fully secular,
just that there is a lot of Christian bias and elements which are prevalent in certain areas.

Laughable statement.

Not even close to being fully secular. There are numerous laws which are not secular.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-35990353

India is a Hindutva state , laughable to call it secular.

There is no real secular state imo.
 
India is secular by constitution. The reality is a bit different. Especially in the Northern Part of India.

US is the greatest nation ever and it fully protects the rights of every citizen irrespective of Religoin/Race/Sex etc. It is as close to being perfect as possible along with some European nations and Aus/NZ.
 
Not even close to being fully secular. There are numerous laws which are not secular.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-35990353

India is a Hindutva state , laughable to call it secular.

There is no real secular state imo.

Oh damn, I guess I was wrong. I was thinking constitutionally it was, but if those kind of laws are allowed to be passed, then I'm unsure it can be called as such.
 
Back
Top