[VIDEOS] Bazball cannot disguise Test cricket's weakest era

No DRS meant batters could play spinners with impunity with their pads.
The advent of DRS has necessitated a change in technique of players against spin — Swann has spoken about this eloquently.

Correct. DRS has altered Cricketing techniques like nothing ever before. Infact it completely trashes the "conventional" wisdom that the old foggies would drone about non-stop. Best thing to have ever happened to Test Cricket.

My only wish is that they get rid of the umpires call nonsense.
 
After the ball hits the pad, the rest of its trajectory is a prediction. Therefore there will always be some margin of error. Umpire's call allows for that margin of error.

I know but its the only loophole that is subjective ... have to make it fully autonomous and take the umpire out of it. If its touching the stumps then its out.
 
I know but its the only loophole that is subjective ... have to make it fully autonomous and take the umpire out of it. If its touching the stumps then its out.
It would still be an issue. How can you be sure the fully autonomous system will make 100% accurate predictions? Touching the stumps on the technology may not always mean touching the stumps in reality.
 
It would still be an issue. How can you be sure the fully autonomous system will make 100% accurate predictions? Touching the stumps on the technology may not always mean touching the stumps in reality.

the idea is to have a uniform system for everyone. Its the same reason why the lbw decision was taken out of the umpires hand.

just like we rely totally on the snicko ... the Hawkeye should be the sile decision maker once it is referred.
 
the idea is to have a uniform system for everyone. Its the same reason why the lbw decision was taken out of the umpires hand.

just like we rely totally on the snicko ... the Hawkeye should be the sile decision maker once it is referred.
So if the tech comes up with a bale skimmer you can't say for sure that the batsman is out. Hawkeye is not flawless and this is arguably more unfair.
 
So if the tech comes up with a bale skimmer you can't say for sure that the batsman is out. Hawkeye is not flawless and this is arguably more unfair.

I understand but the umpire is even more unreliable and most importantly inconsistent. With Hawkeye it will behave consistently. Just like snicko. Even if there is a Small spike its out regardless of what the umpire heard or did not hear.
 
Graeme Swann hails 'Bazball' despite Test series loss to Pakistan, speaking to a local English media outlet:

"Not the first Test, but the second and third ones... Yeah, you know, it's a shame. I don't think the spinners bowled badly at all. It's just you're playing against people who are used to conditions like that, who've grown up on conditions like that. And with the Pakistan spinners, who've been doing that for years... I mean, they're very senior sorts of guys, even though they were new to Test cricket."

"So, it's one of those things. If you don't score massive runs on turning pitches, it's very hard for young spinners, especially. So, I'm not blaming the batsmen, by the way. It's just a team effort, I think."

"I love the way England play their cricket these days - very aggressively, always looking to win. And they've taken the draw out of the game, almost. And I think that's positive. It's brilliant for the future and will, in the long term, be very good for the spinners."

"You know, five days of cricket with no result... Let's face it, we all went through that back in the day, but it's not enjoyable to play nor watch. I love the aggressive nature. I know a lot of people say, 'But it's, you know, you can't go out there not minding if you lose to win a game.' I disagree with that."

"I think, if you dangle the carrot and are always prepared to be positive and take the aggressive route, it's entertaining, and you'll win far more than you lose. Look at the record they've had. Then people are very quick, when there's a loss, to turn around and say, 'Hang on, this doesn't work.' It does work."
 
Back
Top