- Joined
- Mar 19, 2015
- Runs
- 15,745
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
I agree with your viewpoint. Such desperation just elevates Kohli.
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
Almost every Indian poster here including me agree that Babar is a very fine player, we really respect him. Add to that the guy is a good bloke, never acting like a fool on the field. A very, very likeable character. Isn't that enough?
Kohli was 22 when he played his 77th ODI innings and that was way way before he hit his beastly peak (2013-18).....
OTOH, Babar Azam is 26 and is most likely already at his peak....
It just further validates Kohli's overall superiority over Babar when you see that he has similar stats to him even at a time he wasn't anywhere near his best.
Coming back to point, Babar is a good batsman, and he has the talent and ability to get his name among the top 3 Pakistani batsmen ever. But just because he is a good batsman, you don't have to elevate him to a position where he doesn't belong.
The same happened back with Inzamam. Back when Sachin and Lara were fighting tooth and nail for the tag of the best batsman of their era. Pak fans started throwing Inzamam's name. Their logic, because 26 of 25 Inzamam's Test centuries came in wins.
Even Geoffrey Boycott laughed when that question was asked to him over a podcast. He laughed it off and said that Inzamam doesn't belong to the great category, and he was just a fine player and a credit to the game.
That's problem with Pak fans is their superiority complex. Back in the 90's and 2000's, their ego was hurt because an Indian was considered all around the world as the best batsman in the world. How can that be? Pakistan was a better team than India back then, and Pakistan had all the rights to every category of best players back then. It annoyed them to no end that an Indian was considered the best batsman in the world. So they chose Inzamam and tried to elevate him to Sachin's class, and beat him by arguing how soooooooo many of his Test centuries came in wins.
The same is happening now with Babar. Although Pak fans know which team is better between them and India, they try to elevate Babar in the same class as Kohli to soothe their ego.
How many successful 300 plus chases for kohli
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
Why indian compare all their lefties thundler bowler with wasim.
Pakistani never compare inzimam with Sachin. As inzimam was match winners.
At the time of Saeed and Sachin, Saeed Anwar was miles ahead with Sachin
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
It’s natural. India and Pakistan are arch-rivals like AUS-ENG.
ENG is always comparing its fast bowlers to AUS and its spinners to Warne (how much they suck in comparison). ENG and AUS constantly compare their batsmen as well.
Every time an Indian bowler makes headlines, do they compare him to Indian bowlers? No; if he’s really good and performs well, comparisons are made with Wasim, Waqar, and a few AUS bowlers.
Babar is miles ahead.
Pakistan should overcome it delusions and stay in its own lane. It is now a lower-tier side in the same league as Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, West Indies, Afghanistan etc.
South Africa are probably in this league too for now, but they have always had more talent than Pakistan and they will be one of the elite sides soon.
Pakistan is no longer capable of locking horns with the top sides in the world on a consistent basis.
The reality is that if Babar was Indian, he would probably have played around 27 ODIs so far instead of 77.
He won’t be getting into the top 3 - he would primarily be used as backup to the top 3 and will get a few games at 4 every now and then.
Babar is a deaf king among blind men. He is an elite player for Pakistani standards but not by Indian standards. He will never be as good as Kohli and Rohit.
Why indian compare all their lefties thundler bowler with wasim.
Pakistani never compare inzimam with Sachin. As inzimam was match winners.
At the time of Saeed and Sachin, Saeed Anwar was miles ahead with Sachin
Why indian compare all their lefties thundler bowler with wasim.
Pakistani never compare inzimam with Sachin. As inzimam was match winners.
At the time of Saeed and Sachin, Saeed Anwar was miles ahead with Sachin
Edit: Ignore the last sentence. Rohit is a better ODI batsman and Babar is a better Test batsman.Yes, Kohli has played better innings than Babar and is a better player.
However, that doesn’t mean you cannot make comparisons across nations simply because one nation is much better than another.
What would your answer be to Andy Flower vs. Sidhu? Would you say one is better than another simply because of the color of their jersey?
If everyone were to accept your perpetual defeatist attitude, they might as well not tune in since the outcome of every match is pretty much guaranteed.
And even if it is, remember, millions will still tune in because it is PAK vs. IND, not to see who players better cricket. The ICC knows this very well.
As far as Babar vs. Rohit, the former may not be as good a player as the latter overall, but his numbers are superior in ODI’s and in Tests, Babar is a better overall player.
Nice essay but I don’t know what your point is when no one is even claiming Babar is better than Kohli.
Lol which Pakistani fans have claimed that Babar is better than Kohli? I’m genuinely curious about that. Even in this thread there is not a single Pakistani poster who has said that.
It almost seems you want to put words into the mouths of Pakistani fans and then have the outrage over that lol.
Yes there may be some outliers who believe Babar>Kohli but as per your own post a little earlier such people are small minority and shouldn’t be taken seriously.
Besides any great upcoming batsman will naturally be compared to the best LOI batsman of the era. And Kohli undoubtedly is the best white ball batsman of the era.
Then what is the point of this cherry picked comparison? A random 77 match cut off?
Whats the point of thes comparisons if not to compare?
Then what is the point of this cherry picked comparison? A random 77 match cut off?
Whats the point of thes comparisons if not to compare?
I can't imagine what Pakistani fans would have done if Kohli played for the team.
Some of the chases he's pulled off would be the greatest ODI knocks in Pakistan history.
Similar to the situation babar faces now, most of the chases kohli pulled off wouldnt have been successful as he wouldnt of had rohit dhoni etc to assist him in the chase.
Yes, Kohli has played better innings than Babar and is a better player.
However, that doesn’t mean you cannot make comparisons across nations simply because one nation is much better than another.
What would your answer be to Andy Flower vs. Sidhu? Would you say one is better than another simply because of the color of their jersey?
If everyone were to accept your perpetual defeatist attitude, they might as well not tune in since the outcome of every match is pretty much guaranteed.
And even if it is, remember, millions will still tune in because it is PAK vs. IND, not to see who players better cricket. The ICC knows this very well.
As far as Babar vs. Rohit, the former may not be as good a player as the latter overall, but his numbers are superior in ODI’s and in Tests, Babar is a better overall player.
It is not about the color of the jersey. Flower was a far better player than Sidhu, just like Babar is a better better player than Kedhar Jhadav and Rizwan is far better than Dinesh Kartik.
India’s WK batsmen during Flower’s time were the likes of Mongia. Flower was obviously miles ahead of them.
But Babar is not a better batsman than Babar. Rohit is a superstar; he is probably the GOAT ODI opener along with Sachin, and the only reason why it is probably too late for him to become a Test legend is because India have criminally utilized him in the Test format by not opening with him earlier.
Had they promoted him back in 2014-15 when had already established himself as an elite ODI opener, he could have surpassed Sehwag’s Test legacy.
Peak Kohli and Rohit are better batsmen than anyone Pakistan has ever produced. You put Kohli (2012-2019) and Rohit (2018-today) in the same team as Miandad, Majid, Hanif, Zaheer, Saleem, Inzamam, Yousuf, Younis as well as Babar and they will outperform the latter more often than not.
The best Indian batsmen in any era will always be far ahead of the best Pakistan that has produced. That has not changed over the last 40 years that is unlikely to change in the future.
They simply have far more talent and a vastly superior batting culture.
Babar is comparable to the support cast of Indian batting like KL Rahul, Iyer, Agarwal etc. the only reason he has better numbers and more recognition is because he does not have to be in the shadow of the likes of Kohli, Rohit, Dhawan and Pujara (Tests) and the level of competition that he faces in Pakistan is a joke.
I'd still put Babar above that support cast but he's still below the Superstar status of Rohit and Kohli
Between the two I definitely know who I'd want any child/junior/friend to emulate behavior wise on the field, when they are playing with their friends etc....a pity one of them behaves like a headless chook and represents us....and the other clearly is better behaved....
What the stats don't show is that Kohli takes off to GOAT status after a sedate start, by his standards, to his ODI career (he has 35 tons in the next 2 thirds of his ODI career - wow)
These comparison threads man... it doesn't matter what they look like statistically, ATM Babar isn't at the same level. I like Babar for us. He gives me a confidence in Pak batting that I haven't had in years, I hope he can improve further but comparisons with Kohli are off right now.
Kohli started his career when India had guys like Sehwag/Tendulkar/Gambhir/Yuvraj/Dhoni/Raina. So his role was not exactly going to be accumulating runs. This is a pointless comparison.
This is no disrespect towards Pak fans, but I'm genuinely curious why Pak posters are so interested in comparing their players with Indian players. Earlier it was comparing Inzamam with Sachin (which is the biggest joke ever in cricket) based on how 26 of his 25 Test centuries came in wins, and now Babar with Kohli. If it gives you satisfaction in thinking that Babar is a better batsman than Kohli, then so be it. Be happy thinking that.
There are plenty of players around the world whom you can compare with Babar, but it has to be only Kohli.
The thing is, Indians are into worshipping their star cricketers and turn them into gods. So they are very offended, like you, whenever some one dare to compare a cricketer of his country to their "gods".
Indians are long past that though. Kohli is one of the most abused cricketer today anywhere in india. Before that Dhoni was criticized no end before retiting.
It's Pakistanis who bring back fixers and still praise cricketers who turn their back on their country because they performed once against india in a final 4 years ago. IMO that's what worship is, blind faith in someone
No one is offended here. People are just laughing at the comparison.