Who should have been the best Pakistan cricketer of the last decade but wasn't?

Kroll

ODI Debutant
Joined
Jun 4, 2017
Runs
10,069
Post of the Week
1
In a thread posing the question whether Mohammad Hafeez was the best Pakistani cricketer of the last decade is a sobering thought.

This suggestion highlights how poor Pakistan must have been if Hafeez is one of the prime candidates. So who had the potential to be our best player of the last decade? But for whatever reasons, failed to make any sort of lasting impression.

Note: this thread is not for naming those players that could actually have been our best player, that thread already exits here - http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/showthread.php?291546-Was-Mohammad-Hafeez-the-best-Pakistani-cricketer-of-the-last-decade

This sort of rules out the likes of YK and Misbah as these players would be touted as our best. This thread is more about those players that showed great potential but didn't live up to expectations.

I'll throw a few of names into the hat to get started:

Umar Akmal - what is there to add, so I'll leave it that!

Wahab Riaz - a real speed demon who burst onto the scene in the Mohali WC semi-final. Four years later, again left a mark in the WC with a blistering spell of pace bowling against a rattled Australian side, especially Shane Watson.

Unfortunately, these performances were far and few between and he came to be known as a spray gun amongst some other uncomplimentary terms. Will also be known for THAT delivery against Steve Smith in a WC T20 match a year late as that famous Watson spell. He is also in the dubious company of a handful of players conceding more than century of runs in an ODI.

However, I do think Wahab could have been so much more than what he achieved during the last decade. He had the pace and build to carry on the fearsome Pakistan fast bowling legacy but unfortunately could not sustain any sort of quality.

Ahmed Shehzad - again, just like Akmal, a lot has been written and discussed not to mention he was famously described as having more talent than Sachin Tendulkar by one of our own great players.

This seems utterly ridiculous now but had Shehzad made the most of his numerous chances, perhaps had the potential to be one of our leading players during the last decade. He certainly had his hardcore fan support during the early days.

Still relatively young, but has largely been out of the side in the last two or three years and unlikely to make a comeback but you can never say never with this being Pakistan cricket after all.

Sharjeel Khan - big Sarj came to the party a bit late - in the latter half of the century; although he did have the odd appearance earlier making his debut in 2013. But just like Nasir Jamshed before him, made an impact right away when recalled back to the side.

After the failure of the 2015 WC, the Pakistan ODI top order was crying out for such a player. Sharjeel's thunderous starts meant that Paksitan finally had an opener that would propel them into the "modern ODI era" and help achieve those 300+ totals that were now a prerequisite of ODI batting.

Despite being labelled as a leg side hack, there is no doubt that Sharjeel had established himself as a first choice opener and the speed at which he could score was a breath of fresh air. Sadly though, it was off field issues that put paid to his playing days in the process frustrating many fans who came to enjoy and appreciate his batting.

A brute of a bloke who loved smashing the ball to all parts and also showed that he could put the ball away on the off side as well. However, Sharjeel could not showcase his talent at the CT17 and future tournaments due to the off field reasons. He may still make a comeback but what could have been if he was still able to play for the remainder of the last decade?

So who do you feel should have made it as our best player of the last decade? But for whatever reasons, just could not make enough of an impact to reach those lofty heights.
 
If Muhammad Asif wasn't banned in 2010 he would have been our player of the decade.

I am most disappointed at Shehzad as he had potential
 
Last edited:
The waste of the decade is Amir, we saw in 2010 what could have been as a Test bowler and we saw in 2019 WC what he could have consistently been as an ODI bowler.

Apart from these all we are left with are highlights
 
sarfraz ahmed, his return to the test team was a breath of fresh air, reliable keeping and great counter attacking batting in the vain of the best keeper batsmen, and then it just vanished. from 3 hundreds in his first 12 tests to none in the subsequent 37.

whether it was the captaincy or just getting found out. he had his spot on lock and for all of it has a very mediocre career to show for it, groomed to be captain from under 19 days with the champs trophy being his only real highlight as captain.

notable mention, yasir shah, i was this guys biggest fan but despite having a virtual monopoly on the test spinner spot he failed to adapt and progress, still has time to improve, but not much, his record away from asia is abject. the way his career started by all means i expected him to be a 300 wicket, 25 averaging bowler, who would have easily have been paks test bowler of the decade.
 
Hasan Ali and Mohammad Abbas. They looked serious talents as number one ODI and test bowlers respectively but have both lost their mojo in the last year or two.
 
It will always be Asif. The one player we will never get over. I have often fantasized about an alternate reality in which Asif had a full-career and didn't have all the character issues that he did.
 
If Muhammad Asif wasn't banned in 2010 he would have been our player of the decade.

I am most disappointed at Shehzad as he had potential

I don't know where this myth circulated. As far as I remember Shehad had an average in the low 30s and a strike rate that hovered around 72 for most of his career. He played some pretty good innings from time to time and he looked good while batting, but largely, I never got the impression that he had any talent the same way that UAkmal, Asif or Amir had.
 
I would go a bit differently and say Haris Sohail.Guy was in tremendous form in 2013-14 but was wasted due to injuries and all.Another name can be Fawad Alam
 
In a thread posing the question whether Mohammad Hafeez was the best Pakistani cricketer of the last decade is a sobering thought.

This suggestion highlights how poor Pakistan must have been if Hafeez is one of the prime candidates. So who had the potential to be our best player of the last decade? But for whatever reasons, failed to make any sort of lasting impression.

Note: this thread is not for naming those players that could actually have been our best player, that thread already exits here - http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/showthread.php?291546-Was-Mohammad-Hafeez-the-best-Pakistani-cricketer-of-the-last-decade

This sort of rules out the likes of YK and Misbah as these players would be touted as our best. This thread is more about those players that showed great potential but didn't live up to expectations.

I'll throw a few of names into the hat to get started:

Umar Akmal - what is there to add, so I'll leave it that!

Wahab Riaz - a real speed demon who burst onto the scene in the Mohali WC semi-final. Four years later, again left a mark in the WC with a blistering spell of pace bowling against a rattled Australian side, especially Shane Watson.

Unfortunately, these performances were far and few between and he came to be known as a spray gun amongst some other uncomplimentary terms. Will also be known for THAT delivery against Steve Smith in a WC T20 match a year late as that famous Watson spell. He is also in the dubious company of a handful of players conceding more than century of runs in an ODI.

However, I do think Wahab could have been so much more than what he achieved during the last decade. He had the pace and build to carry on the fearsome Pakistan fast bowling legacy but unfortunately could not sustain any sort of quality.

Ahmed Shehzad - again, just like Akmal, a lot has been written and discussed not to mention he was famously described as having more talent than Sachin Tendulkar by one of our own great players.

This seems utterly ridiculous now but had Shehzad made the most of his numerous chances, perhaps had the potential to be one of our leading players during the last decade. He certainly had his hardcore fan support during the early days.

Still relatively young, but has largely been out of the side in the last two or three years and unlikely to make a comeback but you can never say never with this being Pakistan cricket after all.

Sharjeel Khan - big Sarj came to the party a bit late - in the latter half of the century; although he did have the odd appearance earlier making his debut in 2013. But just like Nasir Jamshed before him, made an impact right away when recalled back to the side.

After the failure of the 2015 WC, the Pakistan ODI top order was crying out for such a player. Sharjeel's thunderous starts meant that Paksitan finally had an opener that would propel them into the "modern ODI era" and help achieve those 300+ totals that were now a prerequisite of ODI batting.

Despite being labelled as a leg side hack, there is no doubt that Sharjeel had established himself as a first choice opener and the speed at which he could score was a breath of fresh air. Sadly though, it was off field issues that put paid to his playing days in the process frustrating many fans who came to enjoy and appreciate his batting.

A brute of a bloke who loved smashing the ball to all parts and also showed that he could put the ball away on the off side as well. However, Sharjeel could not showcase his talent at the CT17 and future tournaments due to the off field reasons. He may still make a comeback but what could have been if he was still able to play for the remainder of the last decade?

So who do you feel should have made it as our best player of the last decade? But for whatever reasons, just could not make enough of an impact to reach those lofty heights.

I think Ahmed shehzad was never good enough he may seem pleasing on the eye but if you can't pick gaps in my books this is part of someone's talent and if he can't do that there is a lack of talent involved in that so never really rated

Wahan Riaz not becoming a superstar is really sad to see he seemed to have good fitness ,pace and was intelligent maybe the lack of accuracy just hampered his bowling or maybe he was just not that focused on becoming a GOAT he was cool with bieng average in bilaterals and only worked hard for tournament.

Amir has been a total embarrassment how much money hungry can you be first you sold the country than made a come back decided at 27 to leave test cricket and play leagues around the world like a mercenary so he tops the list of unfulfiled talent and I hope they keep him out of the team we don't need a sellout even if wins every match he ever plays
 
Umar Akmal and Mohammad Amir come to mind. The latter failed outside of the sport but has done well since his return, although he never turned into the star so many hoped for. The former maybe hit his peak and it just happened to be far lower than many of us expected.
 
In order of importance these are 5 players who i think we missed out on.

1. Asif
2. Akmal
3. Amir
4. Ajmal
5. Raza Hasan

Ahmed Shehzad can't achieve more than he already did, he looked good but has been exposed as a mediocre player enough times now. Sharjeel was good but with his technique may have been found out the same way Fakhar has.
 
Wait what was wrong with sharjeel's teqnique he always looked good unlike zaman who looks choppy all the time
 
It will always be Asif. The one player we will never get over. I have often fantasized about an alternate reality in which Asif had a full-career and didn't have all the character issues that he did.

There was a Guptill wicket where he set him so beautifully it was beyond belief. Before that, I would scorn at a bowler bowling in low 140's and think anyone in 130's shouldn't be allowed to bowl. But after that, the whole outlook of bowling changed for me.

Asif's career mirrors Pakistan's cricket of late, flawed sporadic brilliance, but sadly in his case, the flaws overwhelmed his brilliance and he became a tragic footnote in the annals of Pak cricket.
 
To add to already mentioned names.

Umar Amin and Nasir Jamshed (self destroyed their careers ).

Sohail Khan showed what it could have been if he was selected in his prime years.

But above all, it's Asad Shafiq.
 
There was a Guptill wicket where he set him so beautifully it was beyond belief. Before that, I would scorn at a bowler bowling in low 140's and think anyone in 130's shouldn't be allowed to bowl. But after that, the whole outlook of bowling changed for me.

Asif's career mirrors Pakistan's cricket of late, flawed sporadic brilliance, but sadly in his case, the flaws overwhelmed his brilliance and he became a tragic footnote in the annals of Pak cricket.

There's a video on YouTube from 2005 or '06 where he set Kevin Pietersen up with a 10 ball trap. The control and precision of his bowling is almost unbelievable. And when he finally gets the wicket you can see just how carefully and immaculately he set Pietersen up.
 
Haris Sohail deserves a mention.

Debuted in 2013, played the 2015 WC and then injured himself for fun and never got out of that bad habit.
 
Junaid Khan, if he hadn’t been overbowled by Misbah and perhaps mishandled by medical staff. He was great for a couple of years. Obviously all others = Asif, Amir, Alam, Abbas already mentioned above
 
Last edited:
Surely it's Amir by a country mile. That guy's best years of bowling were at 17/18. I'm sure he would have turned out quality had he not been banned and maintained his fitness. It's tough coming back from cricket after such a long layoff and shamed like that, yet even then he was still arguably our best pacer.

Asif lacked the speed, test specialist, might have been less useful on flatter pitches, took drugs and was banned from UAE anyway. Amir had everything and would have been a force in all 3 formats.

Next probably Haris, he would have been something if he hadn't had injury/fitness issues. Can't really say Umar, even though unfairly criticised in media which probably contributed to his demise, but he was given a lot of chances to perform.
 
Back
Top