What's new

Why would Pakistan appoint non-entities to senior positions?

Junaids

Senior T20I Player
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Runs
17,956
Post of the Week
11
It is rumoured that today Pakistan will announce their new National Coach, Batting Coach, Bowling Coach and Chief Selector.

But what is extraordinary is that the only applicants for any of those positions who would even be viewed as qualified enough to get an interview for Bangladesh or Zimbabwe are Waqar Younis and Courtney Walsh as bowling coaches.

The rest of the applicants wouldn't even get a gig in a first job as a state or county coach overseas. Misbah has never coached a First Class team in his life and neither has Dean Jones.

The selection criteria have been absurdly diluted, so that "handling fame" seems to qualify Misbah for the job of coach. That's okay, but surely that makes Katy Perry and Justin Bieber equally qualified for the role of National Coach?

Although, to be fair, neither Katy Perry nor Justin Bieber ever opened the bowling in a Test match in Australia with Yasir Shah. Which clearly makes them both more qualified to coach a national team than Misbah-ul-Haq.

(For the record, when Misbah opened the Test bowling with Yasir Shah at Sydney he produced figures of 14-0-124-1. That is Wile E. Coyote "I am a Genius, a Supergenius" territory).

Does it really matter that nobody good applied? The football coach Guus Hiddinck recently wrote that for the last 20 years of his career he refused to apply for any jobs - if people wanted him they needed to come and get him.

Surely Pakistan should be doing the same. If all else fails they could re-appoint Mickey Arthur and Steve Rixon on improved contracts. But surely even before Arthur was let go they should have been sounding out qualified candidates.

But not the kind of man whose idea of cricket in Australia is to open the bowling in a Test with a leg-spinner who takes 14-0-124-1.
 
It is a simple case of supply and demand. PCB has to choose from the applicants. They can't force anyone to apply.

Real question is why nobody wants to coach PCT and I am not talking about foreigners.
 
It is a simple case of supply and demand. PCB has to choose from the applicants. They can't force anyone to apply.

Real question is why nobody wants to coach PCT and I am not talking about foreigners.

PCB was contacted by a lot of people who inquired about the salary on offer and after that, they never contacted the PCB again. You have to pay above market to attract quality applicants and sadly the PCB should have offered $550,000-600,000 for the role.
 
This guy thinks umar Akmal is better thsnisbah or Younis in tests. Move on
That’s not quite right.

I think that Younis Khan is Pakistan’s GOAT batsman - I’m old enough to remember Javed Miandad enjoying Immunity From LBW and Caught Behind from Pakistani umpires.

I simply showed that after 2009 (when Younis was in age-related decline) the Pakistan Test batsman who outside Asia

1) Scored less than 20 least frequently, and
2) Scored more than 40 most frequently......


........is Umar Akmal, not Younis or Misbah.

Misbah has an inflated reputation due to the statistical anomaly of a brief period atop the ICC Test Rankings.

But the reality is that for all his supposed intellect and analysis, he produced inferior stats compared even with Umar Akmal.

Being old and having a beard does not make a man into a great thinker. It just means that the person is old and has a beard.

Yasir Shah’s spell of 14-0-124-1 at Sydney - when Misbah directed him to open the bowling and the entire crowd laughed aloud at the clown-like captaincy of Misbah - should have seen Misbah blacklisted forever from any duties above a janitorial level in Pakistan cricket.

If the man who opened the bowling at Sydney wants to apply for a job as a cleaner, let him apply. But anything more senior should be absolutely off the agenda for Misbah forever.
 
I agree with you,
Misbah should be last candidate in PCBs mind. He was the same guy who was bashing shaheen through out world cup until he proved him wrong in last matches. Misbah has terrible eye. He can't identify talent and cannot understand modern game.
I fear we will end up seeing hafeez in next wc as a captain.
 
Back
Top