mominsaigol
Senior ODI Player
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2021
- Runs
- 24,113
- Post of the Week
- 2
We lost becauseYou are right, we should not had lost to USA. But why we lost that game? Because Naqvi decided to meddle with the squads. They had babar bought in as captain and than added players that were not good enough.
Whether they are 40 years old, a coaching set up is always needed in sports to adopt the approach and strategy.
One of the best things about Babar was that he could score runs by playing shots on the ground. Something that Kamran Akmal and Umar Akmal did for a very short period of time.
We dont need coaching for basics like how to bat etc. Thats what people confuse coaching for. We need a coach to develop an approach.
In cricket either you can have a Captain who has more control and decides the strategy or you can have a coach. While i would give Salman a chance, but i still believe we need a proper dressing room with proper coaches.
A) Babar scored 44-43 on a road pitch.
B) Rizwan, Usman and Fakhar fell extremely early
C) azam, Chacha and shaheen were useless. Infact it's a miracle we reached 159 because shadab happened to have one if his tulla 40 of 25 scores like he typically does once every 20 innings. He had it vs Afghanistan in the 2nd odi as well in 2023.
Then the bowling and fielding was trash.
A) USA were cruising, they were 104 in 13 overs with only 2 wickets lost. However USA struggled due to minnow mentality. It's the same reason Nepal lost to sa when they had won the game from all fronts.
Minnow mentality and pressure of beating a big side caught up to them and they started to panic however thank to pakistan fielding and bowling it was a tie.
Then during the super over once again horrible fielding and horrible bowling by Amir had us chase 19.
Now yes, 19 is bloody difficult to chase in a super over but against a minnow, I'd back a full strength team to get it, since Australia managed to get like 80 of 30 against Scotland and Scotland is a superior lineup to USA.
But chacha and Shadab have always been corcus clowns in super overs courtesy of their previous Zimbabwe series.
That full toss should have gone for a 6 and we'd be chasing 9 of 3 but chacha had been getting out or missing full tosses left and right during that period.
He got out on a full toss to Neesham, got put on a full toss to an Oracle employee, missed 3 full tosses that should have been dispatched for 3 sixes agaisnt india and the game should have been sealed.
As for squad selection, the entire squad was the exact same that had been playing with zero adjustments. Only changes were Amir replacing hasan Ali and imad wasim replacing nawaz
1) Babar
2) Rizwan
3) Usman Khan (Replaced Tayyab)
4) Azam Khan (Replaced haris)
5) Shadab
6) Chacha
7) Imad (Replaced Nawaz)
8) Amir (Replaced hasan ali)
9) Shahen
10) Naseem
11) Rauf
12) Abrar (Replaced Usama Mir)
13) saim ayub
14) Abass Afridi
15) Fakhar Zaman
^^ The whole team is the exact same? Abrar is an improvement but regardless neither usama or abrar were ever gonna play under Babar as shadab was preferred.
Nawaz and Hasan ali were corpses lol, even if you didn't bring Amir and imad back, these 2 were gonna get the boot anyway.
Tayyab had flunked his international games while usman had clearly outperformed him in psl.
Azam Khan replacing haris was the wrong call tbf but it was once again based of PSL.
You're acting as if they changed the entire squad when they changed only 4 players? With 2 of those players not even playing all or most of the cup?