From Tom Winnifriths weekend editorial :-
"Jim Mellon's reaction to the news that we had made it was instructive. I quote: "This market sell off is going to be wonderful for PEBI - Great opportunities." When I chatted to Malcolm Burne about gold stocks on Friday he came up with a similar line and said that he had been hoovering up Canadian gold and silver stocks on Thursday night. It is, I think, instructive to see what really experienced and talented investors are thinking and doing before continuing."
Panic & Value - non gold
So the world faces a few problems. That we know. I am in a hotel watching CNN with some prat taking about "the markets" as an entity not a collection of stocks. Stocks are valued in relation to earnings. Sometimes they trade way ahead of underlying value (when investors are happy), sometimes well below (when they panic). Investors are panicking. And so they are selling shares on quite derisory multiples becuase they are afraid. Now I am in no doubt that world economic growth will be slower than previously forecast and this will impact on corporate earnings. The issue is whether this is discounted in valuations and in many cases I believe that it is more than discounted. you can look at the yields on offer from utterly secure blue chips and that should give you a hint. Or look at the derisory cash flow multiples on offer and small and mid caps.
Now I am inundated with calls from CEOs who say their stock is too cheap. They blame the structure of AIM, short sellers, market makers, their advisors, private investors panicking, hedge funds selling, fund managers being on holiday, etc, etc. My answer to all of them is simple: if you think your stock is far too cheap buy some more. A. You will make money. B. You send a signal that your stock is too cheap to the rest of us.Stop bleating and blaming and start buying. Stocks that look cheap, have no funding issues and where the board is buying (or where they are not allowed to buy but are exercising unapproved share options ie RSH!) probably are cheap. Any CEO who says his stock is cheap and is not buying shares is not doing his job properly. I do not care if he or she can only afford £2,000 or £5,000 they should buy first thing tomorrow. When the average AIM CEO gets paid £150,000 a year the idea that these folks cannot buy £10,000 of shares is just ludicrous.
Panic & value - gold
Gold is 30% up on the year. Most gold stocks are 20-40% down. Some lost 20% last week as gold moved ahead and - as an added bonus - oil fell. Why is this? Firstly amid a general panic folks tend to sell what they can sell easily first and gold stocks - as there is some demand- suffered across the world. Secondly some folks still think gold is a commodity not a currenmcy and so mistakenly sold on fears of slower economic growth. And thirdly gold stocks have attracted more than their fair share of speculators buying on margin. There were a lot of margin calls last week, initially outside gold, which prompted forced selling. Then gold stocks fell and that prompted more margin calls. The speculators will be squeezed out and then fundamentals re-assert. At $1500 gold there were a raft of mid cap gold stocks on 2 times cashflows. But now we are at $1660. And gold is heading higher so those multiples will get lower and lower and in the end value will out. As investors graps that reality gold stocks will fly. This is a when not an if. The re-rating will be dramatic and savage and so there is no point waiting to call the bottom. You are buying extreme value now. You just have to wait. That is the Malcolm Burne view and mine.