What's new

Could Steve Smith captain Australia again?

Hasan123

Test Star
Joined
Mar 25, 2016
Runs
38,432
Steve Smith will return international cricket some time next year. We all know why he was stripped of captaincy but could he captain Australia again in the future?

I have a lot of respect for Tim Paine . But I just don't see him being a long term captain post the ashes. Aaron Finch is 32 and his form has been inconsistent since being made permanent LO skipper. Don't see current vice captains stepping up to be captains.

There aren't many options to be made captain, Steve Smith seems to me to be the stand out option long term.

Do you think he could captain his country again?

Discuss......
 
No reason not to. Once the ban is over you've served your punishment and everything returns to normal. If he matchfixed it could be different as your name would be tainted for bringing the country down due to your actions but he tampered the ball which is common and not as bad. He understands his mistakes and is determined to still succeed so no reason why they shouldn't do it. That's if he really is the best option.. obviously only the decision which will be better for the team should be made; and the fact that he got banned should be overlooked once he's out of it.
 
CA won't make Smith captain anymore. It will question their dignity. Will always be a newbie or maybe a fast bowler to captain Australia after Paine.

CA aren't stupid enough that after taking such harsh decisions, they will let Smith take the captaincy any more. So, I don't think so.
 
Along with the ban Smith was also served with a punishment that he would not be eligible for leading the national team for 1 year after his return.

Warner received a life ban on captaincy.

Smith is 29 years old right now. By the time he becomes eligible for captaincy he will be 31. And I reckon it's highly unlikely that CA will consider making him captain immediately after that period ends. So add another year or two to that.

By the time that day arrives, Smith will be 32-33.

It's possible that at 32, he might be captain if Australia at that point doesn't have a steady captain. But if there is someone younger who can be groomed, I don't think they will make a 32 year old Steven Smith the captain of Australia.
 
Don't see Cricket Australia appointing him captain. In a way that's a good thing as he can fully focus on his batting, however I don't see Tim Paine captaining for that much longer either. So it will be interesting to see who Australia appoints captain or if they stick with Paine.
 
Don't see Cricket Australia appointing him captain. In a way that's a good thing as he can fully focus on his batting, however I don't see Tim Paine captaining for that much longer either. So it will be interesting to see who Australia appoints captain or if they stick with Paine.

I think Paine will captain till the ashes next year. Australia are good at moving on senior. Also the senior players know when the right time to go is. Look at Haddin,Watson ,Johnson,and Clarke who all retired from ODIs after winning the WC.

If only certain players could learn from such selfless act. :malik :hafeez
 
CA will never do it. They would get plenty of backlash and having a cheat as a captain is not good for their image. It is true though that there are a lack of options.

Shame we don’t see bowling captains anymore or you could give it to one of the pacers. Though with their injury problems that is not practical.
 
The bloody disgraceful cheap should never be allowed to captain at any level again
 
It'll be a cold day in hell before Smith becomes captain. No way will CA make someone with a tainted legacy captain. Especially someone who brought them so much ill-will. They have literally banned Warner from ever captaining Australia and though I don't think such is the case with Smith the message is loud and clear.
 
The bloody disgraceful cheap should never be allowed to captain at any level again

That's very harsh, so you feel the same way for Amir as well ? He is a young kid and deserves a chance to redeem himself. If we always condemned and never forgave the world would be a more terrible place than it currently already is..
 
ill be shocked if he doesnt, there is a lot more sympathy for him than warner ( and rightly so in my opinion)
 
We don't want him as captain, first, he needs to serve his time but CA has already said he won't captain or be involved in any leadership role.
 
When Amir can play, Smith could easily become captain. CA allows or not that's a different issue.

But comparing the crime that was done by Amir, it's like a deewali wala bomb compared to a nuclear one.
 
I think Paine will captain till the ashes next year. Australia are good at moving on senior. Also the senior players know when the right time to go is. Look at Haddin,Watson ,Johnson,and Clarke who all retired from ODIs after winning the WC.

If only certain players could learn from such selfless act. :malik :hafeez

Lol playing after your expiry date is a Desi trend that will never end unfortunately.
 
What nobody is mentioning is that he was a terrible captain even aside from the cheating.

Michael Clarke and Mark Taylor were great thinkers of the game, but Clarke was obnoxious and disliked by his team.

Smith has a much, much lower IQ and barely has the capacity to think, plus he has an intense focus on his batting which means that he provides almost no support to his team-mates. He’s got a harmless, inoffensive interpersonal style, but his intense focus on his batting combined with his dull intellect meant that on the field he left a leadership vacuum.

Clearly Warner didn’t dream up two years of ball-tampering, which had been clear as long ago as the Basin Reserve in February 2016. He and the bowlers obviously either had the support of the skipper or, perhaps more likely, minimised to an unintelligent skipper what they were doing.

When Darren Lehmann runs rings around you intellectually you know that you probably don’t have the intelligence to win an argument with a banana, let alone captain your country.
 
Steve Smith says captaining Australia 'not on my radar'

Steve Smith says captaining Australia again is "not on my radar" as his ban from leading his country enters its final few months.

Smith's punishment for the ball-tampering affair in 2018 - for which he received a 12-month suspension - included not being allowed to captain the Baggy Greens until a year into his comeback.

That ban elapses in March, but the 30-year-old says he is not thinking about the role with Test skipper Tim Paine having guided his side to a 2-2 draw in the Ashes series in England and ODI captain Aaron Finch taking the team to the World Cup semi-finals.

"Not on my radar at all," Smith said of regaining the Australia captaincy. "Finchy and Painey are both doing terrific jobs, so I'm enjoying playing and pretty chilled."

Cricket Australia CEO Kevin Roberts said earlier this week that he did not envisage any change of captain in the near future, despite the fact Paine will turn 35 in December.

"It's important that we crawl before we walk and acknowledge that there's no one in Australian cricket other than Tim that could've led the Australian men's Test team the way he has over the last 18-plus months," Roberts told Australian radio station SEN.

"[He has led Australia] out of crisis [and] into a position of relative strength and improving all the time having retained the Ashes and hoping to win the upcoming series against Pakistan and New Zealand.

"Given Tim's outstanding leadership, what I would say at this point in time is we're not reviewing his position as captain.

"We're excited and grateful that we've got him as our leader for this coming season and we'll address the other matters with Steve when the time comes."

On Finch, who is set to skipper Australia at the T20 World Cup on home soil next November, Roberts added: "Aaron did a fantastic job of captaining the ODI team in the World Cup, and prior to that.

"The good news is we're feeling really good about the leaders that we have now."
https://www.skysports.com/cricket/n...ith-says-captaining-australia-not-on-my-radar
 
What nobody is mentioning is that he was a terrible captain even aside from the cheating.

Michael Clarke and Mark Taylor were great thinkers of the game, but Clarke was obnoxious and disliked by his team.

Smith has a much, much lower IQ and barely has the capacity to think, plus he has an intense focus on his batting which means that he provides almost no support to his team-mates. He’s got a harmless, inoffensive interpersonal style, but his intense focus on his batting combined with his dull intellect meant that on the field he left a leadership vacuum.

Clearly Warner didn’t dream up two years of ball-tampering, which had been clear as long ago as the Basin Reserve in February 2016. He and the bowlers obviously either had the support of the skipper or, perhaps more likely, minimised to an unintelligent skipper what they were doing.

When Darren Lehmann runs rings around you intellectually you know that you probably don’t have the intelligence to win an argument with a banana, let alone captain your country.

To be honest as much as a fan of Smith I am this makes a bit of sense.

The official account is that he saw that the tampering was happening but didn’t involve himself and let it slide which shows weak leadership. Only when he took responsibility did he finally man up
 
Its better if Smith just focuses on his batting, not that captaincy really affected his batting.
 
Tampering saga still leaves a bad taste. Far as Oz cricket goes and the big three, must be delighted that Cricket Australia mopped things up so quickly leaving little time for the who/where/what/how. Now business as usual.

Team tampering was going on for a some time, we’ll never ‘offically’ know how long - aiding potential victories, not forgetting the $ bonuses that come with it.
 
To be honest as much as a fan of Smith I am this makes a bit of sense.

The official account is that he saw that the tampering was happening but didn’t involve himself and let it slide which shows weak leadership. Only when he took responsibility did he finally man up

Every team does some form of ball tempering. And captains are always aware. It's naive to think otherwise.
 
Smith the cricketer and human being may find redemption but his role as captain, in a side which had systematic ball tampering is unacceptable and he should never again be given a place of power in the cricketing set up of Aus or the ICC.
 
‘I hate to see that’: Steve Smith accused of ‘white anting’ Tim Paine with field placements

Former Test captain Ian Chappell has accused Steve Smith of “white anting” his skipper on day four of the second Test.

Chappell took exception to Smith’s involvement in field placements, something which occurred during the Ashes, and believed he was undermining Tim Paine.

Smith, in Chappell’s view, was tweaking Paine’s field placements beyond what the two had agreed by directly approaching players or calling them to change position.

“I tell you what I don’t like to see, Steve Smith is moving a few fieldsmen around,” Chappell said on Macquarie Sports Radio.

“He did have a chat with Tim Paine, trying to talk Tim Paine into moving a fielder on the off-side, but I’m not sure Tim Paine moved him as far as Steve Smith wanted.

“Steve Smith started moving him, I hate to see that.

“England used to do it a bit, blokes other than the captain and I always felt it was white anting the captain.”
https://www.foxsports.com.au/cricke...s/news-story/4daa8046af997d34a1225a1648512db1
 
Steve Smith has responded to claims made by cricket great Ian Chappell that he was undermining Australian captain Tim Paine during Australia's 2-0 series sweep against Pakistan.

It was an early incident on day four of the Adelaide Test involving former captain Smith and his successor Paine that drew the attention Chappell.

Smith appeared to be in Paine's ear suggesting he move a fielder to the offside which led Chappell to suggest that Smith was "white anting" the captain.

"I tell you what I don't like to see, Steve Smith is moving a few fieldsmen around," Chappell said on Macquarie Sports Radio.

"He did have a chat with Tim Paine, trying to talk Tim Paine into moving a fielder on the off-side, but I'm not sure Tim Paine moved him as far as Steve Smith wanted.

"Steve Smith started moving him, I hate to see that.

"England used to do it a bit, blokes other than the captain (moving the field), and I always felt it was white anting the captain."

"I only try and help Tim as much as I can," Smith exclusively told 9News. "He's doing a terrific job, but I give him suggestions and things like that.

"I only want the team to do well. I'm certainly not undermining him."


It's not the first time the issue has surfaced since Smith's return to the Test team after his one-year ban following the ball-tampering scandal. In his very first match back, against England at Edgbaston, Smith was seen given directions to fieldsmen to move positions which raised eyebrows.

It may have been a less than desirable series for Smith with bat in hand but Australia's best player still managed to reach a new milestone when he became the fastest player to reach 7000 Test runs.

The 30-year-old reached 7000 Test runs in his 126th innings, eclipsing the mark of 131 innings set by England great Sir Walter Hammond in 1946.

Smith reached the landmark when he scored his 23rd run at the Adelaide Oval, with a pull shot off Musa Khan to backward square leg.

Smith became the 50th player in Test history, and the 11th Australian, to reach 7000 runs. At age 30, he's also the youngest of the 11 Australians to reach the mark, edging out Ricky Ponting by just over a month.

https://wwos.nine.com.au/cricket/st...e-claims/0ac690bb-75b1-4503-9b5d-040ad6b64176
 
‘I’m not undermining him’: Steve Smith denies ‘white anting’ captain Tim Paine

https://www.foxsports.com.au/cricke...n/news-story/1fd773c96a2369a05a247eb11b9675fb

Australia vs New Zealand, first Test every ball live and ad free on Fox Cricket 501 from 1PM local time December 12-16.
Steve Smith has denied he is “white anting” the Australian Test captain Tim Paine, as accused by cricket legend Ian Chappell.

Chappell made the accusation during the second Test against Pakistan at the Adelaide Oval, when Smith was seen allegedly making field changes on his own accord.

Smith was captain of the team before being banned for a year for his role in the infamous Cape Town ball tampering scandal last year.

Paine has been captain since then, even now Smith is back in the side.

“I tell you what I don’t like to see, Steve Smith is moving a few fieldsmen around,” Chappell said on Macquarie Sports Radio during play.

“He did have a chat with Tim Paine, trying to talk Tim Paine into moving a fielder on the off-side, but I’m not sure Tim Paine moved him as far as Steve Smith wanted.

“Steve Smith started moving him, I hate to see that.

“England used to do it a bit, blokes other than the captain and I always felt it was white anting the captain.”

But Smith denied he was acting outside his jurisdiction.

“I only try to help Tim as much as I can,” Smith told Channel 9 on Tuesday.

“He’s doing a terrific job. I give him suggestions and things like that.

“I only want the team to do well, I’m certainly not undermining him.”
 
Nothing to read into this. Smith is just offering advice lol. I'm sure the Australian bowlers will have a big say in their fields.
 
Nothing to read into this. Smith is just offering advice lol. I'm sure the Australian bowlers will have a big say in their fields.

Apart from quirky fieldsets and mild banter, Paine doesn't do much. But you could see them visibly frustrated when the tailenders were showing resistance.
 
Thanks to Ian Chappell for giving us a good word for describing what most subcontinent senior players do :P
 
Thanks to Ian Chappell for giving us a good word for describing what most subcontinent senior players do :P

Athar ali khan was literally crying that Mahamdulla and Mush were not at all talking to Mominul as they were running ragged on the field. He was whining about it the entire series.
 
Please let Pakistanis "seniors" read this, guys like Hafeez cannot resist themselves from acting as captain in the field.
 
Never good optics. I hated it when Dhoni would do it for Kohli. But Kohli is also a legit West Delhi 'tard punjabi so he needs all the help.

White anting? Need to look up the etymology.
 
Last edited:
This guy barks at every little thing. I can see why the Ok Boomer would work in this scenerio ... :P
 
The dynamics of a sub-continental dressing room and an Australian dressing room are poles apart. Senior players have alot more influence in a sub-continental team if the captain is inexperienced and young. The alternative to this in a sub-continental side is a strong leader who commands respect; with his personality, his performance or both (ala Imran, Ranatunga, Kohli, Mortaza).

In Australia and other countries like South Africa, New Zealand this is not the case as there are far lesser dressing-room politics, although the case of Kim Hughes exists as a major exception.
 
Last edited:
Former Australian captain Mark Taylor says Smith is not ‘white anting’ Paine

Mark Taylor has dismissed Ian Chappell’s comments about Steve Smith “white anting” Australian Test captain Tim Paine.

Footage emerged of Smith moving players in the field during Australia’s Test victory against Pakistan in Adelaide last week.

Former Australian captain Ian Chappell was unimpressed, accusing Smith of “white anting” his skipper.

“I tell you what I don’t like to see, Steve Smith is moving a few fieldsmen around,” Chappell said on Macquarie Sports Radio.

“I hate to see that. England used to do it a bit, blokes other than the captain and I always felt it was white-anting the captain.”

Taylor rubbished Chappell’s claim on Sunday morning, suggesting Smith’s actions were in actuality an indication of a positive working relationship.

“I don’t think Steve Smith is trying to white ant Time Paine at all, and I suspect that Tim and Steve are actually working together,” Taylor said on Sports Sunday.

“Steve Smith’s often at first slip next to Tim Paine, and I reckon Tim Paine is saying to Smithy, ‘I’ve got keeping to worry about, particularly against the slow bowlers’.

“When the spinners were bowling, I think Tim Paine said to him, ‘If you see something, just go ahead and do it. Don’t worry about coming to me, because I’ve got to worry about keeping’.

“I don’t think there’s any white-anting going on. If you listen to Chappelli’s comments, he says he doesn’t like it and I understand that, I really do, because that’s not the way he captained the side, or would want to captain the side.”

Smith captained the Australian Test team before the Cape Town ball-tampering scandal in March 2018. Since Paine took over as skipper, Australia have won seven Tests in 16 matches.

TAYLOR PICKS AUSTRALIA’S NEXT TEST CAPTAIN

Taylor has thrown his support behind Smith to reclaim his position as Australia’s Test captain when the time is right for Paine to step down.

Discussions surrounding Australia’s next Test captain erupted this summer, with paceman Pat Cummins and uncapped wicketkeeper Alex Carey among those in contention.

Taylor emphasised finding a replacement for 35-year-old Paine is crucial, not just in case of a form slump, but also if injury arises.

“Australia have got to be ready. I’ve always said publicly that I think Steve Smith should be available to captain Australia again, and should be at least seriously considered,” Taylor said on Sports Sunday.

“I’d choose Steve Smith, because I think he’s in a better position to captain the side.

“I think the players would like Steve Smith as captain, not that I’m saying that Pat Cummins would not be liked.

“I always found it was easier as a batsman to be a captain rather than a bowler.”

Paine battled a minor finger injury during Australia’s recent Test match against Pakistan, but has been cleared to face New Zealand at Perth Stadium on Thursday.

Former Australian netball captain Liz Ellis agreed with Taylor, but backed Paine to retain the captaincy until he decides to step down, whenever that may be.

“Tim Paine has earnt the right, given what he’s done with the cricket team since sandpaper-gate, he’s earnt the tight to pull the pin when he wants to pull the pin,” Ellis said.

“If he wants to stay on for another summer, if his form still warrants it, then he has to be able to do that.

“He has done something with this team that 12-18 months ago, we could not have thought possible.”
https://www.news.com.au/sport/crick...e/news-story/601c5472c8d35f097f7e14a0e0e49792
 
I never found him to be an amazing captain. He was really average and was dominated by Warner.
 
Legendary wicketkeeper Ian Healy wants to see former Australia captain Steve Smith return to the top job in Tests and seek "redemption", saying he has paid a "heavy price for not doing much" during the ball-tampering scandal.

Smith and vice-captain David Warner had resigned in the aftermath of the scandal during the Cape Town Test against South Africa in March 2018 and since then Tim Paine has been at the helm of the Test team.

Aaron Finch has handled the limited-overs leadership.

ALSO READ| Ponting backs Australia, says India's resilience bound to crack at some stage

"In 12 to 18 months from now, I want him to do it, only if he wants to, because it's a chance for redemption," Healy told 'SEN Radio'.

"I want him to lead strongly, become that statesman of the game and put those doubters and haters to bed. I like redemption – he paid a heavy price for not doing much," he added.

With Paine, at 36, reaching the fag end of his career, a fresh captaincy discussion has started.

"Everyone around the world thinks he scratched the ball. All he was, was a bit of a lazy captain and let things run in his team that he wasn't aware of," Healy opined.

Pace ace Pat Cummins has been touted as Australia's next Test captain following his recent appointment as the sole vice-captain after previously sharing the role with Travis Head.

Healy feels the speedster should be handed the reigns in the white-ball formats to gain experience before potentially leading the Australian Test side.

"I think we should try Pat Cummins in short form games. Give him a taste and get his feedback on how he might cope, that would be a good way to start." The last time a speedster captained Australia was Ray Lindwall in a Test against India in 1956.

https://sportstar.thehindu.com/cric...aine-south-africa-cummins/article33602010.ece
 
It will reflect very badly on Cricket Australia and show their desperation if they give the job to this disgraceful cheat again
 
He is immature. Previous Australian captains Clarke and Ponting led by example, not form but attitude, his childish attitude, immaturity just makes Australia seem like an easy prey. No wonder Warner bullied his way into carrying out the tampering act, Smith probably was scared to create a big deal about it.

I don't know why they don't consider someone like a Hazlewood or Cummins.
 
And people have issues with Pakistanis welcoming cheats back into their side...
 
And people have issues with Pakistanis welcoming cheats back into their side...

What Smith did was more along the lines of Afridi biting the ball to win.. everytime i see the comparison with Amir but its not the same.
 
What Smith did was more along the lines of Afridi biting the ball to win.. everytime i see the comparison with Amir but its not the same.

Afridi is d*mb

He didn’t bite the ball because he wanted to cheat. But the pitch tampering thing was blatant cheating.

Smith on the other hand disgraced, tarnished the Australians forever. Who knows what dirty tricks they have been up to and for how long?
 
Make Usman Khawaja the captain i believe he has lot of experience captaining Australia A.

1. Warner
2. Harris/Pucovosky
3. Khawaja (C)
4. Smith
5. Labuchagne
6. Green
7. Wade (Wk)
8. Cummins (V.C)
9. Starc
10. Hazlewood
11. Lyon
 
Smith was a rubbish captain: he has no leadership skills and isn’t smart enough to time his declarations.

Plus he has never come clean about sandpaper: 24 months before they got caught I walked round the Basin Reserve trying to see who was tampering with the ball.

Healy and Taylor know perfectly well that the terms of reference of the Cricket Australia investigation were designed to make it impossible to convict the bowlers, and impossible to hold Smith to account for 24 months of premature and exaggerated reverse swing.

Then again, Healy and Taylor were key characters in Karachi’94, and we older members of this forum know precisely what that means.
 
I am getting more and more convinced that Smith will be Australian captain for the Ashes. Paine won't survive if they don't win in South Africa.
 
It would.. for 2 years atleast..Plus Paine will be out of the team that helps as well

Paine being out would help but who would keep? Smith leads with his performances with the bat. Not a particularly good tactician. His batting peak may just about be over so his captaincy may not be all that.
 
<b>”Cheating is Cheating": Ian Chappell Slams Cricket Australia For Appointing Steve Smith As Vice-Captain.</b>

Chappell said Cricket Australia should have started on a clean slate after Paine stood down. Going back to Smith as vice-captain was not the right precedent to set.

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell was not happy with Cricket Australia's decision to appoint Steve Smith as vice-captain of the Test side. Smith, a former skipper, was removed as captain and banned from all cricket for 12 months for his involvement in Sandpapergate in Cape Town, South Africa in 2018, which saw Australian cricket go through a host of changes. They face a similar scenario currently after a scandal forced Tim Paine to take indefinite break from all forms of cricket.

Australia named Pat Cummins as their new captain barely a couple of weeks before the Ashes while Smith made a comeback to the leadership group after three years as the vice-captain.

"I wish that Cricket Australia had made a clean break, but for Cricket Australia to get anything right at the moment is asking a bit much," Chappell said on 2GB's Wide World of Sports radio on Saturday.

Chappell said the different treatment for David Warner and Smith for the same offence also doesn't make much sense. Warner, Smith were banned for 12 months while Cameron Bancroft was given a nine-month ban but the left-handed opening batter was also banned from captaincy for life, which was not the case with Smith, who was only banned from leading Australia for two years.

"For starters, I have a problem -- why is Steve Smith looked upon as a different punishment to David Warner? In fact, if anything, I think Steve Smith's crime was greater. For a captain to say, 'I don't want to know' when cheating is involved, is not correct. A captain's got to know, he's got to find out and he's got to do something about it. Either Steve Smith has a two-year ban from captaincy and so does David Warner, or Steve Smith has a life ban and so does Dave Warner. Same thing," said Chappell.

"Cheating is cheating, whether it's big cheating or little cheating, it's still cheating in my book. If I'd have cheated as an Australian captain -- I mean I made a lot of mistakes but I didn't cheat. And if I had cheated, and if I had done what Tim Paine did, I would have expected Cricket Australia to not ask me to resign, they would have taken the job away from me and made sure I didn't continue to play as a player," said Chappell.

Source: NDTV Sports.
 
<b>”Cheating is Cheating": Ian Chappell Slams Cricket Australia For Appointing Steve Smith As Vice-Captain.</b>

Chappell said Cricket Australia should have started on a clean slate after Paine stood down. Going back to Smith as vice-captain was not the right precedent to set.

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell was not happy with Cricket Australia's decision to appoint Steve Smith as vice-captain of the Test side. Smith, a former skipper, was removed as captain and banned from all cricket for 12 months for his involvement in Sandpapergate in Cape Town, South Africa in 2018, which saw Australian cricket go through a host of changes. They face a similar scenario currently after a scandal forced Tim Paine to take indefinite break from all forms of cricket.

Australia named Pat Cummins as their new captain barely a couple of weeks before the Ashes while Smith made a comeback to the leadership group after three years as the vice-captain.

"I wish that Cricket Australia had made a clean break, but for Cricket Australia to get anything right at the moment is asking a bit much," Chappell said on 2GB's Wide World of Sports radio on Saturday.

Chappell said the different treatment for David Warner and Smith for the same offence also doesn't make much sense. Warner, Smith were banned for 12 months while Cameron Bancroft was given a nine-month ban but the left-handed opening batter was also banned from captaincy for life, which was not the case with Smith, who was only banned from leading Australia for two years.

"For starters, I have a problem -- why is Steve Smith looked upon as a different punishment to David Warner? In fact, if anything, I think Steve Smith's crime was greater. For a captain to say, 'I don't want to know' when cheating is involved, is not correct. A captain's got to know, he's got to find out and he's got to do something about it. Either Steve Smith has a two-year ban from captaincy and so does David Warner, or Steve Smith has a life ban and so does Dave Warner. Same thing," said Chappell.

"Cheating is cheating, whether it's big cheating or little cheating, it's still cheating in my book. If I'd have cheated as an Australian captain -- I mean I made a lot of mistakes but I didn't cheat. And if I had cheated, and if I had done what Tim Paine did, I would have expected Cricket Australia to not ask me to resign, they would have taken the job away from me and made sure I didn't continue to play as a player," said Chappell.

Source: NDTV Sports.

Stupid response. Everyone knows that the majority of the team, especially the bowlers were in on it. There needed to be scapegoats. Warner and Smith were it as they were already outed. Warner was never going to captain Australia. He accepted the punishment of a lifetime captaincy ban to keep his head down for a little while and be welcomed back into the team.

Smith has to captain again because he is the best player in the side and arguably the world. This whole drama with Cummins getting it and smith being vice captain is a way to ease him in and make it easier for people to accept. Cummins is a dummy captain.

The era of Smith - greatest test cricketer of the last decade - is back.
 
Back as captain!

Who would have thought?

Totally disagree. He is a proven, convicted cheat. Should not be rewarded. Sure he gets a second chance, which he has. But never captain a national team.
 
FGtpA6hVUAAz4P7
 
Smith will be back to full time captaincy in some time. Cummins will miss some matches anyways due to rotation policy.
 
Interview ahead of play on Day 3 at Adelaide:

<div style="width: 100%; height: 0px; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.250%;"><iframe src="https://streamable.com/e/ntp3aq" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="100%" allowfullscreen style="width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;"></iframe></div>
 
Steve Smith says he always felt that he had the support of the Australian public after slipping back into the captaincy of the Test team this week, capping a remarkable career revival. In March 2018, Smith was enemy number one in the wake of a ball-tampering scandal that shook cricket. It was a long road back -- a two-year leadership ban and one-year playing suspension. But the 32-year-old's redemption was all but complete last month when he was named vice-captain to new skipper Pat Cummins when Tim Paine quit over lewd text messages, even though not everyone agreed with the decision.

By a quirk of fate, Smith was then thrust back into the top job for the first time in nearly four years for the ongoing second Ashes Test against England at Adelaide when Cummins was ruled out hours beforehand over a Covid scare.

"I woke up... I looked at my phone and saw two missed calls from Patty and a message from JL (coach Justin Langer) saying, 'Are you awake?'" Smith -- one of the world's premier batsmen -- told cricket.com.au about how he learned he would again captain the team.

"I wanted to lead the side in Patty's absence and continue on what he started last week," Smith added, referring to Australia's nine-wicket thrashing of England in the first Test.

"I'm looking forward to working with Patty in the future and helping him in any way that I can grow as a leader, and help the team have success."

So unprepared was Smith that he didn't have his captain's blazer with him and had to borrow Cummins', which was a size too big as he walked out for the toss on Thursday.

'Absolutely devastated'

It was a far cry from 2018 when a distraught Smith tearfully fronted a press conference admitting to a "failure of leadership" after the "Sandpaper-gate" scandal in South Africa that saw him sent home in disgrace.

"I'm sorry. I'm absolutely devastated," he said at the time, weeping.

Cameron Bancroft had been caught by television cameras trying to rough up the ball with sandpaper with Smith and his deputy David Warner found to be involved. All three were sanctioned.

Cricket Australia chief Nick Hockley said in the wake of Cummins being exposed to coronavirus that Smith had "served his ban in full and by his own admission has grown a lot as a person".

"The national selection panel and the board, we felt he had demonstrated that he was absolutely fit to hold a leadership position again," he added.

Captaincy appears to agree with Smith.

After winning the toss in Adelaide's day-night Test he chose to bat and saw his team pile on 473 for nine in their first innings, contributing a fine 93 himself, before declaring late Friday to give his bowlers at crack at a wilting England.

It proved to be a good move, with both England openers removed in quick succession.

First-innings century-maker Marnus Labuschagne, who got his break during the Lord's Ashes Test in 2019 as a concussion substitute when Smith was felled by a Jofra Archer bouncer, said the stand-in skipper had taken to the job effortlessly.

"His communication with the team after play and before play in the morning, he's very clear," said Labuschagne, who has made the number three slot his own, with Smith batting at four.

"It's the first time I've been captained by Steve and it's nice to see him in that leadership role."

Despite his past, Smith remains broadly popular in Australia and he was given a standing ovation when he walked out to bat.

"I always felt like I had the support of people here in Australia and it's always special when you lead your country," he said.

https://sports.ndtv.com/the-ashes-2...lessly-back-into-australian-captaincy-2658032
 
David Warner Exposed CA's Tendencies For Back-Side Protecting: Ian Chappell

Cricket Australia has never protected the interest of the players and David Warner's outburst on captaincy ban has exposed the authorities' "tendencies for back-side protecting", feels the legendary Ian Chappell. Warner on Wednesday withdrew the bid to overturn his lifetime captaincy ban, saying the review panel wanted him to go through "public lynching" and he is not prepared to let his family be the "washing machine for cricket's dirty laundry". Chappell became the latest to come out in support of Warner after former skipper Michael Clarke too lashed out at CA for their lopsided review of his leadership ban and making the lefthander a scapegoat in the 2018 sandpaper scandal.

"I couldn't be happier that David Warner told Cricket Australia the equivalent of "go and get stuffed" when he went public about his decision to withdraw his request for a review of his captaincy ban," Chappell wrote in a column for ESPNCricinfo.

"This indicated Warner - who had been advised by CA against a public outburst -- didn't trust the authorities to be mindful of his interests. It was a wise decision by Warner as CA is renowned for only protecting their own interests, not those of players." "Young players should be thankful Warner has exposed CA's tendencies for back-side protecting. They need to keep it in mind for the future.

"Most importantly, though, Warner's withdrawal of his review highlights how appalling the original decision to award him a lifetime leadership ban was," the cricketer-turned-commentator observed.

Then Aussie skipper Steve Smith and his deputy at the time Warner were both suspended for 12 months after Cameron Bancroft was caught applying sandpaper to the ball during a match in South Africa in 2018.

While the trio were handed respective bans from cricket, they also served leadership suspensions.

Smith was banned from holding a leadership position in Australian cricket for two years, while Warner was banned for life in that respect. Bancroft was banned from captaincy for 12 months.

Observing that Warner and Smith should have received the "same leadership punishment after the Cape Town incident", Chappell remarked that the latter's "crime was greater".

"Cheating is indefensible but so also is Smith as Australia captain saying 'I don't want to know' when he walked past Warner and Bancroft, who were deep in discussion in the dressing room before they went ahead with the plan to tamper with the ball," the 79-year-old wrote.

"As a captain it was Smith's job to know what his players were up to. If their motive was illegal, he needed to put a quick stop to any shenanigans.

"Smith's crime was greater than Warner's. So it was no wonder Warner was incensed by his stiff original punishment while others were treated far more leniently." The former Australian captain slammed the authorities for the way they handled the issue.

"In the lead-up to the events in South Africa and in the aftermath, CA has erred regularly because self-protection is a high priority for them.

"The lop-sided punishments, the botched integrity review in South Africa, and then the absurd decision to not allow an appeal by the Australian players - their list of failures goes on. No wonder Warner had a gut full, but he chose the right target to attack." The 36-year-old Warner is still living with the leadership ban, four years since the infamous Cape Town Test but Smith is back leading the side in the ongoing day-night second Test against the West Indies following skipper Pat Cummins injury pullout.

"I doubt Warner was expecting to gain a leadership position in the Australia set-up even with a successful review of the ban he received after the ball-tampering debacle in South Africa in 2018," Chappell wrote.

"He's too old to be considered for a captaincy position in the Australian regime despite the fact that he has always had great leadership instincts.

"However, I think Warner had hoped he might be able to lead his BBL team, Sydney Thunder, at some point. A pity because he would have been the ideal person to guide younger players on their cricketing path. Not to worry CA, because he'll still be a leader and be listened to by any cricketer who wants to get ahead." Chappell feels Warner may have been "disliked" by a CA administrator because he came out openly against the administration in their pay wrangle.

"Whether Warner was disliked by an administrator, or it was because he was prepared to speak out during the feisty pay wrangle is unknown and likely to remain that way. What is known is Warner won't be bullied." Urging Warner to write a tell-all book, Chappell wrote: "He'll have his say and if he does reveal all later in a book, it'll be worth reading. It may take some work to get his book published because there'll be a lot of red faces around if it does reach the public."

NDTV
 
Australia under Steve Smith's captaincy since his leadership ban got lifted (all formats)

W W W W L W W L D W W W

Won a Test away in India and drew the other
Won an ODI series away in India
Whitewashed West Indies at home
Won against England in the series decider
 
Pat Cummins is better. Steve smith is one heck of a player onsong though
 
Back
Top