What's new

England captain Joe Root hints at changes to squad for Pakistan Tests

hadi123

Test Debutant
Joined
Oct 19, 2010
Runs
15,247
Post of the Week
1
After a gruelling five-month tour of Australia and New Zealand, the idea of being able to spend a few afternoons on the sofa watching television would appeal to many. Not Joe Root.

The IPL is in full flow once more and had things gone as he hoped the England captain would be out in India honing his T20 skills rather than recuperating at home.

However, after missing out in the auction, he has had to watch from afar as his international team-mates spend six weeks showcasing their skills in the world's most high-profile domestic tournament.

Not that Root begrudges them this opportunity, despite any personal disappointment at not being involved - it is the performances of the Jason Roy and Ben Stokes that have forced him to spend his time off in front of the TV.


Ben Stokes added another stunning IPL boundary catch to his CV with this cracker for Rajasthan against KKR
"It's not frustration watching the other guys," he told Sky Sports Cricket.

"There have been a number of times I've been sat on the sofa and ended up not being able to go out all afternoon because Jason is playing an unbelievable knock or Sam Billings is doing the same, Jos [Buttler] and Stokesy playing in the same side. I want to see them do well.

"Obviously, on a personal note, I went into the IPL auction to get a bit more exposure to T20 cricket, it didn't materialise, it would have been nice to be involved in that but I've got no bitter feelings towards the other guys, I think it's great.

"They'll benefit hugely from it and we, as a side, will benefit hugely from it. Look at the way Jos and Ben and a few guys came back from it last year and what it has brought to their games, it's been fabulous.

"Hopefully that can happen on a wider scale with more and more players going out there from English cricket, playing under scrutiny and in the high-pressure situations that that tournament brings, it can only be a good thing for us in the long term."

A little over a year since Root was appointed as England's Test captain, he is in a better position than most to talk about having to deal with additional pressures and scrutiny.

There can be few times an England skipper is under the microscope more than when things are going wrong on an Ashes tour.

Even putting aside the defeat in Australia, Root's first year at the helm has been an eventful one - "there have been a few things that I didn't expect to have to deal with" - but he insists that he remains excited by what this team can accomplish.

"There have been a few ups and downs along the way but we've become a lot tighter as a group and I think we'll be a better team for that," he said. "I think it can be a great launch pad for us now to really move forward and make big strides in Test cricket."


The majority of those ups came last summer as England claimed their first home Test series win over South Africa since 1998 before shaking off a surprise defeat at Headingley to beat the Windies.

But seven Tests without a win over the winter has led to suggestions that the side, certainly away from home, is not just standing still but going backwards.

Root, though, seems clear in how he wants to take England forward and key to that is the belief that there is no one way to win in all conditions.

He was certainly encouraged by the performance and balance of the side in their final Test of the winter in Christchurch but adaptability, he stressed, will be crucial in the months and years ahead.

"You have to have an open mind. If something isn't working, you can't continue to keep doing the same things over and over again.

"I thought coming into that last Test match and the way we played over those five days, we played some really good cricket. If the light had held out a little bit more on a few of the other days or on that final day, it might have been a very different end to a difficult winter.


"But there has been a lot to show me, especially in that team, that we can get to where we want to get to. It's going to take a long time, it's not going to happen overnight but there is everything there that shows we can be a force to be reckoned with."

That process is still in its infancy and while the XI in Christchurch felt like a step towards it, this is not yet Root's team, that, he says, will happen gradually.

As ever, the pressure to get results makes the challenge of moulding the team into his image, implementing changes and introducing new ideas all the more difficult.

As Brendan Rodgers once put it: "The problem with being a manager is it's like trying to build an aircraft while it is flying."

The same applies to Root as England captain and as he approaches his second summer in the role, expectations will only increase as the idea that he is 'new to the job' fades.


The travails of the winter only seem to have strengthened Root's resolve though and the indication is that he is ready to make the tough decisions.

"Looking forward, there will be changes, especially long-term and then it is up to guys to come in and take the opportunities.

"If we have to try different formulas in different conditions then so be it but again, from doing that, come great opportunities for someone and a chance to take that and make it difficult to leave them out again.

"I suppose [I want] a better continuation from that last game and to see us become adaptable and have as many options as we had over those five days. I want us to keep searching for ways to be a really effective side in a number of different conditions."

While Stokes, Buttler, Roy and co continue to play to sell-out crowds in India, Root will return to action for Yorkshire in rather more sedate surroundings at Chelmsford on May 4 as he begins his preparations for another hectic summer.

Pakistan and India are expected to provide a stern test of England's credentials and while success abroad may be the ultimate goal, ensuring home series victories remain a staple will be just as important as Root's reign progresses.

http://www.skysports.com/cricket/ne...nd-captain-his-plans-for-the-side-and-the-ipl
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not sure how many changes England can make - no need to panic, Pakistan arent a formidable force in Tests at the moment
 
Pak has a much better chance of staging an upset than India. Early season swing will help Pak bowlers where as Indians might struggle to get 20 wickets once the weather improves.. So Pak should ignore whatever England does and go with their strength..
 
It's only fare that England have a few debutantes in their squad to match the 5 that we have in ours....
 
I expect YJB and Malan to perform well along with Root.

Malan is hit or miss.

Root and YJB are the only quality bats in that T20 lineup.

Cook is on his last legs, Moeen is out of form, Stokes has just come back as well.

This ENG team is desperate for a win here as they have had to go through a loss against the WI, 4-0 in the Ashes and 1-0 in NZ.

Root most of all is paranoid and worried he might be sacked as captain if his team does not come good sooner than later.
 
World is so political, it's filthy, the way SKY is pumping up IPL nowadays just because Star has the rights makes me believe in nothing anymore.

So basically just toe the line.
 
I think a lot of the English batsmen will come good at home, Cook might even play himself into form. I'd be worried for them if this was 2 years ago and Misbah and YK were still around. Pak are a lot weaker without them and they will likely be playing a new batting combination, so lots of question marks on how all those guys will cope in England.

India will be a sterner test, with a more settled side and the pitches eventually flattening out by that point.

England will ikely beta both but this is not the Pakistan that toured in 2016.
 
Not sure how many changes England can make - no need to panic, Pakistan arent a formidable force in Tests at the moment

Regardless of the strength of the opposition, england need to take a serious look at changing the batting line up and trying to build a solid batting line up longterm.

Apart from Cook, Bairstow and Root himself all other batting positions are up for grabs.
 
England toured Australia (and New Zealand) with a ton of nobodies. The only one who made a mark was Malan, and Vince for the wrong reasons.

This summer is make or break for the rest of them: Stoneman and Crane included. Cook is also at the stage where he should decide whether to float or sink.
 
At home everyone is a sher these days. I expect England to find a way to hit some scores against us and then clouderson will do the rest..Al I'm hoping for in the test series is for some of our youngsters to shine..some hundreds and five fers..the result doesnt bother me as I expect to lose this series..
 
At home everyone is a sher these days. I expect England to find a way to hit some scores against us and then clouderson will do the rest..Al I'm hoping for in the test series is for some of our youngsters to shine..some hundreds and five fers..the result doesnt bother me as I expect to lose this series..

Have more respect for someone who has over 500 wickets.
 
England scouting report: The players hoping to gain selection for the first Test against Pakistan

With England's opening Test of the summer against Pakistan three weeks away, these are the men hoping to gain selection:

Mark Stoneman
Remains the favourite to open with Alastair Cook this summer but four low scores in his first two championship matches for Surrey indicate that his struggles continue. One decent score should be enough to keep him in the side for the Pakistan series. Failure in those two Tests will cost him his place.

James Vince
In the same position as Stoneman but has at least strung together some sort of form for Hampshire. His 75 in the opening match of against Worcestershire helped his team win the game and was worth three figures at any other stage of the season. For once, he could be forgiven for not converting a good start. But since then he has made 50 in three innings.

Liam Livingstone
Next in line for a place if England’s selectors remain consistent under Ed Smith. Livingstone toured New Zealand without making a Test debut but, like so many others, has struggled at the start of the championship season. Has a highest score of 48 from five innings.

Haseeb Hameed
His struggles in the county championship continue, much to England’s disappointment. Andy Flower gave him a good tour report from the Lions over the winter and believes Hameed has expanded his game, but whether he is putting too much pressure on himself or just plain out of form, it’s hard to tell. His England career remains on hold.

Keaton Jennings
Moved to Lancashire over the winter but is another one of their batsmen who has failed to fire. Highest score of 27 in five innings is not going to dislodge Stoneman and it is unclear whether he has answered the worries England had over his technique when he was dropped last summer.

Jake Ball
Endured a tough Ashes tour, losing his place after the first Test and never coming close to selection again. England thought his bowling lacked aggression but Ball has been unlucky to play his three Tests on flat batting tracks. Back home in familiar conditions, he has bounced back to form. With Chris Woakes not playing in the IPL, Ball is in a good position to feature in the first Test against Pakistan.

Craig Overton
After his experiences in Australia and New Zealand, Overton has realised he has to add more pace to his game at Test level and is trying to bowl quicker for Somerset. Has started the season solidly and, with Toby Roland-Jones ruled out, he will be in the mix.

Jack Leach
Not much joy for spinners this time of the year. Should be in the 13 for the Lord’s Test against Pakistan but unlikely to play. Missed the win over Yorkshire last weekend with illness, meaning he has played only one game since returning from New Zealand. Mason Crane has still not returned from the injury that cut short his winter, leaving Leach as England’s first-choice specialist spinner.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket...g-report-players-hoping-gain-selection-first/
 
Top 7 from previous Test likely to be the same, and not won't be surprised if the other three or four are retained as well.

I want an unchanged XI because I want Pakistan to win, and England to replace Vince, Stoneman and Overton. None of them are good enough for Test cricket and have enjoyed a good run or two.
 
Hameed has no chance considering his pathetic form.
Rory burns can leapfrog stoneman as a opener or gubbins next in line.
Vince will get another chance at no.3
I really want young dan Lawrence at no.5 but I think England will continue with malan or Livingstone.
 
Would really love it if Hameed could get his form back. That boy was a revelation in India and looked like the perfect successor for Cook. Really disappointing to see that he has not kicked on since then.
 
I think time has also come up for Cook to retire. He has been a great opener for England over the years but he looks completely done. He may be averaging 40+ in last few years but much of that has come through minnow bashing or some dead rubber performance.

The best time for him to retire would be after the upcoming home season against India.
 
Bairstow should give up gloves.

Been saying this for three years. Should play at 5 with Foakes taking the gloves and batting at 7. He's one of England's best batsman yet Bayliss continues to waste him down the order.
 
England ready to try Nick Gubbins against Pakistan in Lord's Test as selectors look to breathe new life into Test side

Nick Gubbins has put himself within touching distance of an England debut against Pakistan at Lord's as new national selector Ed Smith contemplates breathing new life into a Test side without a win in seven matches this winter.

The Middlesex opener was dismissed for 99 against Gloucestershire yesterday and that score, along with three hundreds in four innings across all formats, has propelled him into the frame for the first match of the international summer on May 24.

Sportsmail understands England are seriously considering bringing in 24-year-old Gubbins for Surrey's out-of-touch Mark Stoneman but there will be no radical overhaul under the new stewardship of Smith.

England are keen to move Ben Stokes and Jonny Bairstow up the order and they will probably bat at five and six, with Liam Livingstone another possible debutant at seven after making a good impression in New Zealand.

Jack Leach will retain his place as the sole spinner when the selectors meet at Lord's on Tuesday but the seam attack will have a familiar look, with Mark Wood, Chris Woakes and Craig Overton competing to join Stokes, Jimmy Anderson and Stuart Broad. Moeen Ali misses out but will be in contention as a second spinner when England play India later this summer.

The old will join the new at Tuesday's selection meeting as Smith will be surprisingly joined by Angus Fraser and Mick Newell.

The pair were expected to make way once the national selector role was filled but have been invited, with England coach Trevor Bayliss, to provide their input in picking those to face Pakistan at Lord's the following week.

Test captain Joe Root and director of cricket Andrew Strauss will be present but Smith will have the final say.

The retention of Fraser and Newell, directors of cricket at Middlesex and Nottinghamshire respectively, will provide continuity but slows the ECB's plan to move towards independence in its selection process.

The squad chosen by the selectors will face Pakistan in two Tests at Lord's and Headingley, and Pakistan coach Mickey Arthur revealed his side are using videos of New Zealander Trent Boult's destruction of England at Auckland in March to plan the demise of Root's team.

Boult aimed for a full length with the new ball to expose England's non-existent footwork, reducing them to 27 for nine.

Arthur wants Pakistan's bowlers — especially Boult's fellow left-armers Mohammad Amir and Rahat Ali — to follow suit as they aim for a first Test series win in this country since 1996.

'You don't often see teams 27 for nine,' Arthur said. 'It was bizarre but I did marvel at the spell of swing bowling from Trent Boult. We used it in our bowlers' meeting on Thursday, when we looked at the lengths they should bowl. Our bowlers have been great, but our lengths have just been a little bit short.

'That's common with subcontinental teams who come to England.'

Meanwhile, England's T20 superstar Jos Buttler on Friday night scored a thrilling, unbeaten 95 off 60 balls to lead Rajasthan Royals to a four-wicket win against the Chennai Super Kings in the IPL.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/cr...Nick-Gubbins-against-Pakistan-Lords-Test.html
 
Bob Willis selects his England squad for Test series against Pakistan

England are set to name their first Test squad of the 2018 summer on Tuesday - but who is in contention to play Pakistan in the Lord's Test starting on May 24?

After a winless winter that saw England suffer a 4-0 Ashes drubbing in Australia and then go down 1-0 in New Zealand - bowled out for 58 in the first Test - there are plenty of question marks over certain players and positions to play for.

So, we have turned to Sky Sports Cricket experts David Lloyd, Bob Willis and Rob Key to help sort through the options and pick their preferred squads to take on Pakistan...

David Lloyd's England squad

Cook, Gubbins, Vince, Root (c), Malan, Stokes, Bairstow (wkt), Woakes, Broad, Leach, Anderson
12th man: Livingstone

David Lloyd is 'stubborn' about James Vince and wants England to stick with him at Test level

Staying put

There's nobody knocking the door down, so I don't expect too many changes; England are looking to pick a settled team. As such, I'm keeping James Vincein at No 3 - I'm really stubborn about him; I think he is a damn good player. I haven't got a leg to stand on when people say he keeps getting out the same way but he looks a classy, composed player up till then. Another way they could go is to move Jonny Bairstow up the order to No 5 - I think that's what they're looking at long-term - drop Vince and bring in Liam Livingstone or Moeen Ali at No 7. It wouldn't be the way I go, but I would have Livingstone in the squad as 12th man.

Changes

Nick Gubbins has an excellent chance of playing. I'd be keen to take a look at him, in place of Mark Stoneman. Also, Chris Woakes comes back in for me, in place of Mark Wood. Horses for courses; Woakes has a really good record in England, and he gives me another batting option.

Keep an eye on

Northamptonshire's Richard Gleeson, pictured here in action for the MCC against Essex, could be a 'long shot'

These guys, who have never played before, will play Test cricket at some point this summer. Liam Livingstone - he's in my squad, but he's still to make his debut. There's also Joe Clarke, the talented young batsman from Worcestershire, Olly Stone, the fast bowler at Warwickshire, and my real long shot is Northamptonshire's Richard Gleeson. He is 30 years old, but has no mileage on the clock! You'd think he'd have thousands of overs under his belt, but he hasn't; in cricketing terms he's only 25. A big, strapping, strong, fit bowler - every time I've watched him he is clocking 90 miles per hour plus.

Bob Willis' England squad

Cook, Stoneman, Root (c), Malan, Bairstow (wkt), Stokes, Livingstone, Wood, Broad, Leach, Anderson
12th man: Woakes

Bob Willis would give Lancashire's Liam Livingstone a go lower down the order in the England Test team

Staying put

Some people want Alastair Cook out, but as I always say; we can't find a partner for him, let alone dropping him and finding two openers. There will be people wanting to write Stuart Broad and James Anderson off too, like Cook, but until you've got proven, regularly successful replacements ready, these two are untouchable, particularly in English conditions. I'm sticking with Jack Leach as my spinner and Mark Wood - if he's fit, and can stay fit - should play. Can he bowl at 90 plus miles per hour and give the bowling attack a different dimension?

Changes

I want Joe Root batting at No 3 - I always believe that's where the best player in the side should bat - and I would have Liam Livingstone come in as a specialist batsman at No 7; I'm frustrated, as many people are, by James Vince. I'm very surprised he's been given so many opportunities and he would not be part of my line-up. I also don't think Chris Woakesand Moeen Ali did enough over the winter to warrant immediate recalls. There was such a sameness about Woakes, Craig Overton and Tom Curran in the bowling attack.

Keep an eye on

Worcestershire's 20-year-old batsman Joe Clarke is one with a bright future for England

Haseeb Hameed would have been in my side - temperament-wise when he came into the side in India, he looked like he'd be England's opener for the next 10 years - but he has had another struggle at the start of the season. I think Joe Clarke is probably the form horse of the batting reserves, but the problem is it's an opener England need most, and there aren't many crying out to be selected. There is also a lobby for Ben Foakes, and less so these days for Jos Buttler.

Toby Roland-Jones would have been in the mix, if not injured, after such a promising start in the side last summer, while probably the most successful seamer over the last couple of years has been Jamie Porterat Essex, but he can't really compare to Broad and Anderson. Jake Ball has had a nice start to the summer with Nottinghamshire, but again he offers something very similar to the current attack, and he looked extremely ordinary in the one Test he played in Brisbane over the winter.

Rob Key's England squad

Cook, Gubbins, Root (c), Malan, Bairstow, Stokes, Buttler (wkt), Woakes, Broad, Leach, Anderson
12th man: Wood/ Stone

Rob Key would bring back Jos Buttler as wicketkeeper in the England Test team

Staying put

I don't really mind where Joe Root bats but I've slotted him in at No 3 to break up the left-handers, as I've got Dawid Malan at No 4 - anyone that can play like he did in Australia is nailed on for the summer. I think Jack Leach did enough on debut in New Zealand to deserve another go, and I'm trying to pick the best pure spinner, rather than someone who can bat and bowl a little bit. Moeen Ali is still a fantastic cricketer, but is just a bit low on confidence right now. He needs to find some form before coming back.

Changes

I was close to keeping Mark Stoneman, giving him a couple of Tests to save his England career as no-one is really battering down the door for that spot; Rory Burns - his opening partner at Surrey - has got runs, while an older option could be Joe Denly at Kent, who is batting just about as well as anyone in the country at the moment. But, I think Nick Gubbins is deserving of a go - he hit two hundreds in the North v South series and has started the summer well, with a ton and a 99 in among his first three innings for Middlesex.

It's hard on James Vince, but I've had to drop him for the balance and make-up of the team because I want to move Jonny Bairstow up the order - by doing that you have a better spine of the team. He doesn't keep the gloves though; nothing against Ben Foakes, but I've been pushing for about two years now for Jos Buttler to get back into the Test team. He doesn't play much red-ball cricket, but I think he wants to - I interviewed him after an IPL game and asked him "Do you want to play Test cricket still?" Straight away he said yes. He's too good a player to keep leaving out. Chris Woakes comes back in forMark Wood. English conditions and the extra bit of batting at No 8 are what really tip the scales in his favour.

Keep an eye on

Warwickshire fast bowler Olly Stone could be an option on fast, bouncy tracks

England need to find some Test match batsmen, and young batsmen - that's the real mission for this summer. It can be guys that maybe haven't got the greatest record in first-class cricket, but that you see something in them that means that they're going to have good Test careers. Sam Northeast would probably have featured in this squad, but he's now got a broken finger and is out for eight weeks. I also like young Ollie Pope at Surrey, Dan Lawrence at Essex and I'm still a fan of Ben Duckett, but he's not scoring runs at the moment with Northamptonshire.

I don't think he's fit, but I like the look of Olly Stone. I want him and Wood as pace options in the squad. You could go horses for courses - you might bring in a Wood or a Stone on a hard bouncy surface, but in early-season conditions Woakes probably gets the edge. There's Jamie Porter at Essex too, who could be a like for like for Jimmy Anderson.


http://www.skysports.com/cricket/ne...istan-bob-willis-and-rob-key-make-their-picks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nasser Hussain has also called for a similar 11 with Vince being retained in the side
 
I think vince and malan will be retained but stoneman will axed considering his poor outings for surrey and strong competition from gubbins,burns,jennings.
As a extra batsman Livingston,foakes,joe clarke are in contention.
In Bowling woakes place is under threat but he will get another chance due to his record in English conditions last year.
20 year old josh tongue can be surprise selection if selectors ignore wood.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Rob Key, England needs to trust Buttler across formats. He is an incredible talent and can become a world class batsman in all formats. I find him very similar to de Villiers.

However, I won't give him the gloves either. England needs to play both Bairstow and Buttler as specialist batsmen in Tests. Keeping will weigh them down. Play them at 4 and 5, and watch them fly. Bring Foakes in as the keeper.

I think England are wasting their time with Vince and Malan. They will never be Test class batsmen in my view, Bairstow and Buttler have significantly higher ceilings.
 
Jack Leach currently off the field for Somerset with a hand injury, could change things a bit.
 
Somerset spinner Jack Leach is set to miss England's first Test against Pakistan later in May after the county confirmed he had broken his left thumb.

The 26-year-old left-armer suffered the injury while warming up for Somerset on Monday ahead of the fourth day of their Division One match against Hampshire.

England's new national selector Ed Smith is set to name the squad on Tuesday to face Pakistan from 24 May.

Leach made his Test debut in New Zealand in March, taking two wickets.

Shortly before 13:30 BST on Monday, Somerset posted on social media: "Jack Leach has sustained a broken left thumb. It's too early to know how long he will be out for at the moment."

Leach was struck on the thumb while taking part in a fielding drill with head coach Jason Kerr.

The hosts are pushing for victory over Hampshire, who reached lunch on day four trailing by 15 runs with Somerset still to bat again.

The Taunton club have won two and drawn one of their opening three County Championship matches of the season.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/44111719
 
Leach injured.

Bring back Moeen so we can feast on his spin !
 
Leach injured.

Bring back Moeen so we can feast on his spin !

If he's brought back to face Pakistan, I fear his career might end which would be sad. He's in poor form at the moment and should be brought back against a weaker team like India, who also happen to be his bunny.
 
1) Cook - Not a threat
2) Stoneman - Not a threat
3) Root - Main threat
4) Malan - Threatening
5) Stokes - Threatening
6) Bairstow - Threathening
7) Whoever it is, unlikely to be a threat
8) Leach - Not a threat
9) Broad - Threathning
10) Anderson - Threathning
11) Curran - Not a threat

As long as we get Root out early, at least three times out of four and put up 300+ in the first innings of each match, we'll sweep the series 2:0, InshAllah.
 
Jack Leach currently off the field for Somerset with a hand injury, could change things a bit.

Dont think england need a spinner in the side early summer for either test vs pakistan.
 
England does not need to get its selection right to beat us. Our pathetic batting lineup will do the job for them.
 
1) Cook - Not a threat
2) Stoneman - Not a threat
3) Root - Main threat
4) Malan - Threatening
5) Stokes - Threatening
6) Bairstow - Threathening
7) Whoever it is, unlikely to be a threat
8) Leach - Not a threat
9) Broad - Threathning
10) Anderson - Threathning
11) Curran - Not a threat

As long as we get Root out early, at least three times out of four and put up 300+ in the first innings of each match, we'll sweep the series 2:0, InshAllah.

Easier said than done.
 
Vince hits 200 and Wood takes six wickets on the eve of selection...
 
Been pretty warm lately and likely to stay warm and dry up to and through the first test.
 
England does not need to get its selection right to beat us. Our pathetic batting lineup will do the job for them.

Please report back to these threads after the series. I remember you went missing for weeks on the pretext of being "busy" at the end of the 2016 series when you made similar claims about our team's chances.
 
Please report back to these threads after the series. I remember you went missing for weeks on the pretext of being "busy" at the end of the 2016 series when you made similar claims about our team's chances.

I don't go into hiding, and things were different in 2016. Our team was relatively better, the conditions were favorable and a couple of England's key players were injured.
 
Back
Top