SpiritOf1903
ODI Debutant
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2009
- Runs
- 9,448
The broadcaster was definitely looking in detail.Does that action look legal
They used quite a few freeze frames
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The broadcaster was definitely looking in detail.Does that action look legal
Yeah, I also noticed him chucking today. Even my friends, with whom I was watching the match, all noticed it
It's simply unnatural to bowl in a throwing motion. He's definitely a new speciesBro in simple terms it's backwards bend and it's due to hyperextension. This isn't illegal
These are the same posters that would come out and defend Shoaib Akhtar's action.Every time bumrah performed well,some usual poster's are crying about his actions. Pathetic sore loser's.
-> Has the mind of a newly born Giraffe.Can anyone pls tell me how does KL Rahul avg 33 in test cricket. Guy has class written all over him and his technique is copybook. It is very surprising that he hasn't set the world on fire yet but I understand why BCCI backs him so much.
Yeah, I also noticed him chucking today. Even my friends, with whom I was watching the match, all noticed it
Yes and Indians have PhD in itPakistanis don't understand chucking rules.
Most of all , stat obsessed selfish shameless pig.even after srh decimating lucknow in 9 overs,he played with 100 sr in next match with out any hesitation and shame.-> Has the mind of a newly born Giraffe.
-> Heart of a Kitten
-> Self belief of a deer caught in Tiger's jaws.
We saw ajmal,hafeez enough .we.lost a t20 wc due to another chucker sena nayake.Yes and Indians have PhD in it
Yes and Indians have PhD in it
He has great skill and technique; he can play all kinds of shots and is a versatile batsman. I expected him to be the next big player after Kohli and Rohit, but he has been hugely disappointing. He is mentally not strong and a bit selfish in the white-ball format.Can anyone pls tell me how does KL Rahul avg 33 in test cricket. Guy has class written all over him and his technique is copybook. It is very surprising that he hasn't set the world on fire yet but I understand why BCCI backs him so much.
Aussies dropped 2 catches. Otherwise, India could've been all-out for 130-140.
Anyway, I expect Aussies to win by an innings here.
THey do that for all lol They did that in 2018 as well. They did that in 2021 as well. I remember once Bishop criticizing the guys who talked like you after a loss. Total soure grapesThe broadcaster was definitely looking in detail.
They used quite a few freeze frames
Indian batting is also a joke. Even with Rohit and Gill coming back.India still might lose this first Test match at Perth. But they are definitely winning the series.
Australia's batting is nothing. People have been hyping Australia up but it's India who are favorites.
Even a young West Indies side rolled Australian batting over.
THey do that for all lol They did that in 2018 as well. They did that in 2021 as well. I remember once Bishop criticizing the guys who talked like you after a loss. Total soure grapes
Agreed.Need to clean up the tail quickly tomorrow. Every run is precious on this wicket.
India also needs to come out with an attacking mindset in their second innings. Jaiswal especially needs to back his natural instincts.
Ok the same bishop who is one of the lead commies at the IPL
Did say I expected a low scoring series with two vulnerable batting lineups, but I didn't predict this carnage ! 17 wickets in a day, wow.
Umpire's decision is final.
I stand with the umpire.
I think Bumrah should be tested. This looks like chucking.
Depends on the lead.Austrlaia has never lost a test at Optus stadium. Won 4 out of 4 here. So i still back Australia in this contest. Difference is not that big.
100% agree.I'm coming from a neutral point of view.
You seen the super slow split screen and the break down of his action. It's suspect enough for Bumrah to have to go for tests. No different to the above I mentioned
Still Superior to Australian battingIndian batting is also a joke. Even with Rohit and Gill coming back.
Its about which bowling attack is better on the day that will decide the outcome of the Test.
Ooh that looks bad
I think Bumrah should be tested. This looks like chucking.
Australia is quickly becoming 2017-2019 pakistan with the exception of superior bowling
Both teams rely on one batter to solo carry (Fakhar + Travis) and both rely on bowlers however aussie bowling attack is 100x superior to 2017 pakistan.
Really tough times for aus cricket.
Which commie has even remotely said he is chucking. Give me another name lol Except you guys nobody is talking about it.
That's why Pragyan Ojha was banned from bowling due to chucking in 2014, until he cleared himself next year?Question is does ICC have the spine to ban Bumrah even if he is proven to be chucking? Knowing ICC's track record, it is unlikely.
We may never know.
I suggest stop responding to low quality posters. I block all such posters as they contribute absolutely nothing to cricketing discussion.umpires has no problem with Bumrah action so you should stand with the umpires. Right? #hypocrisy exposed
I can literally call anyone chucking without any proof. Commies analyze all the bowlers. THey analyzed Harshit Rana as well. This is 100% unadulterated sour grapes. I am quiet enjoying it.It's clear, he has significant extension in his elbow.
The comms would definitely not scrutinized his action thoroughly if they weren't suspect about it.
I think not. Both are pretty sad but they have 2 and a half batters while we're making do with 1 and a half or 2 at a stretch right now especially in Australian conditions.Still Superior to Australian batting
There's a reason all they can do is 'analyse'.THey do that for all lol They did that in 2018 as well. They did that in 2021 as well. I remember once Bishop criticizing the guys who talked like you after a loss. Total soure grapes
Australia has 3 solid bowlers and good 4th bowling option. India has just one. Rana on debut. Siraj hsa regressed massively. 4th bowler is not that goodI think not. Both are pretty sad but they have 2 and a half batters while we're making do with 1 and a half or 2 at a stretch right now especially in Australian conditions.
It comes down to the bowling. They need to beat us in this game where their bowling line-up is clearly better else Shami being added to support Bumrah will make the line-ups at par from the next game onwards.
You are a non-Indian. That automatically makes you biased duh. He played in world cup. When he bowled a noball in 2017 CT final you didn't really have to talk about his action lol It comes up only when he does well.There's a reason all they can do is 'analyse'.
It's virtually a home India series. All the sponsors are Indian, which must be unprecedented in Australian Home Test series. It's like a WTC final.
Indians are immune from suspicion. Gorrit.That automatically makes you biased duh. He played in world cup. When he bowled a noball in 2017 CT final you didn't really have to talk about his action lol It comes up only when he does well.
Mental midget.Can anyone pls tell me how does KL Rahul avg 33 in test cricket. Guy has class written all over him and his technique is copybook. It is very surprising that he hasn't set the world on fire yet but I understand why BCCI backs him so much.
What happened to cheater Smith and your god Travis head .Australia is quickly becoming 2017-2019 pakistan with the exception of superior bowling
Both teams rely on one batter to solo carry (Fakhar + Travis) and both rely on bowlers however aussie bowling attack is 100x superior to 2017 pakistan.
Really tough times for aus cricket.
Bumrah is a bowler and a half nowadays to be honest. Throw in Shami and one of supporting gang and we have 3 solid quicks. I'd put that up against the Ozzie 3 headed monster and feel confident we could match. Without Shami of course we're short.Australia has 3 solid bowlers and good 4th bowling option. India has just one. Rana on debut. Siraj hsa regressed massively. 4th bowler is not that good
How are you neutral? lol You are a non-Indian that automatically shows the bias. I can literally call anyone chucking without any proof. Commies analyze all the bowlers. THey analyzed Harshit Rana as well. This is 100% unadulterated sour grapes. I am quiet enjoying it.
Bumrah chucks - only a idiot would believe that . He has played 41 Tests , 89 ODI's & 70 T20's - how many times was he called for '' chucking '' while picking up 415 international wickets ?
was Murali called in a INT game .... YES as far as I know !Some say Murali was a chucker and he had 800 Test wickets.
Some say Bhajji was a chucker and he had 400+ Test wickets.
Just because it wasn't caught before doesn't mean chucking can't happen now. Based on the image @SpiritOf1903 posted, he should be tested.
He cant be. BCCI has too much power and that's the long and short of it. He has a freak action out of Lagaan. His ability to catapult the ball is highly unnaturalBumrah chucks - only a idiot would believe that . He has played 41 Tests , 89 ODI's & 70 T20's - how many times was he called for '' chucking '' while picking up 415 international wickets ?
was 1903 a bad year for .....He cant be. BCCI has too much power and that's the long and short of it. He has a freak action out of Lagaan. His ability to catapult the ball is highly unnatural
Some say Murali was a chucker and he had 800 Test wickets.
Some say Bhajji was a chucker and he had 400+ Test wickets.
Just because it wasn't caught before doesn't mean chucking can't happen now. Based on the image @SpiritOf1903 posted, he should be tested.
2004 article.. One is ex-pak coach and other one is ex-pak player.. So they're not bccicc guy (and bcci not that strong at that time)..But Woolmer and Rameez were willing to make an exception for the cases that involved hyperextension. "I have no problem as the arm bends back past the vertical. In the case of a thrower it is clearly different, where the arm is jerked through."
Let on-field umpires rule on chucking
The issue of chucking divides opinions, but a clear verdict emerged from apanel of former cricketers instituted by <I>Wisden Asia Cricket</I>: five out ofseven members came out in favour of handing the matter back to the umpireswww.espncricinfo.com
The elbow extension rule is much more strict for spinners, with no more than 5 degrees of bending allowed. Murali has a congenital deformity in his bowling arm, which has a natural 15% bend at the elbow. Hence, he was never punished by the ICC..Some say Murali was a chucker and he had 800 Test wickets.
Some say Bhajji was a chucker and he had 400+ Test wickets.
Just because it wasn't caught before doesn't mean chucking can't happen now. Based on the image @SpiritOf1903 posted, he should be tested.
I call bhajji , ojha chuckers dug. But you guys call bumrah , ashwin chuckers.Indians are immune from suspicion. Gorrit.
Only applies to Ajmal and Hasnain
Very good depending on the insinuation of your ellipsis.was 1903 a bad year for .....
@Rajdeep and all indian fan's - how's the Josh now?
2004 article.. One is ex-pak coach and other one is ex-pak player.. So they're not bccicc guy (and bcci not that strong at that time)..
Both Shoaib Akthar and Murali were tested and they were cleared.
Why can't Bumrah be tested? Are Indian players immune from getting tested?
Your last paragraph is sumup mentality of some loser's .My Josh was always high but couldn't be happier seeing all the meltdowns.
Lets be honest, cricket is just a sport and there will be one winner & a loser. We as fans have no stake in it, whatever the performance of the team we support. However, the most fun and satisfactory thing in all these is seeing the meltdown among haters. Moments like these is what makes these kind of day so special.
It all started with hopefully it is 5-0 for Aussies by end of this year to hopefully India will lose by an innings in this test to blaming IPL/T20 cricket for poor batting techniques for Aussies and finally chucking allegations. I will not be surprised if fixing card and players don't try against India for IPL money is played tomorrow. There is no better feeling than reading these gradual meltdowns on a Friday evening. Its bit like watching MSNBC on US election night.
Yes you understood someone chucking from a still picture.seems like arm has to be at a right angle to draw suspicion
Indian lacks swing bowlers like zaheer, Ishant. Whatever we have are hit the deck bowlers. Also batting has been consistently been poor.India has enjoyed its best ever pace battery in its entire history with Bhumrah, Shami, Siraj, Umesh Yadav, Ishant Sharma, Akashdeep, Harshit Rana but still apart from winning in Australia, they have failed to win a test series in England, South Africa, New Zealand in the last decade. How, i mean how? With the bowling resources they have had at their disposal they should have run through these teams in their conditions
India has enjoyed its best ever pace battery in its entire history with Bhumrah, Shami, Siraj, Umesh Yadav, Ishant Sharma, Akashdeep, Harshit Rana but still apart from winning in Australia, they have failed to win a test series in England, South Africa, New Zealand in the last decade. How, i mean how? With the bowling resources they have had at their disposal they should have run through these teams in their conditions
nailed it brother .they are finds conspiracy theories everywhere because they think everyone is like them .The reason why entire world laugh at you guys and the state of your current team.
Yeah. Remember how we intentionally lost the Eng game in 2019 WC to get Pakistan out of world cup or how Afghanistan never plays against India with full intensity due to IPL?nailed it brother .they are finds conspiracy theories everywhere because they think everyone is like them .
Their still my 2 favourite players. I support my players.What happened to cheater Smith and your god Travis head .
Never ever underestimate indians and indian cricket teams.
They can.I think they may still win 2025 CT and WTC. They tend to thrive during ICC events.