Saved a bit of face forcing it into a fifth day, but all in all a bit of a shellacking. Mickey Arthur and Pup will have no shortage of issues to address arising from this Test, not the least of which was a very ordinary bowling attack. Obviously we're not blessed with an abundance of quality spinners to choose from, so the bowlers we have who ARE good will have to pick up the slack. I don't see the point in putting in another spinner for the sake of it, they have to be decent otherwise they're just a waste of space. We need to think creatively and figure out which of the quality bowlers we have can take wickets, just like Patto did. They have to find a way to do that, or at least to keep the runs down. The bowling on Day 3 was listless. I would be inclined to bring in MJ in for Starc because he can cut the ball off the seam on some of these dark side of the moon surfaces. Siddle looks unfit as well. They collectively allowed Dhoni to b!tchslap them which was ultimately the difference between the teams - that innings took the momentum away that the OZ had built over the first couple of days.
As for the batting I always expected it to be somewhat brittle especially with Hussey's departure, but what disappointed me the most was the lack of composure which led to a lot of the dismissals. Other than Clarke and Henriques the rest of them just don't look mentally set, to play each ball on its merits, to have a go when the opportunity presents itself, to value their wicket at other times, and to have the judgment to know when to do what. Cowan's dismissals showed me that he doesn't know whether to attack or defend, to drop anchor or to try and dominate the bowlers.
The thing is, while they bowled very well on Day 4 to a lineup of batsmen turned bunnies, these Indian bowlers aren't that great. The one I thought was a real handful, Ohja, wasn't even playing. This version of Harbadulkar isn't the Saint Harby that we saw in his prime years ago, and there's no Kumble to extract wicked bounce and turn, and no Zaheer Khan to reverse the ball. I shudder to think of what those blokes would have done to this side. There's no need to bat in a shell and be so fearful. They walked out for the second innings like they were going into Auschwitz or something. Henriques doesn't have the talent of a Hughes or a Warner or Twatto but he just showed confidence in his ability and applied himself to the situation with caution but not fear. They have to figure out how to overcome their inner demons.
As for India, I think MS would be the first to admit that there is plenty of room for improvement as well. Ashwin is pretty much going to be their only go-to bowler unless they bring Ohja back in. Harbadulkar and Jadeja got some ghetto wickets in the 2nd innings but they looked very ordinary earlier on. That said, you only need to be as good as the players you are bowling to, and this OZ lineup looks like a team of u-13s from India could take their wickets at the moment. The seamers were essentially ineffectual, and that might be a problem depending on the other wickets in the series. But Tendy looked to be in very smooth touch as did Kohli, who is a big confidence player - that ton will definitely galvanise him for the rest of the series. To not really play that well, other than Dhoni and Ashwin and Kohli, and still win by 9 wickets on the first session of the fifth day is an exceptional result.