- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
The Sahiwal incident is just one instance - there have been many others but are these just isolated or point to some very deep issues with policing in Pakistan?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The biggest issue is going to be one of trust. If they can be bought, that means they have very low standards, or integrity. Now I am not in a position to verify if the reputation they have gained for corruption is unfair, I am just speaking as an outsider, this is the impression I have listening to complaints by Pakistanis themselves. Hence my adopting the username to reflect it.
I think we need to look at things in context. Under the circumstances, with over a decade of hundreds of terrorist attacks are the Pak police worse than any other police in such a situation? The UK has had nowhere near the attacks and if you can recall in 2005 after one attack, the UK police chased an innocent man onto a tube train to execute him in public?
Pak police may be corrupt but no worse than the cold blooded police killers we see in the 'civisled' UK or US.
Police in the UK or US have different issues, the charges laid against them are more usually things like racism, and if they get caught then there is a good chance they will have to answer to someone up the chain. I don't really think of them as corrupt in the sense they could be bought off or attempt shakedowns of ordinary citizens like allegedly happens in Pakistan.
The ATM thief death etc are more examples of this problem.
Reminds me of a series that was on tv called Karachi Cops. Brutal and at times tough to watch.
Cannot get over this, “Aik baat poochu?Maro gay to nahin? App nay maarna kaha say seekha?”
It is heartbreaking.
It took only a matter of hours for the two plain-clothed men to arrive and demand Adeela Suleman close her exhibition. It took another two days for unnamed men to completely destroy it.
Suleman was taken aback: yes, the 440 headstones she had carefully assembled in and around the hall in the Pakistani city of Karachi were supposed to evoke emotion.
And yes, the subject matter was controversial: each of the headstones represents a person killed by one of the country's most notorious police teams.
But now The Killing Fields of Karachi - her entry into the Karachi Biennale that was supposed to be a comment on extrajudicial killings - has become a flashpoint for freedom of expression, and the fight to be heard.
"The state officials have done what they wanted to do," Suleman told BBC Urdu. "They have closed the exhibition.
"I learnt one thing: that art has so much power, that in two hours of the public opening, something, somewhere didn't like that this is happening. That really scared them, to the extent that they had to break each and every pillar, they had to remove it."
'Killing machines'
The topic was always likely to provoke someone in power. After all, you don't need to look far in order to find examples of people killed by Pakistan's police.
At the start of this year, there was the family shot dead by officers as they made their way to a wedding. Just four months earlier, a 10-year-old girl had been killed in the crossfire between officers and a street mugger.
Suleman had chosen to focus on one very particular set of so-called "encounters": those linked to a man who was once one of Karachi's top police officers, Rao Anwar.
According to official police records, his team killed 444 people over the course of seven years. There is some suspicion Anwar may have made a living from staging extra-judicial killings of men wanted by the security establishment.
What is clear is that, as one unnamed police official put it to Pakistan's Dawn newspaper, Anwar had "led a team of killing machines" which went unchecked for years.
But Anwar's role in the killings in Karachi really hit the headlines after a young man called Naqeebullah was killed by police in an alleged "staged encounter". He was, they said, a terrorist. His family said Naqeebullah was no such thing. In fact, he was an aspiring model and this was a "fake encounter".
The case caused outrage: Anwar was removed from his job, while a police inquiry found Anwar guilty of murdering Naqeebullah and others. He has not been tried in court and denies the charges against him.
It was Naqeebullah's death which inspired Suleman, as well as prompting wider protests against the treatment of the ethnic Pashtun community he was from.
"Naqeeb's case was one case which really shook the whole world, not because that policeman was involved, but simply because he was a young, beautiful 27-year-old man," she said.
"It really made us question what kind of a society we live in. I think it stayed with all of us."
The result was her entry to the biennale: the tombstones, and a short film where she - with the help of Naqeebullah's bereaved father - tells the story of his death.
"There was nothing in the film or in the installation which was not out their in the public," she explained to the BBC. "I was working with the father, I was playing with emotions, I was questioning as the viewer, where should I go, what am I looking at. We as viewers, are we the perpetrators because we are not doing anything?"
She did not foresee any backlash. She was wrong.
The men arrived within hours of Sunday's opening, demanding it be shut. The head of the city's parks department came out and described the work as vandalism. By Monday morning, the gravestones which stood outside the hall - and therefore could not be locked away - were on their sides.
Suleman's supporters came and lay down beside them - an act of defiance against the as yet unidentified groups which had taken such offence.
Skip Twitter post by @omar_quraishiEnd of Twitter post by @omar_quraishi
By Tuesday morning, the stones had been smashed to bits. Suleman says it was the security services, but there has been no official comment.
It didn't take long for the organisers of the Karachi Biennale to decide the exhibit was no longer something they could back. They released a statement saying it was "not compatible with the ethos of #KB19".
"We feel that politicising the platform will go against our efforts of bringing art to the public and drawing artists from the fringe to the mainstream cultural discourse," they added, pleading for understanding.
That understanding is, however, in short supply from Karachi's artist community. The organisers, they say, have abandoned their artist.
Skip Twitter post by @propergaandaEnd of Twitter post by @propergaanda
"It's very simple. The work was vetted by the curatorial committee. Seen by the jury. Allowed to be shown to the public. If there was anything that did not adhere to the concept... people should have not allowed it to go forward," Sameera Raja, the founder of Karachi's Canvas Gallery, told the BBC.
"However, once it is allowed, under the ambit of KB, then KB cannot abandon their artist. This is not about Adeela or a particular work. This is not only about freedom of expression. It is about owning up, taking responsibility and respecting the artist and the community at large."
Marvi Mazhar, an architect and urban planner, warned of the chilling effect it will have on future installations - especially at a time when other industries are finding themselves fighting against increasing censorship.
"The whole order of taking No Objection Certificates will now be vetted through censorship, and every public artwork will now go through scrutiny. Now every artist will have this insecurity of some work which will not be accepted and this insecurity is what I am really questioning - how does the state work with the notion of art?"
But it the authorities are going to insist art is removed from politics and comment, they are going to have a problem, Suleman says.
"The moment you make art you are political, the moment you put it out in the public space you are political," she shrugs.
However there is one thing which has given Suleman hope for the future of Pakistan's art scene in the last few days: the number of people who have come out in support of her work.
"I am not alone. I think I have more people with me than before. I am not abandoned at all," she said.
KARACHI: The family of a young man who was gunned down by police near the Cantonment Railway Station last week on Thursday demanded a high-level inquiry into the incident and urged the chief justice of Pakistan to take up the case on priority.
The mother and sister of Nabeel Hoodbhoy along with their lawyer spoke at a press conference at the Karachi Press Club in which they expressed their dissatisfaction over the pace of the inquiry into the murder case.
“My son was a British citizen; yet, I have not sought help from the United Kingdom. We want justice [for] Nabeel in the same manner as the world deals with such brutal murders,” said Nabeel’s mother.
She said her son was a sportsman who was gunned down by the police with impunity.
“Yet, we see no one in the senior authorities who have shown real interest in punishing the killers.”
She said Nabeel’s killing was not a one-off incident since “the police have gone wild particularly in district South where similar incidents have been reported previously”.
She said that no law permitted the police to open fire on unarmed citizens.
“The policemen who shot at my son ran away; and they were even not bothered enough to shift my seriously wounded son to hospital.”
She said despite lapse of around a week since the incident, there was no tangible progress by the police in solving the case.
Though the family was not impressed with the performance of the police vis-à-vis the case, Nabeel’s mother placed her hope in the institutions meant to provide justice to the people.
“No one is safe here in Pakistan as there is no one who can ask our guards as to why they have turned killers. Police are not doing anything; still, we have hope in the institutions in according justice to us.”
She said as things stood so far no one related to the incident had been suspended.
She appealed to Prime Minister Imran Khan to play his part in giving justice to her son.
“The prime minister should wake up to this. I want an eye for an eye. I don’t want to see another mother lose her son in the same fashion and by the same killers.
“I have lost my only son. I want justice for him and not just an apology from anyone. I want justice in a manner that conforms to the standards of justice.”
She demanded the Sindh chief minister to order a high-level committee to investigate the murder case.
Nabeel’s sister said her brother was a law-abiding Pakistani and had committed no crime to pay such a heavy cost.
“I beg for justice [for] Nabeel.”
https://www.dawn.com/news/1519383/family-of-nabeel-hoodbhoy-demands-justice
ASI caught from Karachi on allegations of having links with Indian R&AW
An Additional Sub-Inspector (ASI) of the Karachi (Sindh) Police has been taken under arrest over allegations of having links with Indian spying agency, RAW, ARY News reported on Monday.
According to details, the accused was caught from Gulistan e Jauhar area of the metropolis.
The arrest was undertaken by local police officials along with the Special Services Unit (SSU) of law enforcement.
It has been revealed that the detained officer was found involved in acts of terrorism in the country and was also an active member of a team of the city’s target killers.
The police official was currently performing his duties at the Shahrah e Faisal police station in Karachi and was a resident of Gulistan e Jauhar.
Two hand grenades have been recovered from the residence of Shehzad Pervez who is being claimed as an important member of the notorious’Mehmood Siddiqui Group’ which is touted to have strong connections with Indian spying agency, Research and Analysis Wing (RAW).
The group has been revealed to have been performing under the patronage of Muttahida Qaumi Movement London (MQM-L).
https://arynews.tv/en/asi-caught-from-karachi-allegations-links-indian-raw/
The Police in PK cannot be reformed, the only guys they fear are the guys with tanks, and the guys who control the tanks. It needs to be scrapped altogether, the culture is rotten and these are beghairat officers that have deen or imaanAt least four police officers from Sindh’s Sakrand police station were arrested on Tuesday and two others were suspended after the provincial police chief took notice of cricketer Sohaib Maqsood’s allegations of bribery and extortion.
The incident near Sakrand came to public attention when the cricketer criticised the provincial police in a post on X (formerly Twitter), branding them as “corrupt.”
At least four police officers from Sindh’s Sakrand police station were arrested on Tuesday and two others were suspended after the provincial police chief took notice of cricketer Sohaib Maqsood’s allegations of bribery and extortion.
The latest development was confirmed to Dawn.com by DIG Shaheed Benizarabad District Pervaiz Chandio.
The incident near Sakrand came to public attention when the cricketer criticised the provincial police in a post on X (formerly Twitter), branding them as “corrupt.”
However, in his post, the cricketer did not specify the exact location. Later, while speaking to Geo News, he clarified that the incident took place on an isolated road near Sakrand.
“We informed them that we are international cricketers heading to Multan after our match in Karachi, yet they took Rs8,000 from us before allowing us to proceed,” he claimed in the post.
Furthermore, Maqsood stated that the police also threatened to take them to the police station. He remarked, “We are fortunate to live in Punjab and not in Sindh.”
In a subsequent post, Maqsood mentioned being halted again at some distance even after allegedly paying the earlier amount when he was initially stopped by the police. He asserted: “Corruption is rampant in Sindh police.”
In response, Sindh Inspector General Raffat Raja directed Shaheed Benazirabad Police to hold an immediate inquiry into the matter. “Strict action must be taken against personnel involved in the incident,” the IG said in a statement.
Talking to Dawn.com, DIG Chandio said that four personnel involved in the incident had been arrested. “These officers were on patrol along a Sakrand road when the incident took place. They have confessed to charging cricketer Sohaib Maqsood Rs3,000 as a fine for using a fancy number plate and beam lights,” he said.
However, the DIG said it was not within the jurisdiction of regular police officers to levy fines as this responsibility fell under the purview of traffic police.
Furthermore, the DIG revealed that two senior officials from Sakrand police station, including a station house officer (SHO), had been suspended due to their negligence in the matter.
In response to the incident, the DIG said his team had forwarded images of the four patrolling officers to the cricketer, who had identified one of them.
Maqsood explained that after his team’s last match in the National T20 Cup in Karachi on Monday, where they did not qualify for the next round, he left Karachi with Aamir Yamin.
“I was travelling in a vehicle, and Yamin was with me at around midnight. We passed the toll plaza in Sindh, and after two kilometres, a pair of policemen at a lonely spot near Sakrand stopped us, asking for vehicle documents.”
The cricketer recounted that the officers then inquired about his use of high beam lights, warning a potential fine of Rs100,000. “I informed him that checking papers was not within their jurisdiction, and if traffic police were to stop us, they would typically impose a fine of up to Rs2,500.”
“He then threatened to take us to the police station, as we were travelling for the first time in Sindh, and after negotiation, we gave him Rs8,000,” Maqsood added. “This incident frightened us since it was nighttime and an isolated place.”
He then said his vehicle was stopped by police again after 30-40km, but they did not comply. “Instead, we stopped at a hotel in Sukkur, where we stayed overnight.”
He mentioned that the police had intercepted him approximately 68km before Moro, where the incident unfolded. “The police were rude, and when I requested to speak to one of their officers, their behaviour worsened.”
He stated that the intention behind the tweet was to shed light on the challenges the public faced when law enforcement personnel treated even known individuals badly.
Source: DAWN