What's new

No Pakistan player in Asia XI for Bangladesh T20s (due to PSL): Ehsan Mani [Update Post#176]

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,123
CHENNAI: The BCCI and Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) are set to approach the International Cricket Council for international status to three T20 matches featuring Asia XI and World XI to be held in Dhaka and Ahmedabad in March next year.

The series, which was originally conceived by the BCB to mark the birth centenary of Bangladesh’s first Prime Minister Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, was supposed to feature players from Bangladesh, India, Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Afghanistan and elsewhere, with two matches taking place in Dhaka. But with the BCCI now planning to host one match in Ahmedabad’s new stadium, all eyes are on whether Pakistani players will undertake the journey across the border for the India leg.

When the BCCI proposed the idea of day-night Test to BCB, it was understood that releasing Indian players for the T20s was part of the deal. This was put forward at the BCCI AGM on Sunday, where the BCB’s request to allow Indian players was accepted. While it isn’t clear if the likes of Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma will be part of series, the BCCI has informed the BCB that top players will go. But complicating things is the fact that India are scheduled to play an ODI against South Africa in Kolkata on March 18, the same day BCB has slotted the first T20 between Asia XI and World XI.

Ahmedabad’s under-construction stadium, which will be the biggest in the world in terms of capacity, will be ready by February. The Gujarat Cricket Association wants to make the occasion a grand one by hosting an Asia XI vs World XI fixture. While the BCB has reportedly reached out to PCB for Pakistani players, getting the same set of players to play on Indian soil may be a complicated affair.

As things stand, players from Pakistan are not allowed to be in India for bilateral series. The rule changes if it’s part of a global event. Recently, the Indian Davis Cup team refused to play in Pakistan and the tie was held in a neutral venue. If BCB gets Pakistan players to play in Dhaka, it remains to be seen what happens when the action shifts to Ahmedabad.

Sources tracking developments told this newspaper that the chances of Pakistani players performing in Ahmedabad are remote. As of the now, the BCCI is still to decide whether to approach the government on this. “Since the BCCI will be hosting the third match, there is no need to have continuity. Since India would have completed the ODIs against South Africa, the initial plan was to send five players to Bangladesh depending upon workload. For the match in Ahmedabad, we can make changes, but the understanding is the core of Asia XI and World XI remains the same,” an official told this newspaper.

There is also no clarity with regards to whether the Ahmedabad T20 will be part of the centenary celebrations. “The BCB wants it to be a three-match series including the one in Ahmedabad. We have to see how we go about it since GCA wants to make it their occasion. Things will get clear in the coming weeks. The schedule has to be worked out because there is a clash. But luckily, the ODI is in Kolkata and players won’t take much time to reach Dhaka,” the official added.

https://www.newindianexpress.com/sport/cricket/2019/dec/05/catch-22-for-bcci-over-t20-2071782.html
 
if the ICC give international status to the series then it will be shocking if they bow to BCCI demands and ban pak players
 
if the ICC give international status to the series then it will be shocking if they bow to BCCI demands and ban pak players

There’s a good chance that ICC rejects BCCI’s demands but don’t get surprised if ICC bows to BCCI’s demands. BCCI has the economic clout to do as it wishes unfortunately.
Only in Cricket does a national governing body have more power than the main governing body.
 
Last edited:
Everything aside. Asia XI vs World XI series will be great and would love to see 1 game being played in Pakistan
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?

Babar definately makes it, potentially Shaheen or Abbas as well, india aside sri lanka, bangladesh and pak seem to be on the same level.
 
Its wrong to not allow Pak players playing for Asia XI. What would they do in 2021 T20 WC and 2023 WC which are scheduled in India? Not allow Pakistan to play in it is it?

Ganguly is a good man...hope he dont fall into these petty political issues.
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?

It don't work like that. In a world XI kind of match, you try to accomodate players from as many countries as possible...even though some dont make it on merit. If we purely pick the best XI from Asia, not a single SL or BD players (with Shakib out) will make it. But the point of these games is to have as many representation for all country as possible.
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?
Rohit Sharma
Babar Azam
Virat Kohli
Kusal Perera
Mushfiqur Rahim+
Mohammad Nabi
Imad Wasim
Rashid Khan
Jasprit Bumrah
Mohammad Amir
Lasith Malinga

Rahul and Najibullah would replace Rohit and Kohli. While Shaheen/Mustafiz/Bhuvneshwar replace Bumrah if India take away there ODI players.

So three Pakistani players are locks.
 
If Bangladesh tours to Pakistan, PCB would send the players to participate in Bangladesh leg. I don't think PCB will send the players to Indian leg.
 
When will this circus end!!
We deserve to be third world. 75 years on we still waste money on war equipment and additional army for this bitter rivalry.
 
Rohit Sharma
Babar Azam
Virat Kohli
Kusal Perera
Mushfiqur Rahim+
Mohammad Nabi
Imad Wasim
Rashid Khan
Jasprit Bumrah
Mohammad Amir
Lasith Malinga

Rahul and Najibullah would replace Rohit and Kohli. While Shaheen/Mustafiz/Bhuvneshwar replace Bumrah if India take away there ODI players.

So three Pakistani players are locks.

No way would Imad Wasim and Amir would make it to the XI when Jadeja and Shami are there.

Babar is literally the only Pakistan player who merits a place in an Asian XI.
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?

Then how is Pakistan going to participate in the T20 WC and WC 2023?
 
PCB will not allow its players given the current situation They can continue this circus with bangla and Afghani players.
At the moment PCB's first priorty is building relations with other Countries because ind bangla and afghani are playing petty subcontinent politics with pcb.
 
No way would Imad Wasim and Amir would make it to the XI when Jadeja and Shami are there.

Babar is literally the only Pakistan player who merits a place in an Asian XI.

Imad Wasim has an incredible record in T20s. His economy rate in particular is outstanding and he gives very little away in the opening powerplay. Average too is very good. He easily makes any T20 XI.

Jadeja by comparison has a terrible record in T20Is. Average of 31 is poor in this format and he wasn't even a regular when Kuldeep and Chahal were playing together. Whereas, Shami hasn't even played a T20I in two years. His record in the format is even worse with an economy rate of 10.56 to go with an average of 31
 
When will this circus end!!
We deserve to be third world. 75 years on we still waste money on war equipment and additional army for this bitter rivalry.

Honestly so true I still don’t get why we even fight and have this stupid rivalry when both of our countries are dying of hunger and the biggest problem in our countries is the same thing poverty. Yet we fight over this stupid stuff and don’t even play cricket
 
No way would Imad Wasim and Amir would make it to the XI when Jadeja and Shami are there.

Babar is literally the only Pakistan player who merits a place in an Asian XI.

I am not a big fan of Imad but his T20 stats are vastly superior to Jadeja, even Shadab has better T20 stats than him.

Similarly Amir is definitely a superior T20 bowler than Shami and the stats prove that.


Considering the series is T20s, at least 3-4 Pakistani players merit selection.
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?

If allowed also amir and babar from Pakistan will be picked into team.
 
I think pakistan players will miss out like in IPL as current Indian govt will force bcci and Bcb to not include them
 
Honestly so true I still don’t get why we even fight and have this stupid rivalry when both of our countries are dying of hunger and the biggest problem in our countries is the same thing poverty. Yet we fight over this stupid stuff and don’t even play cricket
It has become an ego issue now for both sides..no one will give in
 
Just like they did the the Hockey World Cup.

Once in a while exceptions for a world event.

From what am reading, they can't play in India. Why can't they participate in this Asia Xl team for the match being played in india? Isn't it also a international match?
 
Only one player deserves to be in Asian xi from Pakistan that is babar Azam and I’m sure India can allow one Pakistani atleast
 
From what am reading, they can't play in India. Why can't they participate in this Asia Xl team for the match being played in india? Isn't it also a international match?

Forget about Pakistani players, even players of Pakistani descent from England can't play in India. Saqib Mahmood got his visa rejected earlier this year for India tour of England Lions and Indians on Twitter came up with pathetic excuses and got embarrassed by English people on Twitter.
 
Forget about Pakistani players, even players of Pakistani descent from England can't play in India. Saqib Mahmood got his visa rejected earlier this year for India tour of England Lions and Indians on Twitter came up with pathetic excuses and got embarrassed by English people on Twitter.

So can anyone go to England? They don’t decide who gets in and out of their country?
 
What is purpose of these useless matches?bcci hypocrisy is annoying we all know what will eventually happen about pakistan players participation So why not announce beforehand instead of creating another drama
 
From what am reading, they can't play in India. Why can't they participate in this Asia Xl team for the match being played in india? Isn't it also a international match?

Match is arranged and hosted by Bcci. Its BCCI's decision who they invite.
 
There’s a good chance that ICC rejects BCCI’s demands but don’t get surprised if ICC bows to BCCI’s demands. BCCI has the economic clout to do as it wishes unfortunately.
Only in Cricket does a national governing body have more power than the main governing body.

No it doesn't. If international status given, pakistani players will play.
 
Should be fun match, remember these sort of exhibition matches being so much fun back in 90's.

Babar, Amir should play from Pakistan, rest are just not good enough.
 
What is purpose of these useless matches?bcci hypocrisy is annoying we all know what will eventually happen about pakistan players participation So why not announce beforehand instead of creating another drama

The pourpose of this tournament is for BD to honor their father of their country - I don't think certain members would be too happy if you called that useless. That is why Asia Xl vs World Xl was scheduled. India wanted to make it a series so added a 3rd match and play the last one in the new stadium.
 
Forget about Pakistani players, even players of Pakistani descent from England can't play in India. Saqib Mahmood got his visa rejected earlier this year for India tour of England Lions and Indians on Twitter came up with pathetic excuses and got embarrassed by English people on Twitter.

Really, even if you have a british citizenship or born there? How absurd ... Humans eh? One of the smartest species to walk the earth, also the stupidest.
 
I don't think India can even invite Pakistan given their tennis federation used the events in Kashmir to justify not visiting Pakistan. And if they invite, and PCB accepts, it would be beyond shameful for the PCB.
 
Perera
Babar (Rahul)
Kohli
Dhoni + *
Mushfiq
Nabi
Imad (Pandya)
Rashid
Amir (Kuldeep)
Mustafizur
Malinga

India can send just Kohli and Dhoni to Bangladesh.

Pak players could play only in Bangladesh leg.

Rahul, Pandya and Kuldeep can replace Babar, Imad and Amir for the Indian leg
 
BCCI disgraceful
Govt of India even more disgraceful
Utter shame
 
Hypothetically even if BCCI invites Babar Azam and Shaheen Afridi(only two players I see really eligible for Asia 11), will PCB allow them given that this is on the anniversary of Sheikh Mujeeb who is not so popular in Pakistan?
 
The world didnot think the same when South Africa lost decades to sports sanction. Did they?

SA govt discriminated against all international sportsmen based on colour of their skin. What are you even trying to say? Read about the Basil D'Oliveira case.
 
Amir and Babar are the only two players from the current lot who can make it to the Asia XI squad.
 
SA govt discriminated against all international sportsmen based on colour of their skin. What are you even trying to say? Read about the Basil D'Oliveira case.

I am saying Barry Richards played only 4 tests and Mike Proctor 7 and Graeme Pollock only 23 tests because politics cut short their playing careers.

Read how long SA continued to play international Rugby and how mixed racial teams toured them.

When you are done with it. Read Israels boycott by certain muslim nations.

Then please read about Moscow 1980 and LA 1984 olympics boycott.

Then may be move to 1990 Asia cup boycott by pakistan.
 
Last edited:
Sports shouldn't be a casualty to politics.

This is not just a matter of politics, though. And if it were just sports, your point would still be valid. But at this point India and Pakistan have practically no international ties. We don't have trade relations anymore. Visas have practically been stopped from both sides. Even passenger flights are not allowed in each other's air space. Compared to all that, banning sporting relations is a small thing.
 
BCCI disgraceful
Govt of India even more disgraceful
Utter shame

It's not upto BCCI here. Even the government is doing it because the people believe in anti-pakistan rhetoric. It's the biggest selling point right now.

So if you want to point fingers the substantial population should be the first one on your list.

I guess the same goes for other sider of the border as well.
 
Think it was foolish to have expected otherwise.
 
SA govt discriminated against all international sportsmen based on colour of their skin. What are you even trying to say? Read about the Basil D'Oliveira case.

Bhai tum log bhi kuch doodh ke Dhule hue nahi ho.. kabhi to introspect karo ke yeh sab kyu ho raha hai.. there was no series played in 70’s for almost 30 years ab tum logon ko kya aag lagi hai khelne ki
 
I'll be very surprised to see Pakistani players playing in India no matter what Ganguly says.

With that said and off-topic, but how many Pakistani cricketers would make an Asia XI anyway?

Quite a few if India are playing SA at the same time
Not sure how many Bengal players would get into the current Asian xi
 
No Pakistan Player to Be Part of Asia XI in Bangladesh T20s: BCCI

New Delhi: The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) is set to celebrate the birth centenary of 'Bongobondhu' Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, the founder of Bangladesh, by hosting two T20 matches in March between the Asia XI and the World XI.

While the ICC is said to have given the games official status, looking at the current situation between India and Pakistan, one would think that it will come to either India or Pakistan players when it comes to filling the XI names in the Asia XI team sheet.

Speaking to IANS, BCCI Joint Secretary Jayesh George though has made it clear that such a scenario where both India and Pakistan players play in the Asia XI wouldn't arise because the message is that there will be no Pakistan players invited.

"What we are aware of is that there will be no Pakistan players in the Asia XI. That is what the message is, so, there is no question of both countries coming together or picking one over the other. Sourav Ganguly will decide the five players who will be a part of the Asia XI," he said.

Things have gone from bad to worse in recent times with Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) chief Ehsan Mani looking to take a dig at the Indian government and saying that the security situation in India is worse than in Pakistan and teams should ideally be happy to play in Pakistan.

"We have proved Pakistan is safe, if someone isn't coming then they should prove that it's unsafe. At this time, India is a far greater security risk than Pakistan.

"No one should now doubt security arrangements in Pakistan after successful Sri Lanka Test series. This is a turning point for revival of Test cricket in Pakistan. Media and fans played an important role in portraying positive image of Pakistan worldwide," Mani had said.

In fact, former Pakistan skipper Rashid Latif took the battle further when he dismissed BCCI President Sourav Ganguly's idea of a 4-nation series, calling it a "flop" plan.

"By playing such a series, these four countries want to isolate the other member nations, which is not good news. But I think this will be a flop idea like the Big Three model, which was introduced a few years back," Latif said in a YouTube video.

Clearly these things will be kept in mind when Ganguly does sit with his team to decide on the plan of sending players for the BCB organised matches.

https://www.news18.com/cricketnext/...-asia-xi-in-bangladesh-t20s-bcci-2436319.html
 
Who is organizing these matches? Is it ICC? And if so, is BCCI deciding to not include Pakistani players unilaterally?
 
Don't really care

Let Bangladeshis and Indian celebrate birth centenary of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman
 
Babar deserves to be in Asia XI. India should get an exception for him. No other Pak player will honestly get in even if the match was to be held in Karachi.
 
Babar deserves to be in Asia XI. India should get an exception for him. No other Pak player will honestly get in even if the match was to be held in Karachi.

Mohammad Amir is one of the best T20 bowler in the world!
 
With Bangladesh set to host the Asia XI vs World XI T20I series in March, celebrating the birth centenary of 'Bongobondhu' Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, questions regarding the participation of Indian and Pakistani players for the same team have started to arise. The current state of political affairs between India and Pakistan has made any sort of sporting activity between the two nations difficult and it now seems like no Pakistani players would be a part of the special series because of the same.

The Asia XI vs World XI match has already been given international status by the International Cricket Council (ICC). While many were hoping to see Indian and Pakistani players don the Asia XI jersey to play against World XI, the pairing isn't going to happen, as none of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) players have reportedly been invited.

BCCI Joint Secretary Jayesh George told news agency IANS that no Pakistan players will be a part of this series while as many as 5 Indian names will be seen on the Asia XI roster.

"What we are aware of is that there will be no Pakistan players in the Asia XI. That is what the message is, so, there is no question of both countries coming together or picking one over the other. Sourav Ganguly will decide the five players who will be a part of the Asia XI," Jayesh said.

The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) had reportedly asked the BCCI to allow Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, Jasprit Bumrah, Hardik Pandya, Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Ravindra Jadeja for the series.

As for Dhoni, the Ranchi-born wicket-keeper batsman hasn't played for India since the conclusion of the 2019 ICC World Cup. If allowed to participate in the Asia XI vs World XI matches, it could go on to be his first appearance in international cricket since the showpiece event in England & Wales.

Dhoni is confirmed to play for the Chennai Super Kings (CSK) in the Indian Premier League (IPL) but no update on his international cricket return has been issued as yet.

Bangladesh and Pakistan have also been in a tug-of-over over the forthcoming series. While the PCB wants to host the 2 Tests and 3 T20Is against the Bangla Tigers, the BCB isn't ready to play the Test matches in Pakistan.

https://www.timesnownews.com/sports...-t20is-5-indians-to-participate-report/531901
 
If no pakistan player is deliberately not been allowed then icc should not allow to give them international status otherwise it would validate icc stance on this issue.

Keep pakistan out it's fine but then it should be nothing other then being a glorified exhibition match.
 
With Bangladesh set to host the Asia XI vs World XI T20I series in March, celebrating the birth centenary of 'Bongobondhu' Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, questions regarding the participation of Indian and Pakistani players for the same team have started to arise. The current state of political affairs between India and Pakistan has made any sort of sporting activity between the two nations difficult and it now seems like no Pakistani players would be a part of the special series because of the same.

The Asia XI vs World XI match has already been given international status by the International Cricket Council (ICC). While many were hoping to see Indian and Pakistani players don the Asia XI jersey to play against World XI, the pairing isn't going to happen, as none of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) players have reportedly been invited.

BCCI Joint Secretary Jayesh George told news agency IANS that no Pakistan players will be a part of this series while as many as 5 Indian names will be seen on the Asia XI roster.

"What we are aware of is that there will be no Pakistan players in the Asia XI. That is what the message is, so, there is no question of both countries coming together or picking one over the other. Sourav Ganguly will decide the five players who will be a part of the Asia XI," Jayesh said.

The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) had reportedly asked the BCCI to allow Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, Jasprit Bumrah, Hardik Pandya, Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Ravindra Jadeja for the series.

As for Dhoni, the Ranchi-born wicket-keeper batsman hasn't played for India since the conclusion of the 2019 ICC World Cup. If allowed to participate in the Asia XI vs World XI matches, it could go on to be his first appearance in international cricket since the showpiece event in England & Wales.

Dhoni is confirmed to play for the Chennai Super Kings (CSK) in the Indian Premier League (IPL) but no update on his international cricket return has been issued as yet.

Bangladesh and Pakistan have also been in a tug-of-over over the forthcoming series. While the PCB wants to host the 2 Tests and 3 T20Is against the Bangla Tigers, the BCB isn't ready to play the Test matches in Pakistan.

https://www.timesnownews.com/sports...-t20is-5-indians-to-participate-report/531901
I don't think that can happen for real. If it really does it's a disaster for ICC.
 
Mohammad Amir is one of the best T20 bowler in the world!

Amit won’t play unless he’s paid big moolah. No one will give@; him that. Second it’s take guts to say Amir is the best T20 bowler in Pakistan, forget Asia or world, in the presence of Bumrah, Chaahal and Kuldeep. Amir best years are behind him now. He’s a has been. Faster PCB forgets him, better it’s for Pakistan.
 
cant really believe this is happening. Cricket now being used as a political tool more than ever. Really sad ICC are a bunch of hypocrites and basically a rubber stamp for anyone with power.
 
PCB should have no expectations from BCB. It should be treated as an extension of BCCI.
If they want to come for T20, let them come. If they dont want to come, that's fine too.
PAK cricket will have home series soon against all major countries regardless of its relationship with BCB.
 
cant really believe this is happening. Cricket now being used as a political tool more than ever. Really sad ICC are a bunch of hypocrites and basically a rubber stamp for anyone with power.

It’s unfortunate. PCB should have thought twice before backing out from IPL earlier for political reasons, suing BCCI on frivolous charges, vetoing world cup plans in India and stabbing BCCI in the back during ICC meetings. BCCI won’t forget its allies. PCB needs to be nicer and less arrogant.
 
It’s unfortunate. PCB should have thought twice before backing out from IPL earlier for political reasons, suing BCCI on frivolous charges, vetoing world cup plans in India and stabbing BCCI in the back during ICC meetings. BCCI won’t forget its allies. PCB needs to be nicer and less arrogant.

How is this relevant? Is BCCI unilaterally supposed to decide who participates and who doesn't? BCCI isn't supposed to run cricket.
 
If no pakistan player is deliberately not been allowed then icc should not allow to give them international status otherwise it would validate icc stance on this issue.

Keep pakistan out it's fine but then it should be nothing other then being a glorified exhibition match.

If BCB is organizing a match, they are well within their rights to decide who they invite to play.
 
It’s unfortunate. PCB should have thought twice before backing out from IPL earlier for political reasons, suing BCCI on frivolous charges, vetoing world cup plans in India and stabbing BCCI in the back during ICC meetings. BCCI won’t forget its allies. PCB needs to be nicer and less arrogant.

Come on, lets not be naive in thinking if PCB had played the nice guy, BCCI would just put up some sort of reward for PCB. I think it is very clear that the political rivalry between these 2 countries is now spoiling the chance to see some great cricket. Sad that this sport which everyone loves and could have built bridges, is now being used as a tool of hate. PCB did it, BCCI did it and BCB now getting on the band wagon.
 
How is this relevant? Is BCCI unilaterally supposed to decide who participates and who doesn't? BCCI isn't supposed to run cricket.

This is not an ICC event that ICC will decide who the players will be.

Its basically organised by BCB and its logical to invite India and not Pakistan on birth centenary or Sheikh Mujib.

Also plan is to hold a third match in Ahmedabad so BCCI is also a co organiser.

So BCB and BCCI will decide which players to invite.

Why is it such an issue?
 
If BCB is organizing a match, they are well within their rights to decide who they invite to play.

but BCB is not organizing a bilateral series. They are organizing something between Asia and World XI teams and if they are to be classified as official matches, ICC should decide the makeup of both XI otherwise just call the series a BCCI/BCB XI vs Australiasia XI or something.
 
If BCB is organizing a match, they are well within their rights to decide who they invite to play.

It seems like BCCI is making the decision. Regardless of that, I don't see how any board can decide which countries participate and which don't. This is not a bilateral series.
 
This is not an ICC event that ICC will decide who the players will be.

Its basically organised by BCB and its logical to invite India and not Pakistan on birth centenary or Sheikh Mujib.

Also plan is to hold a third match in Ahmedabad so BCCI is also a co organiser.

So BCB and BCCI will decide which players to invite.

Why is it such an issue?

The issue is the official match status. Let it be an exhibition match between 2 club sides if there isnt supposed to be an issue?
 
I take it it's going to be 5 players from India, 5 from Afghanistan and 5 from Bangladesh in the squad

Sri Lankans won't be invited since they have just visited pakistan
 
This is not an ICC event that ICC will decide who the players will be.

Its basically organised by BCB and its logical to invite India and not Pakistan on birth centenary or Sheikh Mujib.

Also plan is to hold a third match in Ahmedabad so BCCI is also a co organiser.

So BCB and BCCI will decide which players to invite.

Why is it such an issue?

I've never heard of a series being organized like this before. Usually it's ICC or ACC organizing multi-team tournaments, or other boards getting the series sanctioned by ICC to give it international status. In the OP it mentions BCCI and BCB are approaching ICC to get international status for this match, which makes my point. Based on what I am seeing from BCCI, it shouldn't be considered an international match by ICC. Unless they rebrand Asia XI to India/BD/SL XI (add other teams if they participate, e.g. Afghanistan), it shouldn't have international status.
 
This is not an ICC event that ICC will decide who the players will be.

Its basically organised by BCB and its logical to invite India and not Pakistan on birth centenary or Sheikh Mujib.

Also plan is to hold a third match in Ahmedabad so BCCI is also a co organiser.

So BCB and BCCI will decide which players to invite.

Why is it such an issue?

You people will blindly defend every step taken by BCCI. This is nothing but discrimination against Pakistan and its players. Shame on you guys.

The team representing Asian players should be called India-Bangladesh 11 , not Asian 11.
 
Come on, lets not be naive in thinking if PCB had played the nice guy, BCCI would just put up some sort of reward for PCB. I think it is very clear that the political rivalry between these 2 countries is now spoiling the chance to see some great cricket. Sad that this sport which everyone loves and could have built bridges, is now being used as a tool of hate. PCB did it, BCCI did it and BCB now getting on the band wagon.

India is playing nice to BCB, SL, Afg, NZ and Nepal, totally supporting them. It has been friendly with The other big two. So the trouble is only with Pakistan. You can find your own conclusion. There’s has always been political rivalry between the two nations.

Pakistan always gained from India - first as India supported Pakistan in getting test status and then providing them access to the big India market for decades. Things change when Pak players and PCB earned millions from India and then turned back to insult BCCI and its spectators. The same thing happened in Hockey when Pak players insulted Indian hockey and spectators. The result is for all to see. India is back in top-5 in hockey, Pakistan is out of successive olympics and world cups.
 
but BCB is not organizing a bilateral series. They are organizing something between Asia and World XI teams and if they are to be classified as official matches, ICC should decide the makeup of both XI otherwise just call the series a BCCI/BCB XI vs Australiasia XI or something.

Why will ICC decide?

They are not the organizers. BCB is organizing it. Its upto them to decide who they invite.
 
Back
Top