Pak V Eng: ODI No 1: Lahore: Score updates and discussion thread (Eng innings)

[Hussain]

we might have to chase another 350

seeing the depth in English batting

 

[Big Mac]

What an awesome stumping

 

[Amjid Javed]

Pieterson gone stumped!

well done malik!

 

[smoothcriminal]

Or Not!

 

[team-pak]

some of us think before we post. so, not all us suffer from verbal diarrhea.

its tough to remain calm when you can't back up your words with logic isnt it? koi nahee bhai, hota hay.

 

[pacman]

Good stumping by Akmal. England looking good though at this stage.

 

[desidude]

KV goneeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

 

[KaSaNoVa_G]

OUTTTTTTT

great stumping by the lil keeper... we really needed a wicket now.. and that of him too..

 

[ataullah]

outttttttttttttttttt

 

[iZeeshan]

great stumping...out!

 

[Raz]

Pieterson gone!!! Clever bowling from Malik and smartly stumped by Kami.

 

[Amjid Javed]

flintoff in now.

Eng 185/3 (29.4)

 

[desidude]

What an innings. He is simply turning out another Afridi.

 

[badxhah]

WOW Majority of the last few pages have been on fighting b.w foruumers ON RAMEEZ

 

[pacman]

It was signalled wide by Hair. I was wondering, can a batsman be given out if he is stumped on a noball?

 

[Amjid Javed]

Kaneria back now

 

[nafajafam]

akmal just said "well done dani.. malik" )

 

[team-pak]

It was signalled wide by Hair. I was wondering, can a batsman be given out if he is stumped on a noball?

nope!

 

[MIG]

WOW Majority of the last few pages have been on fighting b.w foruumers ON RAMEEZ

Wanna fight with me huh ?

 

[Raz]

Pieterson in the end paid for getting too cocky. He aint no Afridi and that was a subtle reminder for him.

 

[smoothcriminal]

It was signalled wide by Hair. I was wondering, can a batsman be given out if he is stumped on a noball?

neup

 

[zushy_786]

Wanna fight with me huh ?

) )

 

[Bailan]

Regarding the Rules


Say if Kaneria has Bowled his 10 overs .... can we bring in Arshad Khan?

 

[nafajafam]

186-3

 

[MIG]

Pieterson in the end paid for getting too cocky. He aint no Afridi and that was a subtle reminder for him.

But nuqsaan kar gaya !

 

[Amjid Javed]

It was signalled wide by Hair. I was wondering, can a batsman be given out if he is stumped on a noball?

NO! u can only be run out off a NO-ball.

 

[team-pak]

Kanny boy showing he isnt an ODI bowler. atleast not on such a short ground!

 

[iZeeshan]

u cant be out on no ball...wide yes

 

[Amjid Javed]

eng 190/3 from 31 overs.

 

[nafajafam]

5 singles in the over.
190-3

 

[Bailan]

so can we bring in arshad in place of kaneria?

 

[nafajafam]

isnt stumping similiar to a run out? maybe it should be out

 

[pacman]

nope!

But you can be runout, why not stumped? The batsman is out of his crease.

 

[nafajafam]

194-3. 32 overs bowled. Drinks break

 

[Raz]

But nuqsaan kar gaya !

Inshallah jab Pakistan jeetay ga to nuqsaan bee bhool jayen ge.

 

[badxhah]

Wanna fight with me huh ?

Sir App Lassi Pee kar aye hai .. Meinaay abhi Jam toast Kahaye sirf ;;;;

Kisi or Din Miggy Bahi

 

[team-pak]

But you can be runout, why not stumped? The batsman is out of his crease.

runout belongs to the fielder. stumping goes to the bowler who bowled it illegally.

 

[MIG]

Sir App Lassi Pee kar aye hai .. Meinaay abhi Jam toast Kahaye sirf ;;;;

Kisi or Din Miggy Bahi

You can run but you cant hide ....

 

[Imy]

You can be stumped off a no ball, you cant be caught, bowled or lbw of a no ball

 

[studentsbiryani]

ludoo shudoo, birayni shiryani?

 

[zushy_786]

You can run but you cant hide ....

What's your address

 

[Amjid Javed]

england picking up the ones here..

eng 196/3

 

[Amjid Javed]

Flintoff hit plumb infront and not given!

 

[Jonty]

disappointing to see kaneria in the ODI lineup

 

[deadly_man]

isnt stumping similiar to a run out? maybe it should be out

yaly it is out
are u seeing first time stumping on a wide ball.
salain and tendulakar used to do it a lot wheever batsman comes out of crease early they just send wide ball for stumping

 

[studentsbiryani]

goray billay doing what they do best, cheating

 

[pacman]

runout belongs to the fielder. stumping goes to the bowler who bowled it illegally.

Yes, I understand. But it must be a tricky situation. Cause a keeper can claim the wicket as a runout. The wicket should go to the keeper then

 

[Amjid Javed]

Eng 200/3 (34)

16 overs to go..

 

[Amjid Javed]

superb fielding by sami on boundary.

 

[Rob H]

Very encouraging so far. Unless we have a major collapse we'll get 300. Blackwell, Flintoff, Gojo, Collingwood can all smash it miles. As i speak some good fielding by Sami and 2 more the Strauss. 202-3

 

[Jonty]

wickets are required otherwise 350 on th cards. Doesnt look good!

 

[Big Mac]

Nice bit of fielding on the boundary

 

[Hussain]

Regarding the Rules


Say if Kaneria has Bowled his 10 overs .... can we bring in Arshad Khan?

yes you can always substitute Kaneria with Arshad

but he wont be allowed to bowl if Kaneria already has been bowled out

 

[deadly_man]

You can be stumped off a no ball, you cant be caught, bowled or lbw of a no ball

it was a wide ball not no ball.
I am not sure whether u can be stumped on a no ball..I ghuess not

 

[Rob H]

predicted total for Eng? For it's gonna be 307-7

 

[Bailan]

yes you can always substitute Kaneria with Arshad

but he wont be allowed to bowl if Kaneria already has been bowled out

What if the replacement is after 9 Kaneria overs?

 

[Rob H]

dropped it

 

[Amjid Javed]

unlucky. malik almost clean bowls strauss.

 

[Amjid Javed]

What if the replacement is after 9 Kaneria overs?

arshad can then only bowl 1 over.

 

[iZeeshan]

pak in troube...we need wickets!~

 

[studentsbiryani]

predicted total for Eng? For it's gonna be 307-7

if pak dont reverse, then at least 320 is on the cards

 

[Amjid Javed]

RS by strauss and gets 4.

 

[Rob H]

Reverse sweep for 4. SHOT!

 

[Big Mac]

haha, what a great reverse sweep

 

[Bailan]

what a write off a rule this is then .... always making it a 12 against 11 game

 

[nafajafam]

yaly it is out
are u seeing first time stumping on a wide ball.
salain and tendulakar used to do it a lot wheever batsman comes out of crease early they just send wide ball for stumping

you took it off context. my query was regarding to a stumping off a no-ball.

 

[Amjid Javed]

Eng 212/3 (36)

 

[offstump]

our bowlers aint doing nothing, england are goona post a massive total at this rate

 

[zushy_786]

Reverse sweep for 4. SHOT!

So RH where were you during test series....Showing your true colours coming when england are supposedly doing well.....

 

[team-pak]

Reverse sweep for 4. SHOT!

what would you guys do if the umps werent on your side?

 

[Amjid Javed]

joke fielding by butt in outfield.

eng 215/3

 

[Amjid Javed]

So RH where were you during test series....Showing your true colours coming when england are supposedly doing well.....

hes abit like ian botham.

 

[MIG]

The Swings and Roundabouts rule states clearly that Hair will not give Clean bowleds out in Pak innings - yep it all equals out in the end....

 

[zushy_786]

hes abit like ian botham.

) Really shows what kind of chameleon kind of fan RH is....

 

[nafajafam]

pakistan ko fielding aur noballs lay doobaien gi.

 

[Amjid Javed]

Eng 222/3

 

[Rob H]

wide

 

[nafajafam]

The Swings and Roundabouts rule states clearly that Hair will not give Clean bowleds out in Pak innings - yep it all equals out in the end....

the lassi has filled you with optimism.

 

[Daoud]

The Swings and Roundabouts rule states clearly that Hair will not give Clean bowleds out in Pak innings - yep it all equals out in the end....

I think the swing and roundabout rule will cause Hair to give contentious decisions in the second innings, and when asked about it, he'll say he gave 2 or 3 decisions that were out, not out, then 2 or 3 decisions that were not out, out. In the long run, they evened out

 

[deadly_man]

you took it off context. my query was regarding to a stumping off a no-ball.

for no ball I think its not out because its an illigal delivery.
and there is a clear difference between stumping and run out as some people were saying that keeper can claim it to be a run out