What's new

Pakistan v South Africa | 4th ODI | Abu Dhabi | 8/11/2013 | South African Innings

Status
Not open for further replies.
How did I know that was clipping. I remember in World Cup Afridi was doing ridiculous reviews. I bet this review was just to get back at Davies
 
Pakistan v South Africa | 4th ODI | Abu Dhabi | 8/11/2013 | South African Inn...

Hmm going down?
 
We need another 2 quick wickets here! thats only way we will stiffle the run flow.
 
steve davies will never give a 50/50 in favour in pakistan....other umpires would have given it out....cannot use the words on here to describe this man
 
I don't get that if it's clipping why the decision remains, obviously if the ball clips the stumps, it'll dislodge the bails so why is it still given not out.....
 
S.A Should declare when they make 200 just so that this game is competative
 
You wouldn't be saying that if it was our batsman

I would say that in any case, why is it not out when it's touching the stumps, it should be given out. If there are any doubts over the bails not dislodging due to not enough force, speed and angles can be brought into the system, it's really not that complicated....
 
I would say that in any case, why is it not out when it's touching the stumps, it should be given out. If there are any doubts over the bails not dislodging due to not enough force, speed and angles can be brought into the system, it's really not that complicated....

Because in any case, village cricket or international, anything perceived to be sliding down leg or clipping is never given out. Plus with the reliability of DRS, which could potentially be inaccurate to 1-2 inches, anything clipping should not be given out.
 
Rash decision from Afridi. He should have consulted he keeper and captain.
 
I would say that in any case, why is it not out when it's touching the stumps, it should be given out. If there are any doubts over the bails not dislodging due to not enough force, speed and angles can be brought into the system, it's really not that complicated....

It's actually just because of hawkeye being somewhat inaccurate I suppose, especially when it comes to determining the direction of the ball. I'm sure they probably are trying to improve the system but not exactly a simple thing to do. I don't like it much either to be honest. If it hits it should be out.
 
Misbah should have gone with an extra batsmen in place of either Tanvir or even Afridi.
 
Time to mix things up. Maybe send in Junaid or Ajmal or send a part timer
 
Misbah should have gone with an extra batsmen in place of either Tanvir or even Afridi.

Misbah is banking on Tanvir and Afridi to bowl 10 overs.. and pick up wickets, which both of them almost done.. their batting is a bonus..
 
At this point I would like to say that I hate Steve Davis. Oh and afridi should to talk to the team a bit before going for a review.
 
Said it on page one De Kock is going huge not to shabby by the 20 year old. Remember seeing him 2years ago still at school at our local bar drunk. Look at this youngster has smiths eye
 
Misbah is banking on Tanvir and Afridi to bowl 10 overs.. and pick up wickets, which both of them almost done.. their batting is a bonus..

Hafeez, Afridi, Ajmal are all likely to bowl their quota of 10 overs, with either of Irfan, Junaid & Tanvir not completing their quota of 10 overs. Pakistan is playing with just 5 specialist batsmen, and the a/r's are just not good enough to chase 30 runs collectively with the bat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top