ishtiaq_ctg
Tape Ball Star
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2018
- Runs
- 929
I agree that sunni scholars are also wrong on occasions , but the problem with shia zakirs is that they pick up hadeeth which suits them , and reject the same bukhari which does not suit them
For example you said Prophet wanted to write down something important, in bukhari it is written what he intended to write, why take one portion and reject the rest?
No doubt Umar RA was wrong in that case , but when we judge people we have to be fair
Even in shia Ghali there are people who are abusing and insulting wives of prophet and saying Aisha RA is in hell. Tell me did Imam Ali AS do this ? Did he abuse and curse the khalifas or wives of prophet?
So , by cursing and abusing , are shias following Ali or are they following Muawiyah ?
I think it's such a conflicted issue that there is no right or wrong answers. We as sunnis have read and believe in the upright characters of the companions of Prophet(PBUH) so for us it is unthinkable that a muslim can curse or abuse those esteemed personalities. But go to shias, they've grown reading different version of history where most companions were against the Prophet's Family, which makes them apprehensive towards those companions leading them to cursing and abusing.
I myself believe these acts of cursing and abusing should absolutely be avoided. We should approach history without bias and emotion. Muslims be they sunni or shia sadly havent yet matured enough to have these sort of civilized discussions.