I think captaincy has ruined him. It’s not just his record after the first time he lost captaincy is worse. Which has happened to quite a few players. Shoaib Malik was an example just fell off as a player after that. But focus on captaincy has taken away from focus on development as a player. Which is no surprise as he had to learn captaincy on the job, being far less experienced and a natural affinity than others.
We just made the same mistake again, appointed a player captain just because they were the best batsman. Captaincy shouldn't be learnt in international cricket like this. He didn’t even have a platform to practice it before captaincy given that Karachi Kings were reluctant to give him captaincy.
Still almost feels like people are happy about his decline. For all his faults, this has been our best batsman over all three formats, consistently performing for about 6/7 years. That really isn’t bad, especially from a nation that doesn’t produce many batsmen. If you dissect nearly all these Pakistani batsmen they’re all a bit overrated with inflation against minnows etc., they don’t compare well with the great batsmen of other countries.