[PICTURES/VIDEOS] Is Shubman Gill the best young cricketer in the world today?

Gill demanded a spot at number 3 because he wasn't an opener he said. He is so poor against spin that no position will save him on SC pitches, he even made a fool out of himself in Bangladesh.

Average less than 30 after 20 tests. 8 innings after that Gabba knock, not a single 50 in SENA, highest score 29 and average of 14.
 
On track to becoming the worst ever test batsman from India and the worst ever SC batsman in SENA.
 
No Nagpur pitch
No Ahmedabad cement wicket
No full toss bowler
No IPL

Shabnam Gill is Out for 2(12) in First Test against South Africa. Such an overrated player.
Look at his averages in Test and T20I. But i am more focused on his Test average because a good Test average defines a top class player. If he doesn't have a good Test average, please don't tell me that he is an emerging star.

20231226_155009.jpg
 
He can handle pace and bounce but little bit of movement and he looks out of sorts. Even against spin his game is poor.
Too many weakness to be a good test batsman.
 
The prince can't play swing, seam or spin. The most overhyped player in the world and a choker too. Should try becoming a Bollywood actor
 
This is not going to be his favorite format. He has to put in a concerted effort like Kohli to get better in Tests if he wants to get good at it. You cannot feel for every ball in Tests. Kohli did that initially. Then he started leaving without proper technique and got dismissed a few times. It took a while for him to find the tempo for Tests. Gill has to do hard yards. Jaiswal already looked better than him
 
Runs scored after first 35 Test innings for India:

Ravi Ashwin: 1006
Shubman Gill: 994
Irfan Pathan: 986
 
Dinesh Karthik, while speaking on a sports show, said:

“Shubman Gill is the big question mark here. He has not lived up to the expectations that people have. I think even he would be aware that if you are going to average mid-thirties or early-thirties after having played 20 Tests (19), then you would consider yourself to be a bit lucky to be around. His place will definitely be under the scanner if he doesn’t have a great Test match in the next one.”
 
Indian legendary batter Sunil Gavaskar, while speaking on a local sports channel about Shubman Gill, he said:

"The length was very good, it was a fuller length, but Shubman Gill probably made just one mistake. He wouldn't have been in trouble had he tried to play towards mid-on. He would have got an inside edge. He tried to play towards mid-wicket."

"The bat wasn't straight at all, the edge of the bat was visible, and the ball went through. If even a slight face of the bat was visible, he would have got an inside edge but that didn't happen. Marco Jansen was getting hit when he was bowling on the off-stump. So he thought of bowling on the pads and he (Gill) got out when he did that."
 
An avg of 31, in test cricket for a player who has received so much hype, adulation and chances is very poor.

I am not entirely sold on him. He has many technical flaws and doesn't seem to have the hunger, desire of a young peak Kohli to perform every game.
 
An avg of 31, in test cricket for a player who has received so much hype, adulation and chances is very poor.

I am not entirely sold on him. He has many technical flaws and doesn't seem to have the hunger, desire of a young peak Kohli to perform every game.

Let him play this series.
 
While India have a plethora of strong batting options at their disposal, it is young opener Shubman Gill that Nasser Hussain is tipping to thrive in 2024 and beyond as he attempts to take his game to the next level and become one of the star players in the world.

"He (Gill) had a very good three quarters, or nine-tenths of 2023. You must have learned so much having the likes of Rohit Sharma at the other end," Hussain said.

"He just fell away maybe at the end. Maybe that illness, you know, just got to him a little bit, and he's formed just in a month. We take it far too short when we're in the broadcasting world. He's a super talent, and he's going to be the next sensation for India for years to come. So, hopefully, he'll have a good 2024."

SOURCE: ICC​
 
Babar Azam after 31 test innings

0 hundreds, 8 fifties, 30.44 average


Shubman Gill after 31 test innings

2 hundreds, 4 fifties, 31.06 average


Don't write him off just yet, give him time
 
Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar feels Gill is being "too aggressive" in Test cricket.

"I think he is playing a bit too aggressively in Test cricket. There is a slight difference when you play Test cricket vs T20I and ODI cricket. The difference is in the ball. The red ball moves a little more than the white ball in the air and off the pitch as well. It bounces a little more too. He should keep that in mind,"

"Shubman Gill started off his career so well and we praised his shots. We can only hope that he gets back into his form. Hope he trains harder and does well in the future,"

NDTV
 
Rohit Sharma livid with Shubman after run out in 1st T20I against Afghanistan. Typical Rohit😂😂😅

IMG-20240111-WA0054.jpg
 
Salman Butt on Shubman Gill:

"I think Shubman Gill has done an injustice to his talent in the last few games. He is too good a player and has too much skill for the kind of hurry that he has been showing. He scores 20-odd and then plays a loose shot. This is what he wasn't doing when he had a successful year. He just needs to bat and bat without doing anything special. He needs to realise that even if you are the best batter in the world, you can't play every ball on your own terms. You have to react to the ball instead of dictating it,"​
 
Gill is fine.

The fans and ex-cricketers being motormouth in media should train their guns at the likes of Kohli and Rohit instead.
 
The prince can't play swing, seam or spin. The most overhyped player in the world and a choker too. Should try becoming a Bollywood actor
He can play seam. Has good record in Australia. He likes pace and bounce but genuinely looks like a talender vs swing/spin. He reminds me of more classy version of Imran Nazir. He was lethal vs pace but sitting duck vs swing.
 
Gill needs a few technical adjustments and much improved shot selection according to three formats. When you are playing three formats you have to make sure your game doesn't change much between formats. That is how Kohli was a rockstar in all 3 formats. He put away aerial shots in all the formats. But it does hamper his scoring rate in T20 a bit. But he was able to make up for it in T20 in the backend during his peak. Gill's constant urge to feel for the ball in all formats cause this inconsistency. Jaiswal has so far been able to switch between formats
 
Gill needs a few technical adjustments and much improved shot selection according to three formats. When you are playing three formats you have to make sure your game doesn't change much between formats. That is how Kohli was a rockstar in all 3 formats. He put away aerial shots in all the formats. But it does hamper his scoring rate in T20 a bit. But he was able to make up for it in T20 in the backend during his peak. Gill's constant urge to feel for the ball in all formats cause this inconsistency. Jaiswal has so far been able to switch between formats
Gill is not technically correct most of the time his feet get stuck in the wicket while playing any shot. That is the reason why he is not consistent in scoring runs.
 
Shubman Gill gave his wicket away, hacking to Duckett on the leg side. He won't want to see that shot again! Gone for 23.
He was never in total control throughout his whole inning.
 
Biggest fraudster who feasts on dead tracks against buffet bowling (nothing else).
 
He spent awful lot of time practicing against short ball and not enough against spin. It makes him good only in Australia. He has to change his approach against spin.
 
"Wasn't Trying To...": Ex India Star Rips Into Shubman Gill After Hyderabad Test LossShubman Gill scored just 23 runs across two innings in the first Test as England defeated India by 28 runs

Former India wicketkeeper-batter Parthiv Patel has raised concerns over youngster Shubman Gill's batting approach in the first Test of a five-match series against England in Hyderabad. Gill scored just 23 runs across two innings in the first Test as England defeated India by 28 runs on Sunday, December 28. Chasing a target of 231, India were bowled out for 202 on an extended final session on Day 4. Patel criticised Gill's approach in Hyderabad, saying that he was not trying to play shots at all.

"The way Shubman Gill was batting, especially the approach we saw in the first innings, he wasn't trying to play shots at all. If you don't try to score runs, international-level bowlers won't give you too many loose deliveries," Patel said on Colors Cineplex.

Patel also pointed out a major technical flaw in Gill's batting, saying that the batter defends with hard hands. He also emphasised the importance of rotating strike, which Gill failed to do in both the innings.

"You will have to show your skills there. It's fine if you are not hitting fours, you need to rotate the strike at least. If we talk technically as well, he defends with extremely hard hands. He needs to see how he can work on that," he added.

England's attacking "Bazball" style of play trumped India at home in the first Test but pundits and cricketers on Monday said the hosts remain favourites in the five-match series.

Rohit Sharma's India lost the nail-biting opener by 28 runs in Hyderabad on Sunday on day four of the Test, after being ahead in the match for most of the opening three days.

England's fearless "Bazball" brand of play devised by coach Brendon McCullum and skipper Ben Stokes has brought the team 14 victories in 19 Tests.

"Bazball: Believe the hype", a headline in the Indian Express daily read.

It was India's fourth loss in their last 47 Tests at home since 2013 -- and their first-ever after leading by 190 runs in the first innings of a home game.

Source: NDTV
 
Babar Azam after 31 test innings

0 hundreds, 8 fifties, 30.44 average


Shubman Gill after 31 test innings

2 hundreds, 4 fifties, 31.06 average


Don't write him off just yet, give him time
Totally agree. He is still 24 and have at least 10-11 more years to play, so dangerous to write him off.

The only issue is he is playing for India and the competition is very tough so you have to start performing otherwise people will ask for other deservering players' inclusion.
 
Anderson ka little bunny?

QOqfA8b.png
 
He has natural talent to play shots and has fast hands. But his footwork is almost at tailender level. Until he improves on that, he will be a good batsman on a good day. He will disappoint more than he gives joy.
 
Biggest fraudster who feasts on dead tracks against buffet bowling (nothing else).
Once a fraudster, always a fraudster.

With a non existing technique and temperament for test cricket, this guy should be nowhere near India A team (let alone main team).

I would trust a fading lower order batter in Ashwin more than this clueless excuse for a batter in any situation on any surface against any opposition.
 
At what stage do you say we have given him enough chances and drop him?
His FC average is 48, and he is classy so I'd say give him the rest of the year to prove himself.
 
He's done exceptionally in LOIs. But he has a lot of improving to do.
As an outsider, it looks like he's been given some preferential treatment IMO as compared to others like Jaiswal, Shaw, Gaikwad, Sarfraz etc
A lot of people have been calling him the successor to Kohli in batsmanship in last 12 months. Indian fans would know better regarding whether he has become complacent lately or not.

Still think Shaw has the game to emulate Sehwag.
 
Took some fine catches today. So he is not a total disaster. But he simply cannot survive with this one-dimensional technique. Needs a bit fine tuning. He has to reach out to guys like Sunny, Sachin anybody he can to get his feet movement fixed against spinner.
 
If he fails today, play Patidar at 3 in next match.
Iyer should also be replaced with Sarfaraz
 
Not looking like the best youngster out there. He has been mediocre and living dangerously atm against England in the 2nd test as well. Not impressive at all.
 
Gill has finally scored a 50 and could be a starting point for him to get back in form.
 
I have no problem with Indian players doing well and accepting it. Jaiswal has a terrefic start to his career. Very early in his career but already looks an ATG material.

Gill, well, he will score these kind of innings against poor bowling attacks. I don't rate his innings.
 
Good knock but his 91 at Gabba remains his best. He gave India an aggressive stable start at top, taking apart Starc and keeping the hopes of winning alive as Pant led the famous run chase.
 
Last Wkt: Shubman Gill c Foakes b Shoaib Bashir 104(147) - 211/5 in 55.6 ov.

Job done for Gill.

1. Gained confidence
2. Put India in strong position.
 
Gill's hundred has earned him some words of praise from English great, Alistair Cook. He derserves it though, what an innings for him today. He was down and out but thing innings can be his comeback to form again.

===============

Sir Alastair Cook, speaking to TNT Sports:

"Gill played beautifully. He has serious talent... and there was probably quite a lot of pressure on his shoulders.

"At the World Cup [in India], all the billboards were of Kohli, but he's the next one they want to step into his shoes.

"That's a big thing to have the pressure of a country the size of India on your shoulders.

"As a young talent, that's something that the likes of Tendulkar and Kohli have dealt with... and he now has to learn to deal with it.

"What we've seen today is just how talented he is, the shots he has and we're definitely going to see him the rest of this series.

"He was out of form, hadn't scored many runs, and there's Rahul and Kohli to come back into the side, but he's made sure now that the selectors can't ignore him."​
 
I have no problem with Indian players doing well and accepting it. Jaiswal has a terrefic start to his career. Very early in his career but already looks an ATG material.

Gill, well, he will score these kind of innings against poor bowling attacks. I don't rate his innings.
Gill will have a better career than Babar let alone Shafique. Comparing him with Shafique is as embarrassing as comparing Kohli with Babar.

But as I said, Pakistani fans will never learn. If they did, they won’t embarrass themselves with such comparisons.
 
Gill will have a better career than Babar let alone Shafique. Comparing him with Shafique is as embarrassing as comparing Kohli with Babar.

But as I said, Pakistani fans will never learn. If they did, they won’t embarrass themselves with such comparisons.
Can't believe your "will happen"...
You predicted 6-7 hundreds in Gill's first 20 tests. And the reality was that he scored just 2.
 
Gill reaches 100 - looking very confident now.
Shubman Gill, after scoring a century in the second innings against England, said:

"I'm definitely very pleased, but I think I left a bit out there, to be honest."

"We were in a good position, and I think we could have scored a few more runs... but, overall, I think it was a pretty good effort."

"It's still a pretty decent wicket to bat on. But it's not an easy wicket... you have to apply yourself - the odd ball is turning and keeping low - and if we get the ball in the right areas, we will get the job done tomorrow."
 
Yet another failure for him today against England in the 3rd test. A duck for him in the 1st inning. This guy is not having a good time in red ball format at all. Looks like a walking wicket.
 
At times I feel Gill wants to get dropped from test team just like his mentor Hardik Pandya. He doesn't have any hunger for test cricket.
 
It's not about hunger, he is just a flat track bully as of now because of playing a lot of white ball games and IPL. He needs to work on his game to score runs in bowling friendly conditions.
 
There are so many technical flaws in his batting.

I knew that he wouldn't survive in Test cricket with the stance he uses in which he locks his feet while playing any shot.
 
Biggest fraudster who feasts on dead tracks against buffet bowling (nothing else).
Technique-less wonder who should not be in the playing (Test) XI.

Even the much-maligned (rightly so) Pujara of post-2019 with one leg would consume more balls in an innings (even now) than this clueless cricketer.
 
He smashed a brilliant fifty from 98 balls against England in the 3rd Test match. However, he still needs to work on that rooted back foot, which forces him to chase the ball with hard hands. Though it looks like he has worked on his front foot approach and found ways to score runs.

YVWGDz9.jpg
 
His problem is not confidence. His problem is technique. That technique needs a massive overhaul like Kohli did during his second tour of England. Hope he works on it. Until he fixes that he will continue to be random. I cannot say "he has turned a corner" yet until i see some adjustments. He still bats the same way. Just that he got some runs. Doesn't mean he is okay from here on.
 
Gill was showing some form but he was unfortunate today as Kuldeep got him run-out in the 2nd inning of the 3rd test match. He was playing on 91. Was looking comfortable to score a century here but missed it due to a lack of communication with kuldeep. So unfortunate.
 
At a pre-match press conference ahead of the fourth Test in Ranchi, Shubman Gill was asked whether Rohit was guarded in his praise of Jaiswal since he feared the youngster could develop an attitude:

“I don’t think there’s a problem with the youngsters being not humble. We have seen Jaiswal scoring back-to-back double hundreds. If you don’t have it in you, you won’t be able to do that. There aren’t many people in world Test cricket who have scored back-to-back double hundreds. He definitely is a sensational player. We have seen it over 8-9 Tests."

“I don’t think there’s any conscious decision. Maybe Rohit bhai didn’t want to talk about it at that point of time."

“It’s quite difficult because you keep thinking about so many things. There are expectations from you. When I was going through it [poor form], what people on the outside were saying did not bother me a lot. But I was disappointed because I could not live up to my expectations."
 

Gill rallies behind the team despite key India players unavailable for Ranchi Test​

Shubman Gill, the Indian cricket star, commended the youngsters for stepping up in the absence of senior teammates leading up to the fourth Test against England.​


He faces a challenging task due to the absence of key players. Jasprit Bumrah, the leading wicket-taker with 17 wickets, will be rested to manage his workload. Additionally, KL Rahul is still recovering from injury, and Virat Kohli continues to be on leave after welcoming his second child.

While the bowlers have earned their plaudits in the series, the Indian batters, including Shubman Gill, came under the scanner after a rare defeat in the first Test.

Like the other batters, Gill too bounced back and played an important role in India’s two wins with a century in the second match and 90 in the previous match.

"We have scored close to 400 in the first innings of every match so far in the series. Every batter can't score big runs in every game, everyone goes through ups and downs,” said Gill in the pre-match press conference.

"In the first match, multiple players scored over 80. In the second match, Yashavi Jaiswal scored a double hundred. In the previous match, Rohit Sharma and Ravindra Jadeja scored centuries.

"It's not that only one batter is performing. Everybody is chipping in with runs and that's why we are able to put close to 400 runs on board every time.

In the absence of big players, the youngsters have put their hands up. In the third Test, Sarafaraz Khan scored twin fifties on his debut while Dhruv Jurel was brilliant with the bat and the gloves, his run-out of Ben Duckett in the second innings proving to be a game-changing moment.

Shubman Gill has expressed confidence in the young players, endorsing their ability to sustain the momentum in the series.

"Virat Kohli hasn't been with us for three matches. Obviously, when a player of Kohli's calibre isn't available, it does make a difference but in his place, the way Sarfaraz Khan recently batted, he did very well,” said Gill.

"New players are getting opportunities and they are grabbing them."

"Just like Kohli, any time Jasprit Bumrah isn't playing, it's a huge miss for the team. He is the leader of our fast-bowling attack. But if you look at it, Mohammed Siraj picked four crucial wickets last game. All our pacers are experienced enough in Indian conditions to execute the reverse swing.”

"The way the youngsters have performed in the absence of key players has been great. They are aware that this opportunity has come because of the absence of the senior stars, so everyone has been giving their best."

The action now heads to Ranchi for the fourth Test, starting Friday, 23 February.

Source: ICC
 
Shubman Gill Is 'Disappointed' With Himself, Opens Up On Reason And No. 3 Slot

Shubman Gill had twin challenges to tame when he entered the Test series against England -- a barren run that gripped him for nine innings, which was made grimmer when he dropped down to bat at a rather new No. 3 slot at this level. Three Tests into the ongoing five-match rubber, Gill has managed to find some answers scoring 252 runs at 42 with a match-winning 104 at Visakhapatnam and a classy 91 at Rajkot.

For Gill, it was all about coping with the expectations he had placed on himself, rather than making any sweeping technical changes to his batting.

"It is a bit tough (living up to his own expectations). When people from outside talk about all those things, it did not make much difference to me. But the expectations that I kept on myself made me a bit disappointed," Gill said in a press conference here on Wednesday.

However, Gill said he has still placed the same level of expectations on him but has learned to adjust to them.

"You will definitely have some expectations on you as to how you want to play for the team, the country. But I don't think that has changed my mindset. I still have the same set of expectations for myself.

"It is all about how you are able to forget them and move on quickly and be ready for the next challenge. That is the difference between a big player and an average player," he added.

The 24-year-old could not score a fifty in 11 continuous innings, including the Hyderabad Test against England last month, once he started batting at No. 3, deviating from his preferred opening position.

The rut set in during India's tour to the West Indies mid-last year till he broke it against England at Visakhapatnam.

Gill said batting at No.3 presented him with a different task even though he had batted in that slot in domestic matches earlier.

"I have batted at No. 3 and No. 4 for India A and in some Ranji Trophy matches, and as such, it was not something that I have never done in my life. There are not many technical changes that I had to make to my game.

"But it is different when you open the innings because you don't get that much time to think as you are going right in after the toss. You are the one who is setting the tone." Gill said playing in the middle-order made it mandatory for him to bat as per the situations.

"But when you bat at three or four, there is a certain situation that you have to bat at. If a couple of wickets have fallen early, then you are setting the stage. When you are opening then you are dictating the terms, but in the middle-order you will be playing according to the situations."

Gill offered the examples of Vizag and Rajkot Tests to underline his theory. Gill was joined by Shreyas Iyer when India were 30 for two, and he had to marshal the hosts' innings for their entire second dig while batting for almost 48 overs.

The right-hander said he had a slightly different role in supporting a marauding Yashasvi Jaiswal (214) in the second innings at Rajkot.

"I would not have played any differently even if I was feeling any calm or composed (in Vizag). But definitely, what I was feeling at Vizag was a bit different from what I was feeling in the earlier matches for India (in terms of the match situation).

"But in Rajkot, the situation was different, we were in a very good position, leading by some 300 runs. So, keeping that in mind, it was a much calmer and composed innings." Indian batters' failure to kick on after getting a start was a major reason behind their defeat in the first Test.

Gill said there was a talk in the dressing room about converting the starts into big knocks to pile pressure on the opposition.

"If you look at the first Test, a lot of players had got the starts. They played almost 50 balls and there were 80s and 90s. All the batsmen had the opportunity to make a big score but unfortunately, they did not get a big one.

"So, we had a chat and the point was if a batsmen get set and make a big score like 150 or 200, then it makes a big difference to us and the opposition. It will be good to score runs in the first innings because in India batting gets tough in fourth or fifth day," he explained.

NDTV
 
He is a bit overhyped player who got some extra lime light due to early double ton in ODIs but right after that he is on the decline, Jaiswal is looking more promising and technically sound compare to him.
 
52* for Shubman Gill against England in the fourth test today. A struggling half century but he would take it.
 
Back
Top