What's new

POTW : Dr_Bassim

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,158
An excellent and balanced post regarding the position Pakistan find's itself in after the abandonment of the NZ tour of Pakistan.

Congratulations to [MENTION=43242]Dr_Bassim[/MENTION]




http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...r-PCB-to-host-cricket&p=11296235#post11296235


I know there are going to be plenty of posts related to this topic and the time is an emotional one for most
Pakistanis.

The real question remains , where does Pakistan go from here?

It will be the question of the week or perhaps even the month.

NZ will probably be back home safely in the next 24 hours, unfazed by the events that have unfolded (whether rightly or wrongly) and will be sitting in the comfort of their families. Probably, the would feel they
avoided death or deep injury had they been sitting in Pakistan playing a game of cricket. I don't blame them. Stories have more power than actual events and if the PM of a country is telling a story about being in danger,
no rightful soul will continue to play cricket.

Indian government would probably be gloating at the financial losses incurred to Pakistan by the last minute
withdrawal of the NZ team. Their IPL is going well and they are financially in a position to dictate terms
to all the cricket boards.

The fans will feel the emotional upheaval of missing a few days of cricket and then continue with their lives.

So who lost?

If there is one thing I have learned over many years in and out of Pakistan is that perception is all that matters.The world moves on perception. If the same incident had happened in reverse, possibility, we would have continued the tour, would have got governmental assurances and we would have been more than happy to oblige and fulfill our obligations.

However, for Pakistan the perception is very negative. For those, who have never visited here, mostly its about reports and alerts and threats. For them, even a small lapse is real security threat (I hardly blame them). I was in Hartford once after 6 pm and every person I saw in the shadow looked like carrying a knife. Needless to say, I drove out of the city and never returned. Is Hartford unsafe? Perhaps. But the perception is even worse. And even I, being a brave warrior, managed to evade the city's heart at the thought of being attacked.

For NZ, England and Australia, the perception of Pakistan was always a safe country, bordering its arch rival India on one side and the unstable Afghanistan on the other. They were always gonna fly at the first hint of beforeyoucansaysomethinghappened incidents.

It took 15 years of untroubled waters to get a country's 2nd reserves to visit our nation and to try to hold a cricket
match.

Yet it took only 15 seconds to call it off at the mere possibility of something could go wrong.

You cant blame the players here.

However, you cant help but be peeved that NZ cricket shafted us right before the morning of the match.

The sad situation is that we don't have the PR to keep NZ in the country. We have no say, no team that can convince NZ that the ground situation is much better than their intelligence. We don't have a good standing or media relations team. In my opinion, PM should have done everything in his power to stop NZ from leaving and try to forge some sort of communication or trust.

To build some sort of plank to walk on.

Not because we desperately need NZ to play on this tour.

But we needed this tour, to bring cricket back

And now its gone.

The years of trust we had built is in doldrums.

Will any team tour again in the near future? Probably not.

Its Pakistan, that lost everything tonight.
 
As a cricket fan i can understand your anguish and frustration.
However, your oblique reference of indian govt gloating...etc...is in poor taste and in line with the conspiracy theories doing the rounds on your media.
Perhaps the discovery of NZ by Abel tasman & Captain cook was also in the long run and bigger picture also had to do with this same conspiracy.
All in all an excellent write up if you exclude what i mentioned above.
And yeah, i agree 100 pc with the perception thing.
 
Congratulations !

The obviously conspiratorial tone and direct reference to Indian "Government" gloating are very imaginative but it is an excellent POTW otherwise as it explains very well what every pakistani cricketer and fan must be feeling and you did provide your insights on how it should be handled.
Now let us absolve Indian Governement of this sin as you did NZ players.
 
As a cricket fan i can understand your anguish and frustration.
However, your oblique reference of indian govt gloating...etc...is in poor taste and in line with the conspiracy theories doing the rounds on your media.
Perhaps the discovery of NZ by Abel tasman & Captain cook was also in the long run and bigger picture also had to do with this same conspiracy.
All in all an excellent write up if you exclude what i mentioned above.
And yeah, i agree 100 pc with the perception thing.

Its the truth tho.

Indian govt will probably and most likely gloat.

And I don't feel like criticising them considering Pak's foreign policy.

----

As a fan, I can understand Pak fans' anguish.

It really was bad luck.

But delusions are not going to help anyone.
 
This was a brilliant post.

Don't agree with your future posts (will chalk it up to you being frustrated cos I have rarely seen you this way in all the years) but this one was superbly articulated.
 
Good post, perhaps a bit carried away with the Indian Government.
 
As fans of Pakistan we are rightly concerned about our country. But this has also reduced international cricket to a club of 4.

Are 4 relevant teams one of them as small as New Zealand enough to sustain international cricket?
 
As fans of Pakistan we are rightly concerned about our country. But this has also reduced international cricket to a club of 4.

Are 4 relevant teams one of them as small as New Zealand enough to sustain international cricket?

As long as the second most populous country in the world with a population of almost 1.4 billion remains deeply invested in cricket, cricket’s future is safe and sound.

The future of cricket entirely depends on the Indian market. As long as India remains a cricket mad nation, cricket will survive.
 
Cricket will and is surviving but in what form. This current form is unappealing. There is simply no clear interconnected structure to the cricket schedule. You’re correct in sighting much of that has to do with India.

One of the reasons is because the IPL which once had one window, now has 2. The official window and the unknown second one which must exist because of the instability within India.
 
Nothing new but nicely summed up what many are saying in the forum already.
 
Congratulations to [MENTION=43242]Dr_Bassim[/MENTION] on an articulate and intelligent post.

I do politely differ in terms of the conclusion.

Once the NZ government informed NZ Cricket of an imminent threat, I simply can't see how either the PCB or the Pakistan government could possibly have changed the decision to leave as soon as possible.

It would be "brave" - by which I mean stupid - for the national team to defy its own government and to choose to believe Pakistan's intelligence services and armed forces and government instead of their own.

How could any national team defy its own government and acquiesce to the demands of another?
 
Back
Top