What's new

POTW: shariqnoor

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,137
Congratulations to [MENTION=141811]shariqnoor[/MENTION] for winning the POTW award for his explanation of why the expectations by fans sometimes hide the fact the obvious deficiencies in quality of our players.

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/showthread.php?307592-Expectation-of-Pakistani-fans

Allow me to share a very fine quote regarding expectations:

"Expectations are premeditated resentments."

I feel this quote beautifully summarizes the relationship between the Pakistan cricket team and its fans. The cricket team isn't skilled enough to live up to the fans expectations and the fans resent the cricket team for failing to live up to them.

I wanted to particularly highlight the expectations aspect of our society because I feel this is something that is conveniently ignored in our part of the world. If someone in our society talks about lowering expectations, often the reply back is "you're not ambitious". Culturally we have synonymized expectations with ambitions which is a terrible thing to do. And I use the word culturally because it has become a cultural issue.

Coming back to the cricket team, we as fans need to embrace reality rather than deflect from it by using buzzwords like ambition, and if I'm allowed to take some words from Shoaib Akhtar, daleri and jazba. The unfortunate reality of Pakistan cricket over the past 10 years or so is that the country is not producing quality cricketers barring a few. You cannot pump ambition, jazba, daleri into guys and expect outstanding results when the underlying base of being skilled enough to succeed at the international level with regards to batting and bowling is hollow. It's not going to happen no matter how much you insist it would.

There is literally no cricketing country on Earth that gets so much scrutiny on their players as Pakistan does. One bad match and the knives are out on the players by the fans as well as ex-cricketers. This puts the team under immense mental pressure even before they have stepped out on the field. England have lost multiple matches to the likes of Ireland, Netherlands and Scotland. Scotland posted 371 against England in an ODI. Australia have shelled a Test match to Bangladesh and lost to Zimbabwe recently. Never have their fans or media or ex-cricketers lashed out in public on those results. They take it in their strides and move on. It's only Pakistan where fans and ex-cricketers lambast the team if they lose regardless of the opposition. Imagine a Pakistani team conceding 371 against Netherlands. It would be the Day of Judgment in Pakistan.The pressure this creates on the team is unimaginable. I mentioned in some other thread how this pressure of not being allowed to fail ensures that Pakistan go in with their absolute full strength team against minnow every game which in turn hinders the ability to create a pool of international players.

The recent criticism of Babar-Rizwan as an opening pair is a classic case of Pakistan fans and ex-cricketers raising their expectations to stratospheric levels because they see Buttler, Warner, Rohit as openers in other teams. The truth is, Babar and Rizwan are the best that Pakistan has to offer. Yes, their strike-rates can be a problem, especially when batting first, but that is something that can be improved. Suggesting to remove them altogether as openers is a mindset of ripping things out and starting from scratch rather than trying to improve upon the existing. This habit of ours that the guy sitting on the bench is somehow the answer to our ills is what breeds expectations which ultimately leads to resentments.

As much as the onus of delivering success on the field rests with the players, a lot also lies at the feet of the fans to temper their expectations and align it with the skill levels of the team at hand. Allow the team to fail.
 
Thanks a lot.

I genuinely believe putting unreal expectations on these players does more harm than good. Pakistan getting to the T20 World Cup semi-final was a fantastic achievement in itself. Babar's captaincy leaves a lot to be desired but a semi-final in its own right is praiseworthy.
 
Great post

Completely with players being under constant scrutiny from both fans and ex-cricketers.
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, he is the best poster on the forum by some distance.
 
Fantastic post. Posters who want Rizwan and Babar gone simply do not understand what the team strategy is and why it cannot be completely overhauled every time Pakistan loses .
 
Great post. I think it's not just Pakistan but subcontinent in general obsess over cricket losses in extreme ends. You lose some, you are shredded down to pieces, you win some and you are the King of the 7 kingdoms.

Other than Sri Lanka, the rest three subcontinent countries behave pretty much in similar fashion (Pakistan, India and Bangladesh). Sri Lankan fans are the most mature ones in subcontinent.
 
Translation in plain language: Accept mediocrity. Cuz we got no talent.

Disagree.

Wanting to maximize existing resources and enhance them rationally does not constitute unrealistic expectations.

Fans are right to be angry when the team is underperforming due to mismanagement of resources and wrong tactics for the wrong format.
 
This is like Muhammad Waseem inviting Shan Masood back into the Pakistan side after asking him to score runs at 4, and then going on national tv to say we shouldn’t have any expectations from this team.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Beautifully said. I still think though that our team is stubborn. A minor change of Babar coming one down and Fakhar opening with Rizwan is worth a try and appears to be logical.

Fans actually don’t mind losing as long as their is intent. I am a million percent sure that if Pakistan was bowled out for 110 in 13 overs vs England when they were chasing 200, fans would have been OK with that. Our team management thinks we are fools.
 
Beautifully said. I still think though that our team is stubborn. A minor change of Babar coming one down and Fakhar opening with Rizwan is worth a try and appears to be logical.

Fans actually don’t mind losing as long as their is intent. I am a million percent sure that if Pakistan was bowled out for 110 in 13 overs vs England when they were chasing 200, fans would have been OK with that. Our team management thinks we are fools.

I agree. I watched the Aqib Javed video where he lashes into the management and there isn't a word there I can disagree with. If you dip into the India/SA matches a little, you see how the teams refuse to give up till the last moment despite impossible climbs. What was that thing Pakistan did in the last T20 against England? They should have been all out 110 and tried at least. Otherwise they're making a joke out of what's supposed to be a serious athletic contest. We were pioneers in this format, and just a few years ago no. 1, so it's not like we don't have the talent and resources and don't know how to play this format. We are willful wrong choices.
 
Great post however mentioning England is a bit moot.

Cricket is not their main sport. In comparison England's football team is under the same pressure as our cricket team. If England loose to Faroe Islands 5-0 their public will be out for their team too.

Its just that cricket is now the only sport left in our country
 
Back
Top