What's new

Sanjay Manjrekar on Imran Khan and Sachin Tendulkar in his autobiography

karthikc

Tape Ball Star
Joined
Aug 27, 2013
Runs
778
Sanjay Manjrekar, an international cricketer-turned-commentator, recently released his autobiography titled Imperfect. The book is not an attempt to glorify his days as a cricketer or commentator. It starts with explaining the impact of his father, Vijay Manjrekar, a former Test cricketer, on his life.

Manjrekar also reveals a lot of inside stories about cricket in Mumbai, international cricket, and his time in the commentary box. His flaws as a batsman as well as a person are portrayed perfectly.

The right-hander was one of the most technically sound batsmen in world cricket. He played well on pitches that aided pace and bounce. He was given the title 'Mr.Perfect' and 'Mr. Different' by Sachin Tendulkar because he always strived for perfection and worked on tiny technical flaws. However, he managed to play only 111 international matches.

Manjrekar had a dream start to his Test career, scoring a stunning 108 against a West Indies side that fielded Malcolm Marshall, Curtly Ambrose, Ian Bishop and Courtney Walsh, in just his third Test.

The former Mumbai Ranji team captain continued his rich vein of form as he scored 569 runs at an exceptional average of 94.83 against a strong Pakistan side on their home turf in the subsequent series. He hit two centuries and three fifties, including a career-best 218 against the likes of Imran Khan, Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis, and Abdul Qadir.

His confidence was sky high after the series in Pakistan but he faded away. Why? 'Imperfect' has all the reasons.

The Mumbaikar made 10252 runs in first-class cricket at an excellent average of 55.11. He scored 5175 runs in List A cricket at a healthy average of 45.79. He also captained Mumbai to a Ranji Trophy victory.

Even though these were very good achievements, he announced his retirement at the age of 32, an age cricketers normally reach their peak. He even scored a century in his final Ranji Trophy match. While retirement at the time may have seemed like an odd and immature decision, Manjrekar had his reasons.

Coming back to the book, it covers much more than just the way in which his career nosedived. It also reveals his relationship with his teammates, other dressing room stories, and life in the commentary box.

Let us take a look at some of these stories.

1. Mumbai school of batting

Mumbai have a knack for producing great batsmen and Manjrekar explains why they have been so successful. Their mantra: "After you get to fifty, go for a hundred. After the hundred, look for 150. Then a double hundred..."

"Batsmen who didn't get big scores, who threw their wicket away after a fifty or even a hundred, were treated like outcasts. Mumbai didn't care for them. It didn't invest its time and energy in such players," writes Manjrekar.

2. Love for Imran
The now-52-year-old's idol was the Pakistan great, Imran Khan. He fondly remembers how Imran wanted him to do well. He also speaks about how he fell in love with Imran's leadership skills and singular focus on the game. One of the incidents is as follows:

"In the Faisalabad Test, Sachin Tendulkar got a light feather of a touch on the ball as he looked to work it off his hip. It was such a faint edge that no one appealed. Except for Imran Khan, who was at mid-on. The umpire shook his head, but Imran was convinced that there was some bat in that one. He kept asking his players why they didn't hear it."

"At the end of the over, Tendulkar and I got together and he said, 'What a guy, What sharp ears.' He knew he had edged it. The wicketkeeper didn't hear it, the umpire didn't hear it, but the man at mid-on did. No one was as focused on the game as Imran was."


3. Non-playing commentators
Manjrekar airs his views on why production companies do not try out non-player commentators. He says Harsha Bhogle did a terrific job in covering the emotions of Tendulkar's farewell Test. Though Bhogle has not played international cricket, he has done an excellent job as a commentator.

"I think fans are missing out on possibly great commentators only because production companies these days insist on having former players as commentators".

Talent alone won't make you a successful cricketer and Manjrekar's life story is an example of the same. Failures lead to success, but to be successful, you don't have to commit mistakes of your own. Instead, you can learn from those who made mistakes before you. Manjrekar underlines this point, saying, "Having been a sportsperson, I also want young aspiring sportsmen to learn from my career. Like a father said to his son: 'I made twenty mistakes in my life; you'll make twenty new ones.'"

'Imperfect' is a must-read for players as well as fans of the Gentleman's Game. It is brutally honest, candid, transparent and racy.

https://cricket.yahoo.com/news/reviewing-sanjay-manjrekar-apos-autobiography-214724477.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting remarks on Imran Khan - should have some of our resident 'admirers' jump up and take notice
 
I am sure Tendulkar haters will have found new info in this article to be happy about :D

Never knew Manjrekar scored 218 against that formidable looking bowling attack...
 
Unfortunately he chose not to get in touch with me for I had a better title for his book.

"Mediocre"
 
So SRT didnt walk? Interesting!

Obviously he wasn't a walker. Thanks to the media that this myth came about in the first place. The same media now tries to convince people that Kohli is a nice chap who cares for people and has a big heart. Typical non sense reserved for Indian batting gods.
 
He was a selective walker, just like the other so called walkers like Lara, Gilchrist, Sanga etc. They walked when it suited them, and didn't when it didn't. Hypocritical in a way. Neither did Pakistan's favorite Indian batsman Dravid.

Thats why I preferred Ponting s attitude, he was unashamedly a 'non walker'. At least he didn't pretend.
 
Obviously he wasn't a walker. Thanks to the media that this myth came about in the first place. The same media now tries to convince people that Kohli is a nice chap who cares for people and has a big heart. Typical non sense reserved for Indian batting gods.

SRT is a nice chap, he had literally no controversies on and off the field.. Kohli is a different story, he is a good lad but anything but the human being SRT was... Walking or not doesnt make the batsmen nice or bad, if that was the case almost all of the Australian players would have considered bad.
 
The only compulsive walker that I've seen is Adam Gilchrist, who would walk regardless of match situation. Heck he walked off in a World Cup semi-final even as the umpire was shaking his head. Anyway, the fact that Tendulkar didn't walk doesn't make him a bad fella necessarily. It's just sanctimonious piffle at the end of the day, I prefer cricketers that are inveterate scoundrels who would grab an inch if someone offers them a millimetre, play to win in any way you can.
 
SRT is a nice chap, he had literally no controversies on and off the field.. Kohli is a different story, he is a good lad but anything but the human being SRT was... Walking or not doesnt make the batsmen nice or bad, if that was the case almost all of the Australian players would have considered bad.

What does make one indeed bad is something like what Rashid Latif did in that Test against Bangladesh in 2003/04.
 
Or when Tendulkar tampered with the ball. Both are forms of cheating.

Except that Sachin was cleared by the ICC while Latif was banned by the ICC for cheating. Never mind that history doesn't care for conspiracy theories which Pak fans seem to love so much, history remembers the official verdict.
 
SRT was a never a walker and never pretended to be one.

He did walk on multiple occasions. Once was against West Indies in the 2011 WC when the umpire adjudged him not out. Another one was in one of his famous desert storm innings when the umpire adjudged him not out, yet he walked. Damien Fleming was the bowler.
 
Obviously he wasn't a walker. Thanks to the media that this myth came about in the first place. The same media now tries to convince people that Kohli is a nice chap who cares for people and has a big heart. Typical non sense reserved for Indian batting gods.

good news for Manjrekar ... afterall his book will atleast bough by one person - YOU !! If only there was a way to let him know ... that his book wont go unsold in India :))
 
I am not going to buy this book.

He found the worst possible way to sell it.
 
Imran like Manjrekar because (if I recall correctly) he performed against the might Windies.
 
Sanjay Manjrekar praising Imran leadership in his autobiography

I am right now reading the book and thought I would share the below excerpt

I remember an episode from our tour of Pakistan. I found myself batting with someone who refused to take a single and face Wasim Akram, clearly the quickest and most dangerous bowler in that side. This went on for almost an hour. I was stuck at one end facing Wasim while my partner ensured that he was doing nothing of the kind that would fetch him a single at his end and bring him on strike to face Wasim.
Out of frustration, I complained through a substitute who came to us at some point. I was hoping the captain would send a message to my partner so that he would rotate the strike.
Believe it or not, I got a message back requesting me to let it be and continue focusing on my batting. This was a typical Indian cop out of those days.

If Imran Khan was leading such a team, this batsman would never have played for his country again. However, that was an era when such players flourished and that batsman was smarter than me to know this


There are many more such anecdotes on Imran in the book. A nice read
 
Back
Top