SIF do you think this is the weakest era of batting against spin? The likes of Dilruwan Perrera and Jadeja are picking 10 fers while Likes of Yasir, Ashwin, Herath end up home series with ridiculous numbers 25 @ 15 is their standard series returns in Asia. Its making modern spinners look better then what they are.
Thoughts?
Absolutely.
I was thinking about just this a few days back.
This is an era of real weak spin playing in tests (in LOIs spinners are finding it tough due to flat pattas). In the past too, we had lulloo teams against spin but there used to be good teams where 2 batsmen on either end were equally good, could get set and play well.
These days, spinners can break through from one end and bypass the hard work.
Look at something like this:
Muralitharan averages 45 in India. And 19 in England.
How much disparity good players of spin make.
In today's era, Murali averaging above 20 in any Asian series would be a miracle.
These days we don't get to say "he bowled marvellously well and still went for 2-100". Its very very rare we say it. Almost nil. Several months back, my friend was talking about one test where he said Kaneria bowled well but STILL Lara made 250 odd. Haha. That kind of stuff we don't see these days.
Now we shouldn't look at the past with rose tinted glasses but current factors shouldn't be ignored too.
Its a very confusing era to be honest. That's why we shouldn't use averages as be all and end all and look at bowling.
Also one more thing...the harder the pitch or opposition get, the more difference betweeen good and bad bowlers. Herath picked up like 2 wickets last innings in last test where other spinners wreaked havoc. But this test where the pitch wasn't so easy in first innings, Herath picked 6 while others were scrambling for 1-2.
Of course, every relatively tougher pitch, the better bowler won't click but over a big sample, they will do better.