What's new

The quality of umpiring in the Asia Cup final

Wonderwoman

Debutant
Joined
Sep 25, 2017
Runs
296
Forgetting that couple of umpire's call went in their own favor when they were well on top! Bangla fans have started throwing shades about conspiracy theories about BCCI and umpires etc.

The game is still on. and Bangla fans already preparing their next line of excuses and blames. Somethings won't change!:ashwin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
These things happen in cricket people need to understand that move on like India wasn't given a 6 run against Afg in last over
 
I entered the thread wanting to be nice and speaking good things about Bangla Cricket, but what a bunch of crybabies.

Minnow the, minnow hai, minnow rahenge. :cobra
 
Today they are perfectly justified in their outburst, we fans have been deprived of an entertaining match because of lousy umpiring.
 
Today they are perfectly justified in their outburst, we fans have been deprived of an entertaining match because of lousy umpiring.

So many umpire's call went against India. Only if the onfield umpire had given it out. We would have ended their innings by 150. See,,... everyone can crib over close calls.
 
Today they are perfectly justified in their outburst, we fans have been deprived of an entertaining match because of lousy umpiring.

Today? Are you going to pretend Bengalis weren't robbed in the quarters of WC2015?

The litany of injustices against Tigers is LONG!
 
If pakistan are cornered tigers then bengalis are aggrieved tigers!
 
Bangla may still win the match I feel but they are just a pathetic side in general. They should not have been brought into the international scene, they have showed no progress, if you give Afghanistan the same opportunities like the Bangla pussey cats they would be a force to be reckoned with imo...

What progress did mighty India show in its first 3-4 decades in international cricket? Indians should be the last people to call others ***** cats.
 
Today they are perfectly justified in their outburst, we fans have been deprived of an entertaining match because of lousy umpiring.

What was lousy here? There was nothing behind the line when stumps lit up. It was a close, but he was out.
 
Today? Are you going to pretend Bengalis weren't robbed in the quarters of WC2015?

The litany of injustices against Tigers is LONG!

in WC2015 - OK... lets assume that was not a no-ball and he was given out. if you think that the bangalis could have won?... slow lollllllllllll :)
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.

Loving these posts. Keep them coming
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.
LMAO. I'm loving it.
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.

Such posts make win against Bangladesh all the more sweeter :P
 
Such posts make win against Bangladesh all the more sweeter :P

I think we should give them a win, so they feel they exist, aka ***Fools Homage****........... They have been a terrible side since coming onto the international scene.
 
even without the cheating india might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please bcci. In case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of bcci.

Thank u bcci.

potw
 
What was lousy here? There was nothing behind the line when stumps lit up. It was a close, but he was out.

What is the purpose of Benefit of the Doubt? Can you explain this to me? He foot was not be behind the line per YOUR perspective, but not Mine. So in those situation there should come the Benefit of the doubt?


I think, some microscopic part of his foot was behind the line. Just a smudge but its really difficult to say.
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.

You really think winning any match against Bangladesh has any value lol Seriuosly
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.
You kidding right?
 
In view of the fact that ICC is under the control of BCCI, Bangladesh should walk out of ICC and form its own cricket council. After all their growth rate is more than Indians and they know a lot about GDP and other such stuff. :srini
 
I think we should give them a win, so they feel they exist, aka ***Fools Homage****........... They have been a terrible side since coming onto the international scene.

They have definitely improved as a cricketing nation, but as fans... their emotions are akin to the every obnoxious punch-able kid we had in neighborhood. Win against them gets sweeter by all their whining after the game. Its like they want us to relive our victory again and again and again!!!:D
 
The Bangladeshis have a massive persecution complex - the whole world is out to get them all the time. Heaven-forbid if Bangladesh loses today, the whole circus will start again - their cricket chief making statements, Politicians weighing in etc. What an underconfident bunch!
 
What is the purpose of Benefit of the Doubt? Can you explain this to me? He foot was not be behind the line per YOUR perspective, but not Mine. So in those situation there should come the Benefit of the doubt?


I think, some microscopic part of his foot was behind the line. Just a smudge but its really difficult to say.

How can you think that after this zoomed pic which umpires saw. Another angle from behind also shows that line was visible when stump lit up.

runout.jpg

It was a close call, but after all this evidence, I don't see how umpire won't give it out.
 
Bangladesh fans can only dream of beating India four in a row. We will steamroll them even if the scored over 300. Who cares what excuse they make.
 
The Bangladeshis have a massive persecution complex - the whole world is out to get them all the time. Heaven-forbid if Bangladesh loses today, the whole circus will start again - their cricket chief making statements, Politicians weighing in etc. What an underconfident bunch!

Not just persection, also inferiority complex.
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.
Nothing more entertaining than angry Bangladeshi fan.Keep those conspiracy stories coming.:ashwin
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.

Gajab drive(l) maarey ho! Wah.
 
Add broadcasters to the list of everyone cheating BD of their due.

They refused to show us replays of that gorgeous :cobra Nazmul performed for Dhawan after getting him out.
 
How can you think that after this zoomed pic which umpires saw. Another angle from behind also shows that line was visible when stump lit up.

View attachment 84254

It was a close call, but after all this evidence, I don't see how umpire won't give it out.
I just want to read their excuse after seeing this picture. Common sense bhi kuch hota hai
 
How can you think that after this zoomed pic which umpires saw. Another angle from behind also shows that line was visible when stump lit up.

It was a close call, but after all this evidence, I don't see how umpire won't give it out.

Screenshot (2).jpg

Look at the image carefully. There's no way an umpire can say without any doubt that none of his spikes were inside inside the line. But obviously this umpire was so sure about it because he was in someones pocket.
 
Even without the cheating India might have won the match easily. But obviously umpires needed to show where their loyalty lies. Good job umpires.

Winning a match in this way has no value.

In case of Das nobody could see any white line behind the his shoes but still umpire decided to give that out to please BCCI. IN case of imrul even 10% of the ball wasn't hitting the stump but obviously the umpire decided to give the benefit of the doubt in favor of BCCI.

THANK U BCCI.
i only wateched imrul reviews and it was very bad from umpire. Did not even showed exactly the impact. Pathetic...
 
Umpires aren't conspiring against Bangladesh. They r just giving decisions in favor of India to make BCCI happy. The new rule of ICC is that benefit of the doubt should go to India only.

keep bringing such more of these gems! :)))
 
Umpires aren't conspiring against Bangladesh. They r just giving decisions in favor of India to make BCCI happy. The new rule of ICC is that benefit of the doubt should go to India only.

Don’t bother playing then. Pack up and go home. That’s what you want to do right?

Go through the commentary threads for all the other games. No one else talked conspiracy except you guys. Why? Because sides are becoming more professional.

Conspiracy is an easy excuse which takes the focus from the many faults you have as a team. The less you go there, the better for BD team.
 
Thank u BCCI. u have done it yet again. Congratulation for winning the Asia cup. :))
 
How can you think that after this zoomed pic which umpires saw. Another angle from behind also shows that line was visible when stump lit up.

View attachment 84254

It was a close call, but after all this evidence, I don't see how umpire won't give it out.

Even Rameez was saying benefit of the doubt has to go to batsman. I have always accepted the umpiring decision against BD. However, this even I will admit is just plain stupidity on umpires.

See how the on field umpire gave Jadega's nick not out. What if BD did not have any review?

Out
Litton Das.jpg

Not Out(on field umpire)
jadega.jpg
 
^What Rameez says is irrelevant. The line belongs to the umpire, its the rule in MCCs book. And as per the pic [MENTION=97523]Buffet[/MENTION] had posted, not an inch of his feet was behind the line. Why should umpire break the rule and give batsman benefit of doubt when there was no doubt to begin with?

And your 2nd pic is even hilarious. In a stadium filled with 25000 people, cant umpire miss an edge? DRS is there exactly for that. How is that a conspiracy? :facepalm:

In the last game, a clean six was not given and Afg tied the game. So was the umpires was not favouring BCCI then and suddenly they decided to favour India in finals against mighty BD??

Stoo crying man.. its hilarious but irritating at the same time.
 
View attachment 84256

Look at the image carefully. There's no way an umpire can say without any doubt that none of his spikes were inside inside the line. But obviously this umpire was so sure about it because he was in someones pocket.

More i see more i am convinced it is out lol How can you give that not out. Ther ei s nothing behind the line.
 
Even Rameez was saying benefit of the doubt has to go to batsman. I have always accepted the umpiring decision against BD. However, this even I will admit is just plain stupidity on umpires.

See how the on field umpire gave Jadega's nick not out. What if BD did not have any review?

Out
View attachment 84260

Not Out(on field umpire)
View attachment 84261

Rameez was a joker to say that lol First of all when the lights flashed his toe was not even on the ground. IT was confirmed in the side by side image. Second of all when he finally landed on the line lights were already flashing.
 
i only wateched imrul reviews and it was very bad from umpire. Did not even showed exactly the impact. Pathetic...

Exactly.

In case of imrul the ball was just kissing the stumps but that incompetent Lankan umpire gave that lbw decision in favor of of the bowler because he also follows the new rule that icc has specifically made for India which states that benefit of the doubt should always go to India.
 
Exactly.

In case of imrul the ball was just kissing the stumps but that incompetent Lankan umpire gave that lbw decision in favor of of the bowler because he also follows the new rule that icc has specifically made for India which states that benefit of the doubt should always go to India.

Today I am convinced on the umpires conspiracy. I always thought BD fans were making it up before this game to be honest.

This decision was worse than Litton Das one.

Imrul Kayes.jpg
 
Even Rameez was saying benefit of the doubt has to go to batsman.

Agree with that, but doubt has to exist to begin with. In zoomed picture, which umpire saw, there is absolutely nothing behind the line. I was also doubtful before the zoomed picture came during review. I was rooting for BD in this match despite not being a Bdeshi. So take my view for whatever it's worth.

Also, in close decisions, it's very normal for one set of fans to go one way and another set of fans to go another way. It always happens during the match, but if you take a look later then you can clearly see all mistakes by umpires. In this case, umpire didn't make mistake.
 
Today I am convinced on the umpires conspiracy. I always thought BD fans were making it up before this game to be honest.

This decision was worse than Litton Das one.

View attachment 84262

Why on earth would anybody conspire against Bangladesh? You haven't even won a test series at home against a top 8 team. What would anybody benefit from conspiring against Bangladesh?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Agree with that, but doubt has to exist to begin with. In zoomed picture, which umpire saw, there is absolutely nothing behind the line. I was also doubtful before the zoomed picture came during review. I was rooting for BD in this match despite not being a Bdeshi. So take my view for whatever it's worth.

Also, in close decisions, it's very normal for one set of fans to go one way and another set of fans to go another way. It always happens during the match, but if you take a look later then you can clearly see all mistakes by umpires. In this case, umpire didn't make mistake.

Ok, fair point. Then it is safe to assume "benefit of the doubt" does not exist in cricket. I am cool with that.

What is your take on Imrul Kayes LBW?
 
Ok, fair point. Then it is safe to assume "benefit of the doubt" does not exist in cricket. I am cool with that.

What is your take on Imrul Kayes LBW?

Imrul Kayes decision was given out by technology. how can you argue that mate... and benefit of doubt is when there is a doubt not when its clear that its out.
 
Imrul Kayes decision was given out by technology. how can you argue that mate... and benefit of doubt is when there is a doubt not when its clear that its out.

I am not arguing the technology. I am arguing the umpire's call/decision. The ball barely touches the off stump line and in real time does not look out. I believe good amount of ball need to hit within line.

If umpire can give this as out without hesitation, how come he didnt hear clear nick from Jadega's bat?

Overall, it's safe to assume umpiring in this tournament has been complete comedy.
 
I am not arguing the technology. I am arguing the umpire's call/decision. The ball barely touches the off stump line and in real time does not look out. I believe good amount of ball need to hit within line.

If umpire can give this as out without hesitation, how come he didnt hear clear nick from Jadega's bat?

Overall, it's safe to assume umpiring in this tournament has been complete comedy.

Yes the umpiring has been awful. But it's not country specific. India got it against them vs Afghanistan. It got against us on two occasions. But it's part and parcel of the game. And should not be defined as conspiracy. And certainly should not undermine someone's victory.
 
Exactly.

In case of imrul the ball was just kissing the stumps but that incompetent Lankan umpire gave that lbw decision in favor of of the bowler because he also follows the new rule that icc has specifically made for India which states that benefit of the doubt should always go to India.

Impact was umpire's call
Was hitting the stumps flush

There have been 100s of such decisions since umpire's call was introduced and no it does not specify wether ball was kissing the pads/stupms or there was full impact. Go back to the matches you won, your batsmen/bowlers were beneficiaries too.

It worked exactly like how it should.
 
I am not arguing the technology. I am arguing the umpire's call/decision. The ball barely touches the off stump line and in real time does not look out. I believe good amount of ball need to hit within line.

If umpire can give this as out without hesitation, how come he didnt hear clear nick from Jadega's bat?

Overall, it's safe to assume umpiring in this tournament has been complete comedy.

that's why Bangladesh made it to the finals else it should have lost to Afghanistan. I am assuming some decision must have gone against Afghan brothers.
 
I have no interest in BD games. I check their scorecard on cricinfo lol. I do see their crying faces online though.

I raised the question because you lot seem to think very highly of yourself. I don't see Pak, Ind or SL fans claiming conspiracy theories every time their team loses a close match. It's become a habit. So I was wondering, what makes you think anybody is interested in conspiring against you? Surely you do not believe that anybody is jealous of you, right?

1. I am not sure what you mean by think "highly"? Yes, we are proud of being Bengalis. I am pretty sure most people are proud of what they are.

2. Have you ever attended any Bengalis home? From what I have seen we/they are actually one of the nicest when it comes to treating guests. Don't be fooled by what you read on the internet.

3. Why would anyone be jealous of the Subcontinent in general? No, I do not believe anyone is jealous of us, nor do I believe umpire conspiracy. However, I do acknowledge umpiring making mistakes a lot more when it comes to BD.

4. All of your recent posts are either in IND, PAK or BD threads. You think I am stupid? Grow up.
 
1. I am not sure what you mean by think "highly"? Yes, we are proud of being Bengalis. I am pretty sure most people are proud of what they are.

2. Have you ever attended any Bengalis home? From what I have seen we/they are actually one of the nicest when it comes to treating guests. Don't be fooled by what you read on the internet.

3. Why would anyone be jealous of the Subcontinent in general? No, I do not believe anyone is jealous of us, nor do I believe umpire conspiracy. However, I do acknowledge umpiring making mistakes a lot more when it comes to BD.

4. All of your recent posts are either in IND, PAK or BD threads. You think I am stupid? Grow up.

1. I am talking about your cricket team. You can be proud of your country, but some of you ignorantly think everybody is jealous of your 'progress'

2. I am speaking of cricket fans, so I don't need to visit anybody's home.

3. The way you speak of conspiracy suggests someone is trying to sabotage you out of jealousy. 'We got robbed, ICC = BCCI = Big 3" and what not.

4. I post where there is most activity, and this is a Pakistan based sub so of course I will post on SC based thread (since they get most responses).

I don't think you're stupid, no need to take it personally. I do think you have a victim complex though.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. I am not sure what you mean by think "highly"? Yes, we are proud of being Bengalis. I am pretty sure most people are proud of what they are.

2. Have you ever attended any Bengalis home? From what I have seen we/they are actually one of the nicest when it comes to treating guests. Don't be fooled by what you read on the internet.

3. Why would anyone be jealous of the Subcontinent in general? No, I do not believe anyone is jealous of us, nor do I believe umpire conspiracy. However, I do acknowledge umpiring making mistakes a lot more when it comes to BD.

4. All of your recent posts are either in IND, PAK or BD threads. You think I am stupid? Grow up.

Only a match ago India had several bad calls against Afghanistan. Even in this match BD got two umpire's call. Let me tell you the difference. Others take these calls in their stride. BD fans try to magnify each and every such call to justify their pathetic performance. This is not the first time. Won't be the last time you guys are doing. You will simply deduce every loss into a simple umpiring error almost like you would crush everyone but for these things.
 
As a bd fan, i can say to all my fellow countrymen,please stop all these uproar and be prepared for the wc19. Win that. Rectify all your team flaws and get ready to win it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As a bd fan, i can say to all my fellow countrymen,please stop all these uproar and be prepared for the wc19. Win that. Rectify all your team flaws and get ready to win it.

Calm down.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Today I am convinced on the umpires conspiracy. I always thought BD fans were making it up before this game to be honest.

This decision was worse than Litton Das one.

View attachment 84262

It isn't a conspiracy anymore. It's so obvious now. In case of Imrul any neutral umpire would have given the benefit of the doubt to the batsman. But that srilankan umpire was so quick to raise his finger as if the impact was on the middle stump. But obviously he had to give the decision in favor of India since he was on a mission to please someone.


Then consider that liton dismissal. Some part of of his toe was inside the line, at least there was no clear evidence that suggested that his foot was on the line, hence benefit of the doubt should have gone to him. But obviously, it wasn't the cause since benefit of the doubt always go to BCCI.


Lastly in the second last over that very same Lankan umpire didn't raise his finger when Jadeja nicked a call behind the stump. Even the commentators heard it from the com box. But thankfully we had a review left. There's uno doubt that some of them were desperately trying to please someone. Remember the no ball of the last world cup quarter final?
 
Last edited:
The Indian conspiracy is much deeper than that, my friend. BCCI in fact picks and choses its finalist in Asia cup. BCCI have identified Bangladesh as the easiest opponent to play in Asia Cup final. So they are paying off officials to ensure that Bangladesh reaches the final of Asia Cup against them and not Pakistan or Afghanistan.

So, this Bangladeshi delusion that they are the second best team in Asia has also been created by BCCI by paying off officials to ensure that Bangladesh win against other Asian teams. :sarf2
 
Last edited:
It isn't a conspiracy anymore. It's so obvious now. In case of Imrul any neutral umpire would have given the benefit of the doubt to the batsman. But that srilankan umpire was so quick to raise his finger as if the impact was on the middle stump. But obviously he had to give the decision in favor of India since he was on a mission to please someone.


Then consider that liton dismissal. Some part of of his toe was inside the line, at least there was no clear evidence that suggested that his foot was on the line, hence benefit of the doubt should have gone to him. But obviously, it wasn't the cause since benefit of the doubt always go to BCCI.


Lastly in the second last over that very same Lankan umpire didn't raise his finger when Jadeja nicked a call behind the stump. Even the commentators heard it from the com box. But thankfully we had a review left. There's uno doubt that some of them were desperately trying to please someone. Remember the no ball of the last world cup quarter final?

All 3 were correct decisions. Many decisions have been made like that before this tournament and( surprisingly) India were not part of many of those games.
Stop crying and defaming Bangladesh fans fgs.
 
Bangladesh has been robbed off by the umpires. ICC should stick to the rule that all "umpire's calls" and "marginal" decisions go in Bangladesh's favor.

Bangladesh should also start at 25/0 in 0.0 overs and get additional 2 batsmen to play.
 
Back
Top